Date: 12-07-2017

Case Style:

Case Number: CJ-2016-2033

Judge: Daman H. Cantrell

Court: District Court, Tulsa County, Oklahoma

Plaintiff's Attorney: Clark Phipps and Kris McVay

Defendant's Attorney: Ron Brown

Description: Tulsa, OK - Courtney Grogan and Joe C. Cole Revocable Living Trust sued Miranda K. Renfrow, D.O. and Envision Medical Surgical Eye Care, P.C. on breach of contracts theories.

Issue # 1. Issue: BREACH OF AGREEMENT - CONTRACT (CONTRACT)
Filed By: GROGAN, COURTNEY
Filed Date: 05/31/2016
Party Name Disposition Information
Defendant: ENVISION MEDICAL & SURGICAL EYE CARE PC Disposed: STAYED PENDING ACTION OTHER JURISDICTION, 03/13/2017. Other
Defendant: ENVISION MEDICAL & SURGICAL EYE CARE PC Disposed: JUDGEMENT FOR PLAINTIFF, 12/07/2017. Jury Trial
Defendant: RENFROW, MIRANDA K DO Disposed: JUDGEMENT FOR PLAINTIFF, 12/07/2017. Jury Trial
Docket
Date Code Description Count Party Amount
05-31-2016 TEXT

CIVIL RELIEF MORE THAN $10,000 INITIAL FILING.
1
05-31-2016 CONTRACT

BREACH OF AGREEMENT - CONTRACT

05-31-2016 DMFE

DISPUTE MEDIATION FEE
$ 2.00
05-31-2016 PFE1

PETITION

Document Available (#1032748954) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
$ 163.00
05-31-2016 PFE7

LAW LIBRARY FEE
$ 6.00
05-31-2016 OCISR

OKLAHOMA COURT INFORMATION SYSTEM REVOLVING FUND
$ 25.00
05-31-2016 OCJC

OKLAHOMA COUNCIL ON JUDICIAL COMPLAINTS REVOLVING FUND
$ 1.55
05-31-2016 OCASA

OKLAHOMA COURT APPOINTED SPECIAL ADVOCATES
$ 5.00
05-31-2016 SSFCHSCPC

SHERIFF'S SERVICE FEE FOR COURTHOUSE SECURITY PER BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONER

05-31-2016 CCADMINCSF

COURT CLERK ADMINISTRATIVE FEE ON COURTHOUSE SECURITY PER BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONER

05-31-2016 CCADMIN0155

COURT CLERK ADMINISTRATIVE FEE ON $1.55 COLLECTION
$ 0.16
05-31-2016 SJFIS

STATE JUDICIAL REVOLVING FUND - INTERPRETER AND TRANSLATOR SERVICES
$ 0.45
05-31-2016 CCADMIN04

COURT CLERK ADMINISTRATIVE FEE ON COLLECTIONS
$ 0.50
05-31-2016 LTF

LENGTHY TRIAL FUND
$ 10.00
05-31-2016 SMF

SUMMONS FEE (CLERKS FEE) - (2)
$ 10.00
05-31-2016 SMIP

SUMMONS ISSUED - PRIVATE PROCESS SERVER - (2)

05-31-2016 TEXT

OCIS HAS AUTOMATICALLY ASSIGNED JUDGE CANTRELL, DAMAN H. TO THIS CASE.

05-31-2016 ACCOUNT

RECEIPT # 2016-3346186 ON 05/31/2016.
PAYOR:ATKINSON HASKINS NELLIS BRITTINGHAM GLADD & FIASCO PC TOTAL AMOUNT PAID: $223.66.
LINE ITEMS:
CJ-2016-2033: $173.00 ON AC01 CLERK FEES.
CJ-2016-2033: $6.00 ON AC23 LAW LIBRARY FEE.
CJ-2016-2033: $0.66 ON AC31 COURT CLERK REVOLVING FUND.
CJ-2016-2033: $5.00 ON AC58 OKLAHOMA COURT APPOINTED SPECIAL ADVOCATES.
CJ-2016-2033: $1.55 ON AC59 COUNCIL ON JUDICIAL COMPLAINTS REVOLVING FUND.
CJ-2016-2033: $2.00 ON AC64 DISPUTE MEDIATION FEES.
CJ-2016-2033: $0.45 ON AC65 STATE JUDICIAL REVOLVING FUND, INTERPRETER SVCS.
CJ-2016-2033: $25.00 ON AC79 OCIS REVOLVING FUND.
CJ-2016-2033: $10.00 ON AC81 LENGTHY TRIAL FUND.

06-15-2016 S

PARTY HAS BEEN SUCCESSFULLY SERVED/ SUMMONS PER SERVE TO MIRANDA K RENFROW D.O / BY PS / ON 6-2-16

Document Available (#1033582264) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
RENFROW, MIRANDA K DO
06-15-2016 S

PARTY HAS BEEN SUCCESSFULLY SERVED/SUMMONS CORP SERVE TO ENVISION MEDICAL & SURICAL EYE CARE, P.C. / BY SERVING MIRANDA K RENFROW / ON 6-2-16 / BY PS

Document Available (#1033582260) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
ENVISION MEDICAL & SURGICAL EYE CARE PC
06-20-2016 EAA

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE / CERT OF MAILING / COVER SHEET

Document Available (#1033586519) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
RENFROW, MIRANDA K DO
07-08-2016 A

ANSWER TO PETITION / CERTIFICATE OF MAILING

Document Available (#1033901514) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
RENFROW, MIRANDA K DO
08-15-2016 MO

PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO COMPEL ANSWERS TO DISCOVERY AND TO DEEM REQUESTS FOR ADMISSION ADMITTED / A2J

Document Available (#1034265577) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
GROGAN, COURTNEY
08-18-2016 REQ

REQUEST TO SET CASE FOR SCHEDULING CONFERENCE / A2J

Document Available (#1034261314) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
GROGAN, COURTNEY
08-22-2016 CTFREE

MINUTE ORDER: ORDER ENTERED SETTING PL'S MOTION TO COMPEL ON 9-28-16 AT 3:30 PM. MAILED NOTICE TO CLARK PHIPPS AND BREEANN RICE.

08-22-2016 CTFREE

MINUTE ORDER: ORDER ENTERED SETTING CASE FOR SCHEDULING CONFERENCE ON 9-12-16 AT 10:00 AM.

08-22-2016 NOH

NOTICE OF HEARING / AFD OF MAILING

Document Available (#1034262066) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

08-30-2016 EAA

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE / CERT OF MAILING / COVER SHEET

Document Available (#1034377395) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
RENFROW, MIRANDA K DO
08-31-2016 MO

DEFENDANTS' MOTION FOR AN ENLARGEMENT OF TIME

Document Available (#1034380121) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
RENFROW, MIRANDA K DO
09-01-2016 MO

DEFENDANTS' MOTION FOR AN ENLARGEMENT OF TIME AMENDED TO INCLUDE AFFIDAVIT OF VERIFICATION

Document Available (#1034378276) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
RENFROW, MIRANDA K DO
09-02-2016 CTFREE

MINUTE ORDER: ORDER GRANTING ENLARGEMENT OF TIME TO RESPOND TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO COMPEL; DEFENDANTS HAVE 10 DAYS WITH WHICH TO RESPOND TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO COMPEL; ORDER ENTERED.

09-12-2016 SCHO

SCHEDULING ORDER / 9-12-16

Document Available (#1034551012) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

09-12-2016 CTFREE

MINUTE ORDER: CASE COMES ON FOR SCHEDULING CONFERENCE; CLARK PHIPPS APPEARS FOR PL, HOWARD BERKSON APPEARS FOR DF. HEARING HELD. SCHEDULING ORDER ENTERED; PRETRIAL CONFERENCE SET FOR 9-11-17 AT 10:30 AM.

09-15-2016 RESP

PLAINTIFF'S RESPONSE TO DEFENDANTS' MOITON FOR AN ENLARGEMENT OF TIME / CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

Document Available (#1034606645) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
GROGAN, COURTNEY
09-19-2016 CNOTE

CLERK'S NOTE: DEFENDANT DID NOT PICK UP MOTION FILED ON 9-2-16 AND GRANTED BY THE JUDGE. THE DEFENDANT SHALL HAVE 10 DAYS FROM 9-19-16 TO FILE A RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO COMPEL.

09-19-2016 O

ORDER GRANTING ENLARGEMENT OF TIME TO RESPOND TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO COMPEL

Document Available (#1034607165) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

09-21-2016 RESP

DEFENDANTS' RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO COMPEL ANSWER AND TO DEEM REQUESTS FOR ADMISION ADMITTED / CERTIFICATE OF MAILING

Document Available (#1034606234) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
RENFROW, MIRANDA K DO
09-28-2016 CTFREE

MINUTE ORDER: HEARING ON PL'S MOTION TO COMPEL SET FOR 9-28-16 HAS BEEN STRICKEN BY THE PLAINTIFF AS DEFENDANT'S HAVE COMPLIED.

10-12-2016 CNOTE

CLERK'S NOTE: ORDER SETTING SCHEDULING CONFERENCE FOR 9-12-16 WAS NOT PICKED; FILED BY COURT CLERK.

10-12-2016 O

ORDER SETTING SCHEDULING CONFERENCE

Document Available (#1034767847) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

11-04-2016 APLI

PLAINTIFF'S APPLICATION FOR LEAVE OF COURT TO FILE AMENDED PETITION / A2J

Document Available (#1035191602) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

12-05-2016 CTFREE

MINUTE ORDER: ORDER GRANTING LEAVE TO FILE AMENDED PETITION; ORDER ENTERED.

12-07-2016 AMP

AMENDED PETITION

Document Available (#1035242658) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
GROGAN, COURTNEY
01-03-2017 MO

MOTION TO WITHDRAW AS ATTORNEY OF RECORD FOR MIRANDA RENDROW AND FOR ENVISION MEDICAL & SURGICAL EYE CARE / A TO J / CERTIFICATE OF MAILING

Document Available (#1035216169) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
ENVISION MEDICAL & SURGICAL EYE CARE PC
01-09-2017 APLI

APPLICATION FOR HEARING REQUIRING DEFENDANT RENFROW ATTEND AND PRODUCE OR IN THE ALTERNATIVE SHOW CAUSE / A TO J / CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

Document Available (#1035213638) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
GROGAN, COURTNEY
01-10-2017 CTFREE

MINUTE ORDER; GRANTED - ORDER ALLOWING WITHDRAWAL OF HOWARD BERKSON AND CLIFF STARK AS COUNSELORS OF RECORD DEFENDANTS.

01-10-2017 O

ORDER ALLOWING WITHDRAWAL OF HOWARD BERKSON AND CLIFF STARK AS COUNSELORS OF RECORD

Document Available (#1035214238) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

01-11-2017 CTFREE

MINUTE ORDER: ORDER ENTERED SETTING HEARING ON PL'S MOTION FOR DEFENDANT REFROW TO ATTEND AND PRODUCE IS SET FOR 1-31-17 AT 2:30 PM.

01-11-2017 CTFREE

NIGHTINGALE, REBECCA BRETT: ORDER OF CONSOLIDATION ENTERED. CASE CJ-15-4642 AND CJ-16-2033 ARE HEREBY CONSOLIDATED FOR THE PUROPOSES OF DISCOVERY ONLY.

01-12-2017 O

ORDER GRANTING LEAVE TO FILE AMENDED PETITION

Document Available (#1035214363) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

01-23-2017 RESP

RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFF'S APPLICATION FOR HEARING TO PRODUCE OR SHOW CAUSE

Document Available (#1035796828) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
RENFROW, MIRANDA K DO
01-31-2017 CNOTE

CLERK'S NOTE: ORDER SETTING HEARING ON DF REFROW TO ATTEND AND PRODUCE SIGNED AND ENTERED ON 1-11-17 WAS NOT PICKED UP BY ATTORNEY; FILED BY COURT CLERK.

01-31-2017 CTFREE

MINUTE ORDER: CASE COMES ON FOR HEARING ON MOTION TO COMPEL EARLY; CLARK PHIPPS APPEARS FOR PL, BREEANN RICE APPEARS FOR DF. HEARING HELD. PL'S MOTION TO COMPEL IS GRANTED. DEFENDANT RENFROW IS ORDER TO NOT TALK TO OR CONTRACT THE OPPOSING PARTY. ORDER TO BE SUBMITTED.

03-13-2017 CTFREE

MINUTE ORDER: JOURNAL ENTRY GRANTED ON MOTION TO COMPEL; DOCUMENTS SHALL BE PRODUCED WITHIN 10 DAYS FROM THE DATE OF T HIS ORDER; ORDER ENTERED.

03-13-2017 TEXT

SUGGESTION OF BANKRUPTCY - US BANKRUPTCY COURT, NORTHERN DISTRICT OF OKLAHOMA CASE NO. 17-10385

Document Available (#1035803179) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
RENFROW, MIRANDA K DO
03-13-2017 DISPBRP

BANKRUPTCY
1 RENFROW, MIRANDA K DO
04-13-2017 RESP

RESPONSE TO ORDER

Document Available (#1036648314) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
RENFROW, MIRANDA K DO
07-21-2017 APLI

PLAINTIFF'S APPLICATION FOR LEAVE OF COURT TO FILE A SECOND AMENDED PETITION / CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

Document Available (#1037672737) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
GROGAN, COURTNEY
07-27-2017 CTFREE

MINUTE ORDER: ORDER GRANTING LEAVE TO FILE SECOND AMENDED PETITION; ORDER ENTERED.

07-27-2017 O

ORDER GRANTING LEAVE TO FILE SECOND AMENDED PETITION

Document Available (#1037671037) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

08-01-2017 AMP

SECOND AMENDED PETITION

Document Available (#1037902740) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
GROGAN, COURTNEY
08-21-2017 A

ANSWER TO PLAINTIFF'S SECOND AMENDED PETITION

Document Available (#1037900190) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
RENFROW, MIRANDA K DO
08-21-2017 EAA

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE / BY ATTY RON D BROWN

Document Available (#1037900223) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
ENVISION MEDICAL & SURGICAL EYE CARE PC
09-01-2017 DWP

PARTIAL DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE (BY PLF COURTNEY GROGAN AS TO DEF MIRANDA K RENFROW)

Document Available (#1037773170) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
RENFROW, MIRANDA K DO
09-11-2017 CTFREE

MINUTE ORDER: CASE COMES ON FOR PRETRIAL CONFERENCE; CLARK PHIPPS APPEARS FOR PL, RON BROWN APPEARS FOR DF. HEARING HELD. JURY TRIAL SET FOR 12-5-17 9:30 AM. 1ST UP. 2 DAY TRIAL. PRETRIAL CONFERENCE ORDER TO BE SUBMITTED BY 11-1-11 AND DISCOVERY CUTOFF IS 11-1-11. JURY INSTRUCTIONS TO BE SUBMITTED 7 DAYS BEFORE TRIAL.

09-12-2017 NOH

NOTICE OF HEARING / AFD OF MAILING

Document Available (#1038230854) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

10-03-2017 APLI

APPLICATION TO WITHDRAW AS ATTORNEY OF RECORD FOR DEFENDANT / CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

Document Available (#1038297150) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
RENFROW, MIRANDA K DO
10-05-2017 CTFREE

MINUTE ORDER: GRANTED - ORDER ALLOWING BREEANN RICE TO WITHDRAW AS ATTORNEY OF RECORD FOR DEFENDANT.

11-03-2017 CTFREE

MINUTE ORDER: PRETRIAL CONFERENCE ORDER ENTERED.

11-08-2017 RJT

REQUEST FOR JURY TRIAL
$ 349.00
11-08-2017 CRF

COURT REPORTER FEE-TRIAL ON MERITS
$ 20.00
11-08-2017 ACCOUNT

RECEIPT # 2017-3662744 ON 11/08/2017.
PAYOR: BROWN LAW FIRM TOTAL AMOUNT PAID: $ 369.00.
LINE ITEMS:
CJ-2016-2033: $369.00 ON AC01 CLERK FEES.

11-13-2017 PTO

PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE ORDER

Document Available (#1038416854) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

11-16-2017 O

ORDER GRANTING WITHDRAWAL AS ATTORNEY OF RECORD FOR DEFENDANT

Document Available (#1038774374) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

12-04-2017 TEXT

PLAINTIFF'S PROPOSED JURY INSTRUCTIONS

Document Available (#1038980102) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
GROGAN, COURTNEY
12-05-2017 SS

SUBPOENA SERVED FOR MARK DAVIS / PERS SRV / ON 12-5-17 / BY PS

Document Available (#1038978265) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

12-06-2017 EAA

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE KRISTOPHER K MCVAY AS COUNSEL / CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

Document Available (#1038978365) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
GROGAN, COURTNEY
12-06-2017 MEMO

BENCH MEMORANDUM / A TO J / CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

Document Available (#1038979045) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
GROGAN, COURTNEY
12-06-2017 MEMO

BENCH MENORANDUM / CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

Document Available (#1038978369) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
GROGAN, COURTNEY
12-07-2017 MOLIM

MOTION IN LIMINE / A TO J / CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

Document Available (#1038980381) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
RENFROW, MIRANDA K DO

Outcome: 12-07-2017 DISPJP

CANTRELL, DAMAN: CASE CALLED FOR JURY TRIAL. BOTH SIDES PRESENT IN OPEN COURT AND ANNOUNCE READY FOR TRIAL. PLAINTIFF PRESENT AND REPRESENTED BY CLARK PHIPPS. DEFENDANT PRESENT AND REPRESENTED BY RON BROWN.
THE JURORS ARE CALLED AND SWORN TO THEIR QUALIFICATIONS. THE JURY IS IMPANELED AND EXAMINED FOR CAUSE.

OPENING STATEMENTS ARE MADE. 5 WITNESSES SWORN. RULE WAS INVOKED. REPORTER BRENDA EL HASSAN. PLAINTIFF PRESENTS EVIDENCE AND RESTS. DEFENDANT PRESENTS EVIDENCE AND RESTS. THE JURY IS INSTRUCTED AS TO THE LAW. CLOSING ARGUMENTS ARE MADE. THE SWEARING OF THE BAILIFF IS WAIVED AND AT 4:00 PM THE JURY RETIRES FOR DELIBERATION IN CUSTODY OF THE BAILIFF. AT 5:50 PM THE JURY RETURNS INTO OPEN COURT WITH THEIR VERDICT, WHICH IS READ IN OPEN COURT, "WE, THE JURY, EMPANELED AND SWORN IN THE ABOVE ENTITLED CAUSE, DO, UPON OUR OATHS, FIND AS FOLLOWS:

COUNT 1 - BREACH OF WRITTEN CONTRACT AGAINST DEFENDANT ENVISION - PROMISSORY NOTE 1. BY STIPULATION, THE COURT HAS ALREADY ENTERED A JUDGMENT FOR PLAINTIFF GROGAN AND AGAINST DEFENDANT ENVISION IN THE AMOUNT OF $86,658.29. THIS COUNT IS NOT FOR YOU TO DECIDE.

COUNT - 2 BREACH OF WRITTEN CONTRACT AGAINST DEFENDANT ENVISION - BRIDGE LOAN - $50,000.00 PROMISSORY NOTE.

__X___ FOR PLAINTIFF GROGAN AND AGAINST DEFENDANT ENVISION AND FIX THE AMOUNT
OF DAMAGES IN THE SUM OF $33,933.75.

COUNT 3 - BREACH OF CONTRACT AGAINST DEFENDANT ENVISION - OPERATIONAL LOANS

___X__ FOR PLAINTIFF GROGAN AND AGAINST DEFENDANT ENVISION AND FIX THE AMOUNT
OF DAMAGES IN THE SUM OF $77,300.00.

COUNT 4 - UNJUST ENRICHMENT AGAINST DEFENDANT ENVISION - OPERATIONAL LOANS

___X___ FOR DEFENDANT ENVISION AND AGAINST PLAINTIFF GROGAN.

COUNT 5 - VIOLATION OF OKLAHOMA'S UNIFORM FRAUDULENT TRANSFER ACT AGAINST DEFENDANT
MIRANDA RENFROW.

___X___ FOR PLAINTIFF GROGAN AND AGAINST DEFENDANT RENFROW AND FIX THE AMOUNT OF
DAMAGES IN THE SUM OF $89,500.00, SIGNED THE, FOREPERSON.
1 ENVISION MEDICAL & SURGICAL EYE CARE PC
12-08-2017 TEXT

JURY INSTRUCTIONS

Document Available (#1038976505) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

12-08-2017 TEXT

JURY TRIAL MINUTE

Document Available at Court Clerk's Office

12-08-2017 V

VERDITY FORM (SIGNED)

Document Available at Court Clerk's Office

01-02-2018 CTFREE

MINUTE ORDER: GRANTED - JOURNAL ENTRY OF JUDGMENT.

01-03-2018 T

PARTIAL ORIGINAL TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS ON DECEMBER 6 & 7, 2017 BEFORE JUDGE CANTRELL (NO COPIES)

Document Available (#1038977143) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

01-03-2018 JEJ

JOURNAL ENTRY OF JUDGMENT AGAINST DEFS

Document Available (#1038977146) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
ENVISION MEDICAL & SURGICAL EYE CARE PC

Plaintiff's Experts:

Defendant's Experts:

Comments: