Please E-mail suggested additions, comments and/or corrections to Kent@MoreLaw.Com.

Help support the publication of case reports on MoreLaw

MOM v. Scott Robinson, Vanessa Robinson and Allison Campbell Deberry

Date: 01-26-2023

Case Number: CJ-2018-02983

Judge: William Musseman

Court: In the District Court in and for Tulsa County, Oklahoma

Plaintiff's Attorney: Mark Miller

Defendant's Attorney: Michael Chitwood

Description:
Tulsa, Oklahoma personal injury lawyer represented Plaintiff, who sued Defendants on premises liability negligence theories claiming to have suffered more than $10,000 in damages and injuries as a direct result of a dangerous condition on property where he was an invitee.







MoreLaw Legal News For Tulsa









Plaintiff was an invitee at a residence in Tulsa on July 23, 2016, located at 1911 South Cheyenne Avenue. While the Plaintiff was at the house and standing on a second floor outside deck, he fell through a skylight located on the roof, and fell nearly fifteen fee and located on a concrete patio.



Plaintiff suffered serious injuries including a broken hip.



Plaintiff claimed that the Defendants owed a duty to him to assure that the property was safe and that they breached that duty and, as a direct result, he was injured.



The Defendant's denied fault and claimed that Plaintiff caused or contributed to his own injuries and damages as a direct result of his own failure to exercise due care.



The elements of a personal injury claim are: (1) Failure on the part of the Defendant to exercise due care, (2) damages and/or injuries caused to Plaintiff, and (3) a direct casual relationship between 1 and 2.







Kent Morlan on Torts









Outcome:
Defendants' verdict.
Plaintiff's Experts:
Defendant's Experts:
Comments:
Editor's Note: Insurance companies decide which cases to try and which to settle. An insurance company that elects to force the plaintiff to go to trial before a jury expects to win and they do 60% of the time. The success rate is even higher if the plaintiff is not white, which was the case in this case.

About This Case

What was the outcome of MOM v. Scott Robinson, Vanessa Robinson and Allison Campb...?

The outcome was: Defendants' verdict.

Which court heard MOM v. Scott Robinson, Vanessa Robinson and Allison Campb...?

This case was heard in In the District Court in and for Tulsa County, Oklahoma, OK. The presiding judge was William Musseman.

Who were the attorneys in MOM v. Scott Robinson, Vanessa Robinson and Allison Campb...?

Plaintiff's attorney: Mark Miller. Defendant's attorney: Michael Chitwood.

When was MOM v. Scott Robinson, Vanessa Robinson and Allison Campb... decided?

This case was decided on January 26, 2023.