Please E-mail suggested additions, comments and/or corrections to Kent@MoreLaw.Com.

Help support the publication of case reports on MoreLaw

STATE OF KANSAS v. FILIBERTO B. ESPINOZA JR.

Date: 06-23-2020

Case Number: 118,737

Judge: Caleb Stegall

Court: SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF KANSAS

Plaintiff's Attorney: Lois Malin, assistant district attorney, Mark A. Dupree Sr., district attorney, and Derek Schmidt,

attorney general

Defendant's Attorney:

Need help finding a lawyer for representation for making an as-applied challenge to the constitutionality of a sentence under § 9 of the Kansas Constitution Bill of Rights has an obligation to ensure an adequate factual record is developed in district court in Kansas?



Call 918-582-6422. It's Free







Description:


















Premeditated first-degree murder, conspiracy to commit aggravated robbery, and attempted aggravated robbery











The State charged Filiberto B. Espinoza Jr. with one count of

premeditated first-degree murder, conspiracy to commit aggravated robbery, and

2attempted aggravated robbery for the killing of Louis Scherzer. During the trial,

Espinoza pleaded guilty to first-degree felony murder—an off-grid person felony

mandating a hard 25 sentence. See K.S.A. 2019 Supp. 21-5402(a)(2), (b); K.S.A. 2019

Supp. 21-6620(b)(1). But before sentencing, Espinoza challenged the constitutionality of

his hard 25 sentence as applied to the facts of his case under § 9 of the Kansas

Constitution Bill of Rights. The district court denied his challenge, finding the sentence

constitutional. Espinoza now challenges the district court's decision on direct appeal.

Before the district court, Espinoza acknowledged his offense mandated the hard 25

sentence. See K.S.A. 2019 Supp. 21-5402(a)(2), (b) (defining first-degree felony murder

as an off-grid person felony); K.S.A. 2019 Supp. 21-6620(b)(1) (stating that defendants

convicted of first-degree felony murder "shall not be eligible for parole prior to serving

25 years' imprisonment"). But before sentencing, he moved for a durational departure

arguing that this mandated sentence was unconstitutional as applied to him given the

facts of the case.

Espinoza continued to assert his constitutional claims orally at sentencing. He

argued that the three-pronged proportionality test announced in State v. Freeman, 223

Kan. 362, 367, 574 P.2d 950 (1978), required the district court to assess the specific facts

of his case to determine the constitutionality of his sentence under § 9 of the Kansas

Constitution Bill of Rights. Espinoza then listed facts from his case he believed weighed

in favor of granting a durational departure.

The district court denied this request, finding Espinoza's hard 25 sentence

constitutional:

3

"As both parties have acknowledged, the statute K.S.A. 21-6620 provides that the Court

should not make any suspension, modification, or reduction of the sentence. The Court is

bound by that statute and I have no reason to believe that it's unconstitutional. So the

defendant's motion to depart is denied."

In making this decision, the district court did not make any factual findings concerning

Espinoza's as-applied constitutional challenge. On appeal, Espinoza argues the district

court erred when it failed to make such findings. He requests a remand to the district

court to develop the necessary factual record.

Disproportionality challenges based on § 9 of the Kansas Constitution Bill of

Rights require both legal and factual inquiries. State v. Patterson, 311 Kan. __, 455 P.3d

792, 801 (2020). And a factual record is required for any meaningful appellate review.

455 P.3d at 801 ("'[A] challenge under § 9 of the Kansas Constitution Bill of Rights

generally cannot be raised for the first time on appeal because of the factual inquiries

involved.'"). We have repeatedly emphasized that it is the defendant's responsibility to

ensure the district court makes the factual findings necessary for appellate review. See,

e.g., 455 P.3d at 801-02 (stating that this court has "repeatedly emphasized" that the

defendant bears the responsibility of ensuring that the district court makes adequate

factual findings); State v. Cervantes-Puentes, 297 Kan. 560, 565, 303 P.3d 258 (2013)

(same); State v. Seward, 289 Kan. 715, Syl. ¶ 3, 217 P.3d 443 (2009) (same).

This responsibility goes beyond merely raising a constitutional claim. Our

decision in Seward controls the outcome here. There, as here, Seward filed a motion for a

downward departure and raised the constitutional claim at sentencing. The Seward court

recognized that Seward had—at least in part—preserved the issue by calling the district

court's attention to his constitutional challenge. 289 Kan. at 718. But his efforts "stopped

4

short of moving under Rule 165 to prompt the district judge to place specific findings of

fact and conclusions of law on the constitutional challenges in the record." 289 Kan. at

718-19. Although the unique circumstances of Seward's case led to a remand due to the

"newness of the constitutional issues," the Seward court precluded this remedy for future

litigants:

"We emphasize that we believe this case to be exceptional. In the future, a

defendant who wishes to appeal on the basis of a constitutional challenge to a sentencing

statute must ensure the findings and conclusions by the district judge are sufficient to

support appellate argument, by filing of a motion invoking the judge's duty under Rule

165, if necessary." 289 Kan. at 721.

We have enforced this rule consistently against other defendants. In State v. Reed,

300 Kan. 494, 332 P.3d 172 (2014), the defendant argued his hard 40 sentence violated

the Eighth Amendment to the United States Constitution and § 9 of the Kansas

Constitution Bill of Rights. The trial judge failed to make factual findings. And on

appeal, we rejected Reed's request for a remand:

"Reed ignores the fact that he neither objected to the judge's insufficient findings at the

hearing, nor subsequently filed a motion under Supreme Court Rule 165 (2013 Kan. Ct.

R. Annot. 265) or otherwise asked the sentencing judge to make factual findings.

. . . .

"Because of the factual components of Reed's arguments, Reed should have been

aware that he was responsible for making sure there were adequate findings on the

record. Having failed to do so, Reed's state and federal constitutional challenges fail, and

we affirm the sentencing judge's imposition of concurrent life sentences without the

possibility of parole for 40 years." 300 Kan. at 514.

5

The outcome must be the same here. Espinoza did not object to the district court's

failure to make factual findings at sentencing and he did not file a motion under Kansas

Supreme Court Rule 165 (2020 Kan. S. Ct. R. 215). Because Espinoza failed to meet this

obligation, his as-applied challenge to the constitutionality of his hard 25 sentence is not

amenable to appellate review.
Outcome:
Affirmed
Plaintiff's Experts:
Defendant's Experts:
Comments:

About This Case

What was the outcome of STATE OF KANSAS v. FILIBERTO B. ESPINOZA JR.?

The outcome was: Affirmed

Which court heard STATE OF KANSAS v. FILIBERTO B. ESPINOZA JR.?

This case was heard in SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF KANSAS, KS. The presiding judge was Caleb Stegall.

Who were the attorneys in STATE OF KANSAS v. FILIBERTO B. ESPINOZA JR.?

Plaintiff's attorney: Lois Malin, assistant district attorney, Mark A. Dupree Sr., district attorney, and Derek Schmidt, attorney general. Defendant's attorney: Need help finding a lawyer for representation for making an as-applied challenge to the constitutionality of a sentence under § 9 of the Kansas Constitution Bill of Rights has an obligation to ensure an adequate factual record is developed in district court in Kansas? Call 918-582-6422. It's Free.

When was STATE OF KANSAS v. FILIBERTO B. ESPINOZA JR. decided?

This case was decided on June 23, 2020.