Please E-mail suggested additions, comments and/or corrections to Kent@MoreLaw.Com.

Help support the publication of case reports on MoreLaw

Patrick D. McConnell; Mary Elizabeth McConnell v. Matin B. Stivers, et al.

Date: 01-20-2007

Case Number: 2004-CA-001835-MR

Judge: Miller

Court: Commonwealth of Kentucky Court of Appeals on appeal from the Circuit Court of Jefferson County

Plaintiff's Attorney:

Ray H. Stoess, Louisville, Kentucky for Martin B. Stivers, et al.


Harley N. Blankenship, Louisville, Kentucky for Donna Allgeier and Ronald Allgeier

Defendant's Attorney:

Michael L. Maple, Louisville, Kentucky

Description:

Patrick D. McConnell and Mary Elizabeth
McConnell appeal from a judgment of the Jefferson Circuit Court
which, as relevant to their appeal, (1) required them to remove
structures encroaching upon a tract of property owned by Martin
B. Stivers, Marion Patricia Stivers, William G. Norris, Jr., and
Angela Rosemary Norris (collectively Norris/Stivers) and a tract
of property owned by Ronald and Donna Allgeier, and (2) determined that they do not have an easement by implication to
use a driveway running between the McConnell and Norris/Stivers
properties. (Appeal No. 2004-CA-001835-MR). Norris/Stivers
cross-appeal the trial court's reduction of a jury verdict
awarding them $5,000.00 in punitive damages. (Appeal No. 2004-
CA-001894-MR). The McConnells also appeal and Norris/Stivers
cross-appeal the trial court's awarding of costs. (Appeal Nos.
2004-002213-MR and 2004-CA-002302-MR, respectively). For the
reasons stated below, we affirm upon the issues raised by the
McConnells in Appeal No. 2004-CA-001835-MR, and reverse upon the
issue raised by Norris/Stivers in Cross-Appeal No. 2004-CA-
001894-MR.


Because neither of the parties briefed the matter of
costs, we deem any arguments related to same to be abandoned.
Kentucky Rules of Civil Procedure (CR) 76.12(4)(c)(iii).

* * *

Outcome:
We reverse and remand in Appeal No. 2004-CA-002213-MR
for further proceedings consistent with this opinion.
Plaintiff's Experts:
Unknown
Defendant's Experts:
Unknown
Comments:
None

About This Case

What was the outcome of Patrick D. McConnell; Mary Elizabeth McConnell v. Matin B...?

The outcome was: We reverse and remand in Appeal No. 2004-CA-002213-MR for further proceedings consistent with this opinion.

Which court heard Patrick D. McConnell; Mary Elizabeth McConnell v. Matin B...?

This case was heard in Commonwealth of Kentucky Court of Appeals on appeal from the Circuit Court of Jefferson County, KY. The presiding judge was Miller.

Who were the attorneys in Patrick D. McConnell; Mary Elizabeth McConnell v. Matin B...?

Plaintiff's attorney: Ray H. Stoess, Louisville, Kentucky for Martin B. Stivers, et al. Harley N. Blankenship, Louisville, Kentucky for Donna Allgeier and Ronald Allgeier. Defendant's attorney: Michael L. Maple, Louisville, Kentucky.

When was Patrick D. McConnell; Mary Elizabeth McConnell v. Matin B... decided?

This case was decided on January 20, 2007.