Please E-mail suggested additions, comments and/or corrections to Kent@MoreLaw.Com.
Date: 06-12-2015
Case Style: Michael D. Galier v. Murco Wall Products and Welco Manufacturing Company
Case Number: Cj-2012-6920
Judge: Bryan C. Dixon
Court: District Court, Oklahoma County, Oklahoma
Plaintiff's Attorney: Jessica Dean and Steven Horton and Brent Neighbors
Defendant's Attorney: Mike Carter, Calvin Sharpe and Cathy Campbell for Welco Manufacturing co.
Richard N. Dodson for Murco Wall Products
Description: Oklahoma City, OK - Michael D. Galier, age 51, from Moore, Oklahoma sued Murco Wall Products and Welco Manufacturing o Company on products liability theories claiming that he developed malignant mesothelioma as a direct result of being exposed to products containing asbestos claiming:
Statement of Material Facts To Which No Genuine Issue Existed Before Trial:
1. Plaintiff filed this action on November 1, 2012, and claimed that Plaintiff Michael Galier worked with and/or was exposed to asbestos and/or asbestos-containing products manufactured or sold by 22 defendants. See First Amended Petition, ¶‘ 2-24 (Ex. 1),
Plaintiff claimed childhood through adulthood exposure to residential construction site asbestos-containing products, and that in the early 1990s, Plaintiff worked as a selfI employed auto mechanic. See Amended Petition, ¶ 27. (Ex. I).
On February 13, 2013, Plaintiff was deposed and testified that he was never employed as an auto mechanic. See M. Galier dep. p. 131:22-25 (Ex. 2).
4. Plaintiff was not employed by Ford Motor Company.
For approximately the last twenty-three (23) years, Plaintiff has worked in food
preparation in the food service industry, and currently works as a cook for Embassy
Suites in Oklahoma City. See M. Galier dep. P. 72:22-76:25 (Ex. 2).
All fact witnesses have been deposed, and the uncontroverted evidence shows that Plaintiff occasionally worked with Ford vehicles, but there is no evidence of Ford brake
work:
Plaintiffs brother, Anthony Galier, was listed in this case as a product
identification witness. Anthony Galier described Plaintiffs work with
vehicles:
But I don’t know that -- I don’t know that I would particularly say
he -- that he did a lot of auto mechanic stuff. Pm sure that he did a little bit here and there, but I don’t know specifically what he
did.
See Anthony Galier dep. p.28:13-IS (Ex. 3).
b. Rita Galier, Plaintiff’s mother, was listed in this case as a product identification witness, and described Plaintiffs vehicle work:
Q Well, let me ask you it this way. Did you ever observe your son Michael perform any sort of work on any
vehicles?
A Other than putting gas in the car and putting oil -- you
know, adding oil or windshield fluid or something like
that, I don’t think so.
Q Did you ever see him change brakes on a car?
A No.
See R. Galier dep. p. 92: 8-17 (Ex. 4).
c, Plaintiff testified that during the late 1980s to early 1990s, on Friday evenings after work, if he didn’t have a date, Plaintiff went to a friend’s wrecker facility for a social gathering, where he and friends drank Wild Turkey whiskey, gathered around a fire barrel, and dismantled or rebuilt wrecked vehicles. See M. Galier dep. p. 42: 9-44:6 (Ex. 2).
d. When asked about the vehicles at the wrecker facility, Plaintiff testified:
Q. Okay. Now, going back to the time period where you were doing this work, specifically at Mr. Self s wrecker yard, are you able to tell us the make, model, model year, or mileage of any vehicle that you tore down or you worked on during that time period, whether it was a Ford, Lincoln, Mercury product or not?
A. Yeah, I don’t know -- I don’t know maybe the specifics. I just know it was a huge variety of cars that I never kept up with.
Q. Okay. Can you tell us about the maintenance history of any of those vehicles?
A. No. I thought -- Are we -- No. I mean, I didn’t -- That wasn’t my job, to understand the maintenance.
Q. During that time period, can you tell us anything about how those vehicles were used?
A. Just on the road until we picked them up.
Q. Anything other than that?
A. You know, sometimes it felt like to me they were more beat-up cars, but, you know, they were ones that broke down and people left for dead.
See M. Galier Dep. p. 142:24-143:21 (Ex. 2).
e. Mr. Galier testified that sometimes he removed brake drums and brake shoes from the salvaged vehicles, which included Ford vehicles, but, the
brakes removed were manufactured by another company. See M. Galier dep. p. 47:1-9 (Ex. 2). In fact, Plaintiff testified that the brakes removed had the name of the other manufacturer right on them. Id. Plaintiff testified that the name of the other manufacturer, not Ford, is the only brake manufacturer that he can recall. See M. Galier dep. p. 49:13-15, Plaintiff did not know the manufacturer of new or replacement brakes that might have been put back on any wrecker facility vehicles. See M. Galier dep. p. 283:2-5. In short, this activity did not involve Ford brakes.
f. As for his personal or family vehicles, Plaintiff testified that he twice removed brakes on a 1974 Ford Pinto. See M. Galier dep. p. 153:1-5; 175:14-16; 176: 7-25 (Ex. 2). The brakes removed were not Ford brakes, as the brakes had been removed previously and more than once. See Andrew Galier dep. p. 42:18-43:18 (Ex. 5). Plaintiff does not know the manufacturer of the brakes put back on the Pinto. See M. Galier dep. p.
177:4-6 (Ex. 2).
g. Plaintiff twice assisted his father with a brake change and it might have involved mid-to-late-1970s Ford minivans allegedly owned by his father. See M. Galier dep. p. 185:10-14; 287:12-20; 288:14-17 (Ex. 2). The manufacturer of the brakes removed and replaced could not be identified:
Q, Okay. I guess, do you -- do you have a way to break down how many brake jobs you did on each of the two vehicles?
A: I just remember a couple of times doing brake jobs with my dad.
Q. All right. Do you recall what brand of brakes you took off?
A: No.
Q. What about brand of brakes that you put on?
A: No.
See M. Galier dep. p. 185: 10-19 (Ex. 2). Plaintiff has no evidence that this activity involved a Ford brake.
h. Finally, Plaintiff testified that he likely once changed the brakes on a Crown Vic his girlfriend owned, but he does not know the manufacturer of the brakes removed or replaced on that vehicle. See M. Galier dep. p. 153:18- 154:4 (Ex. 2). There is no evidence that this activity involved a Ford brake.
h. Plaintiff has no evidence that Mr. Galier worked with or around brakes manufactured by Ford.
Statement of Case:
The parties to this case are Michael D. Galier, the Plaintiff, and Murco Wall Products, Inc., Red Devil Corporation, and Welco Manufacturing Company, Inc., the Defendants.
Plaintiff claims that he sustained injuries which were caused by defects in the asbestos joint compound and caulk products manufactured and sold by Defendants. He claims that the use of asbestos in these products andlor the failure to warn about the health hazards of asbestos exposure made the products unreasonably dangerous. He claims there is a significant probability that these defects in Defendants’ asbestos joint compound and caulk products are related to his injuries.
Plaintiff further claims that his injuries were caused by the negligence of Defendants in (1) failing to place warnings on their asbestos joint compound and caulk products about the health hazards of exposure to asbestos dust from the products, (2) failing to include instructions for reducing exposure to asbestos dust from the products, (3) failing to utilize non-asbestos formulas for their joint compound and caulk products, and (4) violating federal regulations banning the use of asbestos in joint compound and caulk products after January of 1978.
Docket
Date Code Description Count Party Amount
11-01-2012 TEXT
Civil relief more than $10,000 Initial Filing.
1
11-01-2012 PROD
PRODUCT LIABILITY
11-01-2012 DMFE
DISPUTE MEDIATION FEE
$ 2.00
11-01-2012 PFE1
PETITION
$ 163.00
11-01-2012 PFE7
LAW LIBRARY FEE
$ 6.00
11-01-2012 OCISR
Oklahoma Court Information System Revolving Fund
$ 25.00
11-01-2012 CCADMIN02
Court Clerk Administrative Fee on $2 Collections
$ 0.20
11-01-2012 OCJC
Oklahoma Council on Judicial Complaints Revolving Fund
$ 2.00
11-01-2012 OCASA
Oklahoma Court Appointed Special Advocates
$ 5.00
11-01-2012 CCADMIN04
Court Clerk Administrative Fee on Collections
$ 0.50
11-01-2012 LTF
Lengthy Trial Fund
$ 10.00
11-01-2012 SMF
Summons Fee (Clerks Fee)X18
$ 90.00
11-01-2012 P
PLAINTIFF'S ORIGINAL Petition
Document Available (#1019968711)
Galier, Michael D.
11-01-2012 TEXT
EXPERT REPORT
11-01-2012 TEXT
OCIS has automatically assigned Judge Dixon, Bryan C. to this case.
11-01-2012 ACCOUNT
Receipt # 2012-2996620 on 11/01/2012.
Payor:HORTON & NEIGHBORS PC Total Amount Paid: $303.70.
Line Items:
CJ-2012-6920: $253.00 on AC01 Clerk Fees.
CJ-2012-6920: $6.00 on AC23 Law Library Fee.
CJ-2012-6920: $0.70 on AC31 Court Clerk Revolving Fund.
CJ-2012-6920: $5.00 on AC58 Oklahoma Court Appointed Special Advocates.
CJ-2012-6920: $2.00 on AC59 Oklahoma Council on Judicial Complaints Revolving Fund.
CJ-2012-6920: $2.00 on AC64 Dispute Mediation Fees.
CJ-2012-6920: $25.00 on AC79 OCIS Revolving Fund.
CJ-2012-6920: $10.00 on AC81 Lengthy Trial Fund.
11-19-2012 EAA
SPECIAL APPEARANCE RESERVING ADDITIONAL TIME TO FURTHER PLEAD OR ANSWER
Document Available (#1019743582)
11-19-2012 EAA
SPECIAL APPEARANCE RESERVING ADDITIONAL TIME TO FURTHER PLEAD ORANSWER
Document Available (#1019743586)
11-27-2012 A
ANSWER of WELCO MANUFACTURING COMPANY TO PLAINTIFF'S ORIGINAL PETITION
Document Available (#1019974813)
Welco Manufacturing Co.
11-27-2012 EAA
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF ATTORNEYS MICHAEL D. CARTER, G. CALVIN SHARPE, AND CATHERINE L. CAMPBELL FOR DEFENDANT, WELCO MANUFACTURING COMPANY
Document Available (#1019974817)
Welco Manufacturing Co.
11-28-2012 EAA
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY ATTY JENNIFER BRUNER FOR DEFTS KCG, INC.
Document Available (#1019508672)
11-28-2012 EAA
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY ATTY J.R. "RANDY" BAKER FOR DEFTS KCG, INC.
Document Available (#1019508676)
11-28-2012 APLI
APPLICATION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO ANSWER OR FURTHER PLEAD ON BEHALF OF KCG INC
11-29-2012 EAA
SPECIAL ENTRY OF APPEARANCE RESERVING ADDITIONAL TIME IN WHICH TO FURTHER ANSWER OR PLEAD BY ATTY THERESA N. HILL FOR DEFT SPECIAL ELECTRIC COMPANY, INC.
Document Available (#1019500774)
11-30-2012 A
DEFENDANT FORD MOTOR COMPANY'S ANSWER TO PLAINTIFF'S ORIGINAL PETITION BY ATTORNEY VANI SINGHAL
Document Available (#1019974514)
11-30-2012 EAA
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY ATTORNEY VANI SIGNHAL FOR DEFENDANT, FORD MOTOR COMPANY
Document Available (#1019974513)
11-30-2012 EAA
DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS, INC.'S SPECIAL ENTRY OF APPEARANCE RESERVING ADDITIONAL TIME IN WHICH TO FURTHER ANSWER OR PLEAD BY ATTORNEY RICHARD N. DODSON
Document Available (#1019974432)
Murco Wall Products, Inc.
11-30-2012 EAA
QUALIFIED ENTRY OF APPEARANCE AND REQUEST FOR ENLARGEMENT OF TIME IN WHICH TO FURTHER ANSWER OR PLEAD BY ATTORNEY JOHN R. WOODARD, III FOR DEFENDANT, DAP PRODUCTS, INC.
Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
DAP Products, Inc.
11-30-2012 O
order granting application for extension of time to answer or further plead by defendant, terex corporation/ dixon
Document Available (#1020114872)
12-03-2012 EAA
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY ATTORNEY TIMOTHY J. BOMHOFF AND KYMALA B. CARRIER FOR DEFENDANT, GEORGIA-PACIFIC LLC F/K/A GEORGIA-PACIFIC CORPORATION
Document Available (#1019974623)
Georgia-Pacific, L.L.C.
12-03-2012 A
ANSWER OF DEFENDANT GEORGIA-PACIFIC LLC TO PLAINTIFF'S ORIGINAL PETITION, AND TO ANY AND ALL CROSS CLAIM BY ATTORNEY KYMALA B. CARRIER
Document Available (#1019974622)
Georgia-Pacific, L.L.C.
12-03-2012 EAA
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY ATTORNEY MICHELLE B. SKEENS FOR THE O' REILLY AUTOMOTIVE STORES, INC.
Document Available (#1019974624)
12-03-2012 EAA
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY ATTORNEY GUS H. BUTHMAN FOR THE O'REILLY AUTOMOTIVE STORE, INC.
Document Available (#1019974625)
O'Reilly Automotive Stores, Inc.
12-03-2012 A
ANSWER TO ORIGINAL PETITION BY ATTORNEY KELLY A HENSLEY FOR DEFENDANT, O'REILLY AUTOMOTIVE STORES, INC.
Document Available (#1019974626)
O'Reilly Automotive Stores, Inc.
12-03-2012 SMS
Summons Returned, Served: BORG-WARNER MORSE TEC INC BY CERTIFIED MAIL ON 11-14-12
Document Available (#1020303339)
12-03-2012 SMS
Summons Returned, Served: WELCO MANUFACTURING CO. MILTON STRADER BY CERTIFIED MAIL ON 11-15-12
Document Available (#1020303418)
12-03-2012 SMS
Summons Returned, Served: UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION THE CORPORATION COMPANY BY CERTIFIED MAIL ON 11-13-12
Document Available (#1020303422)
12-03-2012 SMS
Summons Returned, Served: SPECIAL ELECTRIC COMPANY, INC. CT CORPORATION SYSTEM BY CERTIFIED MAIL ON 11-14-12
Document Available (#1020303426)
12-03-2012 SMS
Summons Returned, Served: RT VANDERBUILT COMPANY, INC. BY CERTIFIED MAIL ON 11-13-12
Document Available (#1020303430)
12-03-2012 SMS
Summons Returned, Served: RED DEVIL, INC. C/O LEGAL DEPARTMENT BY CERTIFIED MAIL ON 11-14-12
Document Available (#1020303434)
12-03-2012 SMS
Summons Returned, Served: PNEUMO ABEX LLC CORPORATION SERVICE CO BY CERTIFIED MAIL ON 11-15-12
Document Available (#1020303438)
12-03-2012 SMS
Summons Returned, Served: THE PEP BOYS - MANNY MOE & JACK OF CALIFORNIA CSC-LAWYERS INCORPORATING SERVICE BY CERTIFIED MAIL ON 11-13-12
Document Available (#1020303442)
12-03-2012 SMS
Summons Returned, Served: O'REILLY AUTOMOTIVE STORES, INC. THE CORPORATION COMPANY BY CERTIFIED MAIL ON 11-13-12
Document Available (#1020303446)
12-03-2012 SMS
Summons Returned, Served: MURCO WALL PRODUCTS, INC. C/O EVA JO BENTON BY CERTIFIED MAIL ON 11-13-12
Document Available (#1020303450)
12-03-2012 SMS
Summons Returned, Served: METROPOLITAN LIFE INSURANCE CO BY CERTIFIED MAIL ON 11-14-12
Document Available (#1020303454)
12-03-2012 SMS
Summons Returned, Served: KCG, INC. CORPORATION SERVICE COMPANY BY CERTIFIED MAIL ON 11-13-12
Document Available (#1020303458)
12-03-2012 SMS
Summons Returned, Served: HONEYWELL INTERNATIONAL, INC. CORPORATION SERVICE COMPANY BY CERTIFIED MAIL ON 11-13-12
Document Available (#1020303462)
12-03-2012 SMS
Summons Returned, Served: GEORGIA-PACIFIC LLC THE CORPORATION COMPANY BY CERTIFIED MAIL ON 11-13-12
Document Available (#1020303466)
12-03-2012 SMS
Summons Returned, Served: GENUINE PARTS COMPANY (AKA NAPA) THE CORPORATION COMPANY BY CERTIFIED MAIL ON 11-13-12
Document Available (#1020303470)
12-03-2012 SMS
Summons Returned, Served: FORD MOTOR COMPANY THE CORPORATION COMPANY BY CERTIFIED MAIL ON 11-13-12
Document Available (#1020303474)
12-03-2012 SMS
Summons Returned, Served: DAP PRODUCTS, INC THE PRENTICE HALL CORPORATION SYSTEM, INC. BY CERTIFIED MAIL ON 11-15-12
Document Available (#1020303478)
12-03-2012 SMS
Summons Returned, Served: CERTAINTEED CORPORATION THE CORPORATION COMPANY BY CERTIFIED MAIL ON 11-14-12
Document Available (#1020303482)
12-04-2012 A
ANSWER FROM DEFENDANT, GENUINE PARTS COMPANY D/B/A NATIONAL AUTOMOTIVE PARTS ASSOCIATION (AKA NAPA) BY THROUGH ATTORNEY RECORD A. MARK SMILING
Document Available (#1019974648)
Genuine Parts Company
12-04-2012 RESP
RESPONSE AND AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES OF DEFENDANT
R.T. VANDERBILT TO PLAINTIFF'S ORIGINAL PETITION BY ATTORNEY GARY D. ELLISTON
Document Available (#1019974644)
RT Vanderbilt Company, Inc.
12-04-2012 EAA
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY ATTORNEY MISTI MOSTELLER FOR DEFENDANT, R.T. VANDERBILT COMPANY INC.,
Document Available (#1019974643)
RT Vanderbilt Company, Inc.
12-04-2012 EAA
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF ATTORNEYS MURRAY E. ABOWITZ AND KAYCE L. GISINGER FOR DEFENDANT, THE PEP BOYS-MANNY, MOE & JACK
Document Available (#1019973752)
The Pep Boys - Manny Moe & Jack of California
12-04-2012 EAA
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE OF ATTORNEYS MURRAY E. ABOWITZ AND KAYCE L. GISINGER FOR DEFENDANT, RED DEVIL, INC
Document Available (#1019973745)
Red Devil, Inc.
12-04-2012 NO
NOTICE OF RESERVICATION OF TIME
12-04-2012 O
DEFENDANT KCG, INC.'S APPLICATION FOR NUNC PRO TUNC ORDER
12-05-2012 A
ANSWER AND DEFENSES OF METROPOLITAN LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY TO PLAINTIFF'S PETITION AND JURY DEMAND AND TO CROSS-CLAIMS OF ANY AND ALL OTHER DEFENDANTS AND THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANTS THROUGH ATTY ROBERT WINTER.
Document Available (#1019976124)
12-05-2012 RESP
DEFENDANT, PNEUMO ABEX LLC, SUCCESSOR IN INTEREST TO ABEX CORPORATION'S RESPONSE AND AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES TO PLAINTIFF'S PETITION THROUGH ATT'YS MARGARET CHAPLINSKY AND MARTHA PHILLIPS, ESQ.
Document Available (#1019976137)
12-05-2012 RESP
DEFENDANT CERTAINTEED CORPORATION'S RESPONSE AND AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES TO PLAINTIFF'S PETITION BY ATTORNEY MARGARET M. CHAPLINSKY AND MARTHA J. PHILLIPS
Document Available (#1020460425)
Certainteed Corporation
12-06-2012 EAA
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY ATTY SHARLA J. FROST AND SHAWN D. GOLDEN FOR DEFENDANT UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION
Document Available (#1019975916)
12-06-2012 RESP
DEFENDANT UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION'S RESPONSE
AND AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES TO PLAINTIFF'S ORIGINAL
PETITION BY ATTORNEY SHARLA J. FROST
Document Available (#1019974475)
12-06-2012 ONPT
ORDER NUNC PRO TUNC/judge dixon
Document Available (#1020307517)
12-14-2012 EAA
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY ATTORNEY R. CHRIS PARK FOR DEFENDANT, BORG WARNER MORSE TEC INC.
Document Available (#1020112417)
Borg-Warner Morse Tec, Inc.
12-14-2012 A
ANSWER OF BORGWARNER MORSE TEC INC. TO ORIGINAL
PETITION BY AND THROUGH ATTORNEY R. CHRIS PARK
Document Available (#1020112424)
Borg-Warner Morse Tec, Inc.
12-17-2012 A
ANSWER - ANSWER OF DEFENDANT KCG, INC.
Document Available (#1020111017)
12-18-2012 EAA
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE AS COUNSEL FOR DEFENDANT, SPECIAL ELECTRIC COMPANY INC BY ATTORNEY DENELDA L. RICHARDSON
Document Available (#1019976208)
12-19-2012 A
ANSWER OF DEFENDANT SPECIAL ELECTRIC COMPANY BY ATTY THERESA N. HILL
Document Available (#1020112997)
12-21-2012 A
ANSWER OF DAP PRODUCTS, INC. BY ATTORNEY JOHN R. WOODARD, III FOR DEFENDANT, DAP PRODUCTS, INC.
Document Available (#1020112981)
DAP Products, Inc.
12-21-2012 MO
defendant murco wall products, inc.'s motion to dismiss and memorandum based upon lack of personal jurisdiction pursuant to 12 okl.st.ann. 2012(b)(2)
Document Available (#1020377113)
12-21-2012 MO
motion to associate counsel
Document Available (#1020454496)
12-26-2012 A
ANSWER OF DEFENDANT THE PEP BOYS - MANNY, MOE & JACK TO PLAINTIFF'S ORIGINAL PETITION BY ATTY KAYCE L. GISINGER
Document Available (#1020113201)
12-26-2012 A
ANSWER OF DEFENDANT RED DEVIL, INC. TO PLAINTIFF'S ORIGINAL PETITION BY ATTY KAYCE L. GISINGER
Document Available (#1020113202)
12-28-2012 EAA
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY ATTORNEY MARTY R. SKRAPKA FOR DEFENDANT, HONEYWELL INTERNATIONAL INC.
Document Available (#1020460110)
Honeywell International, Inc.
12-28-2012 EAA
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY ATTORNEY J. DERRICK TEAGUE FOR DEFENDANT, HONEYWELL INTERNATIONAL INC.
Document Available (#1020460109)
Honeywell International, Inc.
12-28-2012 A
DEFENDANT HONEYWELL INTERNATIONAL INC.'S ANSWER
TO PLAINTIFF'S ORIGINAL PETITION BY ATTORNEY MARTY R. SKRAPKA
Document Available (#1020460108)
Honeywell International, Inc.
12-31-2012 AFD
AFFIDAVIT OF EVA JOAN BENTON IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS INC'S MOTION TO DISMISS BASED UPON LACK OF PERSONAL JURISDICTION
01-07-2013 JIF
PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO ENTER AND MOTION FOR EXPEDITED TRIAL SETTING UNDER 76 O.S. s 67 (B)
Document Available (#1020460440)
$ 349.00
01-07-2013 ACCOUNT
Receipt # 2013-3035011 on 01/07/2013.
Payor: HORTON & NEIGHBORS PC Total Amount Paid: $349.00.
Line Items:
CJ-2012-6920: $349.00 on AC01 Clerk Fees.
01-14-2013 O
order admitting to practice/judge dixon
Document Available (#1020524479)
01-17-2013 RESP
PLAINTIFF'S RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS, INC.'S MOTION TO DISMISS BASED UPON LACK OF PERSONAL JURISDICTION PURSUANT TO 12 OKLA. STAT. ANN. S 2012 (B)(2) BY ATTORNEY STEVEN T. HORTON
Document Available (#1020460745)
Galier, Michael D.
01-22-2013 EAA
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY ATTY RONALD HARRISON ON BEHALF OF DEFENDANT BORGWARNER MORSE TEC INC.
Document Available (#1020462669)
02-05-2013 MO
motion to associate counsel
Document Available (#1020766268)
02-05-2013 MO
motion to associate counsel
Document Available (#1020766264)
02-08-2013 OBJ
UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION'S OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR EXPEDITED TRIAL SETTING
Document Available (#1020548055)
02-11-2013 O
order admitting to practice/judge dixon
Document Available (#1020750420)
02-13-2013 MO
defendant murco wall products, inc.'s motion to associate counsel
Document Available (#1020737087)
02-13-2013 MO
defendant murco wall products, inc.'s motion to associate counsel
Document Available (#1020737083)
02-15-2013 SCHO
SCHEDULING ORDER AND ORDER FOR PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE / JUDGE B DIXON
Document Available (#1020946786)
02-15-2013 CTFREE
JUDGE B DIXON ; MOTION SUSTAINED PRE-TRIAL SET 12-4-2013
02-22-2013 O
order admitting to practice/judge dixon
Document Available (#1020951037)
02-22-2013 O
order admitting to practice/judge dixon
Document Available (#1020951041)
03-08-2013 NO
NOTICE OF HEARING
03-08-2013 MO
motion to associate counsel
Document Available (#1021061380)
03-11-2013 MO
motion to associate counsel
Document Available (#1021040572)
03-14-2013 SMF
3X SUMMONS FEE
$ 15.00
03-14-2013 AMP
FIRST AMENDED PETITION
Document Available (#1021045571)
03-14-2013 ACCOUNT
Receipt # 2013-3082554 on 03/14/2013.
Payor: HORTON & NEIGHBORS PC Total Amount Paid: $15.00.
Line Items:
CJ-2012-6920: $15.00 on AC01 Clerk Fees.
03-22-2013 MOC
defendant, kcg, inc.'s motion to compel plaintiff to respond to discovery
Document Available (#1021033616)
03-22-2013 O
order admitting to practice/judge dixon
Document Available (#1021033852)
03-26-2013 MO
motion to associate counsel
Document Available (#1021036508)
03-27-2013 A
ANSWER OF DEFENDANT KCG, INC. TO PLAINTIFF'S FIRST AMENDED PETITION THROUGH ATTYS J.R. "RANDY" BAKER AND JENNIFER BRUNER.
Document Available (#1021069666)
03-28-2013 RESP
DEFENDANT UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION'S RESPONSE AND AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES TO PLAINTIFF'S FIRST AMENDED PETITION
Document Available (#1021070119)
03-28-2013 RESP
DEFENDANT PNEUMO ABEX LLC SUCCESSOR IN INTEREST TO ABEX CORPORATION'S RESPONSE AND AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES TO PLAINTIFF'S FIRST AMENDED PETITION
Document Available (#1021070128)
Pneumo Abex, L.L.C.
03-28-2013 A
ANSWER OF DEFENDANT GEORGIA-PACIFIC LLC TO PLAINTIFF'S FIRST AMENDED PETITION, AND TO ANY AND ALL CROSS CLAIMS BY AND THROUGH ATTORNEY, KYMALA B. CARRIER
Document Available (#1021067542)
Georgia-Pacific, L.L.C.
03-28-2013 RESP
DEFENDANT CERTAINTEED CORPORATION'S RESPONSE AND AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES TO PLAINTIFF'S FIRST AMENDED PETITION
Document Available (#1015316619)
04-01-2013 A
DEFENDANT SPECIAL ELECTRIC COMPANY INC.'S ANSWER AND AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES TO PLAINTIFF'S FIRST AMENDED PETITION THROUGH ATTY THERESA HILL.
Document Available (#1021069796)
04-01-2013 A
DEFENDANT FORD MOTOR COMPANY'S ANSWER TO PLAINTIFF'S FIRST AMENDED PETITION THROUGH ATTY VANI SINGHAL.
Document Available (#1021069809)
04-01-2013 A
ANSWER OF WELCO MANUFACTURING COMPANY TO PLAINTIFF'S FIRST AMENDED PETITION THROUGH ATTY MICHAEL CARTER.
Document Available (#1021069810)
04-01-2013 A
ANSWER TO 1ST AMENDED PETITION F DEFENDANT O'REILLY AUTOMOTIVE STORES, INC. ("O'REILLY") THROUGH ATTYS RYAN HARPER AND GUS BUTHMAN.
Document Available (#1021069812)
04-01-2013 A
ANSWER OF BORGWARNER MORSE TEC INC. TO FIRST AMENDED PETITION THROUGH ATTY RONALD HARRISON
Document Available (#1021069822)
04-01-2013 MOD
defendant murco wall products, inc.'s motion to dismiss plaintiff's first amended petition and memorandumbased upon lack of personal jurisdiction pursuant to 12 okl. st. ann. 2012 (b)(2)
Document Available (#1021342396)
04-02-2013 DISPDWOP
DISMISSAL WITHOUT PREJUDICE
Document Available (#1021069597)
1 KELLY MOORE PAINT COMPANY
04-02-2013 DISPDWOP
DISMISSAL WITHOUT PREJUDICE
Document Available (#1021069598)
1 KCG, Inc.
04-03-2013 A
DEFENDANT HONEYWELL INTERNATIONAL INC.'S ANSWER TO PLAINTIFF'S FIRST AMENDED PETITION BY ATTY MARTY R. SKRAPKA
Document Available (#1021325109)
Honeywell International, Inc.
04-03-2013 A
ANSWER AND DEFENSES OF METROPOLITAN LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY TO PLAINTIFF'S FIRST AMENDED PETITION AND JURY DEMAND AND TO CROSS-CLAIMS OF ANY AND ALL OTHER DEFENDANTS AND THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANTS BY ATTY ROBERT J. WINTER
Document Available (#1021067693)
Metrolpolitan Life Insurance Company
04-05-2013 A
ANSWER OF DEFENDANT RED DEVIL, INC., TO PLAINTIFF'S FIRST AMENDED PETITION
Document Available (#1021067763)
Red Devil, Inc.
04-05-2013 A
ANSWER OF DENDANT THE PEP BOYS - MANNY, MOE & JACK TO PLAINTIFF'S FIRST AMENDED PETITION
Document Available (#1021067762)
The Pep Boys - Manny Moe & Jack of California
04-08-2013 O
ORDER ADMITTING TO PRACTICE / JUDGE B DIXON
04-08-2013 RESP
PLAINTIFF'S SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT MURCO PRODUCTS, INC.'S MOTION TO DISMISS BASED UPON LACK OF PERSONAL JURISDICTION PURSUANT TO 12 OKLA. STAT. ANN. 2012(B)(2)
Document Available (#1021329215)
04-08-2013 A
ANSWER TO FIRST AMENDED PETITION BY ATTY A. MARK SMILING FOR DEFENDANT GENUINE PARTS COMPANY
Document Available (#1021322437)
Genuine Parts Company
04-08-2013 O
order admitting to practice/judge dixon
Document Available (#1021315504)
04-09-2013 RESP
RESPONSE AND AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES OF DEFENDANT VANDERBILT MINERALS L.L.C., INCORRECTLY NAMES AS R.T. VANDERBILT COMAPNY, INC., TO PLAINTIFF'S FIRST AMENDED PETITION
Document Available (#1021324967)
04-11-2013 LT
LETTER / DODSON & DODSON, L.L.P.
04-11-2013 O
ORDER STRIKING BRIEF FROM RECORD / JUDGE B DIXON
04-11-2013 RESP
DEFENDANTS REPLY TO PLAINTIFFS RESPONSE TO MURCO'S MOTION TO DISMISS ASED ON LACK OF PERSONAL JURISDICTION
04-11-2013 AFD
AFFIDAVIT OF EVA JOAN BENTON IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS, INC.'S MOTION TO DISMISS BASED UPON LACK OF PERSONAL JURISDICTION
04-11-2013 R
DEFENDANT'S REPLY TO PLAINTIFF'S RESPONSES TO MURCO'S MOTION TO DISMISS BASED ON LACK OF PERSONAL JURISDICTION
04-11-2013 AFD
AFFIDAVIT OF EVA JOAN BENTON IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS, INC.'S MOTION TO DISMISS BASED UPON LACK OF PERSONAL JURISDICTION
04-11-2013 SMS
Summons Returned, Served: KELLY MOORE PAINT COMPANY, INC. BY CERTIFIED MAIL ON 3-25-13
Document Available (#1021529665)
04-11-2013 SMS
Summons Returned, Served: MACKLANBURG-DUNCAN INDUSTRIES, MCAFEE & TAFT, PC BY CERTIFIED MAIL ON 3-25-13
Document Available (#1021529669)
04-11-2013 SMS
Summons Returned, Served: M-D BUILDING PRODUCTS, INC., MCAFEE & TAFT, PC BY CERTIFIED MAIL ON 3-25-13
Document Available (#1021529668)
04-11-2013 O
order striking brief from record/judge dixon
Document Available (#1021530594)
04-12-2013 CRF
COURT REPORTER FEE-TRIAL ON MERITS
$ 20.00
04-12-2013 CTFREE
JUDGE B DIXON; DEFENDANT MURCO WALLS MOTION TO DISMISS AND MEMORANDUM BASED UPON LACK OF PERSOAL JURISDICTION STRICKEN TO BE RESET BY AGREEMENT AFTER DISCOVERY COMPLETED ON JURISDICTION ISSUE, COURT REPORTER - SCOTT WILMETH
04-12-2013 ACCOUNT
Receipt # 2013-3103290 on 04/12/2013.
Payor:DODSON & DODSON LLP Total Amount Paid: $20.00.
Line Items:
CJ-2012-6920: $20.00 on AC01 Clerk Fees.
04-17-2013 EAA
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY ATTYS TIMOTHY BOMHOFF AND KYMALA CARRIER ON BEHALF OF DEFENDANTS, M-D BUILDING PRODUCTS, INC. AND MACKLANBURG-DUNCAN INDUSTRIES, INC.
Document Available (#1021071278)
04-22-2013 A
ANSWER OF DEFENDANTS M-D BUILDING PRODUCTS, INC. AND MACKLANDBURG-DUNCAN INDUSTRIES, INC. TO PLAINTIFF'S FIRST AMENDED PETITION, AND TO ANY AND ALL CROSS CLAIMS
Document Available (#1021326812)
04-26-2013 CTFREE
JUDGE B DIXON; MOTION TO COMPEL PLAINTIFF TO RESPOND TO DISCOVERY STRICKEN AS MOOT DEFENDANT KCG INC, DISM WITHOUT PREJUDICE 4-2-2013`
05-09-2013 OBJ
DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS, INC'S OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFF'S SUBPOENA DUCES TECUM ATTACHED TO PLAINTIFF'S NOTICE OF DEPOSITION OF MURCO WALL PRODUCTS, INC
Document Available (#1021324306)
05-16-2013 CT
DEFENDANT UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION'S DESIGNATION OF POTENTIAL FACT AND EXPERT WITNESSES
05-16-2013 EAA
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY AND THROUGH ATTORNEY REBECCA D. HATTABAUGH FOR DEFENDANT BORGWARNER MORSE TEF INC.
Document Available (#1021324173)
Borg-Warner Morse Tec, Inc.
05-17-2013 WL
DEFENDANT CERTAINTEED CORPORATION'S LIST OF POTENTIAL WITNESSES
05-17-2013 WL
DEFENDANT PNEUMO ABEX, LLC, SUCCESSOR IN INTEREST TO ABEX CORPORATION'S LIST OF POTENTIAL WITNESSES
05-20-2013 RESP
Response - PLAINTIFF'S SECOND SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTIONS, INC.'S MOTION TO DISMISS and PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR COSTS
Document Available (#1021683105)
05-20-2013 WL
DEFENDANT VANDERBILT MINERALS, L.L.C.'S, FORMALLY KNOWN AS R.T. VANDERBILT COMPANY, INC.'S EXPERT WITNESS LIST AND DISCLOSURES
05-21-2013 EAA
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY ATTY BRANDON L. BUCHANAN FOR DEFENDANTS GEORGIA-PACIFIC LLC F/K/A GEORGIA-PSCIFIC CORPORATION M-D BUILDING PRODUCTS INC AND MACKLANBURG-DUNCAN INDUSTRIES INC
Document Available (#1021604502)
05-24-2013 WL
defendant murco wall products inc's expert witness disclosures
05-24-2013 WL
defendant murco wall products, inc's fact witness disclosures
05-24-2013 WL
defendant honeywell international inc.'s preliminary WITNESS LIST
05-31-2013 WL
DEFENDANT BORG-WARNER CORPORATION, BY ITS SUCCESSOR IN INTEREST BORGWARNER MORSE TEC, INC.'S DESIGNATION OF EXPERT AND FACT WITNESSES
06-06-2013 NO
Notice of new firm affiliation and change of address
06-07-2013 OBJ
DEFENDANT'S OBJECTIONS AND RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR COSTS, IF NECESSARY
Document Available (#1021682502)
06-13-2013 NOF
Notice Of Filing
06-13-2013 T
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS TAKEN FROM HEARING OF DEFENDANT MURCO'S MOTION TO DISMISS BASED ON LACK OF PERSONAL JURISDICTION HAD ON THE 12TH DAY OF APRIL, 2013 BEFORE THE HONORABLE BRYAN DIXON / COURT REPORTER SCOTT WILMETH (ORIGINAL AND 2 COPIES)
06-13-2013 R
defendant's REPLY to plaintiff's second supplemental response to murco's motion to dismiss based on lack of personal jurisdiction
06-19-2013 MO
motion to associate counsel
Document Available (#1022138938)
06-20-2013 O
order admitting to practice/judge dixon
Document Available (#1022129083)
06-21-2013 CRF
COURT REPORTER FEE-TRIAL ON MERITS
$ 20.00
06-21-2013 CTFREE
JUDGE B DIXON; MOTION OVERRULED AS PER JOURNAL ENTRY , 20 DAYS TO ANSWERE.
06-21-2013 CTFREE
JUDGE B DIXON; PLAINTIFFS MOTION FOR COSTS OVERRULED AS PER JOURNAL ENTRY
06-21-2013 ACCOUNT
Receipt # 2013-3150990 on 06/21/2013.
Payor:DODSON & DODSON LLP Total Amount Paid: $20.00.
Line Items:
CJ-2012-6920: $20.00 on AC01 Clerk Fees.
07-08-2013 JE
JOURNAL ENTRY/judge dixon
Document Available (#1022215589)
07-08-2013 JE
JOURNAL ENTRY/judge dixon
Document Available (#1022215593)
07-10-2013 EAA
SPECIAL ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY ATTYS KENNETH WAGNER, BRYNNA SCHELBAR AND BRANDY SHORES ON BEHALF OF DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS, INC.
Document Available (#1022150038)
07-10-2013 APLI
MURCO WALL PRODUCTS, INC'S APPLICATION TO STAY PROCEEDINGS
07-10-2013 NOF
Notice Of Filing
07-10-2013 T
TRANSCRIPT OF MOTION PROCEEDINGS HAD ON JUNE 21, 2013 BEFORE THE HONORABLE BRYAN C. DIXON / COURT REPORTER PAMELA HARTWICK (ORIGINAL AND ONE COPY)
07-10-2013 O
Order/judge dixon
Document Available (#1022356901)
08-01-2013 MO
motion to associate counsel
Document Available (#1022512825)
08-02-2013 MO
motion to withdraw as counsel of record
Document Available (#1022715021)
08-08-2013 O
agreed order/judge dixon
Document Available (#1022518888)
08-08-2013 MO
motion to associate counsel
Document Available (#1022518632)
08-08-2013 O
order admitting to practice/judge dixon
Document Available (#1022518923)
08-20-2013 O
order admitting to practice/judge dixon
Document Available (#1022726792)
08-22-2013 MO
motion to withdraw as counsel of record
Document Available (#1022737250)
09-04-2013 O
order allowing withdrawal/judge dixon
Document Available (#1020009646)
10-03-2013 A
DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS, INC.'S ANSWER TO PLAINTIFF'S FIRST AMENDED PETITION AND AFFIRMATIVE, DEFENSES BY ATTY RICHARD . N. DODSON
Document Available (#1023037670)
Murco Wall Products, Inc.
10-09-2013 EAA
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE
Document Available (#1023233024)
O'Reilly Automotive Stores, Inc.
10-22-2013 WL
DEFENDANT GENUINE PARTS COMPANY A/K/A NAPA'S PRELIMINARY FACT AND EXPERT WITNESS LIST
11-04-2013 EAA
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE AND REQUEST FOR NOTICE\ CHRISTOPHER B REED ATTNY FOR PL O'REILLY AUTOMOTIVE STEORES,INC
Document Available (#1023385431)
11-12-2013 SCHO
amended scheduling order/judge dixon
Document Available (#1023536755)
11-12-2013 MO
joint motion to amend scheduling order
Document Available (#1023536694)
11-19-2013 MO
motion to withdraw
Document Available (#1023519462)
12-02-2013 O
order allowing withdrawal/judge dixon
Document Available (#1023649554)
12-04-2013 CTFREE
JUDGE B DIXON; PRETRIAL CONTINUED BY AGREEMENT TO 5-28-2014 9:30
12-12-2013 O
order allowing withdraw of counsel/judge dixon
Document Available (#1023639313)
12-17-2013 RPT
defendant metropolitan life insurance company's expert REPORTs
12-18-2013 WL
defendant metropolitan life insurance company's final WITNESS LIST
12-27-2013 WL
DEFENDANT CERTAINTEED CORPORATION'S LIST OF POTENTIAL WITNESSES
12-27-2013 WL
DEFENDANT PNEUMO ABEX LLC, SUCCESSOR IN INTEREST TO ABEX CORPORATION'S LIST OF POTENTIAL WITNESSES
01-03-2014 WL
DEFENDANT VANDERBILT MINERALS, LLC'S FINAL EXPERT WITNESS LIST AND DISCLOSURES
01-03-2014 WL
DEFENDANT BORG-WARNER CORPORATION, BY ITS SUCCESSOR IN INTEREST BORGWARNER MORSE TEC, INC.'S DESIGNATION OF EXPERT AND FACT WITNESSES
01-03-2014 WL
DEFENDANT GENUINE PARTS COMPANY A/K/A NAPA'S FINAL FACT AND EXPERT WITNESS LIST
01-06-2014 NO
Notice OF CHANGE OF ADDRESS
01-17-2014 WL
defendant union carbide corporation's final designation of fact and expert WITNESSes
01-23-2014 EAA
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY ATTORNEY BRITA CANTRELL FOR DEFENDANT
Document Available (#1023906348)
01-29-2014 MO
defendants' motion to amend scheduling order
Document Available (#1024051953)
01-30-2014 MO
motion to withdraw as counsel of record
Document Available (#1024053024)
02-05-2014 O
order allowing withdrawal/judge dixon
Document Available (#1024208028)
02-20-2014 RESP
plaintiff's response in opposition to defendants' motionto amend scheduling order/judge dixon
Document Available (#1024343979)
02-28-2014 CTFREE
JUDGE B DIXON; MOTION STRICKEN AS PER AGREED ORDER
02-28-2014 SCHO
second amended scheduling order/judge dixon
Document Available (#1024475791)
02-28-2014 CER
CERTIFICATE OF COMPLIANCE WITH DISCOVERY
Document Available (#1024886304)
03-05-2014 NO
NOTICE OF CHANGE OF ADDRESS
03-11-2014 DISPDWOP
DISMISSAL WITHOUT PREJUDICE
Document Available (#1024455674)
1 O'Reilly Automotive Stores, Inc.
03-17-2014 DISPDWOP
DISMISSAL WITHOUT PREJUDICE OF DEFENDANT, METROPOLITAN LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY
Document Available (#1024455738)
1 Metrolpolitan Life Insurance Company
03-20-2014 CER
CERTIFICATE OF compliance
Document Available (#1024462178)
03-24-2014 MO
DEFENDANTS' MOTION FOR ORDER REQUIRING DISCLOSURE OF SETTLEMENT AGREEMENTS PRIOR TO TRIAL
Document Available (#1024700477)
03-27-2014 LT
LETTER / WORLDWIDE - FILED BY REBECA AGUIRRE
Document Available (#1024665988)
03-28-2014 MO
motion to associate counsel
Document Available (#1024666466)
03-31-2014 LT
Letter W/ ATTACHMENTS
Document Available (#1024856164)
04-08-2014 DISPDWOP
DISMISSAL WITHOUT PREJUDICE OF DEFENDANTS M-D BUILDING PRODUCTS INC. AND MACKLANBURG-DUNCAN INDUSTRIES, INC.
Document Available (#1024689568)
1 M-D BUILDING PRODUCTS INC
04-08-2014 DISPDWOP
DISMISSAL WITHOUT PREJUDICE OF DEFENDANTS M-D BUILDING PRODUCTS INC. AND MACKANBURG-DUNCAN INDUSTRIES, INC.
Document Available (#1024689568)
1 MACKLANBURG-DUNCAN INDUSTRIES INC
04-08-2014 O
order admitting to practice/judge dixon
Document Available (#1024863895)
04-10-2014 OBJ
DEFENDANT UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION'S OBJECTIONS TO THE SUBPOENA DUCES TECUM ATTACHED TO PLAINTIFF'S NOTICE OF INTENT TO TAKE TEH ORAL/ TELEPHANIC DEPOSITION OF WILLIAM DYSON, PH,D., CIH, AND MOTION FOR PROTECTION
Document Available (#1024857510)
04-10-2014 OBJ
defendant union carbide corporation's objections to the subpoena duces tecum attached to plaintiff's notice of intent to take the oral/telephonic deposition of victor roggli, m.d. and motion for production
Document Available (#1024885994)
04-21-2014 MO
defendant union carbide corporation's motion for leave to reopen the deposition of plaintiff michael galier outside the discovery period for fact issues
Document Available (#1024941029)
04-22-2014 NO
notice of change of address
Document Available (#1024965586)
04-23-2014 NO
notice of oral hearing defendant union carbide corporation's motion for leave to reopen the deposition of plaintiff michael galier outside the discovery period for fact issues
Document Available (#1025085136)
04-24-2014 CTFREE
JUDGE B DIXON; MOTION STRICKEN BY AGREEMENT
04-24-2014 DISPCVDMWP
DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE BY PLAINTIFF FOR DEFENDANT
Document Available (#1025096556)
1 Honeywell International, Inc.
05-05-2014 RESP
plaintiff's response in opposition to defendant union carbide corporation's motion to redepose mr. galier
Document Available (#1025083218)
05-08-2014 NO
amended notice of oral hearing defendant union carbide corporation's motion for leave to reopen the deposition of plaintiff michael galier outside the discovery period for fact issues
Document Available (#1025409376)
05-09-2014 RESP
plaintiff's response in opposition to defendants' motion for order requiring disclosure of settlement agreements
Document Available (#1025084343)
05-12-2014 R
defendant union carbide corporation's reply in support of its motion for leave to reopen the deposition of mr. galier
Document Available (#1025423677)
05-14-2014 DISPDWOP
DISMISSAL WITHOUT PREJUDICE
Document Available (#1024457814)
1 Borg-Warner Morse Tec, Inc.
05-14-2014 NOH
NOTICE OF HEARING
Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
05-19-2014 DISPDWOP
DISMISSAL WITHOUT PREJUDICE OF DEFENDANT, PNEUMO ABEX, LLC
Document Available (#1025410657)
1 Pneumo Abex, L.L.C.
05-19-2014 DISPDWOP
DISMISSAL WITHOUT PREJUDICE OF DEFENDANT, CERTAINTEED CORPORATION
Document Available (#1025410653)
1 Certainteed Corporation
05-22-2014 MOSJ
DEFENDANT VANDERBILT MINERALS, L.L.C.'S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND BRIEF IN SUPPORT
Document Available (#1025098013)
$ 50.00
05-22-2014 ACCOUNT
Receipt # 2014-3368033 on 05/22/2014.
Payor:DEHAY & ELLISTON LLP Total Amount Paid: $50.00.
Line Items:
CJ-2012-6920: $50.00 on AC01 Clerk Fees.
05-23-2014 CTFREE
JUDGE B DIXON; MOTION CONTINUED BY AGREEMENT TO 5-30-2014 10:00
1
05-23-2014 NO
Notice of hearing
Document Available (#1025728298)
05-28-2014 CTFREE
JUDGE B DIXON; PRETRIAL CONTINUED BY AGREEMENT TO 7-9-2014 10:30
05-30-2014 CTFREE
JUDGE B DIXON; MOTION FOR LEAVE TO REOPEN DEPOSITION STRICKEN BY AGREEMENT
05-30-2014 CTFREE
JUDGE B DIXON; MOTION FOR DISCLOSURE OF SETTLEMENT STRICKEN NO APPEARANCES
06-04-2014 MOSJ
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT THE PEP BOYS
Document Available (#1025098143)
$ 50.00
06-04-2014 ACCOUNT
Receipt # 2014-3375984 on 06/04/2014.
Payor:Goolsby Proctor Total Amount Paid: $50.00.
Line Items:
CJ-2012-6920: $50.00 on AC01 Clerk Fees.
06-05-2014 MOSJ
DEFENDANT FORD MOTOR COMPANY'S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND BRIEF IN SUPPORT
Document Available (#1025098207)
$ 50.00
06-05-2014 SO
THIRD AMENDED SCHEDULING ORDER / JUDGE DIXON
Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
06-05-2014 RESP
PLAINTIFF'S RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT VANDERBILT MINERALS , L.L.C.'S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT ( PART 1)
Document Available (#1025974636)
06-05-2014 RESP
RESPONSE ( PART 2 )
Document Available (#1024866798)
06-05-2014 RESP
RESPONSE ( PART 3)
Document Available (#1024866842)
06-05-2014 MO
JOINT MOTION TO AMEND SCHEDULING ORDER
Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
06-05-2014 NOH
NOTICE OF HEARING
Document Available (#1025993501)
06-05-2014 ACCOUNT
Receipt # 2014-3377210 on 06/05/2014.
Payor:mcafee & taft Total Amount Paid: $50.00.
Line Items:
CJ-2012-6920: $50.00 on AC01 Clerk Fees.
06-06-2014 LT
Letter
Document Available (#1025975239)
06-06-2014 MO
DEFENDANT UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION'S MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Document Available (#1025975111)
06-13-2014 RETUC
Return Letter -Unclaimed to STEVEN HORTON
06-19-2014 CTFREE
JUDGE B DIXON; MOTION CONTINUED BY AGREEMENT TO 7-11-2014 10:00
06-20-2014 O
Order
Document Available (#1025984653)
06-25-2014 RESP
PLAINTIFF'S RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION'S MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Document Available (#1026290420)
06-25-2014 RESP
PLAINTIFF'S RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT FORD MOTOR COMPANY'S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Document Available (#1025109233)
06-25-2014 RESP
PLAINTIFF'S Response IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT FORD MOTOR COMPANY'S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGEMENT : PART TWO
Document Available (#1024887720)
06-25-2014 RESP
PLAINTIFF'S Response IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT FORD MOTOR COMPANY'S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGEMENT : PART THREE
Document Available (#1024887724)
06-25-2014 RESP
PLAINTIFF'S RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION'S MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT PART TWO
Document Available (#1024887729)
06-25-2014 RESP
PLAINTIFF'S RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION'S MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT : PART THREE
Document Available (#1024887725)
06-25-2014 RESP
PLAINTIFF'S RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION'S MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT : PART FOUR
Document Available (#1024887721)
06-26-2014 NO
notice of oral hearing on defendant union carbide corporation's motion for partial summary judgment
Document Available (#1026433049)
07-02-2014 R
DEFENDANTS' REPLY IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR ORDER REQUIRING DISCOLSURE OF SETTLEMENT AGREEMENTS PRIOR TO TRIAL
Document Available (#1025977577)
Borg-Warner Morse Tec, Inc.
07-02-2014 MO
MOTION TO WITHDRAW AS COUNSEL OF RECORD
Document Available (#1026498490)
07-02-2014 MO
MOTION TO WITHDRAW AS COUNSEL OF RECORD
Document Available (#1026498498)
07-03-2014 CTFREE
JUDGE B DIXON; MOTION CONTINUED BY AGREEMENT TO 8-8-2014 10:00
07-07-2014 DISPDWOP
DISMISSAL WITHOUT PREJUDICE OF DEFENDANT SPECIAL ELECTRIC COMPANY
Document Available (#1025619517)
1 Special Electric Company, Inc.
07-09-2014 CTFREE
JUDGE B DIXON; PRE TRIAL CONTINUED BY AGREEMENT TO 9-3-2014 11:00
07-09-2014 DISPDWOP
DISMISSAL WITHOUT PREJUDICE OF DEFENDANT THE PEP BOYS- MANNY MOE & JACK OF CALIFORNIA
Document Available (#1026454302)
1 The Pep Boys - Manny Moe & Jack of California
07-09-2014 O
ORDER ALLOWING WITHDRAWAL
Document Available (#1026678994)
07-09-2014 O
ORDER ALLOWING WITHDRAWAL
Document Available (#1026549867)
07-09-2014 MO
JOINT MOTION TO CONTINUE HEARING OF DEFENDANT FORD MOTOR COMPANY'S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Document Available (#1026558284)
07-11-2014 CTFREE
JUDGE B DIXON; MOTION CONTINUED BY AGREEMENT TO 7-18-2014 10:00
07-11-2014 CTFREE
JUDGE B DIXON; MOTION CONTINUED BY AGREEMENT TO 7-18-2014 10:00
07-11-2014 CTFREE
JUDGE B DIXON; MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT (PEP BOYS) STRICKEN AS MOOT , DISMISSED WITHOUT PREJUDICE ON 7-9-2014
07-11-2014 DISPCVDMWP
DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF DEFENDANT, GEORGIA-PACIFIC LLC
Document Available (#1026274209)
1 Georgia-Pacific, L.L.C.
07-15-2014 R
replly of defendant union carbide corporation to plaintiff's response in opposition to the motion for partial summary judgment filed by union carbide
Document Available (#1026528378)
07-18-2014 MOSJ
DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS, INC.'S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND BRIEF IN SUPPORT
Document Available (#1026295190)
$ 50.00
07-18-2014 CTFREE
JUDGE B DIXON; MOTION FOR DISCLOSURE OF SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT SUSTAINED AS TO DISCLOSE PARTIES SETTLED WITH IN 7 DAYS; OVERRULED AS TO AMOUNT AS PER JOURNAL ENTRY
07-18-2014 CTFREE
JUDGE B DIXON; MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT SUSTAINED AS TO PRODUCTS LIABILITY AND NEGLIGENCE CLAIMS UNDER CASE 1987 OR 79 NO SIGNIFICANT PROBABILITY OF EXPOSURE SINCE THERE WAS NO REPEATED , REGULAR AND DIRECT PHYSICAL CONTACT WITH A SPECIFIC IDENTIFIED PRODUCT OF DEFENDANT FORD, AS PER JOURNAL ENTRY
07-18-2014 CTFREE
JUDGE B DIXON; MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT SUSTAINED BY AGREEMENT AS TO CLAIMS FOR BREACH OF WARRANTY; AIDING AND ABETTING AND CONSPIRACY; OVERRULED AS TO PUNITIVE DAMAGES AS PER JOURNAL ENTRY
07-18-2014 ACCOUNT
Receipt # 2014-3406276 on 07/18/2014.
Payor:DODSON & DODSON LLP Total Amount Paid: $50.00.
Line Items:
CJ-2012-6920: $50.00 on AC01 Clerk Fees.
07-21-2014 MOSJ
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT, STATEMENT OF UNDISPUTED MATERIAL FACTS AND BRIEF OF ARGUMENTS AND AUTHORITIES OF DEFENDANT GENUINE PARTS CO.
Document Available (#1026295189)
$ 50.00
07-21-2014 MOSJ
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT RED DEVIL, INC.
Document Available (#1026295270)
$ 50.00
07-21-2014 MOSJ
DEFENDANT WELCO MANUFACTURING COMPANY'S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND BRIEF IN SUPPORT
Document Available (#1026295278)
$ 50.00
07-21-2014 ACCOUNT
Receipt # 2014-3407104 on 07/21/2014.
Payor:A MARK SMILING PLLC Total Amount Paid: $50.00.
Line Items:
CJ-2012-6920: $50.00 on AC01 Clerk Fees.
07-21-2014 ACCOUNT
Receipt # 2014-3407559 on 07/21/2014.
Payor:Phillips Murrah Total Amount Paid: $50.00.
Line Items:
CJ-2012-6920: $50.00 on AC01 Clerk Fees.
07-21-2014 ACCOUNT
Receipt # 2014-3407644 on 07/21/2014.
Payor:GOOLSBY PROCTOR HEEFNER & GIBBS PC Total Amount Paid: $50.00.
Line Items:
CJ-2012-6920: $50.00 on AC01 Clerk Fees.
07-23-2014 EAA
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE of attys amy fischer, andrew bowman, and jordyn eckert for genuine parts co.
Document Available (#1026552623)
07-28-2014 NOH
notice of oral hearing on defendant murco wall product, inc.'s motion for summary judgment and brief in support
Document Available (#1026723485)
07-29-2014 DEPO
Oral Deposition Of: MICHAEL GALIER
Document Available (#1026721032)
07-30-2014 DISPDWOP
DISMISSAL WITHOUT PREJUDICE OF DEFENDANT, R.T. VANDERBILT COMPANY, INC.
Document Available (#1026296320)
1 RT Vanderbilt Company, Inc.
08-04-2014 TEXT
PLAINTIFF'S PAGE AND LINE DESIGNATIONS FROM THE DEPOSITION OF JOAN BENTON TAKEN ON DECEMBER 21, 2012
Document Available (#1026707329)
08-04-2014 TEXT
PLAINTIFF'S PAGE AND LINE DESIGNATIONS FROM THE DEPOSITION OF JACK WALSH TAKEN ON NOVEMBER 20, 2009
Document Available (#1026707325)
08-04-2014 TEXT
PLAINTIFF'S PAGE AND LINE DESIGNATIONS FROM THE DEPOSITION OF MILTON STRADER TAKEN ON AUGUST 30, 2011
Document Available (#1026707321)
08-04-2014 TEXT
PLAINTIFF'S PAGE AND LINE DESIGNATIONS FROM THE DEPOSITION OF JACK WALSH TAKEN ON AUGUST 2, 2011
Document Available (#1026707317)
08-04-2014 TEXT
PLAINTIFF'S PAGE AND LINE DESIGNATIONS FROM THE DEPOSITION OF RICK JOHN REW TAKEN ON AUGUST 30, 2007
Document Available (#1026707313)
08-04-2014 TEXT
PLAINTIFF'S PAGE AND LINE DESIGNATIONS FROM THE VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION OF JACK WALSH TAKEN ON OCTOBER 20, 2011
Document Available (#1026707309)
08-04-2014 MO
DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTIONS, INC.'S MOTION FOR CONTRIBUTION AND SETOFF
Document Available (#1026556043)
08-04-2014 MO
DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTIONS, INC.'S MOTION TO EXCLUDE THE TESTIMONY OF PLAINTIFF'S EXPERT ARNOLD BRODY, PHD
Document Available (#1026707551)
08-04-2014 MO
DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTIONS, INC.'S MOTION TO EXCLUDE THE TESTIMONY OF PLAINTIFF'S EXPERT STEVE HAYS
Document Available (#1026707583)
08-04-2014 MOLIM
DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTIONS, INC.'S MOTION IN LIMINE AND BRIEF
Document Available (#1026707587)
08-04-2014 TEXT
DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTIONS, INC.'S SUPPLEMENTAL MOTION IN LIMINE
Document Available (#1026707591)
08-04-2014 TEXT
DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTIONS, INC.'S SUPPLEMENTAL MOTION IN LIMINE TO EXCLUDE OPINIONS BASED UPON INAPPLICABLE AUTHORITY
Document Available (#1026707579)
08-04-2014 TEXT
DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTIONS, INC.'S SUPPLEMENTAL MOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE INTRODUCTION OF CERTAIN MEDICAL AND SCIENTIFIC ARTICLES, TREATSIES, PERIODICALS, OR PAMPHLETS
Document Available (#1026707575)
08-04-2014 TEXT
DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTIONS, INC.'S SUPPLEMENTAL MOTION IN LIMINE TO EXCLUDE PLAINTIFF'S TESTIMONY THAT PRODUCTS CONTAINED ASBESTOS
Document Available (#1026707571)
08-04-2014 TEXT
DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTIONS, INC.'S SUPPLEMENTAL MOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE PLAINTIFF'S MEDICAL EXPERT FROM TESTIFYING TO ISSUES OF INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE
Document Available (#1026707567)
08-04-2014 TEXT
DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTIONS, INC.'S SUPPLEMENTAL MOTION IN LIMINE REGARDING MEDICAL EXPENSES AND DISABILITY
Document Available (#1026707603)
08-04-2014 TEXT
DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTIONS, INC.'S SUPPLEMENTAL MOTION IN LIMINE REGARDING GROSS NEGLIGENCE AND WILLFUL, WANTON AND RECKLESS CONDUCT AND BRIEF IN SUPPORT
Document Available (#1026707599)
08-04-2014 TEXT
DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTIONS, INC.'S SUPPLEMENTAL MOTION IN LIMINE TO EXCLUDE NO SAFE DOSE EACH AND EVERY EXPOSURE AND CUMULATIVE EXPOSURE OPINIONS
Document Available (#1026707595)
08-04-2014 MOLIM
DEFENDANT UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION'S MOTION IN LIMINE AND BRIEF IN SUPPORT
Document Available (#1026707387)
08-04-2014 B
DEFENDANT UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION'S BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF ITS MOTION IN LIMINE NUMBERS 52 AND 59
Document Available (#1026707383)
08-04-2014 MOLIM
PLAINTIFF'S MOTION IN LIMINE
Document Available (#1026707455)
08-04-2014 MOLIM
DEFENDANT WELCO MANUFACTURING COMPANY'S MOTION IN LIMINE
Document Available (#1026707687)
08-04-2014 MO
DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS, INC.'S Motion TO EXCLUDE THE TESTIMONY OF PLAINTIFF'S EXPERTY JOHN C. MADDOX, M.D.
Document Available (#1026707555)
08-04-2014 NO
defendant murco wall products, inc.'s notice of adoption of co-defendants' pre-trial motions
Document Available (#1024859535)
08-06-2014 RESP
PLAINTIFFS RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION DEFENDANT MURCOS MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT / part 1
Document Available (#1026872274)
08-06-2014 RESP
Response/ part
Document Available (#1026872278)
08-06-2014 RESP
Response/ part 3
Document Available (#1026872290)
08-06-2014 RESP
Response/ 4
Document Available (#1026872286)
08-08-2014 DISPDWOP
DISMISSAL WITHOUT PREJUDICE
Document Available (#1026800504)
1 Genuine Parts Company
08-08-2014 CTFREE
JUDGE B DIXON; MOTION STRICKEN AS MOOT DEFENDANT VANDERBILT MINERALS HAS BEEN DISMISSED BY PLAINTIFF
08-08-2014 O
ORDER GRANTING SUMMARY JUDGMENT TO DEFT FORD MOTOR COMPANY/DIXON
Document Available (#1026873228)
08-11-2014 RESP
plaintiff's Response in opposition to welco manufacturing company's motion for summary judgment
Document Available (#1026869409)
08-14-2014 B
defendant murco wall products, inc.'s reply Brief to plaintiff's response to murco's motion for summary judgment
Document Available (#1026950447)
08-14-2014 EXHI
defendant murco wall products, inc.'s trial exhibit list
Document Available (#1026950451)
08-14-2014 TEXT
defendnt welco manufacturing company's page/line designatino of earl e. stover taken on july 23, 1992
Document Available (#1026950382)
08-14-2014 TEXT
defendant welco manufacturing company's page/line designation of derrel sell taken on february 26, 1992
Document Available (#1026950386)
08-14-2014 TEXT
defendant murco wall products, inc.'s page and line designatinos from the deposition of william thurber taken on june 28, 2002
Document Available (#1026853249)
08-14-2014 TEXT
defendant murco wall products, inc.'s page and line designations from the deposition of milton strader taken on october 11, 2006
Document Available (#1026853253)
08-14-2014 TEXT
defendant murco wall products, inc.'s page and line designations from the deposition of tom norris taken on august 7, 2002
Document Available (#1026853257)
08-14-2014 TEXT
defendant murco wall products, inc.'s page and line designations from the deposition of douglas merrill taken on may 31, 2006, june 1, 2006, june 2, 2006, june 5, 2006 and june 7, 2006
Document Available (#1026853261)
08-14-2014 TEXT
defendant murco wall prodcuts, inc.'s page and line designations from the deposition of charles w. lehnert taken on november 12, 2002
Document Available (#1026853265)
08-14-2014 TEXT
defendant murco wall products, inc.'s page and line designations from the deposition of rita galier taken on april 4, 2014
Document Available (#1026853269)
08-14-2014 TEXT
defendant murco wall products, inc.'s page and line designations from the deposition of michael galier taken on july 3, 2014
Document Available (#1026853273)
08-14-2014 TEXT
defendant murco wall products, inc.'s page and line designations from the deposition of michael galier taken on february 13, 2013
Document Available (#1026853277)
08-14-2014 DEPO
defendant murco wall products, inc.''s page and line designations from the deposition of anthony galier taken on january 31, 2014
Document Available (#1026853281)
08-14-2014 DEPO
defendant murco wall products, inc.'s page and line designations from the deposition of william dyson, ph.d. taken on april 16, 2014
Document Available (#1026853285)
08-14-2014 DEPO
defendant murco wall products, inc.'s page and line designations from the deposition of kim e. anderson, ph.d. taken on july 24, 2014
Document Available (#1026853289)
08-14-2014 DEPO
defendant murco wall products, inc.'s page and line designations from the Deposition Of andrew galier taken on january 31, 2014
Document Available (#1026853293)
08-15-2014 TEXT
DEFENDANT UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION'S PAGE AND LINE DESIGNATIONS
Document Available (#1026853329)
08-15-2014 EXL
DEFENDANT UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION'S EXHIBIT LIST
Document Available (#1026853333)
08-20-2014 RESP
PLAINTIFF'S RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION DEFENDANT RED DEVIL, INC.'S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
08-22-2014 CRF
COURT REPORTER FEE-TRIAL ON MERITS
$ 20.00
08-22-2014 CTFREE
JUDGE B DIXON; MOTION SUSTAINED AS TO AIDING, ABETTING; AND CONSPIRACY CLAIM; OVERRULED AS TO PRODUCTS LIABILITY AND NEGLIGENCE CLAIMS AS QUESTION OF FACT ON CAUSATION - PLAINTIFF HAS SUFFICIENT EVIDENCE TO SATISFY SIGNIFICANT PROBABILITY OF EXPOSURE TEST ON SUMMARY JUDGMENT OVERRULED AS TO PUNITIVE DAMAGES AS PER JOURNA ENTRY
08-22-2014 R
DEFENDANT WELCO MANUFACTURING COMPANY'S REPLY TO PLAINTIFF'S RESPONSE TO WELCO MANUFACTURING COMPANY'S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Document Available (#1026910018)
08-22-2014 ACCOUNT
Receipt # 2014-3428711 on 08/22/2014.
Payor:Dodson & Dodson Total Amount Paid: $20.00.
Line Items:
CJ-2012-6920: $20.00 on AC01 Clerk Fees.
08-28-2014 MO
motion to associate counsel
Document Available (#1026902652)
08-29-2014 CTFREE
JUDGE B DIXON; MOTION SUSTAINED AS TO AIDING ,ABETTING , CONSPIRACY AND BREACH OF CONTRACT CLAIMS, OVERRULED AS TO PRODUCTS LIABILITY AND NEGLIGENCE CLAIMS AND PUNITIVE DAMAGES; OVERRULED AS TO AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE OF MISUSE- QUESTION OF FACT, AS PER JOURNAL ENTRY
08-29-2014 CTFREE
JUDGE B DIXON; MOTION STRICKEN DISMISSAL WITHOUT PREJUDICE BY PLAINTIFF AS TO DEFENDANT GENUINE AUTO PARTS ON 8-8-2014
08-29-2014 CTFREE
JUDGE B DIXON; RED DEVIL MOTION CONTINUED BY AGREEMENT TO 10-3-2014 10:00
08-29-2014 O
Order
Document Available (#1026914368)
09-02-2014 NOF
Notice Of Filing
09-02-2014 T&1
Original Transcript and One Copy of SUMMARY JUDGMENT PROCEEDINGS HAD ON AUGUST 22, 2014 BEFORE THE HONORABLE BRYAN C. DIXON / COURT REPORTER PAMELA HARTWICK
09-02-2014 EAA
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY DANIEL C HAYS OF GOOLSBY, PROCTOR, HEEFNER & GIBBS P C AS COUNSEL FOR DEFENDANT RED DEVIL INC
Document Available (#1027048377)
09-02-2014 O
Order ADMITTING TO PRACTICE /DIXON
Document Available (#1026797847)
09-03-2014 CTFREE
JUDGE B DIXON; PRE TRIAL HELD JURY TRIAL SET 1-26-2015 9:00 WITH MOTION IN LIMINE AND DAUBERT MOTION HEARD ON JANUARY 6,2015 9:00
09-03-2014 PTO
PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE ORDER
Document Available (#1026893673)
09-10-2014 JE
JOURNAL ENTRY
Document Available (#1026937001)
09-10-2014 O
Order
Document Available (#1026937057)
09-25-2014 MO
MOTION TO WITHDRAWAL AS COUNSEL OF RECORD
Document Available (#1026941865)
09-29-2014 O
ORDER ALLOWING WITHDRAWAL
Document Available (#1027244126)
10-03-2014 CTFREE
JUDGE B DIXON.; MOTION CONTINUED BY AGREEMENT TO 11-14-2014 10:00
11-07-2014 R
REPLY IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT OF DEFENDANT RES DEVIL, INC.
Document Available (#1027704470)
11-10-2014 MO
motion for leave of court to amend final designation of fact and expert witnesses of defendant union carbide corporation
Document Available (#1027698421)
11-12-2014 DISPCVDMWP
DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF DEFENDANT, DAP PRODUCTS, INC.
Document Available (#1027638771)
1 DAP Products, Inc.
11-13-2014 JE
JOURNAL ENTRY
Document Available (#1027694046)
11-13-2014 MO
JOINT MOTION FOR CONTINUANCE
Document Available (#1027699030)
11-14-2014 CTFREE
JUDGE B DIXON; MOTION CONTINUED BY AGREEMENT TO 12-19-2014 10:00
11-17-2014 O
Order
Document Available (#1027692665)
11-19-2014 MO
motion to associate counsel
Document Available (#1027689448)
11-21-2014 RESP
PLAINTIFF'S RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION'S MOTION FOR LEAVE OF COURT TO AMEND FINAL DESIGNATION OF FACT AND EXPERT WITNESSES
Document Available (#1027689961)
11-25-2014 O
order admitting to practice
Document Available (#1027687558)
12-15-2014 MO
motion to associate counsel
Document Available (#1027668247)
12-18-2014 OBJ
DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS INCS OBJECTION TO PLAINTIFFS DESIGNATIONS FROM THE VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION OF MILTON STRADER TAKEN ON AUGUEST 30, 2011
Document Available (#1028145650)
12-18-2014 DEPO
DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS INCS COUNTER PAGE AND LINE DESIGNATIONS TO PLAINTIFFS DESIGNATIONS FROM THE VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION OF RICK JOHN REW TAKEN ON AUGUEST 30,2007 SUBJECT TO AND WITHOUT WAIVING MURCO WALL PRODUCTS INCS OBJECTION TO PLAINTIFFS DESIGNATIONS FROM THE VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION OF RICK JOHN REW TAKEN ON AUGUST 30,2007
Document Available (#1028145726)
12-18-2014 DEPO
DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS INCS COUNTER PAGE AND LINE DESIGNATIONS TO PLAINTIFFS DESIGNATIONS FROM THE VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION OF JOAN BENTON TAKEN ON DECEMBER 21,2012 SUBJECT TO AND WITHOUT WAIVING MURCO WALL PRODUCTS INCS OBJECTION TO PLAINTIFFS DESIGNATIONS FROM THE VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION OF JOAN BENTON TAKEN ON DECEMBER 21,2012
Document Available (#1028145722)
12-18-2014 DEPO
DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS INCS COUNTER PAGE AND LINE DESIGNATIONS TO PLAINTIFFS DESIGNATIONS FROM THE VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION OF MILTON STRADER TAKEN ON AUGUST 30,2011
Document Available (#1028145718)
12-18-2014 DEPO
DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS INCS COUNTER PAGE AND LINE DESIGNATIONS TO PLAINTIFFS DESIGNATIONS FROM THE VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION OF JACK WALSH TAKEN ON OCTOBER 20,2011
Document Available (#1028145714)
12-18-2014 DEPO
DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS INCS COUNTER PAGE AND LINE DESIGNATIONS TO PLAINTIFFS DESIGNATIONS FROM THE VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION OF JACK WALSH TAKEN ON AUGUEST 2,2011
Document Available (#1028145710)
12-18-2014 DEPO
DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS INCS COUNTER PAGE AND LINE DESIGNATIONS TO PLAINTIFFS DESIGNATIONS FROM THE VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION OF JACK WALSH TAKEN ON NOVEMBER 20,2009
Document Available (#1028145706)
12-18-2014 OBJ
PLAINTIFF'S OBJECTIONS TO DEFENDANT UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION'S AND MURCO WALL PRODUCTS, INC.'S PAGE AND LINE DESIGNATIONS FROM THE DEPOSITION OF ANTHONY GALIER TAKEN ON JANUARY 31, 2014
Document Available (#1028146450)
12-18-2014 OBJ
PLAINTIFF'S OBJECTIONS TO DEFENDANT UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION'S AND MURCO WALL PRODUCTS, INC.'S PAGE AND LINE DESIGNATIONS FROM THE DEPOSITION OF RITA GALIER TAKEN ON APRIL 4, 2014
Document Available (#1028146454)
12-18-2014 OBJ
PLAINTIFF'S OBJECTIONS TO DEFENDANT UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION'S AND MURCO WALL PRODUCTS, INC.'S PAGE AND LINE DESIGNATIONS FROM THE DEPOSITION OF WILLIAM DYSON, PH.D. TAKEN ON APRIL 16, 2014
Document Available (#1028146809)
12-18-2014 OBJ
PLAINTIFF'S OBJECTIONS TO DEFENDANT UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION'S AND MURCO WALL PRODUCTS, INC.'S PAGE AND LINE DESIGNATIONS FROM THE DEPOSITION OF ANDREW GALIER TAKEN ON JANUARY 31, 2014
Document Available (#1028146829)
12-18-2014 OBJ
PLAINTIFF'S COUNTER-DESIGNATIONS AND OBJECTIONS TO DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS, INC.'S PAGE AND LINE DESIGNATIONS FROM THE DEPOSITION OF MILTON STRADER TAKEN ON OCTOBER 11, 2014
Document Available (#1028146788)
12-18-2014 OBJ
PLAINTIFF'S COUNTER-DESIGNATIONS AND OBJECTIONS TO DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS, INC.'S PAGE AND LINE DESIGNATIONS FROM THE DEPOSITION OF ROBERT E. BYRNE TAKEN ON JUNE 25, 2002 AND JUNE 26, 2002
Document Available (#1028146805)
12-18-2014 OBJ
PLAINTIFF'S COUNTER-DESIGNATIONS AND OBJECTIONS TO DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS, INC.'S PAGE AND LINE DESIGNATIONS FROM THE DEPOSITION OF MICHAEL GALIER ON FEBRUARY 13, 2013
Document Available (#1028146817)
12-18-2014 OBJ
PLAINTIFF'S COUNTER-DESIGNATIONS AND OBJECTIONS TO DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS, INC.'S PAGE AND LINE DESIGNATIONS FROM THE DEPOSITION OF MICHAEL GALIER TAKEN JULY 3, 2014
Document Available (#1028146821)
12-18-2014 OBJ
PLAINTIFF'S COUNTER-DESIGNATIONS AND OBJECTIONS TO DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS, INC.'S PAGE AND LINE DESIGNATIONS FROM THE DEPOSITION OF CHARLES W. LEHNER TAKEN ON NOVEMBER 12, 2002
Document Available (#1028146458)
12-18-2014 OBJ
PLAINTIFF'S COUNTER-DESIGNATIONS AND OBJECTIONS TO DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS, INC.'S PAGE AND LINE DESIGNATIONS FROM THE DEPOSITION OF TOM NORRIS TAKEN ON AUGUST 7, 2002
Document Available (#1028146466)
12-18-2014 OBJ
PLAINTIFF'S COUNTER-DESIGNATIONS AND OBJECTIONS TO DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS, INC.'S PAGE AND LINE DESIGNATIONS FROM THE DEPOSITION OF DOUGLAS MERRILL TAKEN ON MAY 31, 2006, JUNE 1, 2006, JUNE 2, 2006 AND JUNE 7, 2006
Document Available (#1028146462)
12-18-2014 OBJ
PLAINTIFF'S COUNTER-DESIGNATIONS AND OBJECTIONS TO DEFENDANT WELCO MANUFACTURING COMPANY'S PAGE AND LINE DESIGNATIONS FROM THE DEPOSITION OF EARL E. STOVER ON JULY 23, 1992
Document Available (#1028146490)
12-18-2014 OBJ
PLAINTIFF'S COUNTER-DESIGNATIONS AND OBJECTIONS TO DEFENDANT WELCO MANUFACTURING COMPANY'S PAGE AND LINE DESIGNATIONS FROM THE DEPOSITION OF DERREL SELL TAKEN ON FEBRUARY 6, 1992
Document Available (#1028146486)
12-18-2014 OBJ
PLAINTIFF'S COUNTER-DESIGNATIONS AND OBJECTIONS TO DEFENDANT UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION'S PAGE AND LINE DESIGNATIONS FROM THE DEPOSITION OF MICHAEL GALIER TAKEN ON JULY 3, 2014
Document Available (#1028146825)
12-18-2014 OBJ
PLAINTIFF'S COUNTER-DESIGNATIONS AND OBJECTIONS TO DEFENDANT UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION'S PAGE AND LINE DESIGNATIONS FROM THE DEPOSITION OF MICHAEL GALIER TAKEN ON FEBRUARY 13, 2013
Document Available (#1028146813)
12-18-2014 RESP
PLAINTIFF'S Response TO DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS, INC.'S MOTION TO EXCLUDE THE TESTIMONY OF PLAINTIFF'S EXPERT STEVE HAYS
Document Available (#1028145681)
12-18-2014 RESP
PLAINTIFF'S Response TO DEFENDANT UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION'S MOTION IN LIMINE
Document Available (#1028145697)
12-18-2014 RESP
PLAINTIFF'S Response TO DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS, INC.'S MOTION TO EXCLUDE THE TESTIMONY OF PLAINTIFF'S EXPERT ARNOLD BRODY, PHD
Document Available (#1028145677)
12-18-2014 RESP
PLAINTIFF'S Response IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION'S BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF ITS MOTION IN LIMINE NOS. 52 AND 59
Document Available (#1028145685)
12-18-2014 RESP
PLAINTIFF'S CONSOLIDATED Response TO DEFENDANTS' MOTIONS IN LIMINE TO EXCLUDE PLAINTIFF'S EXPERT CAUSATION TESTIMONY
Document Available (#1028145689)
12-18-2014 RESP
PLAINTIFF'S Response IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT WELCO'S MOTION IN LIMINE REGARDING WELCO MANUFACTURING COMPANY OF TEXAS
Document Available (#1028145693)
12-18-2014 OBJ
PLAINTIFF'S ObjectionS TO DEFENDANT UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION'S PAGE AND LINE DESIGNATIONS FROM THE DEPOSITION OF JOHN WALSH TAKEN ON AUGUST 22, 2002
Document Available (#1028146574)
12-18-2014 OBJ
PLAINTIFF'S COUNTER-DESIGNATIONS AND ObjectionS TO DEFENDANT UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION'S PAGE AND LINE DESIGNATIONS FROM THE DEPOSITION OF JOHN WALSH TAKEN ON JUNE 30, 2004
Document Available (#1028146578)
12-18-2014 OBJ
PLAINTIFF'S COUNTER-DESIGNATIONS AND ObjectionS TO DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS, INC.'S PAGE AND LINE DESIGNATIONS FROM THE DEPOSITION OF WILLIAM THURBER TAKEN ON JUNE 29, 2002
Document Available (#1028146582)
12-18-2014 OBJ
PLAINTIFF'S OBJECTIONS TO DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS INC.'S PAGE AND LINE DESIGNATIONS FROM THE DEPOSITION OF KIM E ANDERSON, PHD. TAKEN ON JULY 24, 2014
Document Available (#1028146586)
12-18-2014 OBJ
PLAINTIFF'S COUNTER-DESIGNATIONS AND ObjectionS TO DEFENDANT UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION'S PAGE AND LINE DESIGNATIONS FROM THE DEPOSITION OF JOAN BENTON TAKEN ON MAY 11, 2006
Document Available (#1028146590)
12-18-2014 RESP
PLAINTIFF'S Response IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT MURCO'S SUPPLEMENTAL MOTION IN LIMINE TO EXCLUDE PLAINTIFF'S TESTIMONY THAT PRODUCTS CONTAINED ASBESTOS
Document Available (#1028146646)
12-18-2014 RESP
PLAINTIFF'S Response IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT MURCO'S SUPPLEMENTAL MOTION IN LIMINE
Document Available (#1028146650)
12-18-2014 RESP
PLAINTIFF'S Response IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT WELCO'S MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 10 AND REGARDING OTHER CLAIMS AGAINST IT FROM ITS MOTION IN LIMINE AND BRIEF
Document Available (#1028146654)
12-18-2014 RESP
PLAINTIFF'S Response IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT MURCO'S NO. 87 MOTION IN LIMINE FROM ITS 103 PART MOTION IN LIMINE AND BRIEF
Document Available (#1028146658)
12-18-2014 RESP
PLAINTIFF'S Response IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT MURCO'S MOTION IN LIMINE NOS. 94 AND 95 FROM ITS 103 PART MOTION IN LIMINE AND BRIEF
Document Available (#1028146662)
12-18-2014 RESP
PLAINTIFF'S Response TO DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS, INC.'S SUPPLEMENTAL MOTION IN LIMINE TO EXCLUDE "NO SAFE DOSE," "EACH AND EVERY EXPOSURE," AND "CUMULATIVE EXPOSURE" OPINIONS
Document Available (#1028146666)
12-18-2014 NO
notice of adoption of objections
Document Available (#1028147606)
12-18-2014 OBJ
defendatn murco wall products, inc.'s objection and motion to strike union carbide corporation's page and line designations of the oral trial testimony of john walsh taken on june 30, 2204.
Document Available (#1028147590)
12-18-2014 RESP
PLAINTIFF'S RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT WELCO'S MOTION IN LIMINE TO EXCLUDE CASE REPORTS
Document Available (#1028146494)
12-18-2014 RESP
PLAINTIFF'S RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT MURCO'S MOTION FOR CONTRIBUTION AND SETOFF
Document Available (#1028146478)
12-18-2014 OBJ
defendant welco manufacturing company's objections and counter designations to plaintiff's designations of jack walsh's november 20, 2009 deposition
Document Available (#1028146085)
12-18-2014 RESP
PLAINTIFF'S RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT MURCO'S SUPPLEMENTAL MOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE CERTAIN MEDICAL AND SCIENTIFIC ARTICLES, TREATIES, PERIODICALS, OF PAMPHLETS
Document Available (#1028146470)
12-18-2014 OBJ
defe3ndant welco manufacturing company's objections and counter designations to plaintiff's designations of jack walsh's october 20, 2011 deposition
Document Available (#1028146081)
12-18-2014 OBJ
defendant's objections and counter designations to plaintiff's depsition designation of milton strader taken on august 30, 2011
Document Available (#1028146089)
12-18-2014 OBJ
defendant welco manufacturing company's objections and counter designations to plaintiff's designations of jack walsh's august 2, 2011 deposition
Document Available (#1028146077)
12-18-2014 RESP
PLAINTIFF'S RESPONSE IN OPPOSTION TO DEFENDANT MURCO'S MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 72 TO EXCLUDE ADMISSION AND/OR REFERENCE TO CASE REPORTS, THE AUSTRALIAN REGISTRY, AND CAUSATION OPINION TESTIMONY BASED ON THIS INFORMATION
Document Available (#1028146474)
12-18-2014 RESP
PLAINTIFF'S RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT MURCO'S SUPPLEMENTAL MOTION IN LIMINE REGARDING GROSS NEGLIGENCE, WILLFUL, WANTON, AND RECKLESS CONDUCT
Document Available (#1028146849)
12-18-2014 RESP
PLAINTIFF'S RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT MURCO'S SUPPLEMENTAL MOTION IN LIMINE REGARDING MEDICAL EXPENSES AND DISABILITY
Document Available (#1028146845)
12-18-2014 RESP
PLAINTIFF'S RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT MURCO'S MOTION IN LIMINE AND BRIEF
Document Available (#1028146841)
12-18-2014 RESP
PLAINTIFF'S RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT UCC'S MOTION IN LIMINE NOS. 46 AND 47 FROM ITS MOTION IN LIMINE AND BRIEF
Document Available (#1028146837)
12-18-2014 RESP
PLAINTIFF'S RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT WELCO'S MOTION IN LIMINE
Document Available (#1028146833)
12-18-2014 OBJ
DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS INCS OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS DESIGNATIONS FROM THE VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION OF RICK JOHN REW TAKEN ON AUGUST 30 2007 SUBJECT TO AND WITHOUT WAIVING MURCO WALL PRODUCTS INCS OBJECTION AND MOTION TO STRIKE THE PAGE AND LINE DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS OR RICK REW
Document Available (#1028166424)
12-18-2014 OBJ
DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS INCS OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS DESIGNATIONS FROM THE VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION OF JOAN BENTON TAKEN ON DECEMBER 21 2012
Document Available (#1028166428)
12-18-2014 OBJ
DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS INCS OBJECTION AND MOTION TO STRIKE THE PAGE AND LINE DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS OF RICK REW TAKEN ON AUGUST 30 2007
Document Available (#1028166432)
12-18-2014 OBJ
DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS INCS OBJECTIONS AND RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION IN LIMINE
Document Available (#1028166440)
12-19-2014 CTFREE
JUDGE DIXON - MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT RED DEVIL INC - OVERRULED AS PER J.E.
12-19-2014 MO
Motion TO ASSOCIATE COUNSEL
Document Available (#1028147940)
12-19-2014 MO
DEFENDANT'S Motion FOR LEAVE OF COURT TO USE A JUROR QUESTIONNAIRE
Document Available (#1028147971)
12-19-2014 MO
Motion TO ASSOCIATE COUNSEL
Document Available (#1028148011)
12-19-2014 OBJ
DEFENDANT UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION'S OBJECTIONS AND COUNTER-DESIGNATIONS TO PLAINTIFF'S AND WELCO MANUFACTURING COMPANY'S PAGE AND LINE DESIGNATIONS
Document Available (#1028146569)
12-22-2014 NO
defendant union carbide corporation's notice of joinder and adoption of co-defendants' objections to plaintiff michael galier's motions in limine
Document Available (#1028168066)
12-23-2014 O
order admitting to practice
Document Available (#1028170941)
12-29-2014 EAA
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE
Document Available (#1027995430)
12-29-2014 NO
defendant welco manufacturing company's Notice of adoption of co-defendants' counter-designations and objections to plaintiffs' page and line designations
Document Available (#1028166446)
12-29-2014 NO
defendant welco manufacturing company's Notice of adoptio of co-defendants' pretrial motions and objections to plaintiff's motions
Document Available (#1028166450)
12-31-2014 LT
LETTER TO JUDGE DIXON FROM SHAWN D GOLDEN ATTY
Document Available (#1027070364)
12-31-2014 NO
defendant union carbide corporation's notice of withdrawal of its motion for leave of court to amend final designation of fact and expert witnesses
Document Available (#1028169470)
01-05-2015 OBJ
DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTIONS, INC.'S OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFF'S COUNTER-DESIGNATIONS TO DEFENDANT UNION CARBIDE'S PAGE AND LINE DESIGNATIONS FROM THE DEPOSITION OF JOAN BENTON TAKEN ON MAY 11, 2006
Document Available (#1028162971)
01-05-2015 OBJ
DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTIONS, INC.'S OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFF'S COUNTER-DESIGNATIONS FROM THE VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION OF MICHAEL GALIER TAKEN ON FEBUARY 13,2013
Document Available (#1028162967)
01-06-2015 CRF
COURT REPORTER FEE-TRIAL ON MERITS
$ 20.00
01-06-2015 CTFREE
JUDGE DIXON - PLAINTIFF'S MOTION IN LIMINE - SUSTAINED BY AGREEMENT AS TO #'S 1, 2, 3, 7, 8, 10, 11, 12, 16 & 18 & MOTION IN LIMINE - NO ALCOHOL OR DRUG USE, WITHDRAWN AS TO #'S 4 & 17; SUSTAINED AS TO #6 AS TO DEFENDANT FORD ONLY; OVER RULED AS TO #'S 5, 9, 13 & 15; SUSTAINED IN PART/OVER RULED IN PART AS TO #14: SUSTAINED AS TO 1ST SENTENCE AND OVER RULED AS TO 2ND SENTENCE AS PER J.E. COURT REPORTER PAM HARTWICK
01-06-2015 CTFREE
JUDGE DIXON - DEFENDANT WELCO MANUFACTURING COMPANY'S MOTION IN LIMINE - SUSTAINED BY AGREEMENT AS TO II.1.(B)&C, 5(A), 8, 12-17; III.2; V; AND X. II(3) WEBSITE - SUSTAINED AS TO STAGE 1, RESERVED AS TO STAGE 2; II(11) - OVER RULED; II(18) - OVER RULED; IV(1&2) PUNITIVE DAMAGES - OVER RULED; IX(3) CPSC COMMENTS - OVER RULED AS PER J.E. COURT REPORTER PAM HARTWICK
01-06-2015 CTFREE
JUDGE DIXON - DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS, INC. MOTION IN LIMINE - SUSTAINED BY AGREEMENT AS TO #'S 1, 4, 7-11, 15, 16, 18, 20-22, 24, 30, 36, 39-42, 46, 47, 52, 56, 57, 63, 70, 71, 73, 77, 80, 83, 86, 88-90, 97. WITHDRAWN BY MOVANT #'S 13, 29, 32, 34, 37, 38, 54, 55, 61, 66-68, 75, 82, 91-93, 96, 98-100. SUSTAINED BY AGREEMENT #'S 3, 6 WITH FOUNDATION AND IF RELEVANT, 12 WITH CONDITIONS, 17, 26 BUT CAN EMPLOY PEOPLE TO RESEARCH, 31, 33, 44, 50, 51 EXCEPT AS TO DEFENDANT WELCO, 72 IF RELIED ON BY EXPERTS BUT NOT ADMITTED INTO EVIDENCE, 74, 78 AS TO JOINT COMPOUND AND CAULK WITH OR WITHOUT ASBESTOS, ANY OTHER PRODUCT TO BE ADDRESSED BEFORE OFFERING INTO EVIDENCE, 102 AND 103. SUSTAINED 2, 5, 23, 25, 27 & NO DISCUSS AHERA, 43 EXCEPT AS TO BIAS OF WITNESS, 45, 48, 58, 64 AS TO NON-SCIENTIFIC DATA AFTER EXPOSURE, 65 AS TO POST-EXPOSURE EXCEPT BOOKS RELIED UPON BY EXPERTS, 69 AS TO ALL STATEMENTS BY PLAINTIFF EXCEPT HIS REACTION TO DIAGNOSIS AND TREATMENT OPTIONS, 85 EXPECT CAN DISCUSS FUTURE MEDICAL AND CARE, 87 MUST APPROACH BENCH BEFORE, 94 AND 101 EXPECT CAN PUT ON EVIDENCE OF HOME CONSTRUCTION USE OF JOINT COMPOUND AND CAULK. OVERRULED - 35, 49, 59, 60, 62, 81, 95 DETERMINE AT TRIAL IF PREDICATE CAN BE LAID. WITHDRAWN BY MOVANT - 14, 76 DEFER TO JURY INSTRUCTIONS AND ARGUMENT, 79 AND 84. SUSTAINED IN PART/ OVERRULED IN PART - 19 SUSTAINED AS TO COURT AND JURY DECISION, OVERRULED AS TO OSHA & CPSC, 28 SUSTAINED AS TO "ASBESTOS VICTIM", OVERRULED AS TO "ASBESTOS COMPANY", 53 SUSTAINED AS TO DISCOVERY DISPUTE, OVERRULED AS TO LACK OF DOCUMENTS. COURT REPORTER PAM HARTWICK
01-06-2015 CTFREE
JUDGE DIXON - SUPPLEMENTAL MOTION IN LIMINE - SUSTAINED AS TO #2; OVERRULED AS TO #1; WITHDRAWN BY MOVANT AS TO 3-10 AS PER J.E. COURT REPORTER PAM HARTWICK
01-06-2015 CTFREE
JUDGE DIXON - MOTION FOR CONTRIBUTION AND SETOFF - PASS TO TRIAL COURT REPORTER PAM HARTWICK
01-06-2015 CTFREE
JUDGE DIXON - SUPPLEMENTAL MOTION IN LIMINE TO EXCLUDE "NO SAFE DOSE", "EACH AND EVERY EXPOSURE" AND "CUMULATIVE EXPOSURE" OPINIONS - OVERRULED AS PER J.E. COURT REPORTER PAM HARTWICK
01-06-2015 CTFREE
JUDGE DIXON - SUPPLEMENTAL MOTION IN LIMINE TO EXCLUDE OPINIONS BASED UPON INAPPLICABLE AUTHORITY - OVERRULED AS PER J.E. COURT REPORTER PAM HARTWICK
01-06-2015 CTFREE
JUDGE DIXON - SUPPLEMENTAL MOTION IN LIMINE TO EXCLUDE PLAINTIFF'S TESTIMONY THAT PRODUCTS CONTAIN ASBESTOS - WITHDRAWN BY MOVANT COURT REPORTER PAM HARTWICK
01-06-2015 CTFREE
JUDGE DIXON - SUPPLEMENTAL MOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE INTRODUCTION OF CERTAIN MEDICAL AND SCIENTIFIC ARTICLES, TREATISES, PERIODICALS, OR PHAMPLETS - WITHDRAWN BY MOVANT COURT REPORTER PAM HARTWICK
01-06-2015 CTFREE
JUDGE DIXON - SUPPLEMENTAL MOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE PLAINTIFF'S MEDICAL EXPERT FROM TESTIFYING TO ISSUES OF INDSTRIAL HYGIENE - WITHDRAWN BY MOVANT COURT REPORTER PAM HARTWICK
01-06-2015 CTFREE
JUDGE DIXON - SUPPLEMENTAL MOTION IN LIMINE REGARDING GROSS NEGLIGENCE AND WILLFUL, WANTON AND RECKLESS CONDUCT - WITHDRAWN BY MOVANT COURT REPORTER PAM HARTWICK
01-06-2015 CTFREE
JUDGE DIXON - SUPPLEMENTAL MOTION IN LIMINE REGARDING MEDICAL EXPENSES AND DISABILITY - WITHDRAWN BY MOVANT COURT REPORTER PAM HARTWICK
01-06-2015 CTFREE
JUDGE DIXON - MOTION TO EXCLUDE THE TESTIMONY OF PLAINTIFF'S EXPERT ARNOLD BRODY - OVERRULED AS PER J.E. - THE COURT FINDS AND ADAPTS THE IOWA DISTRICT COURT'S RULING AS FOLLOWS: GIVEN [DR. BRODY'S] EDUCATION, HIS LONG STUDY OF ASBESTOS AND HOW IT CAUSES DISEASE, AND HIS NUMEROUS PEER-REVIEWED ARTICLES ON ASBESTOS (MANY OF WHICH RELATE TO THE EFFECTS OF CHRYSOTILE FIBERS ON A MOLECULAR LEVEL), AMONG OTHER THINGS, I CONCLUDE HIS METHODOLOGY IS RELIABLE AND HIS TESTIMONY IS RELEVANT, PARTICULARLY AS TO THE GENERAL CAUSATION ISSUE. HIS TESTIMONY MAY ASSIST THE JURY IN UNDERSTANDING HOW ASBESTOS CAUSES DISEASES, PARTICULARLY MESOTHELIOMA, AND HOW THE DISEASE MAY REMAIN LATENT FOR SO MANY YEARS. COURT REPORTER PAM HARTWICK
01-06-2015 CTFREE
JUDGE DIXON - MOTION TO EXCLUDE THE TESTIMONY OF PLAINTIFF'S EXPERT JOHN C. MADDOX, M.D. - OVERRULED AS PER J.E. MADDOX IS QUALIFIED UNDER DAUBERT AND CHRISTIAN COURT REPORTER PAM HARTWICK
01-06-2015 CTFREE
JUDGE DIXON - MOTION TO EXCLUDE THE TESTIMONY OF PLAINTIFF'S EXPERT STEVE HAYS - OVERRULED AS PER J.E. - MR HAYS IS QUALIFIED UNDER DAUBERT AND CHRISTIAN COURT REPORTER PAM HARTWICK
01-06-2015 CTFREE
JUDGE DIXON - DEFENDANT UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION'S MOTION IN LIMINE - WITHDRAWN BY MOVANT: 1-50, & 55-57. SUSTAINED BY AGREEMENT 51 WITH CLARIFICATION, 53 BUT CAN USE TRANSCRIPTS TO IMPEACH, 54 UNLESS UCC OPENS THE DOOR AND 58. OVERRULED: 55 AND 59. DEFERRED: 60 AS PER J.E. COURT REPORTER PAM HARTWICK
01-06-2015 O
order granting defendants' motion for leave of court to use a juror questionnaire
Document Available (#1028162423)
01-06-2015 O
order admitting to practice
Document Available (#1028162427)
01-06-2015 ACCOUNT
Receipt # 2015-3518227 on 01/06/2015.
Payor:Dick Dodson Total Amount Paid: $20.00.
Line Items:
CJ-2012-6920: $20.00 on AC01 Clerk Fees.
01-12-2015 O
DEFENDANTS PROPOSED JURY INSTRUCTIONS
Document Available (#1028156605)
01-12-2015 NO
DEFENDANT UNION CARBIDE CORPORATIONS NOTICE OF JOINDER IN AND ADOPTION OF CO - DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS INCS PAGE AND LINE DEPOSITION TESTIMONY OF CHARLES W LEHNERT TAKEN ON NOVEMBER 12 2002 AND PAGE AND LINE DEPOSITION TESTIMONY OF DOUGLAS MERRILL TAKEN ON MAY 31 2006 JUNE 1 2006 JUNE 2 2006 JUNE 5 2006 AND JUNE 7 2006
Document Available (#1028156421)
01-13-2015 NO
Notice OF TRIAL SUBPOENA
Document Available (#1028165515)
01-13-2015 NO
Notice OF TRIAL SUBPOENA
Document Available (#1028165547)
01-13-2015 NO
Notice OF TRIAL SUBPOENA
Document Available (#1028165551)
01-16-2015 CTFREE
JUDGE DIXON - ORDER AS TO DEPOSITION OBJECTIONS
Document Available (#1028187553)
01-16-2015 NO
DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS INCS NOTICE OF ADOPTION OF UNION CARBIDES PROPOSES SPECIAL JURY INSTRUCTIONS
Document Available (#1028415770)
01-16-2015 O
ORDER AS TO DEPOSITION OBJECTIONS
Document Available (#1028187553)
01-20-2015 MOC
motion to compel compliance with the personal injury trust fund transperancy act, 76 o.s. 81, et seq.
Document Available (#1028417626)
01-21-2015 RESP
plaintiff's response in opposition to defendants' motion to compel compliance with the personal injury trust fund transparency act, 76 o.s. 81 et seq.
Document Available (#1028413239)
01-21-2015 O
order directing district court clerk to remove this case from internet view during jury trial beginning january 26, 2015
Document Available (#1028412290)
01-22-2015 IJ
PLAINTIFF'S PROPOSED JURY INSTRUCTIONS AND VERDICT FORMS
Document Available (#1028417464)
01-22-2015 RET
RETURN AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE SERVED MR. ANTHONY GALIER IN PERSON ON 1-15-2015
Document Available (#1028410148)
01-22-2015 RET
RETURN AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE SERVED MR. ANTHONY GALIER IN PERSON ON 1-15-2015
Document Available (#1028410188)
01-22-2015 RET
RETURN AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE SERVED MR. ANDREW GALIER IN PERSON ON 1-14-2015
Document Available (#1028410192)
01-22-2015 RET
RETURN AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE SERVED MRS. RITA GALIER IN PERSON ON 1-14-2015
Document Available (#1028410228)
01-22-2015 RET
RETURN AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE SERVED MR. ANDREW GALIER IN PERSON ON 1-14-2015
Document Available (#1028410224)
01-23-2015 CTFREE
JUDGE DIXON - MOTION FOR LEAVE OF COURT TO AMEND FINAL DESIGNATION OF FACT AND EXPERT WITNESSES OF DEFENDANT UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION - STRICKEN N/A
01-23-2015 DEPO
DEFENDANTS' LEGAL AUTHORITIES REGARDING DEPOSTION DESIGNATIONS OF CHARLES LEHNERT AND MILTON STRADER
Document Available (#1028401863)
01-23-2015 B
PLAINTIFF'S Brief IN SUPPORT OF ITS GLOBAL OBJECTIONS TO DEPOSITIONS
Document Available (#1028402019)
01-23-2015 RESP
DEFENDANTS' LEGAL AUTHORITIES IN RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFF'S GLOBAL MOTION TO STRIKE THE PAGE AND LINE DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS OF WILLIAM DYSON, PH.D., CIH
Document Available (#1028401839)
01-23-2015 RESP
DEFENDANTS' LEGAL AUTHORITIES IN RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFF'S GLOBAL MOTION TO STRIKE THE PAGE AND LINE DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS OF DOUGLAS MERRILL OF MAY 31, 2006; JUNE 1, 2006; JUNE 2, 2006; JUNE 5, 2006 AND JUNE 7, 2006
Document Available (#1028401843)
01-23-2015 RESP
DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS, INC.'S OBJECTION AND LEGAL AUTHORITIES TO STRIKE THE PAGE AND LINE DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS OF RICK REW TAKEN ON AUGUST 30, 2007
Document Available (#1028401847)
01-23-2015 MO
TRIAL BRIEF/Motion TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE
Document Available (#1028401867)
01-26-2015 CTFREE
JUDGE DIXON - JURY TRIAL - STRICKEN TO BE RESET BY AGREEMENT
02-05-2015 NOF
Notice Of Filing
02-05-2015 T&1
Original Transcript and One Copy of THE MOTION IN LIMINE PROCEEDINGS HAD ON JANUARY 6, 2015 BEFORE THE HONORABLE BRYAN C. DIXON / COURT REPORTER PAMELA HARTWICK / EXHIBITS ATTACHED
03-09-2015 DEPO
plaintiff's page and line designations from the deposition of john c. maddox taken on january 22, 2015
Document Available (#1028799077)
03-10-2015 MO
MOTION TO WITHDRAW AS COUNSEL OF RECORD
Document Available (#1028633803)
03-11-2015 O
ORDER ALLOWING WITHDRAWAL
Document Available (#1028797189)
03-20-2015 MO
motion to associate counsel
Document Available (#1029098313)
03-24-2015 OBJ
DEFENDANTS' OBJECTIONS AND COUNTER DESIGNATIONS TO PLAINTIFF'S DESIGNATIONS OF THE DEPOSITION OF DR. JOHN C MADDOX TAKEN ON JANUARY 22, 2015
Document Available (#1029092307)
03-27-2015 DISPCVDMWP
DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE AS TO DEFENDANT, UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION
Document Available (#1028526028)
1 Union Carbide Corporation
03-27-2015 MO
MOTION TO WITHDRAW AS COUNSEL OF RECORD
Document Available (#1029095703)
03-27-2015 MO
PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO ADD PARTY
Document Available (#1029095699)
03-30-2015 MO
motion to associate counsel
Document Available (#1029098337)
04-01-2015 O
Order ALLOWING WITHDRAWAL
Document Available (#1028632556)
04-01-2015 O
ORDER ADMITTING TO PRACTICE
Document Available (#1029088855)
04-01-2015 O
ORDER ADMITTING TO PRACTICE
Document Available (#1029088859)
04-01-2015 DEPO
murco wall products, inc.'s amended counter page and line designations to plaintiff's designations from the videotaped deposition of rick john rew taken on august 30, 2007, subject to and without waiving murco wall products, inc.'s objections to plaintiff's designations from the videotaped deposition of rick john rew taken on august 30, 2007.
Document Available (#1029089266)
04-01-2015 RESP
DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS INCS AMENDED OBJECTIONS ( PARING DOWN ORIGINAL ) TO PLAINTIFFS DESIGNATIONS FROM THE VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION OF RICK JOHN REW TAKEN ON AUGUST 30 , 2007
Document Available (#1028525822)
04-06-2015 LT
Letter
Document Available (#1029086485)
04-06-2015 B
supplemental trial brief/motion to exclude evidence
Document Available (#1029086481)
04-06-2015 RESP
plaintiff's responses to defendants' designations and objections to the deposition of dr. john c. maddox taken on jnuary 22, 2015
Document Available (#1029087304)
04-06-2015 DEPO
plaintiff's revised page and line designations and counter designations from the deposition of jack walsh taken on august 2, 2011.
Document Available (#1029087300)
04-06-2015 RESP
plaintiffs responses to defendants' designations and objection to the deposition of jafck walsh's taken on august 2, 2011
Document Available (#1029087312)
04-06-2015 RESP
plaintiffs responses to defendants' designations and objection to the deposition of rick rew taken on august 30, 2007.
Document Available (#1029087308)
04-09-2015 IJ
COMBINED PROPOSED JURY INSTRUCTIONS AND VERDICT FORMS
Document Available (#1029082359)
04-09-2015 OBJ
DEFENDANTS' OBJECTION AND COUNTER DESIGNATIONS TO PLAINTIFF'S RESPONSES TO DEFENDANTS' DESIGNATIONS AND OBJECTIONS TO THE DEPOSTITION OF DR. JOHN C. MADDOX TAKEN ON JANUARY 22, 2015
Document Available (#1029081265)
04-10-2015 CRF
COURT REPORTER FEE-TRIAL ON MERITS
$ 20.00
04-10-2015 CTFREE
JUDGE DIXON - MOTION TO COMPEL COMPLIANCE WITH THE PERSONAL INJURY TRUST FUND ACT - SUSTAINED - PLAINTIFF TO MAKE A GOOD FAILTH CLAIM WITHIN 60 DAYS ON INFORMATION PROVIDED BY DEFENDANT'S AS PER J.E.
04-10-2015 ADJUST
ADJUSTING ENTRY: MONIES DUE TO AC09-CARD ALLOCATION
$ 0.50
04-10-2015 ACCOUNT
ADJUSTING ENTRY: MONIES DUE TO THE FOLLOWING AGENCIES REDUCED BY THE FOLLOWING AMOUNTS:
CJ-2012-6920: AC01 Clerk Fees -$0.50
04-10-2015 ACCOUNT
Receipt # 2015-3588987 on 04/10/2015.
Payor:STEVEN HORTON Total Amount Paid: $20.00.
Line Items:
CJ-2012-6920: $19.50 on AC01 Clerk Fees.
CJ-2012-6920: $0.50 on AC09 Card Allocations.
04-15-2015 OBJ
COMBINED GLOBAL OBJECTIONS AND RESPONSES
Document Available (#1029077310)
04-16-2015 RESP
DEFENDANTS' RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFF'S "COMBINED GLOBAL OBJECTIONS AND RESPONSES"
Document Available (#1029076177)
04-17-2015 O
JUDGE DIXON - ORDER AS TO DEFENDANT WELCO'S DEPOSITION OBJECTIONS AS TO JACK WALSH IN MUMFREY CASE
Document Available (#1017400398)
04-17-2015 O
JUDGE DIXON - ORDER AS TO GLOBAL OBJECTIONS TO DEPOSITIONS
Document Available (#1029320533)
04-17-2015 O
JUDGE DIXON - ORDER AS TO DEFENDANT MURCO'S DEPOSITION OBJECTIONS AS TO RICK REW
Document Available (#1029320537)
04-20-2015 CTFREE
JUDGE DIXON - ORDER AS TO DEPOSITION OBJECTIONS AS TO WILLIAM DYSON
Document Available (#1029320601)
04-20-2015 IJ
defendants supplemental proposed jury instructions
Document Available (#1029303444)
04-21-2015 O
JUDGE DIXON - ORDER AS TO DEPOSITION OBJECTIONS OF JOHN C. MADDOX
Document Available (#1029318346)
04-21-2015 O
Order as to deposition objections of john c. maddox
Document Available (#1029318346)
04-28-2015 NOF
Notice Of Filing
04-28-2015 T&1
Original Transcript and One Copy of THE MOTION PROCEEDINGS HAD ON APRIL 10, 2015 BEFORE THE HONORABLE BRYAN C. DIXON / COURT REPORTER PAMELA HARTWICK
05-01-2015 O
JUDGE DIXON - ORDER DIRECTING DISTRICT COURT CLERK TO REMOVE THIS CASE FROM INTERNET VIEW DURING JURY TRIAL BEGINNING MAY 4, 2015
Document Available (#1029320576)
05-04-2015 CTFREE
JUDGE DIXON - DAY 1 - CASE COMES ON FOR JURY TRIAL. PLAINTIFF APPEARS WITH COUNSEL STEVEN HORTON AND JESSICA DEAN. RICHARD DODSON APPEARS FOR DEEFNDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS, MICHAEL D. CARTER APPEARS FOR DEFENDANT WELCO MANUFACTURING COMPANY AND KAYCE GISINGER APPEARS FOR DEFENDANT RED DEVIL CORPORATION. BOTH SIDES ANNOUNCE READY. THIRTY FIVE (35) JURORS SWORN TO ANSWER QUESTIONS. EIGHTEEN (18) CALLED TO THE BOX BY THE COURT. PROSPECTIVE JURORS EXCUSED FOR CAUSE. JURY EXAMINATION BY PLAINTIFF AND DEFENDANT AND PASSED FOR CAUSE. PEREMPTORY CHALLENGES. ALL CHALLENGES CALLED. THIRTEEN (13) JURORS SWORN TO TRY CASE. COURT'S INSTRUCTION #1. OPENING STATEMENTS BY PLAINTIFF. COURT ADMONISHES JURY AND RECESSES UNTIL 9:00 AM 5-5-2015. PAM HARTWICK COURT REPORTER
05-05-2015 CTFREE
JUDGE DIXON - DAY 2 - JURY TRIAL CONTINUES AFTER NIGHT'S RECESS. OPENING STATEMENTS BY PLAINTIFF AND DEFENDANT. COURT ADMONISHES JURY AND RECESSES UNTIL 5-6-2015 @ 9:00 AM. PAM HARTWICK AM COURT REPORTER AND SCOTT WILMETH PM COURT REPORTER.
05-06-2015 CTFREE
JUDGE DIXON - DAY 3 - JURY TRIAL CONTINUES AFTER NIGHT'S RECESS. WITNESS SWORN, TESTIMONY HEARD, EXHIBITS OFFERED. COURT ADMONISHES JURY AND RECESSES UNTIL 5-7-2015 @ 9:00 AM. PAM HARTWICK AM COURT REPORTER AND SCOTT WILMETH PM COURT REPORTER.
05-07-2015 CTFREE
JUDGE DIXON - DAY 4 - JURY TRIAL CONTINUES AFTER NIGHT'S RECESS. WITNESS SWORN, TESTIMONY HEARD, EXHIBITS OFFERED. COURT ADMONISHES JURY AND RECESSES UNTIL 5-8-2015 @ 9:00 AM. PAM HARTWICK AM COURT REPORTER AND SCOTT WILMETH PM COURT REPORTER.
05-08-2015 CTFREE
JUDGE DIXON - DAY 5 - JURY TRIAL CONTINUES AFTER NIGHT'S RECESS. WITNESS SWORN, TESTIMONY HEARD, EXHIBITS OFFERED. COURT ADMONISHES JURY AND RECESSES UNTIL 5-11-2015 @ 9:00 AM. PAM HARTWICK AM COURT REPORTER AND SCOTT WILMETH PM COURT REPORTER.
05-11-2015 CTFREE
JUDGE DIXON - DAY 6 - JURY TRIAL CONTINUES AFTER WEEKEND'S RECESS. WITNESS SWORN, TESTIMONY HEARD, EXHIBITS OFFERED. COURT ADMONISHES JURY AND RECESSES UNTIL 5-12-2015 @ 9:00 AM. PAM HARTWICK AM COURT REPORTER AND SCOTT WILMETH PM COURT REPORTER.
05-12-2015 CTFREE
JUDGE DIXON - DAY 7 - JURY TRIAL CONTINUES AFTER NIGHT'S RECESS. WITNESS SWORN, TESTIMONY HEARD, EXHIBITS OFFERED. COURT ADMONISHES JURY AND RECESSES UNTIL 5-13-2015 @ 9:00 AM. PAM HARTWICK AM COURT REPORTER AND SCOTT WILMETH PM COURT REPORTER.
05-13-2015 CTFREE
JUDGE DIXON - DAY 8 - JURY TRIAL CONTINUES AFTER NIGHT'S RECESS. WITNESS SWORN, TESTIMONY HEARD, EXHIBITS OFFERED. COURT ADMONISHES JURY AND RECESSES UNTIL 5-14-2015 @ 9:00 AM. PAM HARTWICK AM COURT REPORTER AND SCOTT WILMETH PM COURT REPORTER.
05-13-2015 OBJ
DEFENDANTS' OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFF'S PROPOSED JURY INSTRUCTIONS AND VERDICT FORMS
Document Available (#1029288947)
05-13-2015 B
DEFENDANT WELCO MANUFACTURING COMPANY'S TRIAL BRIEF ADDRESSING PLAINTIFF'S LACK OF SUPPORT FOR FUTIRE MEDICIAL EXPENSES
Document Available (#1029288679)
05-14-2015 CTFREE
JUDGE DIXON - DAY 9 - JURY TRIAL CONTINUES AFTER NIGHT'S RECESS. WITNESS SWORN, TESTIMONY HEARD, EXHIBITS OFFEED. PLAINTIFF REST. ALL MOTIONS FOR DIRECTED VERDICT OVERRULED. DEFENDANT CALLS WITNESSES, CROSS EXAMINATION, DEFENDANT REST. COURT ADMONISHES JURY AND RECESSES UNTIL 5-15-2015 @ 9:00 AM. PAM HARTWICK AM COURT REPORTER AND SCOTT WILMETH PM COURT REPORTER
05-14-2015 B
trial brief
Document Available (#1029287440)
05-14-2015 B
trial brief
Document Available (#1029287436)
05-14-2015 IJ
DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS, INC.'S SUPLEMENTAL PROPOSED JURY INSTRUCTIONS
Document Available (#1029288181)
05-14-2015 NO
Notice OF ADOPTION BY DEFENDANTS RED DEVIL, INC. AND MURCO WALL PRODUCTS, INC OF DEFENDANT WALCO MANUFACTURING COMPANY'S TRIAL BRIEFS
Document Available (#1029287847)
05-15-2015 CTFREE
JUDGE DIXON - DAY 10 - JURY TRIAL CONTINUES AFTER NIGHT'S RECESS. COURT'S INSTRUCTIONS TO THE JURY. CLOSING ARGUMENTS BY PLAINTIFF AND DEFENDANTS. JURY RETIRES TO DELIBERATE AND RETURNS WITH VERDICT AND FINDS: JUDGMENT FOR THE PLAINTIFF AGAINST DEFENDANTS MURCO WALL PRODUCTS INC., AND WELCO MANUFACTURING COMPANY, INC. IN THE AMOUNT OF $6 MILLION COMPRISED OF ECONOMIC DAMAGES IN THE AMOUNT OF $1.5 MILLION AND NON-ECONOMIC DAMAGES IN THE AMOUNT OF $4.5 MILLION WITH 40% LIABILITY TO MURCO WALL PRODUCTS, INC., AND 60% LIABILITY TO WELCO MANUFACTURING COMPANY, INC. JUDGMENT FOR THE DEFENDANT, RED DEVIL CORPORATION. COURT ADMONISHES JURY AND RECESSES UNTIL 5-18-2015 @ 9:00 AM FOR STAGE 2. PAM HARTWICK AM COURT REPORTER AND SCOTT WILMETH PM COURT REPORTER
05-15-2015 DISPJD
JUDGE DIXON - JUDGMENT FOR DEFENDANT
1 Red Devil, Inc.
05-15-2015 MO
DEFENDANT'S MOTION FOR SETOFF/CREDIT PURSUANT TO 76 OKLAHOMA STATUTE SECTION 88 (TRANSPARENCY ACT)
Document Available (#1029479279)
05-18-2015 JL
JURY LIST
Document Available (#1029318465)
05-18-2015 IJ
DEFENDANTS SUPPLEMENTAL PROPOSED JURY INSTRUCTIONS
Document Available (#1029318453)
05-18-2015 IJ
DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTSM INC'S SUPPLEMENTAL PROPOSED JURY INSTRUCTIONS
Document Available (#1029318449)
05-18-2015 IJ
JURY INSTRUCTIONS - SECOND STAGE
Document Available (#1029318316)
05-18-2015 IJ
JURY INSTRUCTIONS
Document Available (#1029318296)
05-18-2015 IJ
PLAINTIFF'S SUPPLEMENTAL NO 1.
Document Available (#1029318445)
05-18-2015 OAT
OATH OF BAILIFF
Document Available (#1029318461)
05-18-2015 IJ
COMBINED PROPOSED JURY INSTRUCTIONS AND VERDICT FORMS
Document Available (#1029318457)
05-18-2015 VERD
BLUE VERDICT FORM SIGNED BY 9 JURORS
Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
05-18-2015 VERDU
PINK VERDICT FORM - UNSIGNED
Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
05-18-2015 VERD
PINK VERDICT FORM - SECOND STAGE - AS TO DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS INC - SIGNED BY JURY FOREPERSON
Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
05-18-2015 VERDU
BLUE VERDICT FORM - SECOND STAGE - AS TO DEFENDANT MURCO WALL PRODUCTS INC.
Document Available at Court Clerk's Office
05-18-2015 CTFREE
JUDGE DIXON - DAY 11 - JURY TRIAL (SECOND STAGE) CONTINUES AFTER WEEKEND RECESS. DEFENDANT'S MOVE FOR MISTRIAL, ORAL MOTION OVERRULED. DEFENDANT'S RENEW MOTION FOR DIRECTED VERDICT, OVERRULED. PLAINTIFF AND DEFENDANT WAIVE OPENING STATEMENTS. PLAINTIFF PRESENTS EVIDENCE AND REST. DEFENDANTS REST. INSTRUCTIONS SETTLED. COURTS INSTRUCTIONS TO JURY. CLOSING ARGUMENTS BY PLAINTIFF AND DEFENDANT. JURY RETIRES TO DELIBERATE AND RETURNS WITH VERDICT OF $0 IN PUNITIVE DAMAGES. JURY DISCHARGED, CLERK DIRECTED TO FILE AND RECORD VERDICT ACCORDINGLY. PAM HARTWICK COURT REPORTER.
05-18-2015 DISPJP
JUDGE DIXON - JUDGEMENT FOR PLAINTIFF
1 Murco Wall Products, Inc.
05-18-2015 DISPJP
JUDGE DIXON - JUDGMENT FOR PLAINTIFF
1 Welco Manufacturing Co.
05-18-2015 IJ
defendant's supplemental requested jury instruction stage two
Document Available (#1029478737)
05-28-2015 MOSJE
PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO SETTLE JOURNAL ENTRY
Document Available (#1029490210)
Outcome: Plaintiff's verdict for $6 million.
JURY RETIRES TO DELIBERATE AND RETURNS WITH VERDICT AND FINDS: JUDGMENT FOR THE PLAINTIFF AGAINST DEFENDANTS MURCO WALL PRODUCTS INC., AND WELCO MANUFACTURING COMPANY, INC. IN THE AMOUNT OF $6 MILLION COMPRISED OF ECONOMIC DAMAGES IN THE AMOUNT OF $1.5 MILLION AND NON-ECONOMIC DAMAGES IN THE AMOUNT OF $4.5 MILLION WITH 40% LIABILITY TO MURCO WALL PRODUCTS, INC., AND 60% LIABILITY TO WELCO MANUFACTURING COMPANY, INC. JUDGMENT FOR THE DEFENDANT, RED DEVIL CORPORATION.
A second phrase addressing Plaintiff's claim for punitive or exemplary damages resulted in a verdict in favor of the defendants.
Plaintiff's Experts:
Defendant's Experts:
Comments: