Please E-mail suggested additions, comments and/or corrections to Kent@MoreLaw.Com.

Help support the publication of case reports on MoreLaw

Lonnie Lickley v. Max Herbold, Inc.

Date: 07-21-1999

Case Number: 24615

Judge: George Granata, Jr.

Court: Fifth Judicial District Court, Cassia County, Idaho

Plaintiff's Attorney: Donald J. Chisholm, Chisholm Law Office in Burley, Idaho

Defendant's Attorney: Richard K. Smith of Smith & Stone in Burley, Idaho

Description:

Breach of contract - Plaintiff, a potato farmer, entered into a contract with the defendant, a processor, to delivery 12,000 cwt. of potatoes. Price would vary by the quality and conformity of potatoes delivered.

Plaintiff delivered the agreed upon 12,000 cwt. of potatoes, defendant comingled those potatoes with other potatoes delivered over several days.

Defendant later said some potatoes were "rejected" and others accepted during that time period weren't of a high quality and wanted to pay a lower rate.

Outcome:

For plaintiff at reasonable market rate at the time.

Plaintiff's Experts:

Unknown

Defendant's Experts:

Unknown

Comments:

Note: Date shown above is the date of the appeal decision, not the original trial date. See: 984 P.2d 697 (Idaho 1999). -DJS

About This Case

What was the outcome of Lonnie Lickley v. Max Herbold, Inc.?

The outcome was: For plaintiff at reasonable market rate at the time.

Which court heard Lonnie Lickley v. Max Herbold, Inc.?

This case was heard in Fifth Judicial District Court, Cassia County, Idaho, ID. The presiding judge was George Granata, Jr..

Who were the attorneys in Lonnie Lickley v. Max Herbold, Inc.?

Plaintiff's attorney: Donald J. Chisholm, Chisholm Law Office in Burley, Idaho. Defendant's attorney: Richard K. Smith of Smith & Stone in Burley, Idaho.

When was Lonnie Lickley v. Max Herbold, Inc. decided?

This case was decided on July 21, 1999.