Please E-mail suggested additions, comments and/or corrections to Kent@MoreLaw.Com.

Help support the publication of case reports on MoreLaw

Date: 02-13-2006

Case Style: David A. Birchall v. Raintree Estates, Inc.

Case Number: CJ-2004-2098

Judge: Rebecca B. Nightingale

Court: District Court, Tulsa County, Oklahoma

Plaintiff's Attorney: Richard Foster

Defendant's Attorney: Brian Dittrich

Description: David A. Birchall and Linda Birchall sued Raintree Estates, Inc. seeking a declaratory judgment that Raintree Estates did not have the legal authority to "fine" them for failing to comply with certain rules adopted by the condominium association where they owned property.

See docket entries for the case below:

Date Code Count Party Serial # Entry Date
03-29-2004 TEXT 1 50712881 Mar 29 2004 4:31:19:023PM - $ 0.00
CIVIL RELIEF MORE THAN $10,000 INITIAL FILING.
03-29-2004 DECLARE - 50712883 Mar 29 2004 4:31:19:100PM - $ 0.00
DECLARATORY JUDGMENT
03-29-2004 PFE1 - 50712884 Mar 29 2004 4:31:19:130PM Realized $ 150.00
PETITION($ 150.00)
03-29-2004 PFE7 - 50712885 Mar 29 2004 4:31:19:130PM Realized $ 6.00
LAW LIBRARY FEE($ 6.00)
03-29-2004 DMFE - 50712886 Mar 29 2004 4:31:19:130PM Realized $ 2.00
DISPUTE MEDIATION FEE($ 2.00)
03-29-2004 CHAB - 50712887 Mar 29 2004 4:31:19:130PM Realized $ 10.00
C.H.A.B. STATUTORY FEE($ 10.00)
03-29-2004 CCADMIN - 50712888 Mar 29 2004 4:31:19:130PM Realized $ 1.00
COURT CLERK ADMINISTRATIVE FEE ON COLLECTIONS($ 1.00)
03-29-2004 SMF - 50712889 Mar 29 2004 4:31:19:163PM Realized $ 5.00
SUMMONS FEE (CLERKS FEE)($ 5.00)
03-29-2004 SMIMA - 50712890 Mar 29 2004 4:31:19:240PM - $ 0.00
SUMMONS ISSUED - MAILED BY ATTORNEY
03-29-2004 TEXT - 50712882 Mar 29 2004 4:31:19:053PM - $ 0.00
OCIS HAS AUTOMATICALLY ASSIGNED JUDGE THORNBRUGH, P. THOMAS TO THIS CASE.
03-29-2004 ACCOUNT - 50712925 Mar 29 2004 4:33:14:413PM - $ 0.00
RECEIPT # 2004-703599 ON 03/29/2004.
PAYOR: DOERNER SAUNDERS TOTAL AMOUNT PAID: $ 174.00.
LINE ITEMS:
CJ-2004-2098: $155.00 ON AC01 CLERK FEES.
CJ-2004-2098: $6.00 ON AC23 LAW LIBRARY FEE.
CJ-2004-2098: $1.00 ON AC31 COURT CLERK REVOLVING FUND.
CJ-2004-2098: $2.00 ON AC64 DISPUTE MEDIATION FEES.
CJ-2004-2098: $10.00 ON AC69 CHILD ABUSE MULTIDISCIPLINARY FEE.
04-01-2004 S - BIRCHALL, LINDA 50741235 Apr 1 2004 4:44:40:727PM - $ 0.00
PARTY HAS BEEN SUCCESSFULLY SERVED/SUMMONS DELIVERED CERT MAIL TO RAINTREE ESTATES I INC ON 3-31-04 SIGNED JULIA REESE
04-21-2004 A - RAINTREE ESTATES I INC 50883040 Apr 21 2004 3:45:07:560PM - $ 0.00
ANSWER (DAVID ANDERSON ENTERS AS COUNSEL - COVERSHEET ATTACHED)/CERTIFICATE OF MAILING
04-23-2004 R - BIRCHALL, DAVID A 50902307 Apr 23 2004 2:06:56:487PM - $ 0.00
PLTF'S REPLY TO DEFT'S COUNTERCLAIM (A/J)
04-23-2004 MO - BIRCHALL, DAVID A 50902324 Apr 23 2004 2:07:25:500PM - $ 0.00
PTLFS' MOTION FOR SCHEDULING CONFERENCE (A/J)
04-23-2004 R - BIRCHALL, DAVID A 50906217 Apr 26 2004 8:33:27:033AM - $ 0.00
PLTF'S AMENDED REPLY TO DEFT'S COUNTERCLAIM
04-27-2004 CTFREE - 50922349 Apr 27 2004 12:48:46:210PM - $ 0.00
THORNBRUGH, P. THOMAS: ORDER SETTING SCHEDULING CONFERENCE ENTERED AND SET FOR 05/27/04 9:30 AM ROOM 601.
04-29-2004 O - 50941104 Apr 29 2004 12:21:14:287PM - $ 0.00
ORDER SETTING SCHEUDLING CONFERENCE (5-27-04 AT 9:30 A.M.)
05-26-2004 MOSJ - 51223128 May 26 2004 12:13:00:550PM Realized $ 50.00
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT FILE BY PLS($ 50.00)
05-26-2004 ACCOUNT - 51223143 May 26 2004 12:13:32:567PM - $ 0.00
RECEIPT # 2004-734358 ON 05/26/2004.
PAYOR: DOERNER SAUNDERS TOTAL AMOUNT PAID: $ 50.00.
LINE ITEMS:
CJ-2004-2098: $50.00 ON AC01 CLERK FEES.
05-27-2004 CTFREE - 51230818 May 27 2004 10:05:02:513AM - $ 0.00
THORNBRUGH, P. THOMAS: RICHARD FOSTER PRESENT FOR THE PLAINTIFF. DAVID ANDERSON PRESENT FOR THE DEFENDANT. SHCEDULING ORDER ENTERED AS PER ORDER.
05-27-2004 SCHO - 51232886 May 27 2004 11:22:53:407AM - $ 0.00
SCHEDULING ORDER OF 5-27-04
06-07-2004 AMP - BIRCHALL, DAVID A 51304807 Jun 8 2004 8:31:19:897AM - $ 0.00
FIRST AMENDED PETITION
06-08-2004 MOC - BIRCHALL, DAVID A 51313908 Jun 8 2004 4:35:16:307PM - $ 0.00
PLTFS' MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY FROM DEFENDANT (C/J)
06-10-2004 APLI - RAINTREE ESTATES I INC 51334748 Jun 10 2004 4:11:30:313PM - $ 0.00
APPLICATION TO WITHDRAW AS ATTY FOR DEFT (SUBMITTED BY DAVID ANDERSON) A/J
06-10-2004 MO - RAINTREE ESTATES I INC 51336413 Jun 12 2004 12:17:05:383PM - $ 0.00
MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME
06-14-2004 EAA - RAINTREE ESTATES I INC 51344933 Jun 14 2004 2:39:43:330PM - $ 0.00
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE (BRIAN DITTRICH ENTERS AS COUNSEL)/CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
06-14-2004 MOSJ - 51348267 Jun 14 2004 4:41:53:580PM Realized $ 50.00
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT ATTY RICHARD H. FOSTER FOR PLNT($ 50.00)
06-14-2004 ACCOUNT - 51348318 Jun 14 2004 4:43:34:160PM - $ 0.00
RECEIPT # 2004-743869 ON 06/14/2004.
PAYOR: DOERNER SAUNDERS TOTAL AMOUNT PAID: $ 50.00.
LINE ITEMS:
CJ-2004-2098: $50.00 ON AC01 CLERK FEES.
06-15-2004 CTFREE - 51359680 Jun 15 2004 3:12:34:527PM - $ 0.00
THORNBRUGH, P. THOMAS: ORDER GRANTING WITHDRAWAL OF COUNSEL FOR THE DEFENDANT ENTERED.

ORDER GRANTING DEFENDANT TILL 07/09/04 TO FILE RESPONSE ENTERED.
06-15-2004 O - 51360344 Jun 15 2004 3:40:47:693PM - $ 0.00
ORDER ALLOWING ATTY TO WITHDRAWAL (DAVID M ANDERSON)
06-15-2004 O - 51360368 Jun 15 2004 3:41:25:490PM - $ 0.00
ORDER GRANTING EXTENSION OF TIME
06-15-2004 MO - BIRCHALL, DAVID A 51362148 Jun 15 2004 5:48:08:703PM - $ 0.00
UNOPPOSED MOTION OF PLS FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO JOIN ADDITIONAL PARTIES AND AMEND PLEADINGS
06-16-2004 CTFREE - 51368410 Jun 16 2004 1:19:53:440PM - $ 0.00
THORNBRUGH, P. THOMAS: ORDER GRANTING PLAINTIFF'S UNCONTESTED MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME. THE PLAINTIFFS ARE GRANTED THIRTY (30) DAYS OR UNTIL 07/14/04 TO JOIN ADDITIONAL PARTIES OR AMEND PLEADINGS.
06-21-2004 TEXT - BIRCHALL, DAVID A 51403644 Jun 21 2004 4:26:11:393PM - $ 0.00
PLTFS' SUPPLEMENT TO PLTF'S 6-8-04 MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY FROM DEFT/CERTIFICATE OF MAILING (A/J)
06-24-2004 A - RAINTREE ESTATES I INC 51439668 Jun 24 2004 12:00:57:073PM - $ 0.00
ANSWER TO FIRST AMENDED PETITOIN
06-24-2004 APLI - RAINTREE ESTATES I INC 51445377 Jun 25 2004 8:39:06:403AM - $ 0.00
DEFENDANTS UNOPPOSED APPLICATION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO RESPOND TO PLAINTIFFS FIRST MOTION TO COMPEL (BY BRIAN E DITTRICH DEF ATTY/ CERT OF SERVICE/ A TO J MH)
06-25-2004 CTFREE - 51448186 Jun 25 2004 10:43:10:587AM - $ 0.00
THORNBRUGH, P. THOMAS: ORDER GRANTING DEFENDANT'S APPLICATION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO RESPOND TO PLAINTIFFS' FIRST MOTION TO COMPEL ENTERED. DEFENDANT'S TIME TO RESPOND TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTION IS EXTENDED TO 07/08/04.
06-25-2004 O - 51449517 Jun 25 2004 11:42:33:667AM - $ 0.00
ORDER GRANTING PLTFS' UNCONTESTED MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME (UNTIL 7-15-04)
07-01-2004 WL - BIRCHALL, DAVID A 51488967 Jul 1 2004 12:10:44:143PM - $ 0.00
PLTFS' PRELMINARY WITNESS & EXHIBIT LIST
07-01-2004 WL - RAINTREE ESTATES I INC 51492487 Jul 1 2004 3:37:33:037PM - $ 0.00
DEFT'S INTIAL WITNESS & EXHIBIT LIST
07-09-2004 APLI - RAINTREE ESTATES I INC 51551004 Jul 9 2004 4:37:27:437PM - $ 0.00
DEFT'S SECOND UNOPPOSED APPLICATION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO RESPOND TO PLTF'S FIRST MOTION TO COMPEL & MOTIONS FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT
07-13-2004 CTFREE - 51574321 Jul 14 2004 8:01:25:637AM - $ 0.00
THORNBRUGH, P. THOMAS: ORDER GRANTING DEFENDANT'S APPLICATION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO RESPOND TO PLAINTIFFS' FIRST MOTION TO COMPEL AND MOTIONS FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT ENTERED. DEFENDANT'S TIME IS EXTENDED TO 08/15/04.
07-14-2004 MO - BIRCHALL, DAVID A 51586366 Jul 14 2004 4:36:37:947PM - $ 0.00
UNOPPOSED MOTION OF PLTF'S FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO JOIN ADD'L PARTIES & AMEND PLEADINGS (A/J)
07-15-2004 CTFREE - 51591058 Jul 15 2004 11:59:22:350AM - $ 0.00
THORNBRUGH, P. THOMAS: ORDER GRANTING PLAINTIFFS' UNCONTESTED MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME ENTERED. THE PLAINTIFFS' ARE HEREBY GRANTED AN EXTNESION OF THIRTY (30) DAYS, OR FROM 08/15/04 UNTIL 08/16/04, TO JOIN ADDITIONAL PARTIES OR AMEND PLEADINGS.
07-15-2004 TEXT - RAINTREE ESTATES I INC 51596862 Jul 15 2004 4:38:41:573PM - $ 0.00
DEFENDANTS RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFFS MAY 26, 2004 MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT
07-15-2004 RESP - RAINTREE ESTATES I INC 51597799 Jul 16 2004 9:07:52:987AM - $ 0.00
DEFENDANTS COMBINED RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFFS JUNE 14, 2004 MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND JUNE 8, 2004 MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY (BY BRIAN E DITTRICH DEF ATTY/ CERT OF SERVICE/ A TO J ML)
07-16-2004 O - 51601170 Jul 16 2004 11:56:37:183AM - $ 0.00
ORDER GRANTING PTFS' UNCONTESTED MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME (UNTIL 8-16-04)
07-19-2004 REQ - BIRCHALL, DAVID A 51619716 Jul 20 2004 8:45:51:663AM - $ 0.00
PLTF'S REQUEST FOR ORDER SETTING HEARING ON VARIOUS MOTION
07-20-2004 O - 51626512 Jul 20 2004 2:16:17:887PM - $ 0.00
ORDER GRANTING DEFT'S APPLICATION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO RESPOND TO PLTFS' FIRST MOTION TO COMPEL (ORDER SIGNED 6-25-04)
08-03-2004 O - 51734828 Aug 3 2004 2:43:56:530PM - $ 0.00
ORDER GRANTING DF'S APPLICATION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO RESPOND TO PLS' FIRST MOTION TO COMPEL AND MOTIONS FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT (ORDER SIGNED 7-13-04)
08-16-2004 MO - BIRCHALL, DAVID A 51965690 Aug 16 2004 1:46:08:270PM - $ 0.00
UNOPPOSED MOTION OF PLTFS FOR AMENDED SCHEDULING ORDER
08-26-2004 CTFREE - 52213810 Aug 26 2004 1:36:14:103PM - $ 0.00
THORNBRUGH, P. THOMAS: ORDER SETTING HEARING ON PLAINTIFFS' MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT, PLAINTIFFS' MOTION TO COMPEL AND PLAINTIFFS' MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT (COUNT 2) ENTERED AND SET FOR 09/30/04 2:30 PM ROOM 601

AMENDED SCHEDULING ORDER ENTERED.
08-26-2004 OSH - 52219895 Aug 27 2004 9:01:09:390AM - $ 0.00
ORDER SETTING HEARING (PENDING MOTIONS SET FOR HEARING ON 9-30-04 AT 2:30 P.M.)
08-26-2004 SCHO - 52220238 Aug 27 2004 9:12:56:317AM - $ 0.00
AMENDED SCHEDULING ORDER (OF 08-26-04 SEE INSTRUMENT)
09-28-2004 TEXT - BIRCHALL, DAVID A 52471110 Sep 28 2004 4:30:41:323PM - $ 0.00
SUPPLEMENT TO PLTFS' MAY 26, 2004 MOTON FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT (MOTION IS SET FOR HEARING ON 9-30-04 AT 2:30 P.M.) A/J
09-30-2004 CTFREE - 52492790 Oct 1 2004 11:03:41:307AM - $ 0.00
THORNBRUGH, P. THOMAS: BRIAN DITTRICH PRESENT FOR THE DEFENDANT. RICH FOSTER PRESENT FOR THE PLAINTIFFS. COURT REPORTER JODI ILES PRESENT. PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT SUSTAINED IN PART, OVERRULED IN PART ALL AS PER ORDER TO BE SUBMITTED BY MR. FOSTER. DEFENDANT'S GRANTED RIGHT TO INSPECT PLAINTIFF'S UNIT. PLAINTIFF GRANTED RIGHT TO INSPECT RECORD BOOK. PARTIES ORDERED TO SUBMIT TO MEDIATION. ALL TO BE PROVIDED WITHIN TEN (10) DAYS OF TODAY.
10-11-2004 CTFREE - 52562596 Oct 11 2004 11:34:28:437AM - $ 0.00
THORNBRUGH, P. THOMAS: ORDER REPORTING HEARINGS ENTERED.
10-12-2004 O - 52573730 Oct 12 2004 12:51:48:923PM - $ 0.00
ORDER / SIGNED BY JUDGE P. THOMAS THORNBRUGH ON 10-11-04
10-14-2004 CTEXP - 52595840 Oct 14 2004 10:07:21:113AM - $ 0.00
COURT FILE EXPANDED TO VOLUME <..2..> AS OF <..OCTOBER 14, 2004..>
12-10-2004 CTFREE - 53028761 Dec 10 2004 11:47:18:667AM - $ 0.00
THORNBRUGH, P. THOMAS: CONFIDENTIALITY ORDER ENTERED.
12-14-2004 O - 53059455 Dec 15 2004 8:46:23:917AM - $ 0.00
CONFIDENTIALITY ORDER (SEE INSTRUMENT)
12-17-2004 TEXT - RAINTREE ESTATES I INC 53092135 Dec 20 2004 8:54:06:113AM - $ 0.00
DEFENDANTS AMENDED COUNTERCLAIM (BY BRIAN E DITTRICH ATTY FOR DEF)
12-29-2004 MO - BIRCHALL, DAVID A 53149173 Dec 29 2004 12:38:29:113PM - $ 0.00
UNOPPOSED MOTION OF PLTFS FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO RESPOND TO DEFT'S AMENDED COUNTERCLAIM (A/J)
01-07-2005 CTFREE - 53216680 Jan 7 2005 2:47:53:677PM - $ 0.00
THORNBRUGH, P. THOMAS: ORDER GRANTING PLAINTIFFS' UNCONTESTED MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME ENTERED. PLAINTIFFS ARE GRANTED AN EXTENSION OF TEN (10) DAYS, OR UNTIL JANUARY 17TH, 2005, TO RESPOND TO DEFENDANT'S AMENDED COUNTERCLAIM.
01-10-2005 OG - 53224916 Jan 10 2005 1:37:59:407PM - $ 0.00
ORDER GRANTING PLAINTIFFS UNCONTESTED MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME
01-10-2005 MOD - BIRCHALL, DAVID A 53229225 Jan 10 2005 4:48:05:650PM Realized $ 0.00
PLTFS' MOTION TO DISMISS DEFT'S AMENDED COUNTERCLAIM (A/J)
01-12-2005 APLI - BIRCHALL, DAVID A 53252400 Jan 12 2005 4:41:48:297PM - $ 0.00
PLTFS' APPLICATION FOR HEARING ON MOTION TO COMPEL (A/J)
01-18-2005 OH - 53297967 Jan 19 2005 10:50:48:680AM - $ 0.00
ORDER FOR HEARING (2-03-05 AT 9:00 A.M.)
01-25-2005 APLI - RAINTREE ESTATES I INC 53353741 Jan 25 2005 2:36:43:170PM - $ 0.00
DEFENDANTS UNOPPOSED APPLICATION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO RESPOND TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO DISMISS (BY BRIAN E DITTRICH DEF ATTY/ CERT OF SERVICE/ A TO J ML)
01-26-2005 CTFREE - 53363201 Jan 26 2005 12:30:56:130PM - $ 0.00
THORNBRUGH, P. THOMAS: ORDER GRANTING DEFENDANT'S APPLICATION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO RESPOND TO PLAINTIFFS' MOTION TO DISMISS. DEFENDANT IS GIVEN UNTIL 02/11/05 TO RESPOND.
02-03-2005 CTFREE - 53433401 Feb 3 2005 9:29:05:750AM - $ 0.00
THORNBRUGH, P. THOMAS: PER PHONE CONVERSATION WITH RICH FOSTER, EVENT SET FOR 02/03/05 STRICKEN BY STIPULATION OF PARTIES TO BE RE-SET UPON APPLICATION.
02-11-2005 DWOP - 53644127 Feb 11 2005 4:26:20:283PM - $ 0.00
DEFENDANT'S DISMISSAL WITHOUT PREJUDICE BY ATTY BRIAN E DITTICH /ITS AMENDED COUNTERCLAIM
02-11-2005 DISPDWOP 5 BIRCHALL, DAVID A 53868868 Mar 14 2005 8:44:44:843AM - $ 0.00
DEF'S DISMISSAL WITHOUT PREJUDICE
02-11-2005 DISPDWOP 5 BIRCHALL, LINDA 53868869 Mar 14 2005 8:44:45:017AM - $ 0.00
DEF'S DISMISSAL WITHOUT PREJUDICE
03-03-2005 O - 53795935 Mar 3 2005 1:21:42:843PM - $ 0.00
ORDER GRANTING DEFT'S APPLICATION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO RESPOND TO PTFS' MOTION TO DISMISS
04-07-2005 MOSJ - 54091488 Apr 7 2005 4:17:42:363PM Realized $ 50.00
PLAINTIFFS MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON ALL REMAINING CLAIMS AND ISSUES (BY RICHARD H FOSTER ATTY FOR PLNTS - A/J DS)($ 50.00)
04-07-2005 ACCOUNT - 54091504 Apr 7 2005 4:18:44:253PM - $ 0.00
RECEIPT # 2005-887130 ON 04/07/2005.
PAYOR: DOERNER SAUNDERS TOTAL AMOUNT PAID: $ 50.00.
LINE ITEMS:
CJ-2004-2098: $50.00 ON AC01 CLERK FEES.
04-27-2005 RESP - RAINTREE ESTATES I INC 54248254 Apr 27 2005 11:15:48:247AM - $ 0.00
DEFT'S RESPONSE TO PLTFS' MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON ALL REMAINING CLAIMS & ISSUES (A/J)
05-06-2005 REQ - BIRCHALL, DAVID A 54329631 May 6 2005 12:41:12:813PM - $ 0.00
PLTS' REQUEST FOR ORDER SETTING HEARING ON MOTION (A/J)
05-09-2005 CTFREE - 54346004 May 9 2005 4:46:29:393PM - $ 0.00
THORNBRUGH, P. THOMAS: ORDER SETTING HEARING ENTERED AND SET FOR 06/29/05 11 AM ROOM 601.
05-10-2005 OSH - 54352091 May 10 2005 1:21:11:500PM - $ 0.00
ORDER SETTING HEARING (SEE ENTRY ABOVE)
06-14-2005 TEXT - 54633053 Jun 14 2005 2:17:57:163PM - $ 0.00
ADMINISTRATIVELY REASSIGNED BY AOC MIS PER HELP DESK CONTACT 76546
06-29-2005 CRF - 54840814 Jun 29 2005 10:42:49:720AM Realized $ 20.00
COURT REPORTER FEE-TRIAL ON MERITS($ 20.00)
06-29-2005 CTFREE - 54844797 Jun 29 2005 2:01:05:867PM - $ 0.00
NIGHTINGALE, REBECCA B: HEARING HELD ON PLAINTIFFS MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON ALL REMAINING CLAIMS . RICHARD FOSTER APPEARS FOR PLAINTIFF. BRIAN DIETRICH APPEARS FOR DEFENDANT. COURT REPORTER ROBIN QUICK PRESENT. DECISION TAKEN UNDER ADVISEMENT.
06-29-2005 ACCOUNT - 54840822 Jun 29 2005 10:43:03:373AM - $ 0.00
RECEIPT # 2005-929035 ON 06/29/2005.
PAYOR: RICHARD H. FOSTER TOTAL AMOUNT PAID: $ 20.00.
LINE ITEMS:
CJ-2004-2098: $20.00 ON AC01 CLERK FEES.
07-15-2005 O - 55148000 Jul 15 2005 9:01:27:857AM - $ 0.00
ORDER (PLTF'S MOTOIN FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON ALL REMAINING CLAIMS & ISSUES IS DENIED)/AFFIDAVIT OF MAILING
07-18-2005 REQ - BIRCHALL, DAVID A 55171967 Jul 18 2005 4:41:57:313PM - $ 0.00
PLTFS' REQUEST FOR STATUS CONFERENCE / CERTIFICATE OF MAILING
07-19-2005 CTFREE - 55184052 Jul 19 2005 4:47:03:387PM - $ 0.00
NIGHTINGALE, REBECCA BRETT: ORDER ENTERED SETTING STATUS CONFERENCE FOR 8-26-05 AT 9:00 AM.
07-20-2005 O - 55189552 Jul 20 2005 12:40:11:533PM - $ 0.00
ORDER SETTING STATUS CONFERENCE / SIGNED BY JUDGE REBECCA NIGHTINGALE
08-26-2005 SCHO - 56017849 Aug 26 2005 9:35:28:640AM - $ 0.00
SCHEDULING ORDER OF 8-26-05
08-26-2005 CTFREE - 56018309 Aug 26 2005 9:55:35:400AM - $ 0.00
NIGHTINGALE, REBECCA BRETT: STATUS CONFERENCE HELD. RICHARD FOSTER APPEARS FOR PLAINTIFF BRIAN DITTRICH APPEARS FOR DEFENDANT. SCHEDULING ORDER ENTERED. PRETRIAL CONFERENCE SET FOR 12-5-05 AT 11:30 AM.
09-09-2005 WL - RAINTREE ESTATES I INC 56129429 Sep 9 2005 1:59:56:543PM - $ 0.00
DEFT'S PRELIMINARY WITNESS & EXHIBIT LIST
09-09-2005 WL - BIRCHALL, DAVID A 56133024 Sep 9 2005 4:32:57:467PM - $ 0.00
PLTFS' PRELIMINARY WITNESS & EXHIBIT LIST
10-03-2005 WL - BIRCHALL, DAVID A 56322892 Oct 3 2005 4:45:54:080PM - $ 0.00
PLTFS' FINAL WITNESS & EXHIBIT LIST
12-02-2005 MO - BIRCHALL, DAVID A 56927866 Dec 5 2005 9:01:24:293AM - $ 0.00
PLTFS' MOTION FOR SANCTIONS AGAINST DEFT (A/J)
12-05-2005 CTFREE - 56932782 Dec 5 2005 11:44:38:840AM - $ 0.00
NIGHTINGALE, REBECCA B: PRETRIAL CONFERENCE IS HELD. RICHARD FOSTER APPEARS FOR PLT. BRIAN DITTRICH APPEARS FOR DEF. PLT'S MOTIONS FOR SANCTIONS ARE MOOT AND DENIED. TRIAL DATE IS SET FOR 2-1-06 @ 9:30AM
01-13-2006 CRF - 57234334 Jan 13 2006 4:28:20:380PM Realized $ 20.00
COURT REPORTER FEE-TRIAL ON MERITS($ 20.00)
01-13-2006 PTO - 57235542 Jan 17 2006 7:24:50:570AM - $ 0.00
PRE-TRIAL ORDER
01-13-2006 ACCOUNT - 57234381 Jan 13 2006 4:29:26:957PM - $ 0.00
RECEIPT # 2006-1021695 ON 01/13/2006.
PAYOR: DOERNER SAUNDERS TOTAL AMOUNT PAID: $ 20.00.
LINE ITEMS:
CJ-2004-2098: $20.00 ON AC01 CLERK FEES.
01-18-2006 EAA - RAINTREE ESTATES I INC 57264779 Jan 19 2006 8:52:09:900AM - $ 0.00
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE & RESERVATIOPN OF ADD'L TIME WITHIN WHICH TO ANSWER OR FURTHER PLEAD (BRIAN DITTRICH ENTERS AS COUNSEL - COVERSHEET ATTACHED)/CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
01-23-2006 MO - BIRCHALL, DAVID A 57294338 Jan 23 2006 12:58:58:627PM - $ 0.00
PLTFS' MOTION TO ADD OR SUBSTITUTE TRIAL EXHIBIT (A/J)
01-25-2006 B - BIRCHALL, DAVID A 57324180 Jan 25 2006 4:28:16:770PM - $ 0.00
PLTFS' TRIAL BRIEF (A/J)
02-01-2006 CTFREE - 57739317 Mar 16 2006 1:44:24:390PM - $ 0.00
CJ-04-2098

MARCH 16, 2006

DAVID A. BIRCHALL AND LINDA BIRCHALL VS. RAINTREE ESTATES I, INC.

NON JURY TRIAL

CASE CALLED FOR NON-JURY TRIAL. BOTH SIDES PRESENT IN OPEN COURT AND ANNOUNCE READY FOR TRIAL. PLAINTIFFS PRESENT AND REPRESENTED BY RICHARD H. FOSTER. DEFENDANT PRESENT AND REPRESENTED BY BRIAN DITTRICH.

OPENING STATEMENTS ARE MADE. 3 WITNESSES SWORN. RULE WAS NOT INVOKED. REPORTER ROBIN QUICK.

PLAINTIFF PRESENTS EVIDENCE AND RESTS. DEFENDANT PRESENTS EVIDENCE AND RESTS. BOTH SIDES REST.

CLOSING ARGUMENTS ARE MADE.

THE COURT'S DECISION:

COURT RULED IN FAVOR OF PLAINTIFFS.
WITNESSES: DAVID BIRCHALL, DICK BLAKELEY, AND STEVE MEYER

02-10-2006 MO - BIRCHALL, DAVID A 57463759 Feb 10 2006 4:48:50:097PM - $ 0.00
PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO SETTLE JOURNAL ENTRY OR ALTERNATIVELY REQUEST FOR EXPEDITED HEARING (BY RICHARD H FOSTER PLTS ATTY/ CERT OF MAILING)
02-13-2006 DISPJE 1 RAINTREE ESTATES I INC 57465327 Feb 13 2006 9:50:43:950AM - $ 0.00
NIGHTINGALE, REBECCA B: JOURNAL ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ENTERED - SEE INSTRUMENT
02-13-2006 DISPJE 2 RAINTREE ESTATES I INC 57465328 Feb 13 2006 9:50:41:047AM - $ 0.00
NIGHTINGALE, REBECCA B: JOURNAL ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ENTERED - SEE INSTRUMENT
02-13-2006 DISPJE 3 RAINTREE ESTATES I INC 57465329 Feb 13 2006 9:50:41:140AM - $ 0.00
NIGHTINGALE, REBECCA B: JOURNAL ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ENTERED - SEE INSTRUMENT
02-13-2006 DISPJE 4 RAINTREE ESTATES I INC 57465330 Feb 13 2006 9:50:41:250AM - $ 0.00
NIGHTINGALE, REBECCA B: JOURNAL ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ENTERED - SEE INSTRUMENT
02-13-2006 JEJ - 57476788 Feb 13 2006 4:59:58:723PM - $ 0.00
JOURNAL ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ATTY'S FEES FOR DAVID ANDERSON SUM OF $212.50
02-16-2006 CERTS - BIRCHALL, DAVID A 57508039 Feb 16 2006 1:03:00:033PM - $ 0.00
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE OF JOURNAL ENTRY
03-15-2006 DORNJT - 57725998 Mar 15 2006 11:46:37:020AM Realized $ 200.00
DESIGNATION OF RECORD NON-JURY TRIAL COPY TO TOBY
FILED BY APPELLANTS ATTY BRIAN DITTRICH($ 200.00)
03-15-2006 PIE - RAINTREE ESTATES I INC 57726773 Mar 15 2006 12:34:56:320PM Realized $ 0.00
PETITION IN ERROR (C/TJ)
03-15-2006 ACCOUNT - 57726070 Mar 15 2006 11:46:54:317AM - $ 0.00
RECEIPT # 2006-1052420 ON 03/15/2006.
PAYOR: DITTRICH LAW TOTAL AMOUNT PAID: $ 200.00.
LINE ITEMS:
CJ-2004-2098: $200.00 ON AC01 CLERK FEES.
03-20-2006 CNOTE - 57754631 Mar 20 2006 9:13:48:107AM - $ 0.00
DUE DATE FOR NOTICE OF COMPLETION OF RECORD ON APPEAL TO STATE SUPREME COURT> AUGUST 13, 2006
03-21-2006 TEXT - 57768553 Mar 21 2006 10:26:31:530AM - $ 0.00
CERTIFICATE OF APPEAL IN SUPREME COURT CASE # 103155
03-21-2006 RESP - BIRCHALL, DAVID A 57779273 Mar 22 2006 9:36:12:830AM - $ 0.00
RESPONSE TO PETITION IN ERROR (SUPREME CASE NO DF-103155) / BY RICHARD H FOSTER, ATTY FOR PLAINTIFF
03-21-2006 DORNJT - 57779314 Mar 22 2006 9:38:10:827AM Realized $ 0.00
COUNTER-DESIGNATION OF RECORD FOR APPEAL FROM DISTRICT COURT / RICHARD H. FOSTER; ATTY FOR DFS DAVID A. BIRCHALL AND LINDA BIRCHALL
05-25-2006 NO - 60650745 May 25 2006 10:45:41:393AM - $ 0.00
NOTICE OF FILING TRANSCRIPTS BY COURT REPORTER ROBIN QUICK.
05-25-2006 T - 60650780 May 25 2006 10:47:29:843AM - $ 0.00
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS HELD FEBRUARY 1, 2006.
COURT REPORTER ROBIN QUICK (2 COPIES)
05-25-2006 T - 60650811 May 25 2006 10:48:32:657AM - $ 0.00
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS HELD JUNE 29, 2005.
COURT REPORTER ROBIN QUICK ( 2 COPIES)
05-25-2006 EXHI - 60650830 May 25 2006 10:49:10:297AM - $ 0.00
PLAINTIFF'S TRIAL EXHIBITS
05-30-2006 RECP - 60673364 May 30 2006 9:33:20:410AM - $ 0.00
RECEIPT OF TRANSCRIPTS PICKED UP BY BOOKER GILLESPIE FOR ATTY RICHARD FOSTER
08-03-2006 T - 61214591 Aug 3 2006 2:10:09:127PM - $ 0.00
ORIGINAL TRANSCRIPT OF SCHEDULING CONFERENCE HEARD ON SEPTEMBER 30TH, 2004. COURT REPORTER JODI D'VOREE ILES (2 COPIES)
08-07-2006 NO - 61234252 Aug 7 2006 1:50:01:507PM - $ 0.00
NOTICE OF COMPLETION OF RECORD ON APPEAL IN SUPREME COURT CASE # 103155. NOTICES MAILED TO MICHAEL RICHIE CLERK OF THE APPELLATE COURT AND ALL COUNSEL.
08-07-2006 TEXT - 61234314 Aug 7 2006 1:52:06:253PM - $ 0.00
INDEX OF RECORD ON APPEAL IN SUPREME COURT CASE # 103155. RECORD CONSISTS OF 3 VOLUMES OF THE ORIGINAL FILE; 1 BOUND PLEADING; EXHIBIT BINDER; 3 TRANSCRIPTS.
10-13-2006 O - 61808787 Oct 13 2006 3:41:29:750PM - $ 0.00
ORDER FROM THE SUPREME COURT CASE # 103155:
APPELLANT IS GRANTED TO OCTOBER 20, 2006 TO FILE ITS BRIEF.
12-11-2006 MOVAC - 62320120 Dec 11 2006 12:10:20:933PM Realized $ 20.00
JOINT MOTION TO VACATEJUDGMENT AND FOR DISMISSAL OF LAWSUIT WITH PREJUDICE BY RICHARD FOSTER ATTY FOR PLAINTIFF($ 20.00)
12-11-2006 OCISR - 62320121 Dec 11 2006 12:10:21:313PM Realized $ 10.00
OKLAHOMA COURT INFORMATION SYSTEM REVOLVING FUND($ 10.00)
12-11-2006 CCADMIN - 62320122 Dec 11 2006 12:10:21:333PM Realized $ 1.00
COURT CLERK ADMINISTRATIVE FEE ON COLLECTIONS($ 1.00)
12-11-2006 CHAB - 62320123 Dec 11 2006 12:10:21:363PM Realized $ 10.00
C.H.A.B. STATUTORY FEE($ 10.00)
12-11-2006 ACCOUNT - 62320133 Dec 11 2006 12:11:07:123PM - $ 0.00
RECEIPT # 2006-1187065 ON 12/11/2006.
PAYOR: DOERNER SAUNDERS TOTAL AMOUNT PAID: $ 41.00.
LINE ITEMS:
CJ-2004-2098: $20.00 ON AC01 CLERK FEES.
CJ-2004-2098: $1.00 ON AC31 COURT CLERK REVOLVING FUND.
CJ-2004-2098: $10.00 ON AC69 CHILD ABUSE MULTIDISCIPLINARY FEE.
CJ-2004-2098: $10.00 ON AC79 OCIS REVOLVING FUND.
12-12-2006 CTFREE - 62341146 Dec 12 2006 5:17:58:997PM - $ 0.00
NIGHTINGALE, REBECCA: GRANTED - ORDER VACATING JUDGMENT AND DISMISSING ACTION WITH PREJUDICE
12-13-2006 O - 62350566 Dec 13 2006 1:45:28:917PM - $ 0.00
ORDER VACATING JUDGMENT AND DISMISSING ACTION WITH PREJUDICE FILED FEB 13,2006
12-20-2006 O - 62409520 Dec 20 2006 3:14:19:207PM - $ 0.00
ORDER FROM THE SUPREME COURT IN CASE # 103155: DISMISSED
01-17-2007 MAN - 62604584 Jan 17 2007 3:24:15:173PM - $ 0.00
MANDATE RECEIVED IN SUPREME COURT CASE # 103155 AND SENT TO JUDGE NIGHTINGALE FOR SIGNATURE> DISMISSED
01-19-2007 MAN - 62628893 Jan 19 2007 4:35:02:393PM - $ 0.00
MANDATE RECEIVED AND ORDERED FILED AND SPREAD OF RECORD THIS 18 DAY OF JAN 2007 / DISMISSED
09-13-2010 CNOTE - 75771202 Sep 13 2010 7:46:15:070AM - $ 0.00
CASE NOTE: RETURNED 3 VOLUMES OF THE ORIGINAL FILE; 3 TRANSCIPTS; 1 SUMMARY BINDER TO WAREHOUSE//APPEAL DISMISSED JANUARY 18 2007 IN SC #103155//DF

Title 60 O.S. Section 508 provides:

Each unit owner shall comply strictly with the bylaws and with the administrative rules and regulations adopted pursuant thereto, as either of the same may be lawfully amended from time to time, and with the covenants, conditions and restrictions set forth in the declaration or in the deed to his unit. Failure to comply with any of the same shall be grounds for an action to recover sums due, for damages or injunctive relief or both, maintainable by the manager or board of managers on behalf of the council of unit owners or, in a proper case, by an aggrieved unit owner.

Title 15 O.S. Section 213 provides:

Except as expressly provided in Section 215 of this title, penalties imposed by contract for any non-performance thereof, are void. But this section does not render void such bonds or obligations, penal in form, as have heretofore been commonly used; it merely rejects and avoids the penal clauses.

Outcome: Judgment in favor of the Birchalls vacated by agreement of the parties and dismissed.

Plaintiff's Experts:

Defendant's Experts:

Comments:



Find a Lawyer

Subject:
City:
State:
 

Find a Case

Subject:
County:
State: