Please E-mail suggested additions, comments and/or corrections to Kent@MoreLaw.Com.

Help support the publication of case reports on MoreLaw

David and Cara Cook, individually and on behalf of Michael Cook, a minor, v. Stanford Hospital and the Palo Alto Medical Clinic

Date: 09-30-2003

Case Number: Unknown

Judge: Unknown

Court: Superior Court, San Francisco, California

Plaintiff's Attorney:

David B. Baum of Baum Wiss & Blake, San Francisco, California

Defendant's Attorney:

David Sheuerman of Sheuerman Martini & Tabari, San Jose, California of Stanford Hospital

Description:

Medical malpractice claim by and on behalf of Michael Cook against Stanford Hospital and the Palo Alto Medical Clinic for failing to diagnose and treat his genetic disease with resulting brain damage. Michael was born with the metabolic disorder PKU, or phenylketonuria, which allows the buildup of an amino acid that is toxic to the central nervous system. According to medical experts, the disorder occurs once every 10,000 to 15,000 births and can be detected by a test that is required by law for all newborns. If it is diagnosed early, it can usually be controlled by a restrictive, lifelong low-protein diet. If untreated, it can cause severe and permanent retardation.


The hospital conducted its PKU test too early -- four hours after Michael's birth -- to detect the condition, and the clinic pediatrician never tested the boy despite seeing signs of major developmental problems. Michael's disease wasn't diagnosed until he was nearly 6, too late for treatment. By then, his mother was pregnant with another son, whose PKU was diagnosed soon after birth and who is functioning normally.

Outcome:
Jurors assigned 35 percent of the fault to the hospital, where the child was born, and 65 percent to the clinic, where he received pediatric care until he was 2 and awarded the plaintiff $70.9 million.
Plaintiff's Experts:
Unavailable
Defendant's Experts:
Unavailable
Comments:
None

About This Case

What was the outcome of David and Cara Cook, individually and on behalf of Michae...?

The outcome was: Jurors assigned 35 percent of the fault to the hospital, where the child was born, and 65 percent to the clinic, where he received pediatric care until he was 2 and awarded the plaintiff $70.9 million.

Which court heard David and Cara Cook, individually and on behalf of Michae...?

This case was heard in Superior Court, San Francisco, California, CA. The presiding judge was Unknown.

Who were the attorneys in David and Cara Cook, individually and on behalf of Michae...?

Plaintiff's attorney: David B. Baum of Baum Wiss & Blake, San Francisco, California. Defendant's attorney: David Sheuerman of Sheuerman Martini & Tabari, San Jose, California of Stanford Hospital.

When was David and Cara Cook, individually and on behalf of Michae... decided?

This case was decided on September 30, 2003.