M ORE L AW
LEXAPEDIA
Salus Populi Suprema Lex Esto

Information
About MoreLaw
Contact MoreLaw

Please E-mail suggested additions, comments and/or corrections to Kent@MoreLaw.Com.

Help support the publication of case reports on MoreLaw

Date: 01-22-2018

Case Style:

Florence Taulbert v. Megan Harju

MoreLaw Suites

406 South Boulder and 624 South Denver

918-582-3993 or Info@morelaw.com

Case Number: CJ-2016-3192

Judge: Linda G. Morrissey

Court: District Court, Tulsa County, Oklahoma

Plaintiff's Attorney: Tom Ganem

Defendant's Attorney: Mark Smiling

Description: Tulsa, OK - Florence Taulbert sued Megan Harju

Issue # 1. Issue: NEGLIGENCE (GENERAL) (NEGL)
Filed By: TAULBERT, FLORENCE
Filed Date: 09/02/2016
Party Name Disposition Information
Defendant: HARJU, MEGAN Disposed: JUDGEMENT FOR DEFENDANT, 01/22/2018. Jury Trial
Issue # 2. Issue: DAMAGE (DAMAGE)
Filed By: TAULBERT, FLORENCE
Filed Date: 09/02/2016
Party Name Disposition Information
Defendant: HARJU, MEGAN Disposed: DISMISSED WITHOUT PREJUDICE, 03/07/2017. Other
Issue # 3. Issue: PERSONAL INJURY (OTHER)
Filed By: TAULBERT, FLORENCE
Filed Date: 09/02/2016
Party Name Disposition Information
Defendant: HARJU, MEGAN Disposed: JUDGEMENT FOR DEFENDANT, 01/22/2018. Jury Trial
Issue # 4. Issue: TORT- PERSONAL (TORTP)
Filed By: TAULBERT, FLORENCE
Filed Date: 09/02/2016
Party Name Disposition Information
Defendant: HARJU, MEGAN Disposed: JUDGEMENT FOR DEFENDANT, 01/22/2018. Jury Trial
Docket
Date Code Description Count Party Amount
09-02-2016 TEXT

CIVIL RELIEF MORE THAN $10,000 INITIAL FILING.
1
09-02-2016 NEGL

NEGLIGENCE (GENERAL)

09-02-2016 DMFE

DISPUTE MEDIATION FEE
$ 7.00
09-02-2016 PFE1

PETITION

Document Available (#1034266355) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
$ 163.00
09-02-2016 PFE7

LAW LIBRARY FEE
$ 6.00
09-02-2016 OCISR

OKLAHOMA COURT INFORMATION SYSTEM REVOLVING FUND
$ 25.00
09-02-2016 OCJC

OKLAHOMA COUNCIL ON JUDICIAL COMPLAINTS REVOLVING FUND
$ 1.55
09-02-2016 OCASA

OKLAHOMA COURT APPOINTED SPECIAL ADVOCATES
$ 5.00
09-02-2016 SSFCHSCPC

SHERIFF'S SERVICE FEE FOR COURTHOUSE SECURITY PER BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONER
$ 10.00
09-02-2016 CCADMINCSF

COURT CLERK ADMINISTRATIVE FEE ON COURTHOUSE SECURITY PER BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONER
$ 1.00
09-02-2016 CCADMIN0155

COURT CLERK ADMINISTRATIVE FEE ON $1.55 COLLECTION
$ 0.16
09-02-2016 SJFIS

STATE JUDICIAL REVOLVING FUND - INTERPRETER AND TRANSLATOR SERVICES
$ 0.45
09-02-2016 DCADMIN155

DISTRICT COURT ADMINISTRATIVE FEE ON $1.55 COLLECTIONS
$ 0.23
09-02-2016 DCADMIN05

DISTRICT COURT ADMINISTRATIVE FEE ON $5 COLLECTIONS
$ 0.75
09-02-2016 DCADMINCSF

DISTRICT COURT ADMINISTRATIVE FEE ON COURTHOUSE SECURITY PER BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONER
$ 1.50
09-02-2016 CCADMIN04

COURT CLERK ADMINISTRATIVE FEE ON COLLECTIONS
$ 0.50
09-02-2016 LTF

LENGTHY TRIAL FUND
$ 10.00
09-02-2016 SMF

SUMMONS FEE (CLERKS FEE)
$ 10.00
09-02-2016 SMIMA

SUMMONS ISSUED - MAILED BY ATTORNEY

09-02-2016 TEXT

OCIS HAS AUTOMATICALLY ASSIGNED JUDGE MORRISSEY, LINDA G. TO THIS CASE.

09-02-2016 ACCOUNT

RECEIPT # 2016-3406237 ON 09/02/2016.
PAYOR: THEGANEM LAW FIRM TOTAL AMOUNT PAID: $ 242.14.
LINE ITEMS:
CJ-2016-3192: $173.00 ON AC01 CLERK FEES.
CJ-2016-3192: $6.00 ON AC23 LAW LIBRARY FEE.
CJ-2016-3192: $1.66 ON AC31 COURT CLERK REVOLVING FUND.
CJ-2016-3192: $5.00 ON AC58 OKLAHOMA COURT APPOINTED SPECIAL ADVOCATES.
CJ-2016-3192: $1.55 ON AC59 COUNCIL ON JUDICIAL COMPLAINTS REVOLVING FUND.
CJ-2016-3192: $7.00 ON AC64 DISPUTE MEDIATION FEES.
CJ-2016-3192: $0.45 ON AC65 STATE JUDICIAL REVOLVING FUND, INTERPRETER SVCS.
CJ-2016-3192: $2.48 ON AC67 DISTRICT COURT REVOLVING FUND.
CJ-2016-3192: $25.00 ON AC79 OCIS REVOLVING FUND.
CJ-2016-3192: $10.00 ON AC81 LENGTHY TRIAL FUND.
CJ-2016-3192: $10.00 ON AC88 SHERIFF’S SERVICE FEE FOR COURT HOUSE SECURITY.

09-09-2016 EAA

SPECIAL APPEARANCE RESERVONG ADDITIONAL TIME TO FURTHER PLEAD OR ANSWER / A MARK SMILING ENTERING AS COUNSEL/ W-CS / CERTIFICATE OF MAILING

Document Available (#1034550899) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
HARJU, MEGAN
09-12-2016 A

ANSWER / TO THE PETITION OF THE PLAINTIFF / A MARK SMILING ENTERING AS COUNSEL / CERTIFICATE OF MAILING

Document Available (#1034263111) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
HARJU, MEGAN
09-22-2016 CTFREE

MORRISSEY, LINDA G; THE CASE IS SET FOR A SCHEDULING CONFERENCE ON 10-25-2016 AT 1:30 PM IN COURT ROOM 513; COUNSEL OR PARTIES WITHOUT COUNSEL MUST ATTEND THE SCHEDULING CONFERENCE OR DISPOSITION MAY BE MADE IN THEIR ABSENCE; NOTICE OF SCHEDULING CONFERENCE ENTERED; COPIES OF THE NOTICE WERE MAILED TO THOMAS GANEM AND A MARK SMILING;

09-23-2016 NO

NOTICE OF SCHEDULING CONFERENCE / SET ON 10-25-16 @ 1:30 PM IN COURT ROOM 513 / AFFIDAVIT OF MAILING

Document Available (#1034603254) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

10-20-2016 CTFREE

MORRISSEY, LINDA G; AGREED SCHEDULING ORDER ENTERED; PRETRIAL CONFERENCE SET FOR 5-15-2017 AT 10:00 AM IN COURT ROOM 513; COUNSEL OR PARTIES WITHOUT COUNSEL MUST ATTEND THE PRETRIAL CONFERENCE OR DISPOSITION MAY BE MADE IN THEIR ABSENCE; AS PER ENTRY OF THIS AGREED SCHEUDLING ORDER, THE SCHEDULING CONFERENCE ORIGINALLY SET FOR 10-25-2016 AT 1:30 PM IS NOW STRICKEN; THE PARTIES AGREE TO ATTEND PRIVATE MEDIATION PRIOR TO THE DATE OF THE PRETRIAL CONFERENCE; (((((AGREED SCHEUDLING ORDER PLACED IN THE JUDGE'S OUTBOX TO BE PICKED UP FOR FILING)))))

10-21-2016 CTFREE

MORRISSEY, LINDA G; NOTICE OF PRETRIAL CONFERENCE ENTERED; 5-15-2017 AT 10:00 AM; CLERK FILED THE ORIGINAL NOTICE AND MAILED COPIES TO THOMAS FERRIS GANEM, MARK SMILING, AND GENTRY SMILING;

10-21-2016 SCHO

AGREED SCHEDULING ORDER / 10-20-16

Document Available (#1034951797) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

11-29-2016 WL

DEFENDANT MEGAN HARJU'S PRELIMINARY WITNESS AND EXHIBIT LIST

Document Available (#1035245021) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
HARJU, MEGAN
11-30-2016 WL

PLAINTIFF'S PRELIMINARY WITNESS AND EXHIBIT LIST

Document Available (#1035245232) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
TAULBERT, FLORENCE
02-07-2017 WL

DEFENDANT MEGAN HARJU'S FINAL WITNESS AND EXHIBIT LIST

Document Available (#1036085497) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
HARJU, MEGAN
02-27-2017 MOSJ

DEFENDANT MEGAN HARJUS MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY ADJUDICAITON AND BRIEF IN SUPPORT AS TO PLAINTIFFS CLAIM FOR PUNITIVE DAMAGES

Document Available (#1036116640) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
$ 50.00
02-27-2017 ACCOUNT

RECEIPT # 2017-3511575 ON 02/27/2017.
PAYOR: A MARK SMILING PLLC TOTAL AMOUNT PAID: $ 50.00.
LINE ITEMS:
CJ-2016-3192: $50.00 ON AC01 CLERK FEES.

03-07-2017 WL

PLAINTIFF'S FINAL WITNESS AND EXHIBIT LIST

Document Available (#1036214970) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
TAULBERT, FLORENCE
03-07-2017 DWOP

DISMISSAL WITHOUT PREJUDICE OF CLAIM FOR PUNITIVE DAMAGES ONLY

Document Available (#1036084171) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
HARJU, MEGAN
03-07-2017 DISPDWOP

DISMISSAL WITHOUT PREJUDICE
2 HARJU, MEGAN
05-15-2017 CTFREE

MORRISSEY, LINDA G; THE CASE COMES ON FOR PRETRIAL CONFERENCE; TOM GANEM PRESENT FOR THE PLAINTIFF; GENTRY SMILING PRESENT FOR THE DEFENDANT; MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT RENDERED MOOT; PRETRIAL CONFERENCE ORDER ENTERED; JURY TRIAL (1ST UP, 3 DAYS) SET FOR 1-22-2018 AT 10:00 AM IN COURT ROOM 513; TRIAL STATUS CONFERENCE SET FOR 1-8-2018 AT 9:30 AM IN COURT ROOM 513; COUNSEL OR PARTIES WITHOUT COUNSEL MUST ATTEND THE JURY TRIAL AND THE TRIAL STATUS CONFERENCE OR DISPOSITION MAY BE MADE IN THEIR ABSENCE; ORDER AND NOTICE OF TRIAL STATUS CONFERENE AND JURY TRIAL ENTERED; CLERK FILED THE ORIGINAL ORDER AND NOTICE AND MAILED COPIES TO THOMAS GANEM, A MARK SMILING, AND GENTRY SMILING;

05-15-2017 O

ORDER AND NOTICE OF TRIAL STATUS CONFERENCE AND JURY TRIAL / AFD OF MAILING

Document Available (#1036950453) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

10-09-2017 PTO

PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE ORDER

Document Available (#1038295017) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

10-09-2017 RJT

REQUEST FOR JURY TRIAL
$ 349.00
10-09-2017 CRF

COURT REPORTER FEE-TRIAL ON MERITS
$ 20.00
10-09-2017 ACCOUNT

RECEIPT # 2017-3645260 ON 10/09/2017.
PAYOR: SAFECO INSURANCE TOTAL AMOUNT PAID: $ 369.00.
LINE ITEMS:
CJ-2016-3192: $369.00 ON AC01 CLERK FEES.

12-21-2017 MOLIM

DEFENDANT MEGAN HARJU'S FIRST MOTION IN LIMINE AND BRIEF IN SUPPORT / A TO J / CERTIFICATE OF MAILING

Document Available (#1039090621) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
HARJU, MEGAN
12-27-2017 MO

PLAINTIFF'S MOTION IN LIMINE AND BRIEF IN SUPPORT / A2J

Document Available (#1039085227) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
TAULBERT, FLORENCE
12-29-2017 TEXT

DEFENDANT MEGAN HARJU'S JURY INSTRUCTIONS

Document Available (#1039090776) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
HARJU, MEGAN
01-08-2018 CTFREE

MORRISSEY, LINDA G; THE CASE COMES ON FOR TRIAL STATUS CONFERENCE; TOM GANEM PRESENT FOR PLAINTIFF; MARK SMILING AND GENTRY SMILING PRESENT FOR DEFENDANT; THE PARTIES ARE TO SUBMIT OBJECTIONS TO DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS BY 1-12-2018; THE CASE IS SET FOR A HEARING ON "BILL VS. INCURRED" FOR 1-16-2018 AT 3:30 PM IN COURT ROOM 513;

01-08-2018 OBJ

PLAINTIFF'S OBJECTIONS TO TESTIMONY OF DR SAMI FRAMJEE / CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

Document Available (#1039084387) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
TAULBERT, FLORENCE
01-08-2018 OBJ

PLAINTIFF'S OBJECTIONS TO TESTIMONY OF DR MATTHEW POWERS / CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

Document Available (#1039084383) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
TAULBERT, FLORENCE
01-08-2018 TEXT

PLAINTIFF'S DESIGNATION OF TESTIMONY OF DR STEPHEN WILSON / CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

Document Available (#1039084379) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
TAULBERT, FLORENCE
01-08-2018 RESP

PLAINTIFF'S RESPONSE TO DEFENDANT'S MOTION IN LIMINE / CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

Document Available (#1039084375) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
TAULBERT, FLORENCE
01-08-2018 RESP

DEFENDANT MEGAN HARJU'S RESPONSE AND OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFF'S FIRST MOTION IN LIMINE / CERTIFICATE OF MAILING

Document Available (#1039135371) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
HARJU, MEGAN
01-16-2018 CTFREE

MORRISSEY, LINDA G; THE CASE COMES ON FOR HEARING ON MOTION IN LIMINE BILLVS. INCURRED; MARK SMILING PRESENT FOR THE DEFENDANT; TOM GANEM PRESENT FOR PLAINTIFF; HEARING ON THE RECORD WITH GARY WOODSON, COURT REPORTER;

01-16-2018 CTFREE

MORRISSEY, LINDA G; ORDER ON DEFENDANT'S OBJECTIONS TO THE DEPOSITION OF M. STEPHEN WILSON, M.D. ENTERED; CLERK FILED THE ORIGINAL ORDER AND MAILED/FAXED COPIES TO THOMAS GANEM AND A. MARK SMILING; (((((SEE THE SEPARATELY FILED ORDER FOR THE COMPLETE DECISION OF THE COURT)))))

01-17-2018 CTFREE

MORRISSEY, LINDA G; ORDER ON PLAINTIFF'S MOTION IN LIMINE ENTERED; CLERK FILED THE ORIGINAL ORDER AND MAILED AND FAXED COPIES TO THOMAS GANEM, A. MARK SMILING, AND GENTRY SMILING; (((((SEE THE SEPARATELY FILED ORDER FOR THE COMPLETE DECISION OF THE COURT)))))

01-17-2018 CTFREE

MORRISSEY, LINDA G; ORDER ON DEFENDANT MEGAN HARJU'S FIRST MOTION IN LIMINE ENTERED; CLERK FILED THE ORIGINAL ORDER AND MAILED AND FAXED COPIES TO THOMAS GANEM, A. MARK SMILING, AND GENTRY SMILING; (((((SEE THE SEPARATELY FILED ORDER FOR THE COMPLETE DECISION OF THE COURT))))

01-17-2018 O

ORDER ON DEFENDANT'S OBJECTIONS TO THE DEPOSITION OF M STEPHEN WILSON MD / AFFIDAVIT OF MAILING/FAX

Document Available (#1039129800) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

01-17-2018 O

ORDER ON PLAINTIFF'S MOTION IN LIMINE / AFFIDAVIT OF MAILING

Document Available (#1039131269) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

01-17-2018 O

ORDER ON DEFENDANT MEGAN HARJU'S FIRST MOTION IN LIMINE / CERTIFICATE OF MAILING

Document Available (#1039129796) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

01-22-2018 CRF

COURT REPORTER FEE-TRIAL ON MERITS
$ 20.00
01-22-2018 CTFREE

MORRISSEY, LINDA G; THE CASE COMES ON FOR JURY TRIAL; GARY WOODSON, COURT REPORTER; FLORENE TAULBERT PRESENT AS PLAINTIFF; TOM GANEM PRESENT AS ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF; MEGAN HARJU PRESENT AS DEFENDANT; MARK SMILING AND GENTRY SMILING PRESENT AS ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT; DETAILED MINUTE TO BE ENTERED AT CONCLUSION OF TRIAL;

01-22-2018 CTFREE

MORRISSEY, LINDA G.; JOURNAL ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ENTERED (((ORDER PLACED IN THE JUDGE'S OUTBOX TO BE PICKED UP FOR FILING)))

01-22-2018 DISPJD

JOURNAL ENTRY OF JUDGMENT
1 HARJU, MEGAN
01-22-2018 DISPJD

JOURNAL ENTRY OF JUDGMENT
3 HARJU, MEGAN
01-22-2018 DISPJD

JOURNAL ENTRY OF JUDGMENT
4 HARJU, MEGAN
01-22-2018 ACCOUNT

RECEIPT # 2018-3699650 ON 01/22/2018.
PAYOR: A MARK SMILING PLLC TOTAL AMOUNT PAID: $ 20.00.
LINE ITEMS:
CJ-2016-3192: $20.00 ON AC01 CLERK FEES.

Outcome: 01-24-2018 CTFREE

MORRISSEY, LINDA G; STATEMENT OF THE CASE AND INSTRUCTIONS OF LAW ENTERED;

NOW ON THIS 24 DAY OF JANUARY, 2018, THE DISTRICT COURT OF TULSA COUNTY, OKLAHOMA RECONVENES PURSUANT TO ADJOURNMENT. PRESENT AND PRESIDING: HONORABLE LINDA G. MORRISSEY, DISTRICT JUDGE; GARY WOODSON, COURT REPORTER, COURT REPORTER; CALEB MCKEE, BAILIFF; DARCY ASBILL, MINUTE CLERK. PUBLIC PROCEEDINGS WERE HAD TO WIT:

CASE CALLED FOR JURY TRIAL. BOTH SIDES PRESENT IN OPEN COURT AND ANNOUNCE READY FOR TRIAL. PLAINTIFF, FLORENE TAULBERT, IS PRESENT IN PERSON AND WITH COUNSEL, THOMAS GANEM. DEFENDANT, MEGAN HARJU, IS PRESENT IN PERSON AND WITH COUNSEL, A. MARK SMILING AND GENTRY SMILING.

ONE JUROR IS EXCUSED PRIOR TO THE BEGINNING OF THE TRIAL. THE REMAINING JURORS ARE CALLED AND SWORN AS TO QUALIFICATIONS. THE JURY IS IMPANELED AND EXAMINED FOR CAUSE. ONE (1) JUROR IS EXCUSED FOR CAUSE. THE JURORS ARE ACCEPTED FOR CAUSE. THREE (3) PEREMPTORY CHALLENGES ARE MADE BY THE PLAINTIFF. THREE (3) PEREMPTORY CHALLENGES ARE MADE BY THE DEFENDANT. TWELVE (12) JURORS AND ONE (1) ALTERNATE ARE ACCEPTED AND SWORN TO TRY THE CAUSE.

OPENING STATEMENT IS MADE BY THE PLAINTIFF. OPENING STATEMENT MADE BY DEFENDANT. SIX (6) WITNESSES ARE SWORN. GARY WOODSON, COURT REPORTER. PLAINTIFF PRESENTS EVIDENCE AND RESTS. DEFENDANT PRESENTS EVIDENCE AND RESTS. BOTH SIDES REST.

THE JURY IS INSTRUCTED AS TO THE LAW. CLOSING ARGUMENTS ARE MADE. THE ALTERNATE JUROR(S) ARE EXCUSED. THE SWEARING OF THE BAILIFF IS WAIVED AND AT 11:12 AM ON JANUARY 24, 2018, THE JURY RETIRES FOR DELIBERATION IN CUSTODY OF THE BAILIFF. AT 12:00 PM ON JANUARY 24, 2018, THE JURY RETURNS INTO OPEN COURT WITH THEIR VERDICT, WHICH IS READ IN OPEN COURT, ORDERED RECORDED AND FILED, AND IS, TO WIT:

VERDICT FORM FOR DEFENDANT MEGAN HARJU
WE, THE JURY, EMPANELED AND SWORN IN THE ABOVE ENTITLED CAUSE, DO, UPON OUR OATHS, FIND THE ISSUES IN FAVOR OF THE DEFENDANT, MEGAN HARJU.
VERDICT FORM SIGNED BY FOREPERSON, ONLY.

JURY POLLED. TWELVE JURORS CONCURRING. JURY RELEASED.

01-24-2018 O

JURY TRIAL MINUTE

Document Available at Court Clerk's Office

01-24-2018 V

VERDICT FORM FOR DEFENDANT MEGAN HARJU ( SIGNED BY FOREPERSON )

Document Available at Court Clerk's Office

01-24-2018 TEXT

STATEMENT OF THE CASE AND INSTRUCTIONS OF LAW

Document Available (#1039128793) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

02-05-2018 JEJ

JOURNAL ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ( IN FAVOR OF THE DEFENDANT)

Document Unavailable (#1039129015)

Plaintiff's Experts: M. Stephen Wilson, M.D.

Defendant's Experts: Sami F. Framjee, M.D.

Comments:



 
 
Home | Add Attorney | Add Expert | Add Court Reporter | Sign In
Find-A-Lawyer By City | Find-A-Lawyer By State and City | Articles | Recent Lawyer Listings
Verdict Corrections | Link Errors | Advertising | Editor | Privacy Statement
© 1996-2018 MoreLaw, Inc. - All rights reserved.