Please E-mail suggested additions, comments and/or corrections to Kent@MoreLaw.Com.

Help support the publication of case reports on MoreLaw

Meyer Land & Cattle Company v. Lincoln County Conservation District

Date: 09-14-2001

Case Number: 85,400

Judge: Philip C. Vieux

Court: Kansas Court of Appeals

Plaintiff's Attorney: Karen K. McIlvain, of McIlvain Law Office, for appellant.

Defendant's Attorney: M.J. Willoughby, assistant attorney general, and Carla J. Stovall, attorney general, for appellees.

Description:
Meyer Land & Cattle Company (Meyer) appeals from the trial court's dismissal of its action for failure to state an actionable claim against the Lincoln County Conservation District (Lincoln) and its directors in their individual and supervisory capacities and the Kansas State Conservation Commission (Commission). We affirm.


Meyer built a lagoon on a plot of land contemplated for use as a cattle yard. On October 2, 1998, the Lincoln board of directors sent a letter to the Kansas Department of Health and Education (KDHE) expressing a suspicion that the lagoon was leaking water. They were concerned that cattle waste could contaminate the local groundwater. Lincoln requested that the KDHE conduct its own percolation test before Meyer was cleared to use the land for cattle.


Lincoln, for reasons not given, sent copies of the letter to every conservation district in Kansas, to assorted State administrative agencies, and to various elected representatives, including Kansas' United States Senators and Representatives. Meyer proffers that a total of 122 persons or agencies received copies of the letter.


On December 16, 1999, Meyer filed a petition, listing the following nine counts:


I. Action outside the scope of statutory duties;


II. Abuse of power;


III. Misstatement of fact;


IV. Misrepresentation;


V. Interference with business;


VI. False light;


VII. Defamation;


VIII. Failure to carry out duties in a reasonable manner and in good faith; and


IX. Failure to comply with statutory, regulatory, and constitutional duties.


Imbedded in the claim of failure to carry out its duties were an allegation of civil conspiracy and an alleged equal protection violation.


On May 17, 2000, the trial court dismissed all counts. The court found the essence of the action was libel, as all claims stemmed from a single written communication. Because a 1-year statute of limitations applies to libel, K.S.A. 60-514(a), the court concluded all claims were time barred. Meyer appeals, essentially claiming the court dismissed the case without allowing meaningful discovery which would have allowed it to show why the statute of limitations did not apply.

* * *

Click the case caption above for the full text of the
Court's opinion.

Outcome:
Affirmed
Plaintiff's Experts:
Unknown
Defendant's Experts:
Unknown
Comments:
E-mail suggested corrections, comments and/or corrections to:
Kent Morlan





Welcome Video

About This Case

What was the outcome of Meyer Land & Cattle Company v. Lincoln County Conservatio...?

The outcome was: Affirmed

Which court heard Meyer Land & Cattle Company v. Lincoln County Conservatio...?

This case was heard in Kansas Court of Appeals, KS. The presiding judge was Philip C. Vieux.

Who were the attorneys in Meyer Land & Cattle Company v. Lincoln County Conservatio...?

Plaintiff's attorney: Karen K. McIlvain, of McIlvain Law Office, for appellant.. Defendant's attorney: M.J. Willoughby, assistant attorney general, and Carla J. Stovall, attorney general, for appellees..

When was Meyer Land & Cattle Company v. Lincoln County Conservatio... decided?

This case was decided on September 14, 2001.