Please E-mail suggested additions, comments and/or corrections to Kent@MoreLaw.Com.
Help support the publication of case reports on MoreLaw
Niaz Mohammed Khoshnaw v. Susan Washburn
Date: 09-18-2024
Case Number: 18CV05794
Judge: J. Burdett Pratt
Court: Circuit Court, Umatilla County, Oregon
Plaintiff's Attorney:
Click Here For The Best Pendleton Criminal Defense Lawyer Directory
Defendant's Attorney: Oregon Attorney General's Office
Description:
Petitioner was convicted of murder and witness tampering following a jury trial at which petitioner admitted that he shot the victim but claimed to have done so in self-defense. The question for the jury was not whether petitioner had shot the victim, but whether he had done so in self-defense. Following several hours of deliberation, the jury returned unanimous guilty verdicts. Petitioner filed a direct appeal, and we affirmed the judgment of conviction in State v. Khoshnaw, 286 Or.App. 246, 399 P.3d 1083, rev den, 362 Or. 208 (2017).
Petitioner then sought post-conviction relief. The PCR court concluded that petitioner's criminal defense attorney provided inadequate assistance of counsel to him in two ways: (1) she did not move to suppress uncounseled statements that petitioner made to a jailhouse informant, and (2) she did not effectuate a pretrial admission that petitioner "was the shooter." The PCR court nevertheless denied petitioner relief because he did not prove prejudice.
[335 Or.App. 165] To establish prejudice under the Sixth Amendment, petitioner must have demonstrated a reasonable probability that in the absence of counsel's alleged inadequacy there would have been a different result. Strickland v. Washington, 466 U.S. 668, 694,104 S.Ct. 2052, 80 L.Ed.2d 674 (1984). Under Article I, section 11, of the Oregon Constitution, petitioner must have established that the same alleged inadequacy "had a tendency to affect the result of the prosecution." Green, 357 Or at 321 (internal quotation marks omitted).
Pendleton, Oregon post-conviction criminal defense lawyer represented the Plaintiff.
Petitioner was convicted of murder and witness tampering following a jury trial at which petitioner admitted that he shot the victim but claimed to have done so in self-defense. The question for the jury was not whether petitioner had shot the victim, but whether he had done so in self-defense. Following several hours of deliberation, the jury returned unanimous guilty verdicts. Petitioner filed a direct appeal, and we affirmed the judgment of conviction in State v. Khoshnaw, 286 Or.App. 246, 399 P.3d 1083, rev den, 362 Or. 208 (2017).
Petitioner then sought post-conviction relief. The PCR court concluded that petitioner's criminal defense attorney provided inadequate assistance of counsel to him in two ways: (1) she did not move to suppress uncounseled statements that petitioner made to a jailhouse informant, and (2) she did not effectuate a pretrial admission that petitioner "was the shooter." The PCR court nevertheless denied petitioner relief because he did not prove prejudice.
[335 Or.App. 165] To establish prejudice under the Sixth Amendment, petitioner must have demonstrated a reasonable probability that in the absence of counsel's alleged inadequacy there would have been a different result. Strickland v. Washington, 466 U.S. 668, 694,104 S.Ct. 2052, 80 L.Ed.2d 674 (1984). Under Article I, section 11, of the Oregon Constitution, petitioner must have established that the same alleged inadequacy "had a tendency to affect the result of the prosecution." Green, 357 Or at 321 (internal quotation marks omitted).
Outcome:
Affirmed
Khoshnaw v. Washburn, 335 Or.App. 163, A178454 (Or. App. Sep 18, 2024)
Khoshnaw v. Washburn, 335 Or.App. 163, A178454 (Or. App. Sep 18, 2024)
Plaintiff's Experts:
Defendant's Experts:
Comments:
About This Case
What was the outcome of Niaz Mohammed Khoshnaw v. Susan Washburn?
The outcome was: Affirmed Khoshnaw v. Washburn, 335 Or.App. 163, A178454 (Or. App. Sep 18, 2024)
Which court heard Niaz Mohammed Khoshnaw v. Susan Washburn?
This case was heard in Circuit Court, Umatilla County, Oregon, OR. The presiding judge was J. Burdett Pratt.
Who were the attorneys in Niaz Mohammed Khoshnaw v. Susan Washburn?
Plaintiff's attorney: Click Here For The Best Pendleton Criminal Defense Lawyer Directory. Defendant's attorney: Oregon Attorney General's Office.
When was Niaz Mohammed Khoshnaw v. Susan Washburn decided?
This case was decided on September 18, 2024.