Please E-mail suggested additions, comments and/or corrections to Kent@MoreLaw.Com.
Help support the publication of case reports on MoreLaw
Janelle Carlton v. Safeco Insurance Company of Illinois, et al.
Date: 02-12-2026
Case Number: 4:25-cv-00042
Judge: John D. Russell
Court: United States District Court for the Northern District of Oklahoma (Tulsa County)
Plaintiff's Attorney: Daniel Patrick Molloy
Defendant's Attorney: David Charles Senger and David Charles Senger
Description:
Tulsa, Oklahoma, insurance law lawyer represented the Plaintiff who sued on a bad faith breach of insurance contract theory.
In Oklahoma, bad faith breach of an insurance contract occurs when an insurer unreasonably denies, delays, or undervalues a legitimate claim, or fails to investigate it properly, violating their legal duty of good faith and fair dealing
. Insured parties can sue for contract damages plus punitive damages and emotional distress, as established by the Oklahoma Supreme Court.
Key aspects of Oklahoma bad faith insurance law:
Definition: It is a separate tort claim (not just a contract breach) arising when an insurer acts dishonestly or violates the spirit of the insurance policy.
Examples: Examples include failing to investigate promptly, making unreasonably low "lowball" settlement offers, and misrepresenting policy language.
Requirements to Prove: The insured must prove that a covered loss occurred, the insurer was required to pay, the refusal was unreasonable, and the insurer did not act in good faith.
Damages: Successful claims can recover the full value of the original claim, compensation for emotional distress, attorney fees, and punitive damages.
Applicability: This duty applies to both first-party (your own insurer) and third-party (someone else’s liability insurer) claims.
Statutory Updates: As of November 1, 2025, new laws regarding health insurance prohibit insurers from reserving sole discretion to interpret contracts, adding to existing common law protections.
For specific legal advice, consulting an Oklahoma-based insurance attorney is recommended.
In Oklahoma, bad faith breach of an insurance contract occurs when an insurer unreasonably denies, delays, or undervalues a legitimate claim, or fails to investigate it properly, violating their legal duty of good faith and fair dealing
. Insured parties can sue for contract damages plus punitive damages and emotional distress, as established by the Oklahoma Supreme Court.
Key aspects of Oklahoma bad faith insurance law:
Definition: It is a separate tort claim (not just a contract breach) arising when an insurer acts dishonestly or violates the spirit of the insurance policy.
Examples: Examples include failing to investigate promptly, making unreasonably low "lowball" settlement offers, and misrepresenting policy language.
Requirements to Prove: The insured must prove that a covered loss occurred, the insurer was required to pay, the refusal was unreasonable, and the insurer did not act in good faith.
Damages: Successful claims can recover the full value of the original claim, compensation for emotional distress, attorney fees, and punitive damages.
Applicability: This duty applies to both first-party (your own insurer) and third-party (someone else’s liability insurer) claims.
Statutory Updates: As of November 1, 2025, new laws regarding health insurance prohibit insurers from reserving sole discretion to interpret contracts, adding to existing common law protections.
For specific legal advice, consulting an Oklahoma-based insurance attorney is recommended.
Outcome:
Unknown
Plaintiff's Experts:
Defendant's Experts:
Comments:
About This Case
What was the outcome of Janelle Carlton v. Safeco Insurance Company of Illinois, ...?
The outcome was: Unknown
Which court heard Janelle Carlton v. Safeco Insurance Company of Illinois, ...?
This case was heard in United States District Court for the Northern District of Oklahoma (Tulsa County), OK. The presiding judge was John D. Russell.
Who were the attorneys in Janelle Carlton v. Safeco Insurance Company of Illinois, ...?
Plaintiff's attorney: Daniel Patrick Molloy. Defendant's attorney: David Charles Senger and David Charles Senger.
When was Janelle Carlton v. Safeco Insurance Company of Illinois, ... decided?
This case was decided on February 12, 2026.