Please E-mail suggested additions, comments and/or corrections to Kent@MoreLaw.Com.
Help support the publication of case reports on MoreLaw
Date: 11-19-2016
Case Style:
State of Ohio v. Douglas Shine, Jr.
Case Number: CR-16-606156-A
Judge: Joan Synenberg
Court: Court of Common Pleas, Cuyahoga County, Ohio
Plaintiff's Attorney: Timothy McGinty
Defendant's Attorney: Bob Dixon, Tom Shaughnessy, Russell Tye and David Brown
Description: Cleveland, OH - Jury Recommends Defendant Be Executed
The State of Ohio charged Douglas Shine, Jr., age 21, with aggravated murder and many other charges relating to the killing of three men and wounding of three others in a gang relating shooting at the Chalk Linez barbership on February 5, 2015 with the specific intent of killing Walter Lee Barfield, age 23.
The charges against Shine included:
INDICT 2903.01.A AGGRAVATED MURDER
INDICT 2903.01.B AGGRAVATED MURDER
INDICT 2903.01.A AGGRAVATED MURDER
INDICT 2903.01.B AGGRAVATED MURDER
INDICT 2903.01.A AGGRAVATED MURDER
INDICT 2903.01.B AGGRAVATED MURDER
INDICT 2911.11.A(1) AGGRAVATED BURGLARY
INDICT 2903.02.B MURDER
INDICT 2903.02.B MURDER
INDICT 2903.02.B MURDER
INDICT 2903.11.A(1) FELONIOUS ASSAULT
INDICT 2903.11.A(1) FELONIOUS ASSAULT
INDICT 2903.11.A(1) FELONIOUS ASSAULT
INDICT 2903.01.A ATTEMPTED, AGGRAVATED MURDER
INDICT 2903.01.A ATTEMPTED, AGGRAVATED MURDER
INDICT 2903.01.A ATTEMPTED, AGGRAVATED MURDER
INDICT 2903.11.A(1) FELONIOUS ASSAULT
INDICT 2903.11.A(1) FELONIOUS ASSAULT
INDICT 2903.11.A(1) FELONIOUS ASSAULT
INDICT 2903.11.A(2) FELONIOUS ASSAULT
INDICT 2903.11.A(2) FELONIOUS ASSAULT
INDICT 2903.11.A(2) FELONIOUS ASSAULT
INDICT 2903.11.A(2) FELONIOUS ASSAULT
INDICT 2903.11.A(2) FELONIOUS ASSAULT
INDICT 2903.11.A(2) FELONIOUS ASSAULT
INDICT 2903.11.A(2) FELONIOUS ASSAULT
INDICT 2903.11.A(2) FELONIOUS ASSAULT
INDICT 2903.11.A(2) FELONIOUS ASSAULT
INDICT 2903.11.A(2) FELONIOUS ASSAULT
INDICT 2903.11.A(2) FELONIOUS ASSAULT
INDICT 2903.11.A(2) FELONIOUS ASSAULT
INDICT 2903.11.A(2) FELONIOUS ASSAULT
INDICT 2903.11.A(2) FELONIOUS ASSAULT
INDICT 2903.01.A AGGRAVATED MURDER
INDICT 2923.01.A(2) CONSPIRACY
INDICT 2903.11.A(1) FELONIOUS ASSAULT
INDICT 2903.11.A(2) FELONIOUS ASSAULT
INDICT 2903.02.A ATTEMPTED, MURDER
INDICT 2903.11.A(1) FELONIOUS ASSAULT
INDICT 2903.11.A(2) FELONIOUS ASSAULT
INDICT 2923.161.A(1) IMPROPER DISCHARGING FIREARM AT OR INTO HABITATION OR SCHOOL
INDICT 2903.02.A ATTEMPTED, MURDER
INDICT 2903.11.A(2) FELONIOUS ASSAULT
INDICT 2923.161.A(2) IMPROPER DISCHARGING FIREARM AT OR INTO HABITATION OR SCHOOL
INDICT 2903.11.A(2) FELONIOUS ASSAULT
INDICT 2903.11.A(2) FELONIOUS ASSAULT
INDICT 2903.11.A(2) FELONIOUS ASSAULT
INDICT 2903.11.A(2) FELONIOUS ASSAULT
INDICT 2923.162.A(3) DISCHARGE OF FIREARM ON OR NEAR PROHIBITED PREMISES
INDICT 2923.13.A(2) HAVING WEAPONS WHILE UNDER DISABILITY
INDICT 2923.13.A(2) HAVING WEAPONS WHILE UNDER DISABILITY
INDICT 2923.13.A(2) HAVING WEAPONS WHILE UNDER DISABILITY
INDICT 2923.13.A(2) HAVING WEAPONS WHILE UNDER DISABILITY
Outcome: Defendant was found guilty with a recommendation that he be sentenced to death.
Plaintiff's Experts:
Defendant's Experts: Robert Kaplan, psychologist
Comments: