Please E-mail suggested additions, comments and/or corrections to Kent@MoreLaw.Com.
Help support the publication of case reports on MoreLaw
State of Oklahoma v. Esther Lee Bales a/k/a Esther Lee Montgomery
Date: 05-19-2017
Case Number: CF-2016-00050
Judge: Phillip A. Ross
Court: District Court, Kay County, Oklahoma
Plaintiff's Attorney: Brian Hermanson
Defendant's Attorney: Scott Loftis
Description:
Newkirk, OK - Jury Convicts Woman Four Drowning Death of 4-Year-Old
The State of Oklahoma charged Esther Lee Bales a/k/a Esther Lee Montgomery, age 56, with:
1. MURDER, 2ND DEGREE, AFC 2+ (FEL), in violation of 21 OS 701.8
2. OR IN THE ALTERNATIVE:
3. CHILD NEGLECT AFC OF TWO OR MORE FEL.
The State claimed that Bales was responsible for the drowning death of four-year-old Haley Primeaux on July 27, 2015 at the Lake Ponca Swim Beach.
Docket
Date Code Description Count Party Amount
01-27-2016
INFORMATION FELONY COUNT 1 (AMENDED 5/2/17)
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 103.00
. . .MURDER IN THE SECOND DEGREE, AFC 2/MORE
. . .OR IN THE ALTERNATIVE. . .
. . .CHILD NEGLECT, AFC 2/MORE
LAW LIBRARY FEE
$ 6.00
SHERIFF ARREST FEE
$ 5.00
CLEET
$ 9.00
AFIS
$ 5.00
STATE TREASURERS FORENSIC FEE
$ 5.00
10% OF AFS5
$ 0.50
10% OF CLT9
$ 0.90
10% OF FORE
$ 0.50
MEDICAL EXPENSE LIABILITY REVOLVING FUND
$ 10.00
10% OF MLRF
$ 1.00
OKLAHOMA COURT INFORMATION SYSTEM FEE - EFFECTIVE 07/01/04
$ 25.00
DA PROSECUTION FEE-FELONY
$ 25.00
10% OF DARF
$ 2.50
SHERIFF SERVICE FEE-COURTHOUSE SECURITY SUB ACCOUNT
$ 10.00
10% OF COURTHOUSE SECURITY FEE
$ 1.00
ATTORNEY GENERAL VICTIM SERVICES UNIT
$ 3.00
10% OF AG VICTIM SERVICES FEE
$ 0.30
CHILD ABUSE MULTIDISCIPLINARY ACCOUNT
$ 3.00
10% OF CAMA FEE
$ 0.30
01-27-2016
AFFIDAVIT
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
01-27-2016
WARRANT ISSUED WITH BOND ENDORSED AT $150,000
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 50.00
OKLAHOMA COURT INFORMATION SYSTEM FEE
$ 25.00
01-27-2016
AMENDED INFORMATION
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
01-28-2016
RETURN OF ORIGINAL FELONY WARRANT - JAILED
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
01-28-2016
CM:TURNER JAH
CAUSE COMES ON FOR INITIAL APPEARANCE. COURT ORDERS
BOND REMAIN AS PREVIOUSLY SET AND SETS MATTER FOR
INITIAL APPEARANCE ON FEBRUARY 5, 2016 AT 9:00AM. SEE
COURT MINUTE.
01-28-2016
PROBABLE CAUSE AND/OR INITIAL APPEARANCE MINUTE/ORDER
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
(COPY TO DEPUTY FOR DEFT IN KSO)
02-05-2016
CM:TURNER JAH
CAUSE COMES ON FOR INITIAL APPEARANCE. INITIAL
APPEARANCE IS HELD. COURT ORDERS BOND REMAIN AS
PREVIOUSLY SET. COURT SETS MATTER FOR ATTORNEY STATUS
REVIEW ON FEBRUARY 12, 2016 AT 10:00AM. SEE COURT
MINUTE.
02-05-2016
PROBABLE CAUSE AND/OR INITIAL APPEARANCE MINUTE/ORDER
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
(COPY TO DEPUTY FOR DEFT IN KSO)
02-11-2016
CM:BROCK KLG
CAUSE COMES ON FOR ATTY STATUS REVIEW. DEFT APPLIES FOR
COURT APPOINTED COUNSEL. COURT APPROVES AND APPOINTS
COUNSEL, HEIDI BAIER. COURT SETS MATTER FOR STATUS
DOCKET ON MARCH 4, 2016 AT 2:00 P.M. DEFT IS TO APPEAR
AT 10:30 A.M. TO MEET WITH COUNSEL. FURTHER, COURT
ORDERS DEFT IS ORDERED TO APPEAR FOR ATTY CONFERENCE ON
FEBRUARY 26, 2016 AT 1:00 P.M. SEE COURT MINUTE.
02-11-2016
COURT MINUTE/ORDER (COPY SENT TO JAIL FOR DEFT)
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
02-11-2016
APPLICATION FOR APPOINTED COUNSEL AND AFFIDAVIT OF
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 40.00
FINANCIAL INABILITY TO EMPLOY COUNSEL (O.I.D.S. ATTY)
03-03-2016
CM:TURNER MKT
CAUSE COMES ON STATUS DOCKET. DUE TO UNAVAILABLE OF
DEFT'S ATTY HEIDI BAIER OIDS. IT IS THE ORDER OF THE
COURT THAT MATTER (S) ARE CONTINUED TO STATUS DOCKET OF
APRIL 1, 2016 AT 2:00 PM. SEE COURT MINUTE
03-03-2016
COURT MINUTE/ORDER (COPY SENT TO JAIL FOR DEFT)
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
04-01-2016
CM:BANDY MKT
CAUSE COMES ON STATUS DOCKET. PARTIES APPEAR. COURT
SETS MATTER FOR PRELIMINARY HEARING ON JULY 13, 2016 AT
10:00 AM. SEE COURT MINUTE
04-01-2016
COURT MINUTE/ORDER (DEFT SIGNED MINUTE)
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
05-18-2016
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE AND REQUEST FOR LAW ENFORCEMENT
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
REPORTS
06-07-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE BY SHERIFF
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 50.00
TO SERVE:CHARLES BOTTGER
OKLAHOMA COURT INFORMATION SYSTEM ASSESSMENT
$ 25.00
06-07-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE BY SHERIFF
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 50.00
TO SERVE:ELAINE PRIMEAUX
OKLAHOMA COURT INFORMATION SYSTEM ASSESSMENT
$ 25.00
06-07-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE BY SHERIFF
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 50.00
TO SERVE:ROLF CLEMENTS
OKLAHOMA COURT INFORMATION SYSTEM ASSESSMENT
$ 25.00
06-07-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE:STEVEN YINGER PCPD
(POSTAGE $.48) RUNNING TOTAL $.48
06-07-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE:TRISTAN FITZSIMMONS PCPD
(MULTIPLE MAILING)
06-07-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE:CHAD VANHOESEN PCPD
(MULTIPLE MAILING)
06-07-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE:BRIAN DYE PCPD
(MULTIPLE MAILING)
06-09-2016
RETURN OF ORIGINAL SUBPOENA -SERVING ROLF CLEMENTS ON
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
6-8-16 BY KSO TIM PETERS
06-09-2016
RETURN OF ORIGINAL SUBPOENA -SERVING ELAINE PRIMEAUX ON
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
6-8-16 BY KSO TIM PETERS
06-15-2016
RETURN OF ORIGINAL SUBPOENA -CHARLES BOTTGER WAS NOT
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
SERVED
06-16-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE: THELMA KNOWLEN, ARKANSAS CITY, KANSAS
(POSTAGE $.48) RUNNING TOTAL $.96
06-16-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE: BILLIE JEAN KNOWLEN, WICHITA KANSAS
(POSTAGE $.48) RUNNING TOTAL $1.44
06-16-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE: KENTON HARDEE, WICHITA KANSAS
(MULTIPLE MAILING)
06-28-2016
MOTION TO ENDORSE ADDITION WITNESS(ES)/ORDER
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
06-30-2016
STATE'S NOTICE OF INTENT TO OFFER MEDICAL EXAMINER'S
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
REPORT AS EVIDENCE
07-08-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED TO STATE
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
TO SERVE: CHARLES LEE BOTTGER
07-08-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE:DEANNA LINDER, DHS
(POSTAGE $.48) RUNNING TOTAL $1.92
07-08-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE:DANIELLE WEGNER, DHS
(POSTAGE $.48) RUNNING TOTAL $2.40
07-13-2016
RETURN OF ORIGINAL SUBPOENA - CHARLES BOTTGER SERVED
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
7/13/16 BY CHRIS EDWARDS
07-13-2016
CM:TURNER KLG
COURT REPORTER FEE: SHERRIE POWELL
$ 10.00
OKLAHOMA COURT INFORMATION SYSTEM ASSESSMENT
$ 12.50
COURT REPORTER FEE SPLIT WITH CO-DEFT
CAUSE COMES ON FOR PRELIMINARY HRG IN CF-16-50 (BALES)
AND CF-16-51 (JACKSON). DEFT ESTHER BALES APPEARS IN
PERSON AND WITH COUNSEL, SCOTT LOFTIS. DEFT WANITA
JACKSON APPEARS IN PERSON AND WITH COUNSEL, JARROD
STEVENSON. STATE APPEARS BY D.A. BRIAN HERMSON AND
ASS'T D.A. SHAWNA TAYLOR. RULE OF SEQUESTRATION
INVOKED. PARTIES ANNOUNCE READY. STATE'S WITNESS,
ELAINE PRIMEAUX, SWORN. TESTIMONY GIVEN. WITNESS
EXCUSED. STATE'S WITNESS, BILLIE KNOWLEN, SWORN.
TESTITMONY GIVEN. WITNESS EXCUSED. COURT RECESSES AT
11:59 A.M. COURT RESUMES AT 1:03 P.M. ALL PARTIES ARE
PRESENT AND ANNOUNCE READY. STATE'S WITNESS, KENTON
HARDEE, SWORN. TESTIMONY GIVEN. WITNESS EXCUSED.
STATE'S WITNESS, ROLF CLEMENTS, SWORN. TESTIMONY GIVEN.
WITNESS EXCUSED. STATE'S WITNESS, TRISTAN FITZSIMMONS
(PCPD), SWORN. TESTIMONY GIVEN. WITNESS EXCUSED. COURT
RECESSES AT 2:04 P.M. COURT RESUMES AT 2:28 P.M. ALL
PARTIES ARE PRESENT AND ANNOUNCE READY. STATE'S
WITNESS, STEVEN YINGER (PCPD), SWORN. TESTIMONY GIVEN.
WITNESS EXCUSED. STATE'S WITNESS, CHAD VANHOESEN
(PCPD), SWORN. TESTIMONY GIVEN. WITNESS EXCUSED.
PARTIES STIPULATE TO THE ANTICIPATED TESTIMONY OF
STATE'S WITNESS DEANNA LINDER. STATE'S WITNESS, BRIAN
DYE (PCPD), SWORN. STATE'S EXHIBITS 1-3, ADMITTED
WITHOUT OBJECTION. STATE'S EXHIBIT 4, ADMITTED OVER
BOTH DEFT'S OBJECTIONS. TESTIMONY GIVEN. WITNESS
EXCUSED. COURT RECESSES AT 3:48 P.M. COURT RESUMES AT
4:00 P.M. ALL PARTIES ARE PRESENT AND PARTIES ANNOUNCE
READY. STATE'S WITNESS, CHARLES LEE BOTTGER, SWORN.
TESTIMONY GIVEN. WITNESS EXCUSED. PARTIES TO PRESENT
ARGUMENT ON JULY 19, 2016 AT 11:00 A.M. COURT RECESSES
AT 4:30 P.M.
07-14-2016
CERTIFICATION TO COURT CLERK
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
07-14-2016
AFFIDAVIT OF WITNESS ATTENDANCE AND STATE'S WITNESS
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
CLAIM, PAID BY STATE VOUCHER #5274
$ 5.00
(SPLIT WITH CO-DEFT)
07-14-2016
AFFIDAVIT OF WITNESS ATTENDANCE AND STATE'S WITNESS
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
CLAIM, PAID BY STATE VOUCHER #5275
$ 5.00
(SPLIT WITH CO-DEFT)
07-14-2016
AFFIDAVIT OF WITNESS ATTENDANCE AND STATE'S WITNESS
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
CLAIM, PAID BY STATE VOUCHER #5276
$ 48.20
(SPLIT WITH CO-DEFT)
07-14-2016
AFFIDAVIT OF WITNESS ATTENDANCE AND STATE'S WITNESS
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
CLAIM, PAID BY STATE VOUCHER #5277
$ 13.10
(SPLIT WITH CO-DEFT)
07-14-2016
AFFIDAVIT OF WITNESS ATTENDANCE AND STATE'S WITNESS
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
CLAIM, PAID BY STATE VOUCHER #5278
$ 13.10
(SPLIT WITH CO-DEFT)
07-14-2016
AFFIDAVIT OF WITNESS ATTENDANCE AND STATE'S WITNESS
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
CLAIM, PAID BY STATE VOUCHER #5279
$ 5.00
(SPLIT WITH CO-DEFT)
07-19-2016
CM:TURNER KLG
COURT REPORTER FEE: SHERRIE POWELL
$ 10.00
OKLAHOMA COURT INFORMATION SYSTEM ASSESSMENT
$ 12.50
COURT REPORTER FEE SPLIT WITH CO-DEFT
CAUSE COMES ON FOR CONTINUATION OF PRELIMINARY HRG IN
CF-16-50 (BALES) AND CF-16-51 (JACKSON). DEFT BALES
APPEARS IN PERSON AND WITH COUNSEL, SCOTT LOFTIS. DEFT
JACKSON APPEARS IN PERSON AND WITH COUNSEL, JARROD
STEVENSON. STATE APPEARS BY D.A. BRIAN HERMANSON.
PARTIES ANNOUNCE READY. RULE OF SEQUESTRATION
PREVIOUSLY INVOKED. STATE'S EXHIBITS 5,8,10, ADMITTED
WITHOUT OBJECTION. STATE'S EXHIBITS 6,7, ADMITTED OVER
OBJECTION OF LOFTIS. STATE RESTS. LOFTIS MAKES ARGUMENT
AS TO THE LOWERING OF BOND IN REGARDS TO DEFT BALES AND
ENTERS GENERAL AND SPECIFIC DEMURRER AS TO EACH COUNT.
STEVENSON ENTERS GENERAL AND SPECIFIC DEMURRER AS TO
EACH COUNT. STATE MAKES ARGUMENT AS TO DEMURRERS AND
BOND REDUCTION. AS TO BOTH DEFT'S JACKSON AND BALES,
COURT BINDS OVER AS PREVIOUSLY CHARGED. DEFT'S DO NOT
WAIVE 30 DAYS. COURT SETS MATTERS FOR FORMAL
ARRAIGNMENT ON AUGUST 15, 2016 AT 9:00 A.M. FURTHER, AS
TO BOND REDUCTION FOR DEFT BALES, COURT ORDERS BOND
LOWERED TO $75,000 OVER STATE'S OBJECTION. SEE COURT
MINUTE.
07-19-2016
COURT MINUTE/ORDER (DEFT SIGNED MINUTE)
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
07-19-2016
JOURNAL ENTRY AFTER PRELIMINARY EXAMINATION
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
08-15-2016
CM:ROSS JAH
CAUSE COMES ON FOR FORMAL ARRAIGNMENT. ARRAIGNMENT IS
HELD. COURT SETS MATTER FOR PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE ON
OCTOBER 14, 2016 AT 11:00AM AND SETS MATTER FOR THE
FELONY TRIAL SCHEDULING DOCKET ON NOVEMBER 9, 2016 AT
9:00AM. SEE COURT MINUTE.
08-15-2016
COURT MINUTE/ORDER (DEFT SIGNED MINUTE)
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
08-15-2016
FELONY TRIAL SCHEDULING ORDER
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
10-14-2016
STATE OF OKLAHOMA'S PRELIMINARY WITNESS AND EXHIBIT
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
LIST
11-09-2016
CM:ROSS KD
CAUSE COMES ON FOR JURY TRIAL SCHEDULING DOCKET. THE
COURT SETS MATTER FOR JURY TRIAL ON JURY TRIAL ON
JANUARY 24, 2017 AT 9:00 AM. SEE COURT MINUTE.
11-09-2016
COURT MINUTE/ORDER (COPY SENT TO JAIL FOR DEFT)
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
12-16-2016
REQUEST FOR DISCOVERY AND BRIEF IN SUPPORT
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
12-16-2016
SECOND AMENDED INFORMATION
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
12-20-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE: DEANNA LINDER, DHS
(POSTAGE $.48) RUNNING TOTAL $2.88
12-20-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE: DANIELLE WEGNER, DHS
(POSTAGE $.48) RUNNING TOTAL $3.36
12-20-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE: JOE ALLEN
(POSTAGE $.48) RUNNING TOTAL $3.84
12-20-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE: BEAU SPARKS
(POSTAGE $.48) RUNNING TOTAL $4.32
12-20-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE: STEPHEN LONG, PCFD
(POSTAGE $.48) RUNNING TOTAL $4.80
12-20-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE: BRIAN DYE, PCPD
(POSTAGE $.48) RUNNING TOTAL $5.28
12-20-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE: TRISTAN FITZSIMMONS, PCPD
(MULTIPLE MAILING)
12-20-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE: CHAD VANHOESEN, PCPD
(MULTIPLE MAILING)
12-20-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE: STEVEN YINGER, PCPD
(MULTIPLE MAILING)
12-20-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE BY SHERIFF
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 50.00
TO SERVE: ROLF ALLEN CLEMENTS
OKLAHOMA COURT INFORMATION SYSTEM ASSESSMENT
$ 25.00
12-20-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE BY SHERIFF
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 50.00
TO SERVE: ELAINE ELENOR PRIMEAUX
OKLAHOMA COURT INFORMATION SYSTEM ASSESSMENT
$ 25.00
12-20-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE BY SHERIFF
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 50.00
TO SERVE: DR. EDWARD SCOVILL
OKLAHOMA COURT INFORMATION SYSTEM ASSESSMENT
$ 25.00
12-20-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE ISSUED FOR STATE CERT MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE: CHARLES LEE BOTTGER
92148969009997901201654396
(POSTAGE $5.12) RUNNING TOTAL $10.40
12-20-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE ISSUED FOR STATE CERT MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE: DWAYNE CALLISON
92148969009997901201654464
(POSTAGE $5.12) RUNNING TOTAL $15.52
12-20-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE ISSUED FOR STATE CERT MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE: KENTON LEON HARDEE
92148969009997901201654501
(POSTAGE $5.12) RUNNING TOTAL OVER $10
12-20-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE ISSUED FOR STATE CERT MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE: BILLIE JEAN KNOWLEN
92148969009997901201654563
(POSTAGE $5.12) RUNNING TOTAL OVER $10
12-20-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE ISSUED FOR STATE CERT MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE: CLAY NICHOLS, MD
92148969009997901201654587
(POSTAGE $5.12) RUNNING TOTAL OVER $10
12-23-2016
STATE OF OKLAHOMA'S SECOND PRELIMINARY WITNESS AND
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
EXHIBIT LIST
12-28-2016
RETURN RECEIPT OF CERTIFIED MAIL - DATED:12-24-16
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
SIGNED BY:DWAYNE CALLISON
12-28-2016
RETURN RECEIPT OF CERTIFIED MAIL - DATED:12-22-16
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
SIGNED BY:THELMA KNOWLEN FOR KENTON LEON HARDEE
12-28-2016
RETURN RECEIPT OF CERTIFIED MAIL - DATED:12-22-16
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
SIGNED BY:THELMA KNOWLEN FOR BILLIE JEAN KNOWLEN
12-28-2016
RETURN RECEIPT OF CERTIFIED MAIL - DATED:12-22-16
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
SIGNED BY:RENEE STEWART FOR CLAY NICHOLS M.D.
12-30-2016
NOTICE OF DISCOVERY COMPLIANCE
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
12-30-2016
RETURN OF ORIGINAL SUBPOENA -SERVING ELAINE ELENOR
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
PRIMEAUX ON 12-26-16 BY LEWAIN LEARNED
12-30-2016
RETURN OF ORIGINAL SUBPOENA -NOT SERVING EDWARD
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
SCOVILL BY LEWAIN LEARNED
01-05-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED TO STATE
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
TO SERVE: DR. EDWARD SCOVILL
01-09-2017
RETURN OF ORIGINAL SUBPOENA -ROLF CLEMENTS SERVED
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
1-6-17 BY KSO LEWAIN LEARNED
01-09-2017
TRANSCRIPT OF BEGINNING OF PRELIMINARY HEARING
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
01-09-2017
CONTINUED SCANNING
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
DATE/COURT REPORTER: 07-3-16/SHERRIE POWELL
ORIGINAL AND 2 COPIES (SCANNING TRANSFERED TO CO DEFT
CF-16-51)
01-10-2017
STATE OF OKLAHOMA'S THIRED PRELIMINARY WITNESS AND
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
EXHIBIT LIST
01-10-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED TO STATE
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
TO SERVE: CHARLES BOTTGER
01-11-2017
ORDER FOR TRANSCRIPT
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
EST. COSTS OF TRANSCRIPT
$ 75.00
01-11-2017
RETURN OF ORIGINAL SUBPOENA - SERVED EDWARD SCOVILL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
BY CHRIS EDWARDS DA OFFICE
01-17-2017
CM:ROSS MKT
CAUSE COMES ON FOR SCHEDULIG. BY AGREEMENT OF PARTIES.
COURT SETS MATTER FOR JURY TRIAL ON MAY 16, 2017 AT
9:00 AM. WITH PRE TRIAL CONFERENCE SET FOR APRIL 21,
2017 AT 9:00 AM. SEE COURT MINUTE
01-17-2017
COURT MINUTE/ORDER (COPY SENT TO JAIL FOR DEFT)
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
01-18-2017
RETURN OF ORIGINAL SUBPOENA - CHARLES LEE BOTTGER,
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
NOT SERVED, CHRIS EDWARDS
01-18-2017
RETURN RECEIPT OF CERTIFIED MAIL - DATED: 01/10/17
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
SIGNED BY: NOT LEGIBLE FOR CHARLES BOTTGER
01-19-2017
NOTICE OF FILING
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
01-19-2017
TRANSCRIPT OF CONCLUSION OF PRELIMINARY HEARING AND
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
ESTHER BALES MOTION FOR BOND REDUCTION
HRG DATE/COURT REPORTER: 07/19/16 SHERRIE POWELL
ORIGINAL AND ONE COPY IN CASE NUMBER CF-16-50
ONE COPY IN CASE NUMBER CF-16-51
03-09-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE BY SHERIFF
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 50.00
TO SERVE:ROLF ALLEN CLEMENTS
OKLAHOMA COURT INFORMATION SYSTEM ASSESSMENT
$ 25.00
03-09-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE BY SHERIFF
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 50.00
TO SERVE:EDWARD SCOVILL DR.
OKLAHOMA COURT INFORMATION SYSTEM ASSESSMENT
$ 25.00
03-09-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE:STEVEN YINGER
(POSTAGE $.48) RUNNING TOTAL OVER $10
03-09-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE:TRISTAN FITZSIMMONS
(MULTIPLE MAILING)
03-09-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE:CHAD VANHOESEN
(MULTIPLE MAILING)
03-09-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE:BRIAN DYE
(MULTIPLE MAILING)
03-09-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE:ELAINE ELENOR PRIMEAUX
(POSTAGE $.48) RUNNING TOTAL OVER $10
03-09-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE:BEAU SPARKS
(POSTAGE $.48) RUNNING TOTAL OVER $10
03-09-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE:DANIELLE WEGNER
(POSTAGE $.48) RUNNING TOTAL OVER $10
03-09-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE:JOE ALLEN
(POSTAGE $.48) RUNNING TOTAL OVER $10
03-09-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE:DEANNA JANETTE LINDER
(POSTAGE $.48) RUNNING TOTAL OVER $10
03-09-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE:STEPHEN LONG
(POSTAGE $.48) RUNNING TOTAL OVER $10
03-09-2017
FEE ADJUSTMENT-NOT ALL MAILING FEES PREVIOUSLY ASSESSED
$ 23.28
03-09-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE ISSUED FOR STATE CERT MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
(OUT OF COUNTY)
TO SERVE: BILLIE KNOWLEN
9214 8969 0099 9790 1201 9423 94
(POSTAGE $5.26) RUNNING TOTAL OVER $10
$ 5.26
03-09-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE ISSUED FOR STATE CERT MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
(OUT OF COUNTY)
TO SERVE: CLAY NICHOLS M.D., CHIEF MEDICAL EXAMINER
9214 8969 0099 9790 1201 9426 22
(POSTAGE $5.26) RUNNING TOTAL OVER $10
$ 5.26
03-09-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE ISSUED FOR STATE CERT MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
(OUT OF COUNTY)
TO SERVE: CHARLES BOTTGER
9214 8969 0099 9790 1201 9426 39
(POSTAGE $5.26) RUNNING TOTAL OVER $10
$ 5.26
03-09-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE ISSUED FOR STATE CERT MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
(OUT OF COUNTY)
TO SERVE: KENTON HARDEE
9214 8969 0099 9790 1201 9427 76
(POSTAGE $5.26) RUNNING TOTAL OVER $10
03-09-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE ISSUED FOR STATE CERT MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
(OUT OF COUNTY)
TO SERVE: DWAYNE CALLISON
9214 8969 0099 9790 1201 9428 37
(POSTAGE $5.26) RUNNING TOTAL OVER $10
03-13-2017
RETURN OF ORIGINAL SUBPOENA -SERVING EDWARD SCOVILL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
ON 3-10-17 BY KSO TIM PETERS
03-13-2017
RETURN OF ORIGINAL SUBPOENA - SERVING ROLF CLEMENTS
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
ON 3-10-17 BY KSO TIM PETERS
03-15-2017
RETURN RECEIPT OF CERTIFIED MAIL - DATED:3-11-17
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
SIGNED BY:NOT LEDGIBLE
03-22-2017
RETURN RECEIPT OF CERTIFIED MAIL - DATED:3-14-17
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
SIGNED BY:KENTON HARDEE FOR SAME
03-22-2017
RETURN RECEIPT OF CERTIFIED MAIL - DATED:3-13-17
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
SIGNED BY:P.PEDIGO FOR CLAY NICHOLS
03-22-2017
RETURN RECEIPT OF CERTIFIED MAIL - DATED:3-14-17
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
SIGNED BY:KENTON HARDEE FOR BILLIE KNOWLEN
04-13-2017
RETURN RECEIPT OF CERTIFIED MAIL - DATED:4-6-17
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
SIGNED BY:GAIL BROOKSHIRE
04-21-2017
FEE ADJUSTMENT ON TRANSCRIPT ESTIMATE...CC
$ -75.00
04-21-2017
PD SHERRIE POWELL CL 715A VO 35985A; PH 7/19/17 IN BOTH
$ 57.75
DEFTS. CF-16-50 AND CF-16-51 . AND HRG 7/13/17
$ 344.75
05-02-2017
3RD AMENDED INFORMATION
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
05-03-2017
NOTICE OF INTENT TO USE EVIDENCE OF OTHER CRIMES
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
05-03-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED TO STATE
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
(OUT OF COUNTY)
TO SERVE: CHARLES BOTTGER
05-03-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
(OUT OF COUNTY)
TO SERVE: DWAYNE CALLISON
(POSTAGE $.48) RUNNING TOTAL OVER $10
$ 0.48
05-04-2017
DEFT'S LIST OF WITNESSES AND EXHIBITS
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
05-05-2017
STATE OF OKLAHOMA'S FOURTH PRELIMINARY WITNESS AND
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
EXHIBIT LIST
05-05-2017
RETURN OF ORIGINAL SUBPOENA -CHARLES BOTTHER SERVED
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
ON 5-3-17 BY RON TEEL
05-09-2017
DEFT'S OBJECTION AND DAUBERT MOTION TO EXCLUDE THE
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
STATE'S EVIDENCE OF OTHER CRIMES AS STATED IN THE
STATE'S NOTICE OF INTENT
05-11-2017
STATE'S RESPONSE TO DEFT'S OBJECTION AND DAUBERT MOTION
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
TO EXCLUDE THE STATE'S EVIDENCE OF OTHER CRIMES AS
STATED IN THE STATE'S NOTICE OF INTENT
05-15-2017
SUBPOENA ISSUED FOR DEFENDANT TO SHERIFF
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 50.00
TO SERVE: OFFICER STEVEN YINGER
OKLAHOMA COURT INFORMATION SYSTEM ASSESSMENT
$ 25.00
05-16-2017
CM:ROSS JAH REPORTER: LEA MCBRIDE
COURT REPORTER FEE
$ 20.00
OKLAHOMA COURT INFORMATION SYSTEM ASSESSMENT
$ 25.00
CAUSE COMES ON FOR JURY TRIAL. STATE APPEARS BY
DISTRICT ATTORNEY, BRIAN HERMANSON AND ASS'T DA SHAWNA
TAYLOR. DEFT APPEARS IN PERSON AND WITH COUNSEL, SCOTT
LOFTIS. COURT GOES ON RECORD AT 8:54AM, OUT OF PRESENCE
OF POTENTIAL JURORS TO HEAR ARGUMENT ON STATE'S NOTICE
OF INTENT TO USE EVIDENCE OF OTHER CRIMES. STATE MAKES
ARGUMENT IN SUPPORT. DEFT RESPONDS. STATE RESPONDS.
COURT ORDERS EVIDENCE WILL BE ABLE TO COME IN DURING
TRIAL. POTENTIAL JURY ENTERS COURTROOM AT 9:17AM. COURT
GIVES OPENING STATEMENTS TO POTENTIAL JURORS. CLERK
SWEARS POTENTIAL JURORS VOIR DIRE. CLERK CALLS THE
NAMES OF 22 POTENTIAL JURORS. COURT BEGINS VOIR DIRE OF
POTENTIAL JURORS. COURT PASSES THE JURY FOR CAUSE.
STATE BEGINS VOIR DIRE OF POTENTIAL JURORS. COURT TAKES
RECESS AT 10:34AM. COURT GOES BACK ON RECORD AT 10:49AM
WITH POTENTIAL JURORS SEATED. STATE PASSES THE JURY FOR
CAUSE. DEFT BEGINS VOIR DIRE OF POTENTIAL JURORS. DEFT P
PASSES THE JURY FOR CAUSE. PARTIES EXERCISE PREEMPTORY
CHALLENGES OUT OF PRESENCE OF POTENTIAL JURORS. COURT
GOES BACK ON RECORD IN OPEN COURT AT 11:43AM AND
EXCUSES POTENTIAL JURORS NOT SELECTED DURING PREEMPTORY
CHALLENGES. JURY IS SWORN TO TRY CAUSE. COURT TAKES
LUNCH RECESS AT 11:46AM. COURT GOES BACK ON RECORD AT
1:12PM WITH JURY SEATED. COURT READS OPENING
INSTRUCTIONS TO JURY. STATE READS INFORMATION TO JURY
AND GIVES OPENING STATEMENT. RESTS. DEFT GIVES OPENING
STATEMENT. RESTS. STATE CALLS WITNESS, ELAINE PRIMEAUX.
SWORN. STATE EVOKES RULE OF SEQUESTRATION. TESTIMONY
GIVEN. STATE OFFERS EXHIBIT 1. ADMITTED. PUBLISHED.
WITNESS EXCUSED. STATE CALLS WITNESS, KENTON HARDEE.
SWORN. TESTIMONY GIVEN. WITNESS EXCUSED. STATE CALLS
WITNESS, DR. EDWARD SCOVILL. SWORN. TESTIMONY GIVEN.
WITNESS EXCUSED. STATE CALLS WITNESS, ROLF CLEMENTS.
SWORN. TESTIMONY GIVEN. WITNESS EXCUSED. COURT TAKES
AFTERNOON RECESS AT 2:33PM. COURT GOES BACK ON RECORD
AT 2:48PM WITH JURY SEATED. STATE CALLS WITNESS, DWAYNE
CALLISON. WITNESS EXCUSED. COURT TAKES RECESS AT 2:55PM.
COURT GOES BACK ON RECORD AT 3:17PM WITH JURY SEATED.
STATE CALLS WITNESS, OFFICER TRISTAN FITZSIMMONS.
SWORN. TESTIMONY GIVEN. WITNESS EXCUSED. STATE CALLS
WITNESS, OFFICER STEVEN YINGER. SWORN. TESTIMONY GIVEN.
WITNESS EXCUSED. STATE CALLS WITNESS, STEPHEN LONG.
SWORN. TESTIMONY GIVEN. WITNESS EXCUSED. COURT IS
ADJOURNED FOR THE DAY AT 4:10PM.
05-16-2017
INSTRUCTIONS TO THE JURY BEFORE TRIAL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
05-17-2017
CAUSE COMES ON FOR CONTINUATION OF JURY TRIAL. COURT
GOES BACK ON RECORD AT 9:06AM WITH JURY SEATED. PARTIES
ANNOUNCE READY. STATE CALLS WITNESS, CHARLES BOTTGER.
SWORN. TESTIMONY GIVEN. WITNESS EXCUSED. STATE CALLS
WITNESS, DR. CLAY NICHOLS. SWORN. TESTIMONY GIVEN.
STATE OFFERS EXHIBIT 25. ADMITTED. WITNESS EXCUSED.
STATE CALLS WITNESS, SGT. BRIAN DYE. SWORN. TESTIMONY
GIVEN. STATE OFFERS EXHIBIT 20. ADMITTED. PUBLISHED.
STATE OFFERS EXHIBIT 2. ADMITTED. PUBLISHED. STATE
OFFERS EXHIBIT 3. ADMITTED. PUBLISHED. STATE OFFERS
EXHIBIT 4. ADMITTED. PUBLISHED. STATE OFFERS EXHIBIT
24. ADMITTED. PUBLISHED. STATE OFFERS EXHIBIT 21.
ADMITTED. PUBLISHED. STATE OFFERS EXHIBITS 22 AND 23.
ADMITTED. PUBLISHED. WITNESS EXCUSED. STATE CALLS
WITNESS, DEANNA LINDER. SWORN. TESTIMONY GIVEN. STATE
OFFERS EXHIBIT 5. ADMITTED. PUBLISHED. STATE OFFERS
EXHIBITS 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18
AND 19. ADMITTED. PUBLISHED. WITNESS EXCUSED. STATE
RESTS. JURY IS EXCUSED FOR LUNCH AT 10:55AM. OUT OF
PRESENCE OF JURY, DEFT ENTERS BOTH GENERAL AND SPECIFIC
DEMURRER AND OFFERS ARGUMENT IN SUPPORT. OVERRULED.
DEFT UNDERSTANDS RIGHT TO TESTIFY AND CHOOSES NOT TO.
COURT GOES OFF RECORD AT 10:58AM.
05-17-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED TO STATE
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
TO SERVE: MARILEE THORNTON, OR DESIGNEE
05-17-2017
CAUSE COMES ON FOR CONTIUANCE OF JURY TRIAL. COURT GOES
BACK ON RECORD AT 1:03PM WITH JURY SEATED. COURT FINDS
THAT THERE ARE NO OBJECTIONS TO JURY INSTRUCTIONS. THE
COURT READS FINAL INSTRUCTIONS. STATE GIVES CLOSING
STATEMENTS. DEFENSE GIVES CLOSING STATEMENTS. STATE
REBUTTLES. CLOSING ARGUEMENTS CONCLUDED. BALIFF IS
SWORN AND JURORS EXCUSED TO RETIRE TO DELIBERATION.
COURT IN RECESS AT 2:30PM. COURT RECONVINES AT 3:43PM
WITH JURORS AND VERDICT. THE VERDICT WHICH READS AS
FOLLOWS: WE THE JURY, EMPANELED AND SWORN IN IN THE
ABOVE ENTITLED CAUSE DO UPON OUR OATHS, IN COUNT ONE
MURDER IN THE 2ND DEGREE AFC FIND THE DEFT GUILTY
SIGNED /S/ DONNIE JACKSON FOREPERSON. JURY IS EXCUSED
COURT RECESS AT 3:55PM. COURT RECONVINES AT 4:18PM ON
RECORD WITH JURY SEATED. STATE CALLS MARILEE THORNTON, A
AS AN 4OFFICER OF THE COURT WITNESS NOT SWORN IN AND
TESTIMONY GIVEN. STATE OFFERS EXHIBITS 26-30 OFFERED
AND ADMITTEDWITHOUT OBJECTION. COURT READS FINAL
INSTRUCTION TO JURY TO RENDER VERDICT. STATE GIVES
CLOSING ARUGMENTS. DEFENSE GIVE CLOSING ARGUMENTS.
STATE GIVES FINAL CLOSING ARGUEMENT. JURORS EXCUSED TO
DELIBERATION. COURT RECESSES AT 4:42PM. COURT
RECONVINES AT 5:01PM WITH JURORS AND VERDICT. THE COURT
FINDS THAT PUNISHSMENT HAS NOT BEEN ESTABLISHED AND
EXCUSES JURORS BACK TO DELIBERATION. COURT RECESSES AT
5:02PM. COURT RECONVINES AT 5:20PM WITH JURORS AND
VERDICT WICH READS AS FOLLOWS: WE THE JURY, EMPANELED
AND SWORN IN THE ABOVE ENTITLED CAUSE DO UPON OUR
OATHS, FIND AS FOLLOWS: DEFT IS GUILT OF THE CRIME OF
MURDER IN THE SECOND DEGREE AFTER TWO (2) OR MORE
PREVIOUS CONVICTIONS AND FIX PUNISHMENT AT 30 YEARS
SIGNED /S/ DONNIE JACKSON FOREPERSON. COURT DISCHARGES
JURY AT 5:23PM. COURT SETS MATTER FOR SENTENCING ON
JULY 10, 2017 AT 9:00AM. FURTHER, DEFT IS ADVISED THAT
CRIME IS AN 85% CRIME. SO ORDERED.
05-17-2017
RETURN OF ORIGINAL SUBPOENA - MARILEE THORNTON, SERVED
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
BY DANIELLE TAVANELLO ON MAY 17, 2017
05-17-2017
RETURN OF ORIGINAL SUBPOENA - OFFICER STEVEN YINGER,
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
NOT SERVED, DEOUTY JARVIS
05-17-2017
CERTIFICATION TO COURT CLERK
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
05-17-2017
AFFIDAVIT OF WITNESS ATTENDANCE AND STATE'S WITNESS
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
CLAIM, PAID BY STATE VOUCHER #5402
$ 85.20
05-17-2017
AFFIDAVIT OF WITNESS ATTENDANCE AND STATE'S WITNESS
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
CLAIM, PAID BY STATE VOUCHER #5403
$ 10.00
05-17-2017
AFFIDAVIT OF WITNESS ATTENDANCE AND STATE'S WITNESS
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
CLAIM, PAID BY STATE VOUCHER #5404
$ 24.10
05-17-2017
AFFIDAVIT OF WITNESS ATTENDANCE AND STATE'S WITNESS
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
CLAIM, PAID BY STATE VOUCHER #5405
$ 24.10
05-17-2017
AFFIDAVIT OF WITNESS ATTENDANCE AND STATE'S WITNESS
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
CLAIM, PAID BY STATE VOUCHER #5406
$ 24.10
05-17-2017
AFFIDAVIT OF WITNESS ATTENDANCE AND STATE'S WITNESS
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
CLAIM, PAID BY STATE VOUCHER #5407
$ 38.20
05-17-2017
AFFIDAVIT OF WITNESS ATTENDANCE AND STATE'S WITNESS
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
CLAIM, PAID BY STATE VOUCHER #5408
$ 62.64
05-17-2017
INSTRUCTIONS TO THE JURY AFTER TRIAL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
05-17-2017
QUESTION
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
See: http://www.oscn.net/dockets/GetCaseInformation.aspx?db=kay&number=CF-2016-00050&cmid=1211151
The State of Oklahoma charged Esther Lee Bales a/k/a Esther Lee Montgomery, age 56, with:
1. MURDER, 2ND DEGREE, AFC 2+ (FEL), in violation of 21 OS 701.8
2. OR IN THE ALTERNATIVE:
3. CHILD NEGLECT AFC OF TWO OR MORE FEL.
The State claimed that Bales was responsible for the drowning death of four-year-old Haley Primeaux on July 27, 2015 at the Lake Ponca Swim Beach.
Docket
Date Code Description Count Party Amount
01-27-2016
INFORMATION FELONY COUNT 1 (AMENDED 5/2/17)
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 103.00
. . .MURDER IN THE SECOND DEGREE, AFC 2/MORE
. . .OR IN THE ALTERNATIVE. . .
. . .CHILD NEGLECT, AFC 2/MORE
LAW LIBRARY FEE
$ 6.00
SHERIFF ARREST FEE
$ 5.00
CLEET
$ 9.00
AFIS
$ 5.00
STATE TREASURERS FORENSIC FEE
$ 5.00
10% OF AFS5
$ 0.50
10% OF CLT9
$ 0.90
10% OF FORE
$ 0.50
MEDICAL EXPENSE LIABILITY REVOLVING FUND
$ 10.00
10% OF MLRF
$ 1.00
OKLAHOMA COURT INFORMATION SYSTEM FEE - EFFECTIVE 07/01/04
$ 25.00
DA PROSECUTION FEE-FELONY
$ 25.00
10% OF DARF
$ 2.50
SHERIFF SERVICE FEE-COURTHOUSE SECURITY SUB ACCOUNT
$ 10.00
10% OF COURTHOUSE SECURITY FEE
$ 1.00
ATTORNEY GENERAL VICTIM SERVICES UNIT
$ 3.00
10% OF AG VICTIM SERVICES FEE
$ 0.30
CHILD ABUSE MULTIDISCIPLINARY ACCOUNT
$ 3.00
10% OF CAMA FEE
$ 0.30
01-27-2016
AFFIDAVIT
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
01-27-2016
WARRANT ISSUED WITH BOND ENDORSED AT $150,000
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 50.00
OKLAHOMA COURT INFORMATION SYSTEM FEE
$ 25.00
01-27-2016
AMENDED INFORMATION
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
01-28-2016
RETURN OF ORIGINAL FELONY WARRANT - JAILED
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
01-28-2016
CM:TURNER JAH
CAUSE COMES ON FOR INITIAL APPEARANCE. COURT ORDERS
BOND REMAIN AS PREVIOUSLY SET AND SETS MATTER FOR
INITIAL APPEARANCE ON FEBRUARY 5, 2016 AT 9:00AM. SEE
COURT MINUTE.
01-28-2016
PROBABLE CAUSE AND/OR INITIAL APPEARANCE MINUTE/ORDER
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
(COPY TO DEPUTY FOR DEFT IN KSO)
02-05-2016
CM:TURNER JAH
CAUSE COMES ON FOR INITIAL APPEARANCE. INITIAL
APPEARANCE IS HELD. COURT ORDERS BOND REMAIN AS
PREVIOUSLY SET. COURT SETS MATTER FOR ATTORNEY STATUS
REVIEW ON FEBRUARY 12, 2016 AT 10:00AM. SEE COURT
MINUTE.
02-05-2016
PROBABLE CAUSE AND/OR INITIAL APPEARANCE MINUTE/ORDER
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
(COPY TO DEPUTY FOR DEFT IN KSO)
02-11-2016
CM:BROCK KLG
CAUSE COMES ON FOR ATTY STATUS REVIEW. DEFT APPLIES FOR
COURT APPOINTED COUNSEL. COURT APPROVES AND APPOINTS
COUNSEL, HEIDI BAIER. COURT SETS MATTER FOR STATUS
DOCKET ON MARCH 4, 2016 AT 2:00 P.M. DEFT IS TO APPEAR
AT 10:30 A.M. TO MEET WITH COUNSEL. FURTHER, COURT
ORDERS DEFT IS ORDERED TO APPEAR FOR ATTY CONFERENCE ON
FEBRUARY 26, 2016 AT 1:00 P.M. SEE COURT MINUTE.
02-11-2016
COURT MINUTE/ORDER (COPY SENT TO JAIL FOR DEFT)
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
02-11-2016
APPLICATION FOR APPOINTED COUNSEL AND AFFIDAVIT OF
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 40.00
FINANCIAL INABILITY TO EMPLOY COUNSEL (O.I.D.S. ATTY)
03-03-2016
CM:TURNER MKT
CAUSE COMES ON STATUS DOCKET. DUE TO UNAVAILABLE OF
DEFT'S ATTY HEIDI BAIER OIDS. IT IS THE ORDER OF THE
COURT THAT MATTER (S) ARE CONTINUED TO STATUS DOCKET OF
APRIL 1, 2016 AT 2:00 PM. SEE COURT MINUTE
03-03-2016
COURT MINUTE/ORDER (COPY SENT TO JAIL FOR DEFT)
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
04-01-2016
CM:BANDY MKT
CAUSE COMES ON STATUS DOCKET. PARTIES APPEAR. COURT
SETS MATTER FOR PRELIMINARY HEARING ON JULY 13, 2016 AT
10:00 AM. SEE COURT MINUTE
04-01-2016
COURT MINUTE/ORDER (DEFT SIGNED MINUTE)
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
05-18-2016
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE AND REQUEST FOR LAW ENFORCEMENT
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
REPORTS
06-07-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE BY SHERIFF
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 50.00
TO SERVE:CHARLES BOTTGER
OKLAHOMA COURT INFORMATION SYSTEM ASSESSMENT
$ 25.00
06-07-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE BY SHERIFF
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 50.00
TO SERVE:ELAINE PRIMEAUX
OKLAHOMA COURT INFORMATION SYSTEM ASSESSMENT
$ 25.00
06-07-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE BY SHERIFF
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 50.00
TO SERVE:ROLF CLEMENTS
OKLAHOMA COURT INFORMATION SYSTEM ASSESSMENT
$ 25.00
06-07-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE:STEVEN YINGER PCPD
(POSTAGE $.48) RUNNING TOTAL $.48
06-07-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE:TRISTAN FITZSIMMONS PCPD
(MULTIPLE MAILING)
06-07-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE:CHAD VANHOESEN PCPD
(MULTIPLE MAILING)
06-07-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE:BRIAN DYE PCPD
(MULTIPLE MAILING)
06-09-2016
RETURN OF ORIGINAL SUBPOENA -SERVING ROLF CLEMENTS ON
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
6-8-16 BY KSO TIM PETERS
06-09-2016
RETURN OF ORIGINAL SUBPOENA -SERVING ELAINE PRIMEAUX ON
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
6-8-16 BY KSO TIM PETERS
06-15-2016
RETURN OF ORIGINAL SUBPOENA -CHARLES BOTTGER WAS NOT
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
SERVED
06-16-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE: THELMA KNOWLEN, ARKANSAS CITY, KANSAS
(POSTAGE $.48) RUNNING TOTAL $.96
06-16-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE: BILLIE JEAN KNOWLEN, WICHITA KANSAS
(POSTAGE $.48) RUNNING TOTAL $1.44
06-16-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE: KENTON HARDEE, WICHITA KANSAS
(MULTIPLE MAILING)
06-28-2016
MOTION TO ENDORSE ADDITION WITNESS(ES)/ORDER
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
06-30-2016
STATE'S NOTICE OF INTENT TO OFFER MEDICAL EXAMINER'S
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
REPORT AS EVIDENCE
07-08-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED TO STATE
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
TO SERVE: CHARLES LEE BOTTGER
07-08-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE:DEANNA LINDER, DHS
(POSTAGE $.48) RUNNING TOTAL $1.92
07-08-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE:DANIELLE WEGNER, DHS
(POSTAGE $.48) RUNNING TOTAL $2.40
07-13-2016
RETURN OF ORIGINAL SUBPOENA - CHARLES BOTTGER SERVED
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
7/13/16 BY CHRIS EDWARDS
07-13-2016
CM:TURNER KLG
COURT REPORTER FEE: SHERRIE POWELL
$ 10.00
OKLAHOMA COURT INFORMATION SYSTEM ASSESSMENT
$ 12.50
COURT REPORTER FEE SPLIT WITH CO-DEFT
CAUSE COMES ON FOR PRELIMINARY HRG IN CF-16-50 (BALES)
AND CF-16-51 (JACKSON). DEFT ESTHER BALES APPEARS IN
PERSON AND WITH COUNSEL, SCOTT LOFTIS. DEFT WANITA
JACKSON APPEARS IN PERSON AND WITH COUNSEL, JARROD
STEVENSON. STATE APPEARS BY D.A. BRIAN HERMSON AND
ASS'T D.A. SHAWNA TAYLOR. RULE OF SEQUESTRATION
INVOKED. PARTIES ANNOUNCE READY. STATE'S WITNESS,
ELAINE PRIMEAUX, SWORN. TESTIMONY GIVEN. WITNESS
EXCUSED. STATE'S WITNESS, BILLIE KNOWLEN, SWORN.
TESTITMONY GIVEN. WITNESS EXCUSED. COURT RECESSES AT
11:59 A.M. COURT RESUMES AT 1:03 P.M. ALL PARTIES ARE
PRESENT AND ANNOUNCE READY. STATE'S WITNESS, KENTON
HARDEE, SWORN. TESTIMONY GIVEN. WITNESS EXCUSED.
STATE'S WITNESS, ROLF CLEMENTS, SWORN. TESTIMONY GIVEN.
WITNESS EXCUSED. STATE'S WITNESS, TRISTAN FITZSIMMONS
(PCPD), SWORN. TESTIMONY GIVEN. WITNESS EXCUSED. COURT
RECESSES AT 2:04 P.M. COURT RESUMES AT 2:28 P.M. ALL
PARTIES ARE PRESENT AND ANNOUNCE READY. STATE'S
WITNESS, STEVEN YINGER (PCPD), SWORN. TESTIMONY GIVEN.
WITNESS EXCUSED. STATE'S WITNESS, CHAD VANHOESEN
(PCPD), SWORN. TESTIMONY GIVEN. WITNESS EXCUSED.
PARTIES STIPULATE TO THE ANTICIPATED TESTIMONY OF
STATE'S WITNESS DEANNA LINDER. STATE'S WITNESS, BRIAN
DYE (PCPD), SWORN. STATE'S EXHIBITS 1-3, ADMITTED
WITHOUT OBJECTION. STATE'S EXHIBIT 4, ADMITTED OVER
BOTH DEFT'S OBJECTIONS. TESTIMONY GIVEN. WITNESS
EXCUSED. COURT RECESSES AT 3:48 P.M. COURT RESUMES AT
4:00 P.M. ALL PARTIES ARE PRESENT AND PARTIES ANNOUNCE
READY. STATE'S WITNESS, CHARLES LEE BOTTGER, SWORN.
TESTIMONY GIVEN. WITNESS EXCUSED. PARTIES TO PRESENT
ARGUMENT ON JULY 19, 2016 AT 11:00 A.M. COURT RECESSES
AT 4:30 P.M.
07-14-2016
CERTIFICATION TO COURT CLERK
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
07-14-2016
AFFIDAVIT OF WITNESS ATTENDANCE AND STATE'S WITNESS
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
CLAIM, PAID BY STATE VOUCHER #5274
$ 5.00
(SPLIT WITH CO-DEFT)
07-14-2016
AFFIDAVIT OF WITNESS ATTENDANCE AND STATE'S WITNESS
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
CLAIM, PAID BY STATE VOUCHER #5275
$ 5.00
(SPLIT WITH CO-DEFT)
07-14-2016
AFFIDAVIT OF WITNESS ATTENDANCE AND STATE'S WITNESS
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
CLAIM, PAID BY STATE VOUCHER #5276
$ 48.20
(SPLIT WITH CO-DEFT)
07-14-2016
AFFIDAVIT OF WITNESS ATTENDANCE AND STATE'S WITNESS
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
CLAIM, PAID BY STATE VOUCHER #5277
$ 13.10
(SPLIT WITH CO-DEFT)
07-14-2016
AFFIDAVIT OF WITNESS ATTENDANCE AND STATE'S WITNESS
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
CLAIM, PAID BY STATE VOUCHER #5278
$ 13.10
(SPLIT WITH CO-DEFT)
07-14-2016
AFFIDAVIT OF WITNESS ATTENDANCE AND STATE'S WITNESS
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
CLAIM, PAID BY STATE VOUCHER #5279
$ 5.00
(SPLIT WITH CO-DEFT)
07-19-2016
CM:TURNER KLG
COURT REPORTER FEE: SHERRIE POWELL
$ 10.00
OKLAHOMA COURT INFORMATION SYSTEM ASSESSMENT
$ 12.50
COURT REPORTER FEE SPLIT WITH CO-DEFT
CAUSE COMES ON FOR CONTINUATION OF PRELIMINARY HRG IN
CF-16-50 (BALES) AND CF-16-51 (JACKSON). DEFT BALES
APPEARS IN PERSON AND WITH COUNSEL, SCOTT LOFTIS. DEFT
JACKSON APPEARS IN PERSON AND WITH COUNSEL, JARROD
STEVENSON. STATE APPEARS BY D.A. BRIAN HERMANSON.
PARTIES ANNOUNCE READY. RULE OF SEQUESTRATION
PREVIOUSLY INVOKED. STATE'S EXHIBITS 5,8,10, ADMITTED
WITHOUT OBJECTION. STATE'S EXHIBITS 6,7, ADMITTED OVER
OBJECTION OF LOFTIS. STATE RESTS. LOFTIS MAKES ARGUMENT
AS TO THE LOWERING OF BOND IN REGARDS TO DEFT BALES AND
ENTERS GENERAL AND SPECIFIC DEMURRER AS TO EACH COUNT.
STEVENSON ENTERS GENERAL AND SPECIFIC DEMURRER AS TO
EACH COUNT. STATE MAKES ARGUMENT AS TO DEMURRERS AND
BOND REDUCTION. AS TO BOTH DEFT'S JACKSON AND BALES,
COURT BINDS OVER AS PREVIOUSLY CHARGED. DEFT'S DO NOT
WAIVE 30 DAYS. COURT SETS MATTERS FOR FORMAL
ARRAIGNMENT ON AUGUST 15, 2016 AT 9:00 A.M. FURTHER, AS
TO BOND REDUCTION FOR DEFT BALES, COURT ORDERS BOND
LOWERED TO $75,000 OVER STATE'S OBJECTION. SEE COURT
MINUTE.
07-19-2016
COURT MINUTE/ORDER (DEFT SIGNED MINUTE)
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
07-19-2016
JOURNAL ENTRY AFTER PRELIMINARY EXAMINATION
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
08-15-2016
CM:ROSS JAH
CAUSE COMES ON FOR FORMAL ARRAIGNMENT. ARRAIGNMENT IS
HELD. COURT SETS MATTER FOR PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE ON
OCTOBER 14, 2016 AT 11:00AM AND SETS MATTER FOR THE
FELONY TRIAL SCHEDULING DOCKET ON NOVEMBER 9, 2016 AT
9:00AM. SEE COURT MINUTE.
08-15-2016
COURT MINUTE/ORDER (DEFT SIGNED MINUTE)
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
08-15-2016
FELONY TRIAL SCHEDULING ORDER
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
10-14-2016
STATE OF OKLAHOMA'S PRELIMINARY WITNESS AND EXHIBIT
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
LIST
11-09-2016
CM:ROSS KD
CAUSE COMES ON FOR JURY TRIAL SCHEDULING DOCKET. THE
COURT SETS MATTER FOR JURY TRIAL ON JURY TRIAL ON
JANUARY 24, 2017 AT 9:00 AM. SEE COURT MINUTE.
11-09-2016
COURT MINUTE/ORDER (COPY SENT TO JAIL FOR DEFT)
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
12-16-2016
REQUEST FOR DISCOVERY AND BRIEF IN SUPPORT
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
12-16-2016
SECOND AMENDED INFORMATION
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
12-20-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE: DEANNA LINDER, DHS
(POSTAGE $.48) RUNNING TOTAL $2.88
12-20-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE: DANIELLE WEGNER, DHS
(POSTAGE $.48) RUNNING TOTAL $3.36
12-20-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE: JOE ALLEN
(POSTAGE $.48) RUNNING TOTAL $3.84
12-20-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE: BEAU SPARKS
(POSTAGE $.48) RUNNING TOTAL $4.32
12-20-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE: STEPHEN LONG, PCFD
(POSTAGE $.48) RUNNING TOTAL $4.80
12-20-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE: BRIAN DYE, PCPD
(POSTAGE $.48) RUNNING TOTAL $5.28
12-20-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE: TRISTAN FITZSIMMONS, PCPD
(MULTIPLE MAILING)
12-20-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE: CHAD VANHOESEN, PCPD
(MULTIPLE MAILING)
12-20-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE: STEVEN YINGER, PCPD
(MULTIPLE MAILING)
12-20-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE BY SHERIFF
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 50.00
TO SERVE: ROLF ALLEN CLEMENTS
OKLAHOMA COURT INFORMATION SYSTEM ASSESSMENT
$ 25.00
12-20-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE BY SHERIFF
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 50.00
TO SERVE: ELAINE ELENOR PRIMEAUX
OKLAHOMA COURT INFORMATION SYSTEM ASSESSMENT
$ 25.00
12-20-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE BY SHERIFF
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 50.00
TO SERVE: DR. EDWARD SCOVILL
OKLAHOMA COURT INFORMATION SYSTEM ASSESSMENT
$ 25.00
12-20-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE ISSUED FOR STATE CERT MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE: CHARLES LEE BOTTGER
92148969009997901201654396
(POSTAGE $5.12) RUNNING TOTAL $10.40
12-20-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE ISSUED FOR STATE CERT MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE: DWAYNE CALLISON
92148969009997901201654464
(POSTAGE $5.12) RUNNING TOTAL $15.52
12-20-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE ISSUED FOR STATE CERT MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE: KENTON LEON HARDEE
92148969009997901201654501
(POSTAGE $5.12) RUNNING TOTAL OVER $10
12-20-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE ISSUED FOR STATE CERT MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE: BILLIE JEAN KNOWLEN
92148969009997901201654563
(POSTAGE $5.12) RUNNING TOTAL OVER $10
12-20-2016
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE ISSUED FOR STATE CERT MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE: CLAY NICHOLS, MD
92148969009997901201654587
(POSTAGE $5.12) RUNNING TOTAL OVER $10
12-23-2016
STATE OF OKLAHOMA'S SECOND PRELIMINARY WITNESS AND
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
EXHIBIT LIST
12-28-2016
RETURN RECEIPT OF CERTIFIED MAIL - DATED:12-24-16
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
SIGNED BY:DWAYNE CALLISON
12-28-2016
RETURN RECEIPT OF CERTIFIED MAIL - DATED:12-22-16
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
SIGNED BY:THELMA KNOWLEN FOR KENTON LEON HARDEE
12-28-2016
RETURN RECEIPT OF CERTIFIED MAIL - DATED:12-22-16
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
SIGNED BY:THELMA KNOWLEN FOR BILLIE JEAN KNOWLEN
12-28-2016
RETURN RECEIPT OF CERTIFIED MAIL - DATED:12-22-16
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
SIGNED BY:RENEE STEWART FOR CLAY NICHOLS M.D.
12-30-2016
NOTICE OF DISCOVERY COMPLIANCE
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
12-30-2016
RETURN OF ORIGINAL SUBPOENA -SERVING ELAINE ELENOR
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
PRIMEAUX ON 12-26-16 BY LEWAIN LEARNED
12-30-2016
RETURN OF ORIGINAL SUBPOENA -NOT SERVING EDWARD
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
SCOVILL BY LEWAIN LEARNED
01-05-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED TO STATE
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
TO SERVE: DR. EDWARD SCOVILL
01-09-2017
RETURN OF ORIGINAL SUBPOENA -ROLF CLEMENTS SERVED
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
1-6-17 BY KSO LEWAIN LEARNED
01-09-2017
TRANSCRIPT OF BEGINNING OF PRELIMINARY HEARING
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
01-09-2017
CONTINUED SCANNING
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
DATE/COURT REPORTER: 07-3-16/SHERRIE POWELL
ORIGINAL AND 2 COPIES (SCANNING TRANSFERED TO CO DEFT
CF-16-51)
01-10-2017
STATE OF OKLAHOMA'S THIRED PRELIMINARY WITNESS AND
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
EXHIBIT LIST
01-10-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED TO STATE
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
TO SERVE: CHARLES BOTTGER
01-11-2017
ORDER FOR TRANSCRIPT
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
EST. COSTS OF TRANSCRIPT
$ 75.00
01-11-2017
RETURN OF ORIGINAL SUBPOENA - SERVED EDWARD SCOVILL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
BY CHRIS EDWARDS DA OFFICE
01-17-2017
CM:ROSS MKT
CAUSE COMES ON FOR SCHEDULIG. BY AGREEMENT OF PARTIES.
COURT SETS MATTER FOR JURY TRIAL ON MAY 16, 2017 AT
9:00 AM. WITH PRE TRIAL CONFERENCE SET FOR APRIL 21,
2017 AT 9:00 AM. SEE COURT MINUTE
01-17-2017
COURT MINUTE/ORDER (COPY SENT TO JAIL FOR DEFT)
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
01-18-2017
RETURN OF ORIGINAL SUBPOENA - CHARLES LEE BOTTGER,
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
NOT SERVED, CHRIS EDWARDS
01-18-2017
RETURN RECEIPT OF CERTIFIED MAIL - DATED: 01/10/17
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
SIGNED BY: NOT LEGIBLE FOR CHARLES BOTTGER
01-19-2017
NOTICE OF FILING
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
01-19-2017
TRANSCRIPT OF CONCLUSION OF PRELIMINARY HEARING AND
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
ESTHER BALES MOTION FOR BOND REDUCTION
HRG DATE/COURT REPORTER: 07/19/16 SHERRIE POWELL
ORIGINAL AND ONE COPY IN CASE NUMBER CF-16-50
ONE COPY IN CASE NUMBER CF-16-51
03-09-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE BY SHERIFF
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 50.00
TO SERVE:ROLF ALLEN CLEMENTS
OKLAHOMA COURT INFORMATION SYSTEM ASSESSMENT
$ 25.00
03-09-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE BY SHERIFF
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 50.00
TO SERVE:EDWARD SCOVILL DR.
OKLAHOMA COURT INFORMATION SYSTEM ASSESSMENT
$ 25.00
03-09-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE:STEVEN YINGER
(POSTAGE $.48) RUNNING TOTAL OVER $10
03-09-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE:TRISTAN FITZSIMMONS
(MULTIPLE MAILING)
03-09-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE:CHAD VANHOESEN
(MULTIPLE MAILING)
03-09-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE:BRIAN DYE
(MULTIPLE MAILING)
03-09-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE:ELAINE ELENOR PRIMEAUX
(POSTAGE $.48) RUNNING TOTAL OVER $10
03-09-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE:BEAU SPARKS
(POSTAGE $.48) RUNNING TOTAL OVER $10
03-09-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE:DANIELLE WEGNER
(POSTAGE $.48) RUNNING TOTAL OVER $10
03-09-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE:JOE ALLEN
(POSTAGE $.48) RUNNING TOTAL OVER $10
03-09-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE:DEANNA JANETTE LINDER
(POSTAGE $.48) RUNNING TOTAL OVER $10
03-09-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
TO SERVE:STEPHEN LONG
(POSTAGE $.48) RUNNING TOTAL OVER $10
03-09-2017
FEE ADJUSTMENT-NOT ALL MAILING FEES PREVIOUSLY ASSESSED
$ 23.28
03-09-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE ISSUED FOR STATE CERT MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
(OUT OF COUNTY)
TO SERVE: BILLIE KNOWLEN
9214 8969 0099 9790 1201 9423 94
(POSTAGE $5.26) RUNNING TOTAL OVER $10
$ 5.26
03-09-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE ISSUED FOR STATE CERT MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
(OUT OF COUNTY)
TO SERVE: CLAY NICHOLS M.D., CHIEF MEDICAL EXAMINER
9214 8969 0099 9790 1201 9426 22
(POSTAGE $5.26) RUNNING TOTAL OVER $10
$ 5.26
03-09-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE ISSUED FOR STATE CERT MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
(OUT OF COUNTY)
TO SERVE: CHARLES BOTTGER
9214 8969 0099 9790 1201 9426 39
(POSTAGE $5.26) RUNNING TOTAL OVER $10
$ 5.26
03-09-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE ISSUED FOR STATE CERT MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
(OUT OF COUNTY)
TO SERVE: KENTON HARDEE
9214 8969 0099 9790 1201 9427 76
(POSTAGE $5.26) RUNNING TOTAL OVER $10
03-09-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE ISSUED FOR STATE CERT MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
(OUT OF COUNTY)
TO SERVE: DWAYNE CALLISON
9214 8969 0099 9790 1201 9428 37
(POSTAGE $5.26) RUNNING TOTAL OVER $10
03-13-2017
RETURN OF ORIGINAL SUBPOENA -SERVING EDWARD SCOVILL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
ON 3-10-17 BY KSO TIM PETERS
03-13-2017
RETURN OF ORIGINAL SUBPOENA - SERVING ROLF CLEMENTS
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
ON 3-10-17 BY KSO TIM PETERS
03-15-2017
RETURN RECEIPT OF CERTIFIED MAIL - DATED:3-11-17
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
SIGNED BY:NOT LEDGIBLE
03-22-2017
RETURN RECEIPT OF CERTIFIED MAIL - DATED:3-14-17
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
SIGNED BY:KENTON HARDEE FOR SAME
03-22-2017
RETURN RECEIPT OF CERTIFIED MAIL - DATED:3-13-17
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
SIGNED BY:P.PEDIGO FOR CLAY NICHOLS
03-22-2017
RETURN RECEIPT OF CERTIFIED MAIL - DATED:3-14-17
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
SIGNED BY:KENTON HARDEE FOR BILLIE KNOWLEN
04-13-2017
RETURN RECEIPT OF CERTIFIED MAIL - DATED:4-6-17
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
SIGNED BY:GAIL BROOKSHIRE
04-21-2017
FEE ADJUSTMENT ON TRANSCRIPT ESTIMATE...CC
$ -75.00
04-21-2017
PD SHERRIE POWELL CL 715A VO 35985A; PH 7/19/17 IN BOTH
$ 57.75
DEFTS. CF-16-50 AND CF-16-51 . AND HRG 7/13/17
$ 344.75
05-02-2017
3RD AMENDED INFORMATION
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
05-03-2017
NOTICE OF INTENT TO USE EVIDENCE OF OTHER CRIMES
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
05-03-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED TO STATE
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
(OUT OF COUNTY)
TO SERVE: CHARLES BOTTGER
05-03-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED BY MAIL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 10.00
(OUT OF COUNTY)
TO SERVE: DWAYNE CALLISON
(POSTAGE $.48) RUNNING TOTAL OVER $10
$ 0.48
05-04-2017
DEFT'S LIST OF WITNESSES AND EXHIBITS
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
05-05-2017
STATE OF OKLAHOMA'S FOURTH PRELIMINARY WITNESS AND
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
EXHIBIT LIST
05-05-2017
RETURN OF ORIGINAL SUBPOENA -CHARLES BOTTHER SERVED
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
ON 5-3-17 BY RON TEEL
05-09-2017
DEFT'S OBJECTION AND DAUBERT MOTION TO EXCLUDE THE
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
STATE'S EVIDENCE OF OTHER CRIMES AS STATED IN THE
STATE'S NOTICE OF INTENT
05-11-2017
STATE'S RESPONSE TO DEFT'S OBJECTION AND DAUBERT MOTION
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
TO EXCLUDE THE STATE'S EVIDENCE OF OTHER CRIMES AS
STATED IN THE STATE'S NOTICE OF INTENT
05-15-2017
SUBPOENA ISSUED FOR DEFENDANT TO SHERIFF
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
$ 50.00
TO SERVE: OFFICER STEVEN YINGER
OKLAHOMA COURT INFORMATION SYSTEM ASSESSMENT
$ 25.00
05-16-2017
CM:ROSS JAH REPORTER: LEA MCBRIDE
COURT REPORTER FEE
$ 20.00
OKLAHOMA COURT INFORMATION SYSTEM ASSESSMENT
$ 25.00
CAUSE COMES ON FOR JURY TRIAL. STATE APPEARS BY
DISTRICT ATTORNEY, BRIAN HERMANSON AND ASS'T DA SHAWNA
TAYLOR. DEFT APPEARS IN PERSON AND WITH COUNSEL, SCOTT
LOFTIS. COURT GOES ON RECORD AT 8:54AM, OUT OF PRESENCE
OF POTENTIAL JURORS TO HEAR ARGUMENT ON STATE'S NOTICE
OF INTENT TO USE EVIDENCE OF OTHER CRIMES. STATE MAKES
ARGUMENT IN SUPPORT. DEFT RESPONDS. STATE RESPONDS.
COURT ORDERS EVIDENCE WILL BE ABLE TO COME IN DURING
TRIAL. POTENTIAL JURY ENTERS COURTROOM AT 9:17AM. COURT
GIVES OPENING STATEMENTS TO POTENTIAL JURORS. CLERK
SWEARS POTENTIAL JURORS VOIR DIRE. CLERK CALLS THE
NAMES OF 22 POTENTIAL JURORS. COURT BEGINS VOIR DIRE OF
POTENTIAL JURORS. COURT PASSES THE JURY FOR CAUSE.
STATE BEGINS VOIR DIRE OF POTENTIAL JURORS. COURT TAKES
RECESS AT 10:34AM. COURT GOES BACK ON RECORD AT 10:49AM
WITH POTENTIAL JURORS SEATED. STATE PASSES THE JURY FOR
CAUSE. DEFT BEGINS VOIR DIRE OF POTENTIAL JURORS. DEFT P
PASSES THE JURY FOR CAUSE. PARTIES EXERCISE PREEMPTORY
CHALLENGES OUT OF PRESENCE OF POTENTIAL JURORS. COURT
GOES BACK ON RECORD IN OPEN COURT AT 11:43AM AND
EXCUSES POTENTIAL JURORS NOT SELECTED DURING PREEMPTORY
CHALLENGES. JURY IS SWORN TO TRY CAUSE. COURT TAKES
LUNCH RECESS AT 11:46AM. COURT GOES BACK ON RECORD AT
1:12PM WITH JURY SEATED. COURT READS OPENING
INSTRUCTIONS TO JURY. STATE READS INFORMATION TO JURY
AND GIVES OPENING STATEMENT. RESTS. DEFT GIVES OPENING
STATEMENT. RESTS. STATE CALLS WITNESS, ELAINE PRIMEAUX.
SWORN. STATE EVOKES RULE OF SEQUESTRATION. TESTIMONY
GIVEN. STATE OFFERS EXHIBIT 1. ADMITTED. PUBLISHED.
WITNESS EXCUSED. STATE CALLS WITNESS, KENTON HARDEE.
SWORN. TESTIMONY GIVEN. WITNESS EXCUSED. STATE CALLS
WITNESS, DR. EDWARD SCOVILL. SWORN. TESTIMONY GIVEN.
WITNESS EXCUSED. STATE CALLS WITNESS, ROLF CLEMENTS.
SWORN. TESTIMONY GIVEN. WITNESS EXCUSED. COURT TAKES
AFTERNOON RECESS AT 2:33PM. COURT GOES BACK ON RECORD
AT 2:48PM WITH JURY SEATED. STATE CALLS WITNESS, DWAYNE
CALLISON. WITNESS EXCUSED. COURT TAKES RECESS AT 2:55PM.
COURT GOES BACK ON RECORD AT 3:17PM WITH JURY SEATED.
STATE CALLS WITNESS, OFFICER TRISTAN FITZSIMMONS.
SWORN. TESTIMONY GIVEN. WITNESS EXCUSED. STATE CALLS
WITNESS, OFFICER STEVEN YINGER. SWORN. TESTIMONY GIVEN.
WITNESS EXCUSED. STATE CALLS WITNESS, STEPHEN LONG.
SWORN. TESTIMONY GIVEN. WITNESS EXCUSED. COURT IS
ADJOURNED FOR THE DAY AT 4:10PM.
05-16-2017
INSTRUCTIONS TO THE JURY BEFORE TRIAL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
05-17-2017
CAUSE COMES ON FOR CONTINUATION OF JURY TRIAL. COURT
GOES BACK ON RECORD AT 9:06AM WITH JURY SEATED. PARTIES
ANNOUNCE READY. STATE CALLS WITNESS, CHARLES BOTTGER.
SWORN. TESTIMONY GIVEN. WITNESS EXCUSED. STATE CALLS
WITNESS, DR. CLAY NICHOLS. SWORN. TESTIMONY GIVEN.
STATE OFFERS EXHIBIT 25. ADMITTED. WITNESS EXCUSED.
STATE CALLS WITNESS, SGT. BRIAN DYE. SWORN. TESTIMONY
GIVEN. STATE OFFERS EXHIBIT 20. ADMITTED. PUBLISHED.
STATE OFFERS EXHIBIT 2. ADMITTED. PUBLISHED. STATE
OFFERS EXHIBIT 3. ADMITTED. PUBLISHED. STATE OFFERS
EXHIBIT 4. ADMITTED. PUBLISHED. STATE OFFERS EXHIBIT
24. ADMITTED. PUBLISHED. STATE OFFERS EXHIBIT 21.
ADMITTED. PUBLISHED. STATE OFFERS EXHIBITS 22 AND 23.
ADMITTED. PUBLISHED. WITNESS EXCUSED. STATE CALLS
WITNESS, DEANNA LINDER. SWORN. TESTIMONY GIVEN. STATE
OFFERS EXHIBIT 5. ADMITTED. PUBLISHED. STATE OFFERS
EXHIBITS 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18
AND 19. ADMITTED. PUBLISHED. WITNESS EXCUSED. STATE
RESTS. JURY IS EXCUSED FOR LUNCH AT 10:55AM. OUT OF
PRESENCE OF JURY, DEFT ENTERS BOTH GENERAL AND SPECIFIC
DEMURRER AND OFFERS ARGUMENT IN SUPPORT. OVERRULED.
DEFT UNDERSTANDS RIGHT TO TESTIFY AND CHOOSES NOT TO.
COURT GOES OFF RECORD AT 10:58AM.
05-17-2017
SUBPOENA IN CRIMINAL CASE FOR STATE ISSUED TO STATE
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
TO SERVE: MARILEE THORNTON, OR DESIGNEE
05-17-2017
CAUSE COMES ON FOR CONTIUANCE OF JURY TRIAL. COURT GOES
BACK ON RECORD AT 1:03PM WITH JURY SEATED. COURT FINDS
THAT THERE ARE NO OBJECTIONS TO JURY INSTRUCTIONS. THE
COURT READS FINAL INSTRUCTIONS. STATE GIVES CLOSING
STATEMENTS. DEFENSE GIVES CLOSING STATEMENTS. STATE
REBUTTLES. CLOSING ARGUEMENTS CONCLUDED. BALIFF IS
SWORN AND JURORS EXCUSED TO RETIRE TO DELIBERATION.
COURT IN RECESS AT 2:30PM. COURT RECONVINES AT 3:43PM
WITH JURORS AND VERDICT. THE VERDICT WHICH READS AS
FOLLOWS: WE THE JURY, EMPANELED AND SWORN IN IN THE
ABOVE ENTITLED CAUSE DO UPON OUR OATHS, IN COUNT ONE
MURDER IN THE 2ND DEGREE AFC FIND THE DEFT GUILTY
SIGNED /S/ DONNIE JACKSON FOREPERSON. JURY IS EXCUSED
COURT RECESS AT 3:55PM. COURT RECONVINES AT 4:18PM ON
RECORD WITH JURY SEATED. STATE CALLS MARILEE THORNTON, A
AS AN 4OFFICER OF THE COURT WITNESS NOT SWORN IN AND
TESTIMONY GIVEN. STATE OFFERS EXHIBITS 26-30 OFFERED
AND ADMITTEDWITHOUT OBJECTION. COURT READS FINAL
INSTRUCTION TO JURY TO RENDER VERDICT. STATE GIVES
CLOSING ARUGMENTS. DEFENSE GIVE CLOSING ARGUMENTS.
STATE GIVES FINAL CLOSING ARGUEMENT. JURORS EXCUSED TO
DELIBERATION. COURT RECESSES AT 4:42PM. COURT
RECONVINES AT 5:01PM WITH JURORS AND VERDICT. THE COURT
FINDS THAT PUNISHSMENT HAS NOT BEEN ESTABLISHED AND
EXCUSES JURORS BACK TO DELIBERATION. COURT RECESSES AT
5:02PM. COURT RECONVINES AT 5:20PM WITH JURORS AND
VERDICT WICH READS AS FOLLOWS: WE THE JURY, EMPANELED
AND SWORN IN THE ABOVE ENTITLED CAUSE DO UPON OUR
OATHS, FIND AS FOLLOWS: DEFT IS GUILT OF THE CRIME OF
MURDER IN THE SECOND DEGREE AFTER TWO (2) OR MORE
PREVIOUS CONVICTIONS AND FIX PUNISHMENT AT 30 YEARS
SIGNED /S/ DONNIE JACKSON FOREPERSON. COURT DISCHARGES
JURY AT 5:23PM. COURT SETS MATTER FOR SENTENCING ON
JULY 10, 2017 AT 9:00AM. FURTHER, DEFT IS ADVISED THAT
CRIME IS AN 85% CRIME. SO ORDERED.
05-17-2017
RETURN OF ORIGINAL SUBPOENA - MARILEE THORNTON, SERVED
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
BY DANIELLE TAVANELLO ON MAY 17, 2017
05-17-2017
RETURN OF ORIGINAL SUBPOENA - OFFICER STEVEN YINGER,
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
NOT SERVED, DEOUTY JARVIS
05-17-2017
CERTIFICATION TO COURT CLERK
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
05-17-2017
AFFIDAVIT OF WITNESS ATTENDANCE AND STATE'S WITNESS
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
CLAIM, PAID BY STATE VOUCHER #5402
$ 85.20
05-17-2017
AFFIDAVIT OF WITNESS ATTENDANCE AND STATE'S WITNESS
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
CLAIM, PAID BY STATE VOUCHER #5403
$ 10.00
05-17-2017
AFFIDAVIT OF WITNESS ATTENDANCE AND STATE'S WITNESS
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
CLAIM, PAID BY STATE VOUCHER #5404
$ 24.10
05-17-2017
AFFIDAVIT OF WITNESS ATTENDANCE AND STATE'S WITNESS
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
CLAIM, PAID BY STATE VOUCHER #5405
$ 24.10
05-17-2017
AFFIDAVIT OF WITNESS ATTENDANCE AND STATE'S WITNESS
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
CLAIM, PAID BY STATE VOUCHER #5406
$ 24.10
05-17-2017
AFFIDAVIT OF WITNESS ATTENDANCE AND STATE'S WITNESS
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
CLAIM, PAID BY STATE VOUCHER #5407
$ 38.20
05-17-2017
AFFIDAVIT OF WITNESS ATTENDANCE AND STATE'S WITNESS
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
CLAIM, PAID BY STATE VOUCHER #5408
$ 62.64
05-17-2017
INSTRUCTIONS TO THE JURY AFTER TRIAL
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
05-17-2017
QUESTION
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
See: http://www.oscn.net/dockets/GetCaseInformation.aspx?db=kay&number=CF-2016-00050&cmid=1211151
Outcome:
05-17-2017
VERDICT COUNT 1- MURDER IN THE SECOND DEGREE, GUILTY
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
05-17-2017
VERDICT COUNT 1- CHILD NEGLECT, NOT GUILTY
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
05-17-2017
VERDICT (SECOND STAGE) COUNT 1- MURDER ON THE SECOND
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
DEGREE
05-17-2017
JURY SLIP
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
VERDICT COUNT 1- MURDER IN THE SECOND DEGREE, GUILTY
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
05-17-2017
VERDICT COUNT 1- CHILD NEGLECT, NOT GUILTY
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
05-17-2017
VERDICT (SECOND STAGE) COUNT 1- MURDER ON THE SECOND
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
DEGREE
05-17-2017
JURY SLIP
Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
Plaintiff's Experts:
Defendant's Experts:
Comments:
About This Case
What was the outcome of State of Oklahoma v. Esther Lee Bales a/k/a Esther Lee Mo...?
The outcome was: 05-17-2017 VERDICT COUNT 1- MURDER IN THE SECOND DEGREE, GUILTY Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office 05-17-2017 VERDICT COUNT 1- CHILD NEGLECT, NOT GUILTY Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office 05-17-2017 VERDICT (SECOND STAGE) COUNT 1- MURDER ON THE SECOND Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office DEGREE 05-17-2017 JURY SLIP Pursuant to 12 O.S. § 39, Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
Which court heard State of Oklahoma v. Esther Lee Bales a/k/a Esther Lee Mo...?
This case was heard in District Court, Kay County, Oklahoma, OK. The presiding judge was Phillip A. Ross.
Who were the attorneys in State of Oklahoma v. Esther Lee Bales a/k/a Esther Lee Mo...?
Plaintiff's attorney: Brian Hermanson. Defendant's attorney: Scott Loftis.
When was State of Oklahoma v. Esther Lee Bales a/k/a Esther Lee Mo... decided?
This case was decided on May 19, 2017.