Paul Clabough and Pamela Jo Clabough v. State of Arizona, ex rel. Arizona Department of Transportation

Phoenix, AZ - Paul Clabough and Pamela Jo Clabough sued State of Arizona, ex rel. Arizona Department of Transportation on governmental tort claim theories.



Court docket entries:



Filing Date Description Docket Date Filing Party

8/25/2015 SJU - Satisfaction Of Judgment 8/25/2015

NOTE: Notice of Satisfaction of Judgment

7/16/2015 JUD - Judgment 7/16/2015

NOTE: JUDGMENT

6/25/2015 RES - Response 6/26/2015

NOTE: Response to Defendant's Objection To Proposed Form of Judgment

6/16/2015 OBJ - Objection/Opposition. 6/16/2015

NOTE: State Defendants' Objection to Proposed Form of Judgment

6/9/2015 NOT - Notice 6/10/2015

NOTE: NOTICE OF ERRATA RE: PROPOSED FORM OF JUDGMENT

6/4/2015 SOC - Statement Of Costs 6/4/2015

NOTE: Plaintiffs' Verified Statement of Costs Pursuant To A.R.S. 12-346

6/4/2015 NOF - Notice Of Filing 6/4/2015

NOTE: NOTICE OF FILING PROPOSED FORM OF JUDGMENT

6/3/2015 023 - ME: Order Entered By Court 6/3/2015

5/28/2015 012 - ME: Trial 5/28/2015

5/27/2015 JJF - Judgment For Jury Fees 6/1/2015

NOTE: Notice of filing and entry provided to the parties

5/26/2015 WSH - Worksheet 5/27/2015

NOTE: TRIAL/HEARING

5/26/2015 VER - Verdict 5/27/2015

5/26/2015 VER - Verdict 5/27/2015

5/26/2015 EXW - Exhibits Work Sheet 7/6/2015

5/26/2015 VER - Verdict 5/27/2015

5/26/2015 012 - ME: Trial 5/26/2015

5/26/2015 012 - ME: Trial 5/26/2015

5/22/2015 023 - ME: Order Entered By Court 5/22/2015

5/21/2015 012 - ME: Trial 5/21/2015

5/21/2015 PJI - Proposed Jury Instructions 5/21/2015

NOTE: Plaintiffs' Revised Proposed Additional Jury Instructions

5/21/2015 PJI - Proposed Jury Instructions 5/21/2015

NOTE: REVISED STIPULATED JURY INSTRUCTIONS AND VERDICT FORMS PER COURT’S 5/20/15 RULING ON PLAITIFFS’ MOTION FOR DIRECTED VERDICT

5/21/2015 JIN - Jury Instructions 5/27/2015

NOTE: FINAL

5/20/2015 012 - ME: Trial 5/20/2015

5/20/2015 012 - ME: Trial 5/20/2015

5/20/2015 NOF - Notice Of Filing 5/20/2015

NOTE: Notice of Filing Plaintiffs' Revised Proposed Jury Instruction No. 4 Re Non-Delegable Duty

5/20/2015 NOF - Notice Of Filing 5/20/2015

NOTE: Notice of Filing of Revised Verdict Forms

5/20/2015 RES - Response 5/20/2015

NOTE: STATE DEFENDANTS’ RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION TO INCLUDE WILLITS INSTRUCTION REGARDING STATE’S FAILURE TO PRESERVE BATTERIES

5/20/2015 RES - Response 5/20/2015

NOTE: Plaintiffs' Response to Defendant's Motion for Court Instruction Limiiting Dr. Glover's Trial Testimony

5/20/2015 NOF - Notice Of Filing 5/20/2015

NOTE: Notice of Filing Transcript Citations supporting Plaintiffs' Proposed Additional Jury Instruction #6

5/19/2015 012 - ME: Trial 5/19/2015

5/19/2015 MOT - Motion 5/19/2015

NOTE: State Defendants' Motion for Court Instruction Limiting Dr. Glover's Trial Testimony

5/19/2015 MOT - Motion 5/19/2015

NOTE: Plaintiffs' Motion to Include Willits Instruction Regarding State's Failure to Preserve Batteries

5/19/2015 PJI - Proposed Jury Instructions 5/19/2015

NOTE: Plaintiffs' Supplemental Proposed Additional Jury Instructions

5/19/2015 JQU - Jury Question 5/27/2015

5/19/2015 JQU - Jury Question 5/27/2015

5/19/2015 JQU - Jury Question 5/27/2015

5/18/2015 DPR - Deposition Report 5/27/2015

NOTE: LISA J ANDERSON/FEBRUARY 12 2013/TRAVIS QUALLS

5/18/2015 JQU - Jury Question 5/27/2015

5/18/2015 DPR - Deposition Report 5/27/2015

NOTE: LISA J ANDERSON/SEPTEMBER 27 2013/MARK VAN ERT

5/18/2015 JQU - Jury Question 5/27/2015

5/18/2015 DPR - Deposition Report 5/27/2015

NOTE: LISA J ANDERSON/DECEMBER 4 2012/ANNE GILMORE

5/18/2015 DPR - Deposition Report 5/27/2015

NOTE: LISA J ANERSON/FEBRUARY 12 2013/MARY PARRISH

5/18/2015 DPR - Deposition Report 5/27/2015

NOTE: LISA J ANDERSON/SEPTEMBER 27 2013/JOHN SULLIVAN

5/18/2015 DPR - Deposition Report 5/27/2015

NOTE: LISA J ANDERSON/DECEMBER 4 2012/DONNA BROCK

5/18/2015 JQU - Jury Question 5/27/2015

5/14/2015 JQU - Jury Question 5/27/2015

5/14/2015 JQU - Jury Question 5/27/2015

5/14/2015 JQU - Jury Question 5/27/2015

5/14/2015 JQU - Jury Question 5/27/2015

5/14/2015 JQU - Jury Question 5/27/2015

5/14/2015 JQU - Jury Question 5/27/2015

5/13/2015 JQU - Jury Question 5/27/2015

5/13/2015 JQU - Jury Question 5/27/2015

5/13/2015 012 - ME: Trial 5/13/2015

5/12/2015 012 - ME: Trial 5/12/2015

5/12/2015 MOT - Motion 5/12/2015

NOTE: PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION TO PRECLUDE DEFENSE FROM ASSERTING NEW SPOLIATION THEORY, OR THAT PLAINTIFFS’ ALLEGED FAILURE TO IMMEDIATELY REPORT SYMPTOMS PREVENTED DEFENSE FROM PERFORMING IMMEDIATE TESTING

5/12/2015 JQU - Jury Question 5/27/2015

5/12/2015 JQU - Jury Question 5/27/2015

5/12/2015 JQU - Jury Question 5/27/2015

5/12/2015 JQU - Jury Question 5/27/2015

5/11/2015 JQU - Jury Question 5/27/2015

5/11/2015 JQU - Jury Question 5/27/2015

5/11/2015 012 - ME: Trial 5/11/2015

5/7/2015 JIN - Jury Instructions 5/27/2015

NOTE: PRELIMINARY

5/6/2015 DPR - Deposition Report 5/27/2015

NOTE: CATHY J TAYLOR/NOVEMBER 12 2013/LESTER E HENDRICKSON

5/6/2015 DPR - Deposition Report 5/27/2015

NOTE: LISA S BISHOP/DECEMBER 10 2013/RICHARD A PARENT

5/6/2015 025 - ME: Case Status Minute Entry 5/6/2015

5/6/2015 DPR - Deposition Report 5/27/2015

NOTE: HALEY WESTRA/OCTOBER 19 2012/PAUL RAY CLABOUGH

5/6/2015 DPR - Deposition Report 5/27/2015

NOTE: MICHELLE R BUCKHANNON/JANUARY 13 2014/JOHN N GLOVER

5/6/2015 DPR - Deposition Report 5/27/2015

NOTE: MARY SMITH/DECEMBER 5 2013/RAMASWAMI VASUDEVAN

4/22/2015 027 - ME: Pretrial Conference 4/22/2015

4/16/2015 NOT - Notice 4/16/2015

NOTE: Notice of Substitution of Exhibit #148

4/15/2015 ORD - Order 4/15/2015

NOTE: ORDER RE AGREED UPON MOTIONS IN LIMINE

4/10/2015 PJI - Proposed Jury Instructions 4/13/2015

NOTE: Stipulated Jury Instructions and Verdict Forms

4/10/2015 PJI - Proposed Jury Instructions 4/13/2015

NOTE: DEFENDANT STATE OF ARIZONA’S SEPARATE, NON-AGREED UPON JURY INSTRUCTIONS

4/10/2015 PJI - Proposed Jury Instructions 4/13/2015

NOTE: Plaintiffs' Proposed Additional Jury Instructions

4/10/2015 STA - Statement 4/13/2015

NOTE: Joint Pretrial Statement

4/10/2015 NOT - Notice 4/13/2015

NOTE: Joint Proposed Voir Dire

4/9/2015 STP - Stipulation 4/10/2015

NOTE: Stipulation re Agreed Upon Motions In Limine

3/30/2015 RES - Response 3/31/2015

NOTE: STATE DEFENDANT’S RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 1 TO PRECLUDE DUPLICATIVE EXPERT TESTIMONY ON SINGLE ISSUE OF SUPPOSED LACK OF MEDICAL CAUSATION

3/30/2015 RES - Response 3/31/2015

NOTE: STATE DEFENDANT’S RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 7 TO PRECLUDE UNDISCLOSED EXPERT OPINIONS OF DR. VAN ERT

3/30/2015 RES - Response 3/31/2015

NOTE: STATE DEFENDANT’S RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 8 TO PRECLUDE UNDISCLOSED EXPERT OPINIONS OF DR. JOHN SULLIVAN

3/30/2015 NOT - Notice 3/31/2015

NOTE: State Defendant's Notice of No Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motions in Limine Nos. 4 and 5

3/30/2015 RES - Response 3/31/2015

NOTE: State Defendant's Response to Plaintiffs' Motion in Limine No. 2 to Preclude Mary Parrish from Testifying about Battery Design or Operation

3/30/2015 RES - Response 3/31/2015

NOTE: State Defendant's Response to Plaintiffs' Motion in Limine No. 3 to Preclude Any Testimony that the Batteries did not Emit a Sufficient Quantity of Toxic Fumes to Cause Injury and for a Willis Instruction

3/30/2015 RES - Response 3/31/2015

NOTE: STATE DEFENDANT’S RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 6 TO PRECLUDE ANNE GILMORE FROM OFFERING UNSUBSTANTIATED OPINIONS REGARDING PAUL CLABOUGH’S HEALTH

3/30/2015 RES - Response 3/31/2015

NOTE: STATE DEFENDANT’S RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 9 TO EXCLUDE UNQUALIFIED EXPERT OPINIONS OF DR. VAN ERT

3/30/2015 RES - Response 3/31/2015

NOTE: PLAINTIFFS’ RESPONSE TO STATE DEFENDANTS’ MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 3 TO PRECLUDE PLAINTIFFS’ EXPERT PARENT’S CAUSATION OPINIONS

3/30/2015 RES - Response 3/31/2015

NOTE: PLAINTIFFS’ RESPONSE TO STATE DEFENDANTS’ MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 4 TO PRECLUDE DR. GLOVER FROM OFFERING CAUSATION OPINION

3/30/2015 RES - Response 3/31/2015

NOTE: PLAINTIFFS’ RESPONSE TO STATE DEFENDANTS’ MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 5 REGARDING SPOLIATION ISSUE

3/30/2015 RES - Response 3/31/2015

NOTE: PLAINTIFFS’ RESPONSE TO STATE DEFENDANTS’ MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 1 REGARDING LIMITING PLAINTIFFS’ EXPERT VASUDEVAN TO FAILURE ANALYSIS ISSUES

3/30/2015 RES - Response 3/31/2015

NOTE: Plaintiffs' Response to State Defendants' Motion in Limine No. 2 to Limit Plaintiffs Expert Hendrickson to the Chemical Opinions Provided through his Disclosure and Deposition

3/30/2015 RES - Response 3/31/2015

NOTE: PLAINTIFFS’ RESPONSE TO STATE DEFENDANTS’ MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 6 TO EXCLUDE DECISION OF INDUSTRIAL COMMISSION

3/18/2015 MIL - Motion In Limine 3/19/2015

NOTE: State Defendants' Motion in Limine No. 1 Regarding Limiting Plaintiffs' Expert Vasudevan to Failure Analysis Issues

3/18/2015 MIL - Motion In Limine 3/19/2015

NOTE: STATE DEFENDANTS’ MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 3 TO PRECLUDE PLAINTIFFS’ EXPERT PARENT’S CAUSATION OPINIONS

3/18/2015 MIL - Motion In Limine 3/19/2015

NOTE: STATE DEFENDANTS’ MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 6 REGARDING DECISION OF INDUSTRIAL COMMISSION

3/18/2015 MIL - Motion In Limine 3/19/2015

NOTE: State Defendants' Motion in Limine No. 2 to Limit Plaintiffs' Expert Hendrickson to the Chemical Opinions Provided Through his Disclosure and Deposition

3/18/2015 MOT - Motion 3/19/2015

NOTE: STATE DEFENDANTS’ MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 5 REGARDING SPOLIATION ISSUE

3/18/2015 MIL - Motion In Limine 3/19/2015

NOTE: STATE DEFENDANTS’ MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 4 TO PRECLUDE DR. GLOVER FROM OFFERING CAUSATION OPINION

3/18/2015 NOT - Notice 3/19/2015

NOTE: NOTICE OF FIRST EXTENSION OF TIME TO FILE RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE SECOND AMENDED COMPLAINT

3/18/2015 MIL - Motion In Limine 3/19/2015

NOTE: Plaintiffs' Motion in Limine No. 1 to Preclude Duplicative Expert Testimony on Single Issue of Supposed Lack of Medical Causation

3/18/2015 MIL - Motion In Limine 3/19/2015

NOTE: Plaintiffs' Motion in Limine No. 5 to Preclude any Mention of the Dollar Amount Set Forth in Plaintiffs' Notice of Claim

3/18/2015 MIL - Motion In Limine 3/19/2015

NOTE: Plaintiffs' Motion in Limine No. 9 to Exclude Unqualified Expert Opinions of Dr. Van Ert

3/18/2015 MIL - Motion In Limine 3/19/2015

NOTE: Plaintiffs' Motion in Limine No. 2 to Preclude Mary Parrish from Testifying About Battery Design or Operation

3/18/2015 MIL - Motion In Limine 3/19/2015

NOTE: PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 6 TO PRECLUDE ANNE GILMORE FROM OFFERING UNSUBSTANTIATED OPINIONS REGARDING PAUL CLABOUGH’S HEALTH

3/18/2015 MIL - Motion In Limine 3/19/2015

NOTE: PLAINTIFF’S MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 7 TO PRECLUDE UNDISCLOSED EXPERT OPINIONS OF DR. VAN ERT

3/18/2015 MIL - Motion In Limine 3/19/2015

NOTE: PLAINTIFF’S MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 8 TO PRECLUDE UNDISCLOSED EXPERT OPINIONS OF DR. JOHN SULLIVAN

3/18/2015 MIL - Motion In Limine 3/19/2015

NOTE: PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 3 TO PRECLUDE ANY TESTIMONY THAT THE BATTERIES DID NOT EMIT A SUFFICIENT QUANTITY OF TOXIC FUMES TO CAUSE INJURY, and FOR A WILLITS INSTRUCTION

3/18/2015 MIL - Motion In Limine 3/19/2015

NOTE: Plaintiffs' Motion in Limine No. 4 to Preclude Witness John Andrews from Testifying

3/5/2015 REQ - Request 3/6/2015

NOTE: Plaintiffs' Request For Court Reporter at Trial Management Conference

3/4/2015 ORD - Order 3/4/2015

NOTE: ORDER EXTENDING DEADLINES

2/27/2015 STP - Stipulation 3/2/2015

NOTE: Stipulation to Extend Deadlines

2/18/2015 083 - ME: Conference Reset/Cont 2/18/2015

1/20/2015 NOT - Notice 1/21/2015

NOTE: Notice of Association of Counsel

11/25/2014 926 - ME: Under Advisement Ruling 11/25/2014

11/3/2014 089 - ME: Trial Setting 11/3/2014

10/15/2014 020 - ME: Matter Under Advisement 10/15/2014

8/15/2014 094 - ME: Oral Argument Set 8/15/2014

7/18/2014 028 - ME: Status Conference Set 7/18/2014

5/21/2014 ORD - Order 5/21/2014

NOTE: Order vacating the oral argument of June 13, 2014

5/19/2014 STP - Stipulation 5/19/2014

NOTE: JOINT STIPULATION RE: ORAL ARGUMENT MOTIONS FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT CURRENTLY SCHEDULED ON JULY 13, 2014

4/10/2014 095 - ME: Oral Argument Reset 4/10/2014

4/8/2014 094 - ME: Oral Argument Set 4/8/2014

4/3/2014 NOT - Notice 4/3/2014

NOTE: Plaintiffs' Notice of Errata Re: Caption of "Motion to Strike Materials Provided In Support of Defendant State of Arizona's Reply In Support of Motion For Summary Judgment"

3/31/2014 023 - ME: Order Entered By Court 3/31/2014

3/31/2014 NOT - Notice 3/31/2014

NOTE: Notice of Supplemental Authority In Support Of Response To Defendant's Motion For Summary Judgment

3/31/2014 MOT - Motion 4/1/2014

NOTE: MOTION TO STRIKE MATERIALS PROVIDED IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT STATE OF ARIZONA’S REPLY IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT

3/17/2014 NOT - Notice 3/17/2014

NOTE: Notice of Service of Plaintiffs' Offer of Judgment

3/17/2014 REL - Reply 3/17/2014

NOTE: Defendant State of Arizona's Reply in Support of Motion for Summary Judgment

3/13/2014 REL - Reply 3/13/2014

NOTE: PLAINTIFFS’ REPLY IN SUPPORT OF ITS MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON THE ISSUE OF COMPARATIVE FAULT

3/13/2014 SOF - Statement Of Facts 3/13/2014

NOTE: Plaintiffs' Supplemental Statement of Facts and Controverting Statement of Facts In Support of Their Reply In Support of Their Motion For Partial Summary Judgment Re: The Issue of Comparative Fault

2/24/2014 RES - Response 2/24/2014

NOTE: DEFENDANT STATE OF ARIZONA’S RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON THE ISSUE TO COMPARATIVE FAULT

2/24/2014 SOF - Statement Of Facts 2/24/2014

NOTE: DEFENDANT STATE OF ARIZONA’S CONTROVERTING STATEMENT OF FACTS IN RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFFS’ CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF FACTS IN SUPPORT OF THEIR MOTIONS FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT RE: 1) DEFENDANT’S DESIGNATION OF BLACK BOX AS A NON-PARTY AT FAULT AND (2) THE ISSUE OF COMPARATIVE FAULT

2/24/2014 RES - Response 2/24/2014

NOTE: RESPONSE TO DEFENDANT STATE OF ARIZONA’S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT

2/24/2014 SOF - Statement Of Facts 2/24/2014

NOTE: PLAINTIFFS’ STATEMENT OF FACTS IN SUPPORT OF THEIR RESPONSE TO DEFENDANT’S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT, AND CONTROVERTING STATEMENT OF FACTS IN RESPONSE TO DEFENDANT’S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT

1/17/2014 MSJ - Motion For Summary Judgment 1/17/2014

NOTE: Defendant State of Arizona's Motion for Summary Judgment

1/17/2014 SOF - Statement Of Facts 1/17/2014

NOTE: Defendant State of Arizona's Statement of Facts in Support of Motion for Summary Judgment

1/17/2014 MSJ - Motion For Summary Judgment 1/21/2014

NOTE: MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON DEFENDANTS’ DESIGNATION OF BLACK BOX AS A NON-PARTY AT FAULT

1/17/2014 SOF - Statement Of Facts 1/21/2014

NOTE: PLAINTIFFS’ CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF FACTS IN SUPPORT OF THEIR MOTIONS FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT RE: 1) DEFENDANT’S DESIGNATION OF BLACK BOX AS A NON-PARTY AT FAULT and 2) THE ISSUE OF COMPARATIVE FAULT

1/17/2014 MSJ - Motion For Summary Judgment 1/21/2014

NOTE: Motion For Partial Summary Judgment On The Issue Of Comparative Fault

1/8/2014 ORD - Order 1/8/2014

NOTE: ORDER EXTENDING DEADLINES

12/19/2013 STP - Stipulation 12/19/2013

NOTE: Stipulation To Extend Deadlines

11/4/2013 ORD - Order 11/4/2013

NOTE: Order EXTENDING PRIVATE MEDIATION DEADLINE

10/29/2013 STP - Stipulation 10/29/2013

NOTE: STIPULATION TO EXTEND PRIVATE MEDIATION DEADLINE

7/16/2013 ORD - Order 7/16/2013

NOTE: SCHEDULING ORDER

7/12/2013 MEM - Memorandum 7/12/2013

NOTE: Joint Status Memo and Request of Modify Scheduling Order

6/5/2013 003 - ME: Hearing Reset 6/5/2013

6/4/2013 ORD - Order 6/4/2013

NOTE: SCHEDULING ORDER

5/29/2013 MEM - Memorandum 5/30/2013

NOTE: Joint Status Memo and Request to Modify Scheduling Order

2/4/2013 ORD - Order 2/4/2013

NOTE: Order REVISING SCHEDULING ORDER

1/31/2013 MOT - Motion 2/1/2013

NOTE: Stipulated Motion to Revise Scheduling Order

12/3/2012 073 - ME: Motion Withdrawn 12/3/2012

11/28/2012 NOT - Notice 11/28/2012

NOTE: Plaintiffs Notice of Withdrawal of Motion to Strike Defendant State of Arizona's Non-Party at Fault Designation Re Black Box

11/27/2012 ORD - Order 11/27/2012

NOTE: ORDER REVISING JOINT COMPREHENSIVE SCHEDULING CONFERENCE MEMORANDUM

11/20/2012 MEM - Memorandum 11/21/2012

NOTE: Revised Joint Comprehensive Scheduling Conference Memorandum

11/9/2012 MOT - Motion 11/9/2012

NOTE: Plaintiffs' Motion to Strike Defendant State of Arizona's Non-Party at Fault re: Black Box

10/5/2012 002 - ME: Hearing Vacated 10/5/2012

10/3/2012 NNF - Not Of Non-Parties At Fault 10/4/2012

NOTE: Defendant State of Arizona's Notice of Non-Party at Fault Regarding Black Box

10/1/2012 NOT - Notice 10/1/2012

NOTE: DEFENDANT STATE OF ARIZONA’S NOTICE OF WITHDRAWAL OF ITS NOTICE OF NON-PARTY AT FAULT REGARDING BATTERY MANUFACTURER

9/27/2012 ORD - Order 9/27/2012

NOTE: ORDER CONTINUING ORAL ARGUMENT REGARDING DEFENDANT’S NOTICE OF NONPARTY AT FAULT AND PLAINTIFFS’ OBJECTION THERETO TO 1:30 P.M. ON OCTOBER 22, 2012

9/26/2012 SFC - Stipulation For Continuance 9/26/2012

NOTE: Stipulation to Continue Oral Argument on the Notice of Objection to 1:30 P.M. on October 22, 2012

9/10/2012 094 - ME: Oral Argument Set 9/10/2012

8/28/2012 REL - Reply 8/28/2012

NOTE: PLAINTIFFS’ REPLY IN SUPPORT OF NOTICE OF OBJECTION TO DEFENDANT STATE OF ARIZONA’S NON-PARTY AT FAULT DESIGNATION

8/17/2012 RES - Response 8/20/2012

NOTE: Defendant State of Arizona's Response to Plaintiffs' Objection to Notice of Non-Party at Fault

7/19/2012 OBJ - Objection/Opposition. 7/19/2012

NOTE: Plaintiffs Notice of Objection to Defendant State of Arizonas Non Party At Fault Designation

4/25/2012 ORD - Order 4/25/2012

NOTE: IT IS ORDERED suspending the provisions of Rule 38.1, as to the Motion to Set and Certificate of Readiness practice

4/24/2012 STP - Stipulation 4/25/2012

NOTE: Stipulation Regarding Waiver of Rule 38.1 Requirements Regarding Motion to Set

3/14/2012 ORD - Order 3/14/2012

NOTE: SCHEDULING ORDER

3/12/2012 MEM - Memorandum 3/13/2012

NOTE: Joint Comprehensive Pretrial Conference Memorandum

2/13/2012 023 - ME: Order Entered By Court 2/13/2012

1/30/2012 REQ - Request 1/30/2012

NOTE: Plaintiffs' Request for Rule 16 Scheduling Conference

1/18/2012 311 - ME: 150 Day Minute Entry 1/18/2012

12/13/2011 ANS - Answer 12/14/2011

NOTE: Defendants State of Arizona and Arizona Department of Transportation's Answer to Plaintiffs' Complaint / CO-CHG REC# 21824883

12/13/2011 CAA - Cert Of Agreement/Arbitration 12/14/2011

NOTE: Defendants State of Arizona and Arizona Department of Transportation's Certificate of Agreement

12/13/2011 NJT - Not Demand For Jury Trials 12/14/2011

NOTE: Defendants State of Arizona and Arizona Department of Transportation's Demand for Jury Trial

11/30/2011 SUM - Summons 12/5/2011

11/30/2011 SUM - Summons 12/5/2011

11/30/2011 AFS - Affidavit Of Service 12/12/2011

NOTE: ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION SERVED 11/23/11

11/30/2011 AFS - Affidavit Of Service 12/12/2011

NOTE: STATE OF ARIZONA SERVED 11/23/11

11/16/2011 322 - ME: Notice Of Intent To Dismiss 11/16/2011

8/12/2011 COM - Complaint 8/16/2011

8/12/2011 NJT - Not Demand For Jury Trials 8/16/2011

8/12/2011 CCN - Cert Arbitration - Not Subject 8/16/2011

Date (F)or / (A)gainst Amount Frequency Type Status

7/16/2015 F:Paul Clabough $74,991.17 One Time Charges Satisfied

F:Pamela Jo Clabough

A: State Of Arizona

7/16/2015 F:Paul Clabough $24,591.76 One Time Costs Satisfied

F:Pamela Jo Clabough

A: State Of Arizona

7/16/2015 F:Paul Clabough $21,088.17 One Time Costs Satisfied

F:Pamela Jo Clabough

A: State Of Arizona

7/16/2015 F:Paul Clabough $4,355,903.00 One Time Principal Satisfied

F:Pamela Jo Clabough

A: State Of Arizona

5/27/2015 F:State Of Arizona $2,827.00 One Time Judgment for Jury Fees