Please E-mail suggested additions, comments and/or corrections to Kent@MoreLaw.Com.

Help support the publication of case reports on MoreLaw

Michael Beloyianis and Virginia Beaton, individually and on behalf of the Estate of Edward Beloyianis, deceased, v. Presbyterian Hospital/Columbia University Medical Center and Dr. David P. Roye, Jr.

Date: 05-30-2015

Case Number: 014121/2004

Judge: Howard H. Serman

Court: Supreme Court, Bronx County, New York

Plaintiff's Attorney: Evan Torgan

Defendant's Attorney: ELLENBERG & PARTNERS, L.L.P. and MARTIN,CLEARWATER & BELL, L.L.P.

Description:
Bronx, NY - Michael Beloyianis and Virginia Beaton, individually and on behalf of the Estate of Edward Beloyianis, deceased, v. Presbyterian Hospital/Columbia University Medical Center and Dr. David P. Roye, Jr. on medical negligence (medical malpractice) theories claiming that their son was paralyzed as a result of improper placement of four screws placed in his spine during surgery to correct his scoliosis in 2002. Edward died at age 22 while attending college.



Defendants denied wrongdoing.



Court Docket Entries:



05/27/2015 Supreme Trial Verdict For Plaintiff HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 VERDICT RECORDED

3:10PM

05/26/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 DELIBERATING

10:00AM ROOM 413

05/21/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:15AM ROOM 413

05/20/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

05/19/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:15AM ROOM 413

05/18/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

05/15/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

05/13/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

05/12/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

05/08/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

05/07/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:00 ROOM 413

05/06/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

05/05/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

05/01/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

04/30/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

04/28/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

04/27/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

04/23/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

04/22/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

04/21/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

04/17/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

04/15/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

04/14/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

04/13/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

04/10/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

04/08/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

04/07/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

04/01/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

10:00AM ROOM 413

03/31/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

03/30/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

10:00AM ROOM 413

03/26/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

12:00PM ROOM 413

03/25/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

03/24/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

10:00AM ROOM 413

03/19/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

03/18/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

11:00AM ROOM 413

03/16/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

10:00AM ROOM 413

03/13/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

03/10/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

03/09/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

10:00AM ROOM 413

03/06/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

03/03/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

02/26/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

02/25/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

02/24/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

02/19/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

02/18/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 7 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

02/17/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

02/11/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

02/10/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

02/06/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

02/05/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

01/30/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

01/27/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:15AM ROOM 413

01/21/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

01/20/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

01/16/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

01/15/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

01/14/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

01/13/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

10:00AM ROOM 413

01/09/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

10:00AM ROOM 413

01/08/2015 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

10:00AM ROOM 413

12/10/2014 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30 AM ROOM 413

12/08/2014 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

12/04/2014 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

10:30AM ROOM 413

12/03/2014 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

11/25/2014 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

10:00AM ROOM 413

11/21/2014 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 JURY TRIAL

9:30AM ROOM 413

11/20/2014 Supreme Trial Jury Trial Continued HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 JURY TRIAL COMMENCES10:00AM ROOM 413

11/18/2014 Supreme Trial Adjourned HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 CASE ON TRIAL

10:00AM ROOM 413

11/14/2014 Supreme Trial Adjourned HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4



11/12/2014 Supreme Trial Jury Select HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4



11/10/2014 Supreme Trial Jury Select HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4



11/07/2014 Supreme Trial Jury Select HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 JURY SELECTION

11:00AM ROOM 413

11/06/2014 Supreme Trial Jury Selection HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 JURY SELECTION

10:00AM ROOM 413

11/05/2014 Supreme Trial Jury Selection HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 JURY SELECTION

10:00AM ROOM 413

10/31/2014 Supreme Trial Jury Selection HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 JURY SELECTION

10:00AM ROOM 413

10/30/2014 Supreme Trial Jury Selection HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 JURY SELECTION

10:00AM ROOM 413

10/29/2014 Supreme Trial Jury Selection HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4 JURY SELECTION

CONTINUES AT 10:00AM

10/28/2014 Supreme Trial Jury Selection HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 4



10/28/2014 Supreme Trial Referred To Another Judge HOWARD H. SHERMAN

IA PART 5 AS PER JSC MCKEON



10/24/2014 Supreme Trial Jury Select ALISON Y. TUITT

IA PART 5



10/23/2014 Supreme Trial Jury Select ALISON Y. TUITT

IA PART 5



10/21/2014 Supreme Trial Jury Select ALISON Y. TUITT

IA PART 5



10/17/2014 Supreme Trial Jury Select ALISON Y. TUITT

IA PART 5



10/16/2014 Supreme Trial Jury Select ALISON Y. TUITT

IA PART 5



10/14/2014 Supreme Trial Status Conference Held ALISON Y. TUITT

IA PART 5 120 JURORS

24 ON STAND BY

10/09/2014 Supreme Trial Status Conference Held ALISON Y. TUITT

IA PART 5 5 ON STAND BY

5 ON CALL

10/08/2014 Supreme Trial Status Conference Held ALISON Y. TUITT

IA PART 5 94 JURORS

9 ON STAND BY

10/07/2014 Supreme Trial Jury Select ALISON Y. TUITT

IA PART 5 DAY 1



10/01/2014 Supreme Trial Status Conference Held ALISON Y. TUITT

IA PART 5 30 JURORS SCREENED

4 ON STAND BY

09/30/2014 Supreme Trial Status Conference Adjourned ALISON Y. TUITT

IA PART 5 95 JURORS SCREENED

16 ON STAND BY

09/29/2014 Supreme Trial Status Conference Adjourned ALISON Y. TUITT

IA PART 5 92 JURORS SCREENED

10 ON STAND BY

09/25/2014 Supreme Trial Status Conference Adjourned ALISON Y. TUITT

IA PART 5 44 JURORS SCREENED

3 ON STAND BY

09/24/2014 Supreme Trial Status Conference Held ALISON Y. TUITT

IA PART 5 109 JURORS SCREENED

17 ON STAND BY

09/23/2014 Supreme Trial Status Conference Adjourned ALISON Y. TUITT

IA PART 5 84 JURORS SCREENED

14 ON STAND BY

09/22/2014 Supreme Trial Status Conference Adjourned ALISON Y. TUITT

IA PART 5



09/16/2014 Supreme Trial Adjourned ALISON Y. TUITT

19A - FEDERAL GRANT



09/03/2014 Supreme Trial Adjourned DOUGLAS E. MCKEON - DM6

19A - FEDERAL GRANT



04/11/2014 Supreme Trial Adjourned DOUGLAS E. MCKEON - DM6

19A - FEDERAL GRANT



03/10/2014 Supreme Trial Adjourned DOUGLAS E. MCKEON - DM6

19A - FEDERAL GRANT



02/25/2014 Supreme Trial Adjourned DOUGLAS E. MCKEON - DM6

19A - FEDERAL GRANT



01/14/2014 Supreme Trial Adjourned DOUGLAS E. MCKEON - DM6

19A - FEDERAL GRANT



10/21/2013 Supreme Trial Status Conference Adjourned DOUGLAS E. MCKEON - DM6

19A - FEDERAL GRANT



09/20/2013 Supreme Trial Adjourned DOUGLAS E. MCKEON - DM6

19A - FEDERAL GRANT



07/08/2013 Supreme Trial Adjourned DOUGLAS E. MCKEON - DM6

19A - FEDERAL GRANT



06/14/2013 Supreme Trial Adjourned DOUGLAS E. MCKEON - DM6

19A - FEDERAL GRANT



04/05/2013 Supreme Trial Adjourned DOUGLAS E. MCKEON - DM6

19A - FEDERAL GRANT



02/22/2013 Supreme Trial Adjourned DOUGLAS E. MCKEON - DM6

19A - FEDERAL GRANT



02/05/2013 Supreme Trial Adjourned DOUGLAS E. MCKEON - DM6

19A - FEDERAL GRANT



11/15/2012 Supreme Trial Adjourned DOUGLAS E. MCKEON - DM6

19A - FEDERAL GRANT



10/30/2012 Supreme Trial Adjourned DOUGLAS E. MCKEON - DM6

19A - FEDERAL GRANT



07/17/2012 Supreme Trial Adjourned DOUGLAS E. MCKEON - DM6

19A - FEDERAL GRANT



03/19/2012 Motion Fully Submitted DOUGLAS E. MCKEON - DM6

SUBMISSION MOTIONS-ROOM 217- 19A

PER STIP 003

03/12/2012 Motion Adjourned DOUGLAS E. MCKEON - DM6

SUBMISSION MOTIONS-ROOM 217- 19A

PER STIP 003

03/05/2012 Motion Adjourned DOUGLAS E. MCKEON - DM6

SUBMISSION MOTIONS-ROOM 217- 19A

PER STIP 003

02/14/2012 Motion Adjourned DOUGLAS E. MCKEON - DM6

SUBMISSION MOTIONS-ROOM 217 19A

PER STIP 003

05/11/2011 Supreme Trial Adjourned LAURA G. DOUGLAS

CC SPEC.CONF.



03/18/2011 Supreme Trial Strike Frm Cal/Cont As Pre-N DOUGLAS E. MCKEON - DM6

SPECIAL TRIAL PART RBS



11/09/2010 Supreme Trial Pretrial Conference Adj STANLEY GREEN - STP

19A - FEDERAL GRANT 2;30



10/29/2010 Supreme Trial Adjourned DOUGLAS E. MCKEON - DM6

19A - FEDERAL GRANT MED MAL



10/01/2010 Supreme Trial Adjourned DOUGLAS E. MCKEON - DM6

19A - FEDERAL GRANT MED MAL



09/22/2010 Supreme Trial Adjourned DOUGLAS E. MCKEON - DM6

19A - FEDERAL GRANT MED MAL-FEDERAL

10:30AM

08/31/2010 Supreme Trial Adjourned DOUGLAS MCKEON

19A - FEDERAL GRANT MED MAL-FEDERAL

10:30AM

06/22/2010 Supreme Trial Adjourned STANLEY GREEN - STP

SPECIAL TRIAL PART



06/22/2010 Motion Motion Decided-Open Appearance STANLEY GREEN - STP

SPECIAL TRIAL PART, OSC

002

06/22/2010 Motion Adjourned STANLEY GREEN - STP

SPECIAL TRIAL PART, OSC

002

04/29/2010 Supreme Trial Adjourned HOWARD R. SILVER - STP

SPECIAL TRIAL PART



04/29/2010 Motion Adjourned HOWARD R. SILVER - STP

SPECIAL TRIAL PART, OSC

002

02/17/2010 Supreme Trial Adjourned HOWARD R. SILVER - STP

SPECIAL TRIAL PART



02/17/2010 Motion Adjourned HOWARD R. SILVER - STP

SPECIAL TRIAL PART, OSC

002

02/10/2010 Supreme Trial Adjourned HOWARD R. SILVER - STP

SPECIAL TRIAL PART



02/10/2010 Motion Adjourned HOWARD R. SILVER - STP

SPECIAL TRIAL PART, OSC

002

11/17/2009 Supreme Trial Adjourned STANLEY GREEN - STP

SPECIAL TRIAL PART



07/17/2009 Supreme Trial Adjourned STANLEY GREEN - STP

SPECIAL TRIAL PART



06/19/2009 Supreme Trial Adjourned HOWARD R. SILVER - STP

SPECIAL TRIAL PART



04/30/2009 Supreme Trial Adjourned HOWARD R. SILVER - STP

SPECIAL TRIAL PART



02/13/2009 Supreme Trial Pretrial Conference Held PAUL VICTOR (2)

PRE TRIAL CAL.



11/19/2008 Supreme Initial (first time on) Pretrial Conference Adj PAUL VICTOR (2)

PRE TRIAL CAL. NEW



05/31/2008 Supreme Trial Noi Filed Refer Back ALISON Y. TUITT (2)

TRACK.NO.APP. - OFFTR STIP S/



05/28/2008 Supreme Trial Status Conference Adjourned ALISON Y. TUITT (2)

TRACK.NO.APP. - OFFTR STIP S/O



01/29/2008 Supreme Initial (first time on) Adj.Notice-Served ALISON Y. TUITT (2)

CC SPEC.CONF. NEW



08/02/2006 Supreme Trial Compliance Conference Held ALISON Y. TUITT (2)

COMPLIANCE CAL. STATUS



04/10/2006 Supreme Trial Status Conference Held ALISON Y. TUITT (2)

COMPLIANCE CAL. STATUS



02/15/2006 Supreme Trial Status Conference Held ALISON Y. TUITT (2)

COMPLIANCE CAL. STATUS



10/14/2005 Supreme Trial Status Conference Held ALISON Y. TUITT (2)

COMPLIANCE CAL. STATUS



05/19/2005 Supreme Trial Compliance Conference Held NELSON S. ROMAN

COMPLIANCE CAL.



03/24/2005 Motion Motion Granted## LUCY A. BILLINGS 2

PRE.CONF.DISC.MO.

001

03/01/2005 Motion Adjourned LUCY A. BILLINGS 2

SUBMISSION MOTIONS-ROOM 217 06

001

10/28/2004 Supreme Trial Preliminary Conference Held NELSON S. ROMAN

PC CALENDAR



09/28/2004 Supreme Initial (first time on) Preliminary Conference Adjourn NELSON S. ROMAN

PC CALENDAR
Outcome:
Plaintiffs' verdict for $45.6 million.
Plaintiff's Experts:
Defendant's Experts:
Comments:

About This Case

What was the outcome of Michael Beloyianis and Virginia Beaton, individually and ...?

The outcome was: Plaintiffs' verdict for $45.6 million.

Which court heard Michael Beloyianis and Virginia Beaton, individually and ...?

This case was heard in Supreme Court, Bronx County, New York, NY. The presiding judge was Howard H. Serman.

Who were the attorneys in Michael Beloyianis and Virginia Beaton, individually and ...?

Plaintiff's attorney: Evan Torgan. Defendant's attorney: ELLENBERG & PARTNERS, L.L.P. and MARTIN,CLEARWATER & BELL, L.L.P..

When was Michael Beloyianis and Virginia Beaton, individually and ... decided?

This case was decided on May 30, 2015.