Please E-mail suggested additions, comments and/or corrections to Kent@MoreLaw.Com.

Help support the publication of case reports on MoreLaw

State of Florida v. Johnathan Ishmael Alcergaire

Date: 09-29-2018

Case Number: 2016CF000284A000XX

Judge: Jalal Harb

Court: Circuit Court, Polk County, Florida

Plaintiff's Attorney: Hope Pattey

Defendant's Attorney: Kevin Kohl

Description:








Bartow, FL - The State of Florida charged Johnathan Ishmael Alcergaire with three courts of first-degree murder and other charges for killing David Washington, age 24, Eneida "Stacy" Branch, age 31, and Angelica Castro, age 23, during a drug related robbery in 2016. All three were shot in the head.



Felix Campos, age 21, who survived a gun shot wound to his face testified that Alcergaire was involved in the murders.



Docket:



01/13/2016 AFFIDAVIT COMPLAINT FILED 6 1

01/13/2016 WARRANT ISSUED 1 2

01/15/2016 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 1/15/2016 0 3

Re: FAHR--FIRST APPEARANCE HEARING BY JESSESTR

01/15/2016 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 2/16/2016 0 4

Re: ARRG--ARRAIGNMENT BY JESSESTR

01/15/2016 WARRANT SERVED 1 5

01/15/2016 BOOKING SHEET 2 6

01/15/2016 FIRST APPEARANCE HEARING ORDER - 01/15/2016 2 7

01/19/2016 ASA of Record, PATTEY HOPE 0 8

01/19/2016 MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY 1 9

01/20/2016 NOTICE OF EXERCISE OF RIGHTS 1 10

01/25/2016 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 1/26/2016 /PER CINDY 0 11

Re: MOTN--HEARING ON ALL PENDING MOTIONS BY LUPEGUIJ

01/25/2016 NOTICE OF HEARING FILED 1 13

01/27/2016 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) 01/26/16 1 12

01/28/2016 CAPIAS ISSUED 1 14

01/28/2016 INDICTMENT FILED (CORRECTED FRONT PAGE) 7 15

01/28/2016 GRAND JURY INSTRUCTIONS 2 16

01/29/2016 NO BILL BY STATE ATTORNEY 1 17

02/01/2016 ORDER DENYING MOTION TO COMPEL DEFENDANT TO SUBMITT TO BUCCAL SWABS 2 18

02/02/2016 CAPIAS SERVED 01282016 1 19

02/03/2016 BOOKING SHEET 2 20

02/03/2016 DEMAND DISCLOSURE MATERIAL FAVORABLE TO DEFT 2 26

02/03/2016 DEMAND/NOTICE FOR DISCOVERY FILED 1 27

02/03/2016 WRITTEN PLEA OF NOT GUILTY 1 28

02/04/2016 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 2/4/2016 0 21

Re: FAHR--FIRST APPEARANCE HEARING BY SHANMART

02/04/2016 APD of Record, RODRIGUEZ TONMIEL 0 22

02/04/2016 FIRST APPEARANCE HEARING ORDER 2/4/16 2 23

02/04/2016 CAPIAS SERVED 1 24

02/04/2016 BOOKING SHEET 3 25

02/10/2016 AMENDED PLEA OF DEFT AND RESERVATION OF RIGHT TO CHALLENGE INDICTMENT 2 29

02/11/2016 TRIAL SUPPORT COST AFFIDAVIT 1 30

02/11/2016 AMENDED PLEA OF DEF AND RESERVATION OF RIGHT TO CHALLENGE INDICTMENT 2 31

02/15/2016 DELETE HEARING FOR THE DATE: 2/16/2016 0 32

Re: ARRG--ARRAIGNMENT BY LUPEGUIJ

02/15/2016 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 3/10/2016 /PER JOANNA 0 33

Re: STHR--STATUS HEARING BY LUPEGUIJ

02/16/2016 APPLICATION FOR SEARCH WARRANT /SEARCH WARRANT 6 34

02/16/2016 APPLICATION FOR SEARCH WARRANT /SEARCH WARRANT 7 35

02/16/2016 APPLICATION FOR SEARCH WARRANT /SEARCH WARRANT 6 36

02/16/2016 APPLICATION FOR SEARCH WARRANT /SEARCH WARRANT 7 37

02/16/2016 APPLICATION FOR SEARCH WARRANT /SEARCH WARRANT 7 38

02/16/2016 APPLICATION FOR SEARCH WARRANT /SEARCH WARRANT 7 39

02/16/2016 APPLICATION FOR SEARCH WARRANT /SEARCH WARRANT 10 40

02/16/2016 APPLICATION FOR SEARCH WARRANT /SEARCH WARRANT 9 41

02/16/2016 APPLICATION FOR SEARCH WARRANT /SEARCH WARRANT 10 42

02/16/2016 APPLICATION FOR SEARCH WARRANT /SEARCH WARRANT 10 43

02/16/2016 APPLICATION FOR SEARCH WARRANT /SEARCH WARRANT 10 44

02/16/2016 APPLICATION FOR SEARCH WARRANT /SEARCH WARRANT 6 45

02/16/2016 APPLICATION FOR SEARCH WARRANT /SEARCH WARRANT 11 46

02/25/2016 NOTICE OF INTENT TO SEEK DEATH PENALTY 1 47

03/03/2016 APD of Record, MILLS PETER NATHAN 0 48

03/04/2016 NOTICE OF ISSUANCE OF SUBPOENA FOR MED REC 1 49

03/04/2016 NOTICE OF ISSUANCE OF SUBPOENA FOR MED REC 1 50

03/11/2016 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) 03/10/16 1 51

03/11/2016 SPEEDY TRIAL WAIVED (ORALLY/FILED) 1 52

03/14/2016 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 5/12/2016 0 53

Reason: STHR--STATUS HEARING BY GINGGASH

03/28/2016 DEMAND RECIPROCAL DISCOVERY & NOTICE OF ALIBI 13 54

03/30/2016 NOTICE OF INTENT TO SEEK DEATH PENALTY AND DISCLOSURE OF AGGRAVATING FACTORS 2 55

05/13/2016 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) 05/12/16 1 56

05/18/2016 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 8/18/2016 0 57

Reason: STHR--STATUS HEARING BY EMYLSALA

05/18/2016 SUPPLEMENTAL DISCOVERY 29 58

05/23/2016 SUPPLEMENTAL DISCOVERY 1 59

05/25/2016 APPLICATION FOR SEARCH WARRANT /SEARCH WARRANT 7 60

05/27/2016 STATE WITNESS LIST 1 61

05/27/2016 APPLICATION FOR SEARCH WARRANT /SEARCH WARRANT 6 62

05/27/2016 APPLICATION FOR SEARCH WARRANT /SEARCH WARRANT 7 63

06/16/2016 STATE WITNESS LIST 1 64

06/23/2016 STATE WITNESS LIST 1 65

06/28/2016 SUPPLEMENTAL DISCOVERY 1 66

08/09/2016 SUPPLEMENTAL DISCOVERY 1 67

08/17/2016 STATE WITNESS LIST 1 68

08/22/2016 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) 08/18/16 1 69

08/22/2016 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 10/13/2016 0 70

Re: STHR--STATUS HEARING BY EMYLSALA

10/13/2016 APPLICATION FOR SEARCH WARRANT 3 71

10/13/2016 SEARCH WARRANT 4 72

10/18/2016 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) 10/13/16 1 73

10/18/2016 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 12/8/2016 0 74

Reason: STAT--STATUS CONFERENCE BY DIANLOMB

12/06/2016 NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION 2 76

12/06/2016 NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION 2 77

12/09/2016 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) 12/8/16 1 75

12/13/2016 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 3/9/2017 0 78

Re: STAT--STATUS CONFERENCE BY GINGGASH

01/06/2017 SUBPOENA SERVED 2 79

01/06/2017 SUBPOENA UNSERVED 2 80

01/06/2017 SUBPOENA UNSERVED 2 81

01/31/2017 ORDER WITHDRAWING AND APPOINTING COUNSEL (RC) COPIES SENT 1 82

01/31/2017 MOTION TO WITHDRAW AS COUNSEL 2 83

02/01/2017 NOTICE APPEARANCE OF COUNSEL (RC HILEMAN) 1 84

02/01/2017 DEMAND/NOTICE FOR DISCOVERY AND DISCLOSURE OF MATERIAL FAV TO DEFT 2 85

02/01/2017 WRITTEN PLEA OF NOT GUILTY AND RESERVATION OF RIGHT TO CHALLENGE GRAND JURY INDICTMENT 2 86

02/01/2017 MOTION TO WITHDRAW AS COUNSEL 3 87

02/03/2017 DELETE HEARING FOR THE DATE: 3/9/2017 0 88

Re: STAT--STATUS CONFERENCE BY LUPEGUIJ

02/03/2017 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 2/9/2017 /RSET PER CINDY 0 89

Re: STHR--STATUS HEARING BY LUPEGUIJ

02/06/2017 NOTICE APPEARANCE OF COUNSEL , WPNG, NOT OF DISCOVERY (CA CARMICHAEL) COPIES SENT 2 90

02/06/2017 MOTION TO APPOINT INVESIGATOR 2 92

02/06/2017 SUPPLEMENTAL DISCOVERY 1 93

02/06/2017 SUPPLEMENTAL DISCOVERY 1 94

02/06/2017 NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION 2 95

02/06/2017 NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION 2 96

02/07/2017 ORDER WITHDRAWING AND APPOINTING COUNSEL (CA CARMICHAEL) 1 91

02/08/2017 ORDER APPOINTING INVESTIGATOR & AUTHORIZING PAYMENT BY JUSTICE ADIMINSTRATIVE COMMISSION 3 97

02/09/2017 NOTICE OF PRIOR COMPLIANCE WITH DISCOVERY 1 99

02/10/2017 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) - 02/09/17 1 98

02/10/2017 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 4/6/2017 0 100

Reason: STHR--STATUS HEARING BY JUDYCHRI

02/28/2017 NOTICE OF SCHEDULING CONFLICT 1 101

03/27/2017 SUPPLEMENTAL DISCOVERY 1 102

04/03/2017 NOTICE OF CANCELLATION OF TAKING DEPO 1 103

04/04/2017 SUPPLEMENTAL DISCOVERY 1 104

04/06/2017 AMENDED NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION 2 107

04/07/2017 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) 4-6-17 1 105

04/10/2017 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 6/8/2017 0 106

Reason: STHR--STATUS HEARING BY JANEPHIL

04/10/2017 SUPPLEMENTAL DISCOVERY 1 108

04/21/2017 DEFT'S MOTION FOR STATEMENT OF PARTICULARS (SAO/CA) 2 109

04/21/2017 DEFENDANT MOTION TO DEMAND FOR THE STATES EVIDENCE FAVORABLE TO ACCUSED OR BRADY MAT (C:SAO/CA) 2 110

04/21/2017 DEFENDANT MOTION TO DEMAND TO SET PRETRIAL HEARINGTO CHALLENGE STATES ALLEGED EVIDENCE(C:SAO/CA) 3 111

04/26/2017 SUPPLEMENTAL DISCOVERY 3 112

05/05/2017 SUPPLEMENTAL DISCOVERY 1 113

05/15/2017 SUPPLEMENTAL DISCOVERY 2 114

05/31/2017 MOTION TO APPOINT SECOND CHAIR COUNSEL 2 115

05/31/2017 MOTION FOR CONTINUANCE OF STATUS 2 116

06/05/2017 ORDER FOR CONTINUANCE GRANTED 1 117

06/05/2017 DELETE HEARING FOR THE DATE: 6/8/2017 0 118

Reason: STHR--STATUS HEARING BY JOANMCCL

06/05/2017 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 7/13/2017 0 119

Reason: STHR--STATUS HEARING BY JOANMCCL

06/08/2017 MOTION TO INCUR COSTS FOR DEPOSITION TRANSCRIPT 2 120

06/13/2017 ORDER APOINTING SECOND CHAIR ATTORNEY (CA KOHL) 5 121

06/13/2017 ORDER AUTHORIZING THE DEFENSE TO INCUR COST FOR DEPOSITION TRANSCRIPT 1 122

06/13/2017 CORRESPONDENCE 2 123

06/14/2017 AMENDED ORDER APPOINTING SECOND CHAIR ATTORNEY 1 124

07/11/2017 SUPPLEMENTAL DISCOVERY 1 125

07/13/2017 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) 7-13-17 1 126

07/17/2017 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 10/12/2017 0 127

Reason: STHR--STATUS HEARING BY JANEPHIL

08/18/2017 DEFENDANT FIRST DISCOVERY DISCLOSURE FILED 2 128

09/28/2017 NOTICE OF HEARING FILED 1 129

09/28/2017 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 10/13/2017 0 130

Re: STHR--STATUS HEARING BY JULICLAR

09/29/2017 STATE WITNESS LIST 1 131

10/13/2017 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) 10/12/17 1 132

10/13/2017 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 12/14/2017 0 133

Reason: STHR--STATUS HEARING BY MIRIWEST

10/13/2017 SUPPLEMENTAL DISCOVERY 1 135

10/16/2017 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) 10-13-2017 1 134

12/13/2017 NOTICE 1 137

12/14/2017 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 12/20/2017 0 136

Re: STHR--STATUS HEARING BY SANDSMIT

12/15/2017 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) 12-14-2017 1 138

12/18/2017 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 12/19/2017 /PER CINDY 0 139

Re: STHR--STATUS HEARING BY LUPEGUIJ

12/18/2017 DELETE HEARING FOR THE DATE: 12/19/2017 /PER CINDY 0 140

Re: STHR--STATUS HEARING BY LUPEGUIJ

12/22/2017 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) 12-20-2017 1 141

12/22/2017 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 1/23/2018 0 142

Reason: STHR--STATUS HEARING BY KATHROBE

12/27/2017 MOTION TO INCUR ADDITIONAL COST 2 143

01/03/2018 NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION 2 144

01/03/2018 NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION 2 145

01/03/2018 NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION 2 146

01/03/2018 NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION 2 147

01/04/2018 ORDER AUTHORIZING THE DEFENSE TO INCUR ADDITIONAL COSTS FOR PRIVATE INVESTIGATOR 2 148

01/09/2018 AMENDED NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION - 2ND 2 149

01/11/2018 SUPPLEMENTAL DISCOVERY 2 150

01/11/2018 SUPPLEMENTAL DISCOVERY 1 151

01/12/2018 NOTICE OF FILING - DEPOSITION SUBUPEONA'S RETURN SERV 56 152

01/22/2018 MOTION TO REIMBURSE COSTS OF TRAVEL 2 153

01/23/2018 SUBPOENA SERVED 1 154

01/24/2018 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) 01/23/18 1 155

01/25/2018 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 2/16/2018 0 156

Re: STHR--STATUS HEARING BY EMYLSALA

01/30/2018 ORDER ON MOTION TO REIMBURSE COSTS OF TRAVEL 1 157

02/05/2018 NOTICE OF FILING - CERTIFICATE OF NON APPEARENCE -CANTRELL MANNING DET. JEAN JANVIER /EMILL HALL/ 8 158

02/06/2018 STATE WITNESS LIST 11 159

02/06/2018 SUPPLEMENTAL DISCOVERY 1 160

02/13/2018 SUBPOENA SERVED 3 161

02/19/2018 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) 02/16/18 1 162

02/21/2018 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 4/13/2018 0 163

Re: STHR--STATUS HEARING BY EMYLSALA

02/22/2018 MOTION TO COMPEL 1 164

02/28/2018 STATE WITNESS LIST 2 167

03/01/2018 NOTICE OF HEARING FILED 1 165

03/01/2018 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 3/9/2018 0 166

Re: MOTN--HEARING ON ALL PENDING MOTIONS BY JULICLAR

03/12/2018 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) 3/9/18 1 168

03/14/2018 NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION 2 169

04/13/2018 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 4/18/2018 0 170

Re: STHR--STATUS HEARING BY MELIMAXW

04/16/2018 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) 04/13/18 1 171

04/17/2018 DEMAND FOR SPEEDY TRIAL 1 172

04/18/2018 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 4/24/2018 0 173

Re: STHR--STATUS HEARING BY ESTHJEAN

04/23/2018 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) 4/18/18 1 174

04/23/2018 ORDER GRANTING MOTION TO SUBMIT TO BUCCAL SWABS 1 175

04/23/2018 DEFENDANT'S SECOND DISCOVERY DISCLOSURE FILED 2 177

04/24/2018 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) 4/24/18 1 176

04/25/2018 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 7/16/2018 0 178

Reason: JSEL--JURY SELECTION BY DIANLOMB

04/25/2018 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 5/3/2018 0 179

Reason: STHR--STATUS HEARING BY DIANLOMB

04/26/2018 MOTION TO INCUR COSTS FOR PRIVATE INVESTIGATOR 2 180

04/30/2018 ORDER GRANTING MOTION TO INCUR ADDITIONAL COST FOR PRIVATE INVESTIGATOR 2 181

04/30/2018 NOTICE OF CANCELLATION OF DEPO 1 182

05/03/2018 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) 5-3-2018 1 183

05/04/2018 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 5/23/2018 0 184

Reason: STHR--STATUS HEARING BY KATHROBE

05/08/2018 CORRECTION TO COURT MEMO 5/3/18 1 185

05/08/2018 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 5/23/2018 0 186

Re: STHR--STATUS HEARING BY KATHROBE

05/08/2018 DELETE HEARING FOR THE DATE: 5/23/2018 0 187

Re: STHR--STATUS HEARING BY KATHROBE

05/10/2018 NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION 2 188

05/24/2018 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) 5/23/18 1 189

05/25/2018 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 6/4/2018 0 190

Reason: STHR--STATUS HEARING BY DIANLOMB

05/30/2018 SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE TO NOTICE FOR DISCOVERY 2 191

06/05/2018 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) 6/4/18 1 192

06/05/2018 APPLICANT DECLARED INDIGENT BY CLERK 1 193

06/05/2018 DELETE HEARING FOR THE DATE: 7/16/2018 0 194

Reason: JSEL--JURY SELECTION BY DIANLOMB

06/05/2018 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 6/25/2018 0 195

Reason: STHR--STATUS HEARING BY DIANLOMB

06/05/2018 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 9/11/2018 0 196

Reason: JSEL--JURY SELECTION BY DIANLOMB

06/06/2018 CERTIFICATE TO PROCEDURE OUT-OF-STATE WITNESSES 2 197

06/06/2018 AFFIDAVIT TO PROCURE OUT-OF-STATE WITNESS 2 198

06/08/2018 MOTION APPOINTMENT OF EXPERTS 2 199

06/21/2018 NOTICE OF CANCELLATION OF DEPO 1 200

06/25/2018 SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE TO NOTICE FOR DISCOVERY 1 202

06/26/2018 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) 6/25/18 1 201

06/26/2018 MOTION TO REIMBURSE COSTS OF TRAVEL 2 204

06/27/2018 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 8/2/2018 0 203

Reason: MULTI--MULTIPLE HEARINGS / MOTIONS BY DIANLOMB

06/29/2018 MOTION FOR TRANSCRIPT OF GRAND JURY PROCEEDINGS 2 205

06/29/2018 MOTION ASKING TRIAL COURT TO STATE BASIS OF ITS RULINGS 3 206

06/29/2018 MOTION FOR SPECIAL VERDICT AS TO THEORY OF GUILT 3 207

06/29/2018 MOTION TO PRECLUDE CAPITAL PUNISHMENT AS A POSSIBLE SENTENCE 4 208

06/29/2018 MOTION TO PRECLUDE JURY DEATH QUALIFICATION 29 209

06/29/2018 MOTION TO PROHIBIT DEATH QUALIFICATION OF PROSPECTIVE JURORS OR FOR SEPARATE JURIES FOR THE GUILT & 6 210

06/29/2018 MOTION FOR INDIVIDUAL VOIR DIRE & SEQUESTRATION OF JURORS DURING VOIR DIRE & MEMORANDUM OF LAW 3 211

06/29/2018 MOTION TO DECLARE 921.141(1) FL STAT UNCONS & TO BAR STATES USE OF HEARSAY EVIDENCE AT PENALTY PHASE 5 212

06/29/2018 MOTION TO PROHIBIT ANY REFERENCE TO AN ADVISORY ROLE OF THE JURY AT SENTENCING 2 213

06/29/2018 MOTION TO DECLARE SECTIONS 921.141 &/OR 921.141(6)(H) FL STAT "HEINOUS ATROCIOUS OR CRUEL" AGG &/OR 2 214

06/29/2018 MOTION TO DECLARE SECTION 921.14(6)(I) FL STAT UNCONSTITUTIONAL AS WRITTEN & AS APPLIED 11 215

06/29/2018 MOTION TO DECLARE 921.141(6)(N) FL STAT UNCONSTITUTIONAL 9 216

06/29/2018 MOTION TO DECL FL DEATH PENALTY UNCONST BASED ON THE UNCONST USE OF 921.141(7)(G) FL STAT (THE "AGE" 5 217

06/29/2018 MOTION & ARGUMENT TO DECLARE 921.141 & 921.141(8) FL STAT UNCONSTITUTIONAL 17 218

06/29/2018 MOTION TO ALLOW VICTIM IMPACT EVIDENCE BEFORE THE JUDGE ONLY 5 219

06/29/2018 MOTION TO VIDEOTAPE VICTIM IMPACT EVIDENCE TO PRESERVE ISSUES FOR APPELLATE REVIEW 2 220

06/29/2018 MOTION TO LIMINE TO REQ STATE TO PROFFER ANY AND ALL VICTIM IMPACT EVIDENCE 5 221

06/29/2018 MOT TO COMPEL THE STATE TO DISCLOSE VICTIM IMPACT FOR REV, WITN'S NAMES & VICTIM IMPACT STMTS PRIOR 2 222

06/29/2018 NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION 2 225

06/29/2018 MOTION TO REIMBURSE COSTS 2 226

07/02/2018 ORDER ON MOTION FOR APPOINTMENT OF CONFIDENTIAL PSYCHOLOGICAL EXPERT 1 223

07/02/2018 ORDER ON MOTION TO REIMBURSE COSTS TO TRAVEL 1 224

07/09/2018 SUPPLEMENTAL DISCOVERY 2 227

07/09/2018 MOTION TO INCUR ADDTIONAL COSTS FOR PRIVATE INVESTIGATOR 2 228

07/17/2018 ORDER ON MOTION TO REIMBURSE COSTS OF COURT REPORTER EXPENSES 3 229

07/17/2018 ORDER ON MOTION TO INCUR ADDITIONAL COSTS FOR PRIVATE INVESTIGATOR 3 230

07/20/2018 NOTICE OF CONFLICT 2 231

07/31/2018 AMENDED MOTION TO REIMBURSE COSTS OF COURT REPORTER EXPENSES 3 232

08/02/2018 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 8/10/2018 0 233

Re: STHR--STATUS HEARING BY RENEBLAC

08/02/2018 ORDER ON AMENDED MOTION TO REIMBURSE COSTS OF COURT REPORTER EXPENSES 1 234

08/02/2018 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) 08/02/18 1 235

08/10/2018 SUPPLEMENTAL DISCOVERY 1 240

08/13/2018 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) 08/10/18 1 236

08/13/2018 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 8/22/2018 0 237

Re: STHR--STATUS HEARING BY EMYLSALA

08/13/2018 NOTICE OF HEARING FILED 2 238

08/13/2018 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 9/7/2018 0 239

Re: MULTI--MULTIPLE HEARINGS / MOTIONS BY JULICLAR

08/13/2018 DEFENDANT'S THIRD DISCOVERY DISCLOSURE FILED 2 241

08/17/2018 SUBPOENA SERVED 1 242

08/21/2018 MOTION FOR CONTINUANCE 2 244

08/22/2018 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 8/24/2018 0 243

Re: STHR--STATUS HEARING BY MARIWILS

08/22/2018 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) 8-22-2018 1 245

08/24/2018 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 8/31/2018 0 246

Re: STHR--STATUS HEARING BY ESTHJEAN

08/27/2018 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) 08/24/18 1 247

08/29/2018 DEFENDANT'S MOTION IN LIMINE 4 248

08/31/2018 MOTION TO TRANSPORT DEFT 1 249

08/31/2018 SUPPLEMENTAL DISCOVERY 1 250

08/31/2018 SUPPLEMENTAL DISCOVERY 2 251

08/31/2018 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 9/5/2018 0 252

Re: STHR--STATUS HEARING BY MELIMAXW

08/31/2018 DEFENDANT'S FIRST PENALTY PHASE DISCOVERY DISCLOSURE 2 254

09/04/2018 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) 08/31/18 1 253

09/06/2018 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) 09/05/18 1 255

09/06/2018 SUPPLEMENTAL DISCOVERY 1 259

09/06/2018 SUPPLEMENTAL DISCOVERY 1 260

09/10/2018 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) 9-7-2018 1 256

09/10/2018 MOTION TO INCUR COSTS FOR DEPOSITION TRANSCRIPTS 2 257

09/11/2018 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 9/12/2018 0 258

Re: JSEL--JURY SELECTION BY SANDSMIT

09/12/2018 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 9/13/2018 0 261

Re: JSEL--JURY SELECTION BY SANDSMIT

09/12/2018 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) 9/11/18 1 262

09/12/2018 CERTIFICATE OF JURORS' OATH 1 263

09/13/2018 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 9/14/2018 0 264

Re: JSEL--JURY SELECTION BY SANDSMIT

09/13/2018 DELETE HEARING FOR THE DATE: 9/14/2018 0 265

Re: JSEL--JURY SELECTION BY SANDSMIT

09/13/2018 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 9/14/2018 0 266

Re: JTRL--JURY TRIAL BY SANDSMIT

09/13/2018 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 9/17/2018 0 267

Re: JTRL--JURY TRIAL BY SANDSMIT

09/13/2018 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 9/18/2018 0 268

Re: JTRL--JURY TRIAL BY SANDSMIT

09/13/2018 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 9/20/2018 0 269

Re: JTRL--JURY TRIAL BY SANDSMIT

09/13/2018 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 9/21/2018 0 270

Re: JTRL--JURY TRIAL BY SANDSMIT

09/13/2018 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 9/24/2018 0 271

Re: JTRL--JURY TRIAL BY SANDSMIT

09/13/2018 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 9/25/2018 0 272

Re: JTRL--JURY TRIAL BY SANDSMIT

09/13/2018 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 9/26/2018 0 273

Re: JTRL--JURY TRIAL BY SANDSMIT

09/13/2018 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 9/27/2018 0 274

Re: JTRL--JURY TRIAL BY SANDSMIT

09/13/2018 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 9/28/2018 0 275

Re: JSEL--JURY SELECTION BY SANDSMIT

09/13/2018 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) 9/12/2018 1 276

09/13/2018 ORDER DENYING MOTION FOR TRANSCRIP OF GRAND JURY PROCEEDINGS 1 277

09/13/2018 ORDER GRANTING MOTION ASKING TRIAL COURT TO STATE BASIS OF ITS RULINGS 1 278

09/13/2018 ORDER ON DEFT'S MOTN FOR SPECIAL VERDICT AS TO THEORY OF GUILT 2 279

09/13/2018 ORDER DENYING MOTION TO PRECLUDE CAPITAL PUNISHMENT AS POSSIBLE SENT 1 280

09/13/2018 ORDER DENYING MOTION PRECLUDE JURY DEATH QUALIFICATION PURSUANT TO FLA STATUTE 1 281

09/13/2018 ORDER DENYING MOTION PROHIBIT DEATH QUALIFICATION OF PROSPECTIVE JURORS 1 282

09/13/2018 ORDER DENYING MOTION DECLARE FS 921.141(1) UNSCONSTITUTIONAL & BAR STATES USE OF HEARSAY EVID AT PEN 1 283

09/13/2018 ORDER GRANTING MOTION INDIVIDUAL VOIR DIRE & SEQUESTRATION OF JURORS DURING VOIR DIRE & MEMO OF LAW 1 284

09/13/2018 ORDER GRANTING MOTION PROHIBIT ANY REFERENCE TO ADVISORY ROLE OF JUREY AT SENTENCING. 1 285

09/13/2018 ORDER DENYING MOTION DECLARE SECTIONS 921.141 &/OR 921.141 (6)(B) FS HEINOUS ATROCIOUS OR CRUEL... 1 286

09/13/2018 ORDER DENYING MOTION DECLARE SECTION 921.141(6)(1) F.S. UNCONSTITUTIONAL AS WRITTEN AND APPLIED 1 287

09/13/2018 ORDER DEFT'S MOTN TO DECLARE 921.141(6)(A) F.S. UNSTITUTIONAL RENDERED MOOT 1 288

09/13/2018 ORDER DENYING MOTION DECLARE FLA DEATH PENALTY UNCONSTITIONAL BASED ON UNCOONSTITUTIONAL USE... 1 289

09/13/2018 ORDER DENYING MOTION & ORGUMENT TO DECLARE 921.141 & 921.141(8) F.S. UNCONSTITUTIONAL 1 290

09/13/2018 ORDER DENYING MOTION TO ALLOW VICTIM IMPACT EVID BEF JUDGE ONLY 1 291

09/13/2018 ORDER GRANTING MOTION VIDEOTAPE VICTIM IMPACT EVID TO PRESERVE ISSUES FOR APPL REVIEW 1 292

09/13/2018 ORDER ON DEFT'S MOTN IN LIMINE TO REQ STATE TO PROFFER ANY AND ALL VICTIM IMPACT EVIDENCE 1 293

09/13/2018 ORDER GRANTING MOTION COMPEL STATE DISCL VICTIM IMPACT FOR REVIEW, WITN'S NAMES & VICTIM IMPACT... 1 294

09/13/2018 ORDER ON DEFT'S MOTION IN LIMINE 3 295

09/14/2018 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) 9/13/2018 1 296

09/14/2018 CORRESPONDENCE 1 297

09/14/2018 SUPPLEMENTAL DISCOVERY 1 298

09/14/2018 SUPPLEMENTAL DISCOVERY 2 299

09/18/2018 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) 09/14/18 1 300

09/18/2018 SECOND ORDER ON DEFENDANT'S MOTION IN LIMINE 4 301

09/18/2018 MOTION TO REIMBURSE COST 2 304

09/20/2018 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) 09/17/18 1 302

09/20/2018 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) 09/18/18 1 303

09/20/2018 ORDER ON MOTION TO INCUR COSTS FOR DEPO TRANSCRIPTS 2 305

09/20/2018 ORDER ON MOTION TO REIMBURSE COST OF JURY TRIAL TRANSCRIPT EXPENSE 2 306

09/21/2018 ASA of Record, DUCHARME KRISTIE 0 307

09/21/2018 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) 09/20/18 1 308

09/24/2018 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 10/1/2018 0 309

Re: JTRL--JURY TRIAL BY SANDSMIT

09/24/2018 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 10/2/2018 0 310

Re: JTRL--JURY TRIAL BY SANDSMIT

09/24/2018 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 10/3/2018 0 311

Re: JTRL--JURY TRIAL BY SANDSMIT

09/24/2018 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 10/4/2018 0 312

Re: JTRL--JURY TRIAL BY SANDSMIT

09/24/2018 INSERT HEARING FOR THE DATE: 10/5/2018 0 313

Re: JTRL--JURY TRIAL BY SANDSMIT

09/24/2018 STIPULATION FOR VIDEO RECORDING 1 314

09/25/2018 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) 9-21-2018 1 315

09/25/2018 CORRECTION TO COURT MEMO 9-14-18 1 316

09/25/2018 CORRECTION TO COURT MEMO 9-17-18 1 317

09/25/2018 CORRECTION TO COURT MEMO 9-18-18 1 318

09/25/2018 CORRECTION TO COURT MEMO 9-20-18 1 319

09/25/2018 CORRECTION TO COURT MEMO 9-21-18 1 320

09/25/2018 CORRECTION TO COURT MEMO 9-24-18 1 321

09/26/2018 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) 9-24-2018 1 322

09/26/2018 MEMO OF COURT (SNAPOUT) 9-25-2018 1 323

09/27/2018 TRIAL SUPPORT COST AFFIDAVIT 1 324

09/27/2018 REQUEST FOR JURY INSTRUCTIONS 2 325

09/28/2018 MOTION TO INCUR COSTS FOR VIDEO OF VICTIM IMPACT STATEMENTS 2 326

09/28/2018 DELETE HEARING FOR THE DATE: 10/1/2018 0 327

Re: JTRL--JURY TRIAL BY SANDSMIT

09/28/2018 DELETE HEARING FOR THE DATE: 10/2/2018 0 328

Re: JTRL--JURY TRIAL BY SANDSMIT

09/28/2018 DELETE HEARING FOR THE DATE: 10/3/2018 0 329

Re: JTRL--JURY TRIAL BY SANDSMIT

09/28/2018 DELETE HEARING FOR THE DATE: 10/4/2018 0 330

Re: JTRL--JURY TRIAL BY SANDSMIT

09/28/2018 DELETE HEARING FOR THE DATE: 10/5/2018 0 331

Re: JTRL--JURY TRIAL BY SANDSMIT

Outcome:
Guilty
Plaintiff's Experts:
Defendant's Experts:
Comments:

About This Case

What was the outcome of State of Florida v. Johnathan Ishmael Alcergaire?

The outcome was: Guilty

Which court heard State of Florida v. Johnathan Ishmael Alcergaire?

This case was heard in Circuit Court, Polk County, Florida, FL. The presiding judge was Jalal Harb.

Who were the attorneys in State of Florida v. Johnathan Ishmael Alcergaire?

Plaintiff's attorney: Hope Pattey. Defendant's attorney: Kevin Kohl.

When was State of Florida v. Johnathan Ishmael Alcergaire decided?

This case was decided on September 29, 2018.