Please E-mail suggested additions, comments and/or corrections to Kent@MoreLaw.Com.
Help support the publication of case reports on MoreLaw
Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. Jonovan Gonzalez
Date: 12-13-2024
Case Number: 23-P-851
Judge: Not Available
Court: Superior Court, Bristol County, Massachusetts
Plaintiff's Attorney: Bristol County, Massachusetts District Attorney's Office
Defendant's Attorney:
Click Here For The Best Taunton Criminal Defense Lawyer Directory
Description:
A grand jury indicted the defendant for murder, G. L. c. 265, § 1, and two firearms offenses.[1] The defendant moved to suppress (1) cell site location information (CSLI)[2] that police received in response to a warrantless request of the defendant's cell phone provider; and (2) evidence derived from the CSLI, namely, the location of the defendant's 2003 Toyota Corolla and various surveillance video recordings depicting the vehicle
driving on public roads. After hearing testimony from nine witnesses and considering numerous video recording, photographic, and documentary exhibits, a Superior Court judge allowed the motion. A single justice of the Supreme Judicial Court thereafter allowed the Commonwealth's application for leave to file the instant interlocutory appeal "limited to the issue of inevitable discovery." After review, we agree with the motion judge that the Commonwealth failed to establish that the car and video recordings inevitably would have been discovered.
* * *
Legal issue Can evidence obtained without a warrant be admitted under the inevitable discovery doctrine if the police would not have found it without unlawful evidence acquisition?
Key Phrases Warrantless request. Cell site location information. Motion to suppress. Inevitable discovery. Constitutional violation.
Taunton, Massachusetts criminal defense lawyer represented the Defendant charged with murder.
A grand jury indicted the defendant for murder, G. L. c. 265, § 1, and two firearms offenses.[1] The defendant moved to suppress (1) cell site location information (CSLI)[2] that police received in response to a warrantless request of the defendant's cell phone provider; and (2) evidence derived from the CSLI, namely, the location of the defendant's 2003 Toyota Corolla and various surveillance video recordings depicting the vehicle
driving on public roads. After hearing testimony from nine witnesses and considering numerous video recording, photographic, and documentary exhibits, a Superior Court judge allowed the motion. A single justice of the Supreme Judicial Court thereafter allowed the Commonwealth's application for leave to file the instant interlocutory appeal "limited to the issue of inevitable discovery." After review, we agree with the motion judge that the Commonwealth failed to establish that the car and video recordings inevitably would have been discovered.
* * *
Legal issue Can evidence obtained without a warrant be admitted under the inevitable discovery doctrine if the police would not have found it without unlawful evidence acquisition?
Key Phrases Warrantless request. Cell site location information. Motion to suppress. Inevitable discovery. Constitutional violation.
Outcome:
Affirmed
Plaintiff's Experts:
Defendant's Experts:
Comments:
About This Case
What was the outcome of Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. Jonovan Gonzalez?
The outcome was: Affirmed
Which court heard Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. Jonovan Gonzalez?
This case was heard in Superior Court, Bristol County, Massachusetts, MA. The presiding judge was Not Available.
Who were the attorneys in Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. Jonovan Gonzalez?
Plaintiff's attorney: Bristol County, Massachusetts District Attorney's Office. Defendant's attorney: Click Here For The Best Taunton Criminal Defense Lawyer Directory.
When was Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. Jonovan Gonzalez decided?
This case was decided on December 13, 2024.