Please E-mail suggested additions, comments and/or corrections to Kent@MoreLaw.Com.
Help support the publication of case reports on MoreLaw
Cathy L. Stroud v. Ozark National Life Insurance Co. and Stephen I. Guinn
Date: 03-01-2025
Case Number: 124,348
Judge: Stephen J. Ternes
Court: District Court, Sedgwick County, Oklahoma
Plaintiff's Attorney:
Click Here For The Best Wichita Insurance Law Lawyer Directory
Click Here For The Best Wichita Insurance Law Lawyer Directory
Defendant's Attorney: William E. Hanna
Description:
Wichita, Kansas insurance law lawyer represented the Plaintiff.
Cathy L. Stroud sued Ozark National Life Insurance Company and its agent and manager Stephen Guinn for negligent misrepresentation and breach of fiduciary duty after her husband, Alan Stroud, converted his term life insurance policy to a whole life policy that reduced the death benefit provided to her as the sole beneficiary
Legal issue Does an insurance agent owe a fiduciary duty to a policyholder and beneficiary when advising on converting a life insurance policy, and can negligent misrepresentation be claimed when an agent provides incomplete but not false information?
Headnote
INSURANCE LAW. REAL PARTY IN INTEREST. The case addresses whether a beneficiary of a life insurance policy can bring a lawsuit for breach of fiduciary duty and negligent misrepresentation without being the policy owner or representing the estate of the deceased policyholder.
INSURANCE LAW. BREACH OF FIDUCIARY DUTY. The court evaluates if an insurance agent owes a fiduciary duty to the policy beneficiary and policyholder, particularly when advising on policy changes, and determines that a special relationship must exist with conscious assumption of duty by the fiduciary.
INSURANCE LAW. NEGLIGENT MISREPRESENTATION. The court examines whether negligent misrepresentation claims require an affirmative false statement and not merely a failure to disclose certain information in the context of life insurance policy advice.
PROCEDURAL LAW. SUMMARY JUDGMENT STANDARD. The court reviews the application of summary judgment principles, emphasizing that summary judgment is proper if there is no genuine issue as to any material fact, focusing on facts related to the insurance agent's representations.
CIVIL PROCEDURE. PRESERVATION OF ISSUES. The court underscores the necessity for cross-petitions for review in preserving issues for appeal and analyzes the application of plain error doctrine in appellate review.
Key Phrases Breach of fiduciary duty. Negligent misrepresentation. Real party in interest. Summary judgment. Fiduciary relationship.
Cathy L. Stroud sued Ozark National Life Insurance Company and its agent and manager Stephen Guinn for negligent misrepresentation and breach of fiduciary duty after her husband, Alan Stroud, converted his term life insurance policy to a whole life policy that reduced the death benefit provided to her as the sole beneficiary
Legal issue Does an insurance agent owe a fiduciary duty to a policyholder and beneficiary when advising on converting a life insurance policy, and can negligent misrepresentation be claimed when an agent provides incomplete but not false information?
Headnote
INSURANCE LAW. REAL PARTY IN INTEREST. The case addresses whether a beneficiary of a life insurance policy can bring a lawsuit for breach of fiduciary duty and negligent misrepresentation without being the policy owner or representing the estate of the deceased policyholder.
INSURANCE LAW. BREACH OF FIDUCIARY DUTY. The court evaluates if an insurance agent owes a fiduciary duty to the policy beneficiary and policyholder, particularly when advising on policy changes, and determines that a special relationship must exist with conscious assumption of duty by the fiduciary.
INSURANCE LAW. NEGLIGENT MISREPRESENTATION. The court examines whether negligent misrepresentation claims require an affirmative false statement and not merely a failure to disclose certain information in the context of life insurance policy advice.
PROCEDURAL LAW. SUMMARY JUDGMENT STANDARD. The court reviews the application of summary judgment principles, emphasizing that summary judgment is proper if there is no genuine issue as to any material fact, focusing on facts related to the insurance agent's representations.
CIVIL PROCEDURE. PRESERVATION OF ISSUES. The court underscores the necessity for cross-petitions for review in preserving issues for appeal and analyzes the application of plain error doctrine in appellate review.
Key Phrases Breach of fiduciary duty. Negligent misrepresentation. Real party in interest. Summary judgment. Fiduciary relationship.
Outcome:
Summary judgment in favor of the Defendants.
Affirmed
Affirmed
Plaintiff's Experts:
Defendant's Experts:
Comments:
About This Case
What was the outcome of Cathy L. Stroud v. Ozark National Life Insurance Co. and ...?
The outcome was: Summary judgment in favor of the Defendants. Affirmed
Which court heard Cathy L. Stroud v. Ozark National Life Insurance Co. and ...?
This case was heard in District Court, Sedgwick County, Oklahoma, KS. The presiding judge was Stephen J. Ternes.
Who were the attorneys in Cathy L. Stroud v. Ozark National Life Insurance Co. and ...?
Plaintiff's attorney: Click Here For The Best Wichita Insurance Law Lawyer Directory. Defendant's attorney: William E. Hanna.
When was Cathy L. Stroud v. Ozark National Life Insurance Co. and ... decided?
This case was decided on March 1, 2025.