Please E-mail suggested additions, comments and/or corrections to Kent@MoreLaw.Com.

Help support the publication of case reports on MoreLaw

Date: 08-26-2007

Case Number: 268482

Judge: Unknown

Court: Michigan Court of Appeals on appeal from the Circuit Court of Ottawa County

Plaintiff's Attorney: Unknown

Defendant's Attorney: Unknown

Description:

Plaintiffs Faargsob, L.L.C. (Faargsob) and Auto Sports Unlimited, Inc. (Auto Sports)1
entered into a contract with defendant Holland Transmission Services, Inc. (Holland
Transmission)2 for the purchase of an automotive transmission service business. Under the terms
of the contract, plaintiff Suzanne Bosgraaf, as trustee of the Suzanne Lee Bosgraaf Trust, agreed
to purchase real property from defendant HTSTS L.L.C. (HTSTS). HTSTS is a holding
company that leased land and equipment to Holland Transmission. Defendants Terry and Scott
Joldersma owned both HTSTS and Holland Transmission.


Terry and Scott Joldersma operated Holland Transmission. The business enjoyed healthy
sales and growth. Terry Joldersma and Scott Bosgraaf entered into an informal dialogue
regarding the sale of the business. Bosgraaf determined the value of the business from three
years of Holland Transmission's tax returns (1998 to 2000). Terry Joldersma rejected Bosgraaf's
initial offer of $2,000,000, making a counteroffer of $3,300,000. Terry Joldersma forwarded
additional financial statements, which demonstrated substantial growth in sales. Bosgraaf
adjusted his previous valuation calculation, and made an offer of $2,654,579, which was
accepted. Among other things, the purchase agreement included non-compete covenants to be
executed by Terry and Scott Joldersma.


Bosgraaf assumed control of Holland Transmission in November 2001. However, he left
the Joldersmas' management team in place. Bosgraaf learned of some inventory irregularities in
early 2002, which prompted an internal investigation. Bosgraaf then discovered that the
Joldersmas made certain adjustments at the end of the year on their inventory that were not
relevant to any transaction. Bosgraaf was suspicious, and he noted that a "balancing account"
had increased almost $500,000 over a two-year period. Bosgraaf began to question the
information on which he had based his valuation of the business.


After the sale, Scott Joldersma went to work for one of Bosgraaf's other businesses,
which rebuilt automatic transmissions. He worked for Bosgraaf until February 2003, when
Bosgraaf laid him off. Thereafter, Scott Joldersma worked for other mechanic shops and also
started his own general repair shop. Bosgraaf learned of Scott Joldersma's business activities,
and plaintiffs sent Scott Joldersma a notice stating that he was in breach of the covenant not to
compete.


Plaintiffs filed an amended complaint, alleging various counts of breach of contract,
unjust enrichment, fraudulent misrepresentation, innocent misrepresentation, and breach of the
covenant not to compete. A number of the counts were dismissed during pretrial proceedings.
However, trial proceeded on the remaining seven counts: (1) breach of contract for failure to pay
a special assessment, (2) breach of contract for overstating sales, (3) breach of contract for
overstating expenses, (4) an alternate count of breach of contract for overstating expenses, (5)
breach of contract for overstating costs, (6) breach of contract for overstating inventory, and (7)
breach of a covenant not to compete. The jury found that defendants were obligated to pay the
special assessment. But it also found that defendants were not liable for providing inaccurate tax
returns and financial statements, for overstating costs and expenses, or for overstating inventory.
The jury further found that defendant Scott Joldersma had breached the non-compete covenant
by engaging in transmission repair work, but that plaintiffs were not entitled to withhold the
amounts payable to defendant Scott Joldersma. The jury awarded plaintiffs damages in the
amount of $200,000.


Defendant Scott Joldersma moved for JNOV with respect to the jury's verdict concerning
the covenant not to compete. The trial court commented that "a jury just can't pull a number out
of the air," and it asked what evidence supported the jury's award of $200,000. Plaintiffs'
counsel contended that the competition caused "good will damage," and that there was testimony
regarding referrals to the businesses where Scott Joldersma was working. Plaintiffs' counsel also
asserted that there was evidence that Scott Joldersma had done independent repair work for one
of Holland Transmission's largest customers. The trial court ruled that "[t]here was no evidence
to support the jury verdict of $200,000 for breach of the covenant not to compete." The trial court noted that Scott Joldersma had merely performed "a job or two or three," causing minimal
damage to defendants. The trial court concluded:


[T]he record is devoid of any method by which the jury could calculate damages
in the amount of $200,000. And I am not going to enter [J]NOV. I am going to
order a new trial on that issue, which I think moots your - What you have left
with [plaintiffs'] claim for attorney fees at this point, is a $22,000 recovery and a
potential additional recovery if we retry the issue of the breach of a covenant not
to compete. And I am going to simply withhold ruling on your request for
attorney fees until the litigation is resolved.


Defendant Scott Joldersma then moved for partial reconsideration of the trial court's order
granting a new trial as to damages. On reconsideration, the trial court rescinded its order for a
new trial as to damages, and granted JNOV in favor of defendants with respect to this issue.

Plaintiffs then moved for JNOV, or in the alternative, for a new trial on the claim that
defendants had breached the contract by overstating expenses, costs, and inventory. Plaintiffs
argued that defendants had provided inaccurate information at the time of sale, which resulted in
an overpayment of $678,000. The trial court concluded that only one inference could logically
be made based on the jury's verdict: "The jury did not believe that plaintiffs met their burden of
proof on each of the elements of the cause of action." The trial court determined that the jury
had accepted the testimony of defendants' witnesses, and that there was accordingly sufficient
evidence to support the verdict on this claim. Thus, the trial court denied plaintiffs' motion for
JNOV or a new trial


* * *


The party asserting a breach of contract has the burden to prove his damages with
reasonable certainty, and may recover only those damages, which are the direct, natural and
proximate result of the breach. Alan Custom Homes, Inc v Krol, 256 Mich App 505, 512; 667
NW2d 379 (2003). When a plaintiff proves injury, recovery is not precluded simply because
proof of the amount of damages is not mathematically precise. Severn v Sperry Corp, 212 Mich
App 406, 415; 538 NW2d 50 (1995). However, damages that are based on speculation or
conjecture are not recoverable. Berrios v Miles, Inc, 226 Mich App 470, 478; 574 NW2d 677
(1997). A trial court should grant JNOV if the jury engaged in speculation in reaching its
damages determination. Kallabat v State Farm Mut Auto Ins Co, 256 Mich App 146, 151; 662
NW2d 97 (2003); Attard, supra at 321.

* * *

Outcome:
Affirmed.
Plaintiff's Experts:
Unknown
Defendant's Experts:
Unknown
Comments:
None

About This Case

What was the outcome of ?

The outcome was: Affirmed.

Which court heard ?

This case was heard in Michigan Court of Appeals on appeal from the Circuit Court of Ottawa County, MI. The presiding judge was Unknown.

Who were the attorneys in ?

Plaintiff's attorney: Unknown. Defendant's attorney: Unknown.

When was decided?

This case was decided on August 26, 2007.