Please E-mail suggested additions, comments and/or corrections to Kent@MoreLaw.Com.

Help support the publication of case reports on MoreLaw

John Gary Butler v. Cynthia Prine

Date: 02-20-2015

Case Number: 2D14-2561

Judge: Per Curiam

Court: Florida Court of Appeal, Second District on appeal from the Circuit Court, Pinellas County

Plaintiff's Attorney: Toni Butler of Alderuccio & Butler, LLC, Naples, for Appellant.

Defendant's Attorney: Kathy Welsh of KM Welsh, P.A., Largo, for Appellee.

Description:
John Gary Butler appeals a "supplemental final judgment" that was

entered in a postdissolution proceeding that resolved several postjudgment motions and

petitions that had been filed on his behalf, as well as on behalf of his former wife,

Cynthia Prine. Mr. Butler raises several issues concerning the trial court's findings,

rulings, and awards that are set forth in the supplemental final judgment. We affirm in

all respects without discussion except for $93,202.26 in attorney's fees that was

- 2 -

awarded to Ms. Prine. The evidence presented to the trial court justified a fee award of

some amount in this case. However, we are unconvinced that the trial court adequately

considered the reasonableness and necessity of all of the legal work underlying these

fees. Accordingly, we reverse only the award of attorney's fees and remand that matter

to permit the trial court to reconsider the award. On remand, the court is authorized to

receive evidence in addition to the evidence in this record.



Outcome:
Affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded.
Plaintiff's Experts:
Defendant's Experts:
Comments:

About This Case

What was the outcome of John Gary Butler v. Cynthia Prine?

The outcome was: Affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded.

Which court heard John Gary Butler v. Cynthia Prine?

This case was heard in Florida Court of Appeal, Second District on appeal from the Circuit Court, Pinellas County, FL. The presiding judge was Per Curiam.

Who were the attorneys in John Gary Butler v. Cynthia Prine?

Plaintiff's attorney: Toni Butler of Alderuccio & Butler, LLC, Naples, for Appellant.. Defendant's attorney: Kathy Welsh of KM Welsh, P.A., Largo, for Appellee..

When was John Gary Butler v. Cynthia Prine decided?

This case was decided on February 20, 2015.