Date: 10-24-2017

Case Style:

Case Number: CJ-2014-1

Judge: Dana Kuehn

Court: District Court, Tulsa County, Oklahoma

Plaintiff's Attorney: Jason Marshall and Jarrett Wilson

Defendant's Attorney: Doug Borochoff for Preferred Total Mechanical and Plumbing

Rodney K. Hunsinger and Jared R. Boyer for Nibco, Inc.

Description: Tulsa, OK - Larry Zayat sued Preferred Total Mechanical and Plumbing, Nibco, Inc. and Sutton Concrete, Inc.

Issue # 1. Issue: BREACH OF AGREEMENT - CONTRACT (CONTRACT)
Filed By: ZAYAT, LARRY
Filed Date: 01/02/2014
Party Name Disposition Information
Defendant: Sutton Construction Inc Disposed: DISMISSED - WITH PREJUDICE, 12/22/2015. Other
Defendant: NIBCO INC Disposed: DISMISSED - SETTLED, 10/24/2017. Dismissed- Settled
Defendant: PREFERRED TOTAL MECHANICAL AND PLUMBING Disposed: DISMISSED - SETTLED, 10/24/2017. Dismissed- Settled
Defendant: Ruhl Construction Llc Disposed: DISMISSED - SETTLED, 10/24/2017. Dismissed- Settled
Issue # 2. Issue: PRODUCT LIABILITY (PROD)
Filed By: ZAYAT, LARRY
Filed Date: 01/02/2014
Party Name Disposition Information
Defendant: NIBCO INC Disposed: DISMISSED - SETTLED, 10/24/2017. Dismissed- Settled
Defendant: PREFERRED TOTAL MECHANICAL AND PLUMBING Disposed: DISMISSED - SETTLED, 10/24/2017. Dismissed- Settled
Issue # 3. Issue: NEGLIGENCE (GENERAL) (NEGL)
Filed By: ZAYAT, LARRY
Filed Date: 01/02/2014
Party Name Disposition Information
Defendant: NIBCO INC Disposed: DISMISSED - SETTLED, 10/24/2017. Dismissed- Settled
Defendant: PREFERRED TOTAL MECHANICAL AND PLUMBING Disposed: DISMISSED - SETTLED, 10/24/2017. Dismissed- Settled
Issue # 4. Issue: CROSSCLAIM AGAINST NIBCO INC (OTHER)
Filed By: PREFERRED TOTAL MECHANICAL AND PLUMBING
Filed Date: 08/13/2014
Party Name Disposition Information
Defendant: NIBCO INC Disposed: DISMISSED - SETTLED, 10/24/2017. Dismissed- Settled


Plaintiff claimed that he home was damaged by numerous water leaks.

Docket
Date Code Description Count Party Amount
01-02-2014 TEXT

CIVIL RELIEF MORE THAN $10,000 INITIAL FILING.
1
01-02-2014 CONTRACT

BREACH OF AGREEMENT - CONTRACT

01-02-2014 DMFE

DISPUTE MEDIATION FEE
$ 2.00
01-02-2014 PFE1

PETITION

Document Available (#1023766374) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
$ 163.00
01-02-2014 PFE7

LAW LIBRARY FEE
$ 6.00
01-02-2014 OCISR

OKLAHOMA COURT INFORMATION SYSTEM REVOLVING FUND
$ 25.00
01-02-2014 CCADMIN02

COURT CLERK ADMINISTRATIVE FEE ON $2 COLLECTIONS
$ 0.20
01-02-2014 OCJC

OKLAHOMA COUNCIL ON JUDICIAL COMPLAINTS REVOLVING FUND
$ 2.00
01-02-2014 OCASA

OKLAHOMA COURT APPOINTED SPECIAL ADVOCATES
$ 5.00
01-02-2014 CCADMIN04

COURT CLERK ADMINISTRATIVE FEE ON COLLECTIONS
$ 0.50
01-02-2014 LTF

LENGTHY TRIAL FUND
$ 10.00
01-02-2014 SMF

SUMMONS FEE (CLERKS FEE)2
$ 10.00
01-02-2014 SMIMA

SUMMONS ISSUED - MAILED BY ATTORNEY

01-02-2014 EAA

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE / JARRETT A WILSON ENTERING AS COUNSEL /

Document Available (#1023873675) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
ZAYAT, LARRY
01-02-2014 TEXT

OCIS HAS AUTOMATICALLY ASSIGNED JUDGE KUEHN, DANA TO THIS CASE.

01-02-2014 ACCOUNT

RECEIPT # 2014-2753150 ON 01/02/2014.
PAYOR:CATHCART & DOOLEY TOTAL AMOUNT PAID: $223.70.
LINE ITEMS:
CJ-2014-1: $173.00 ON AC01 CLERK FEES.
CJ-2014-1: $6.00 ON AC23 LAW LIBRARY FEE.
CJ-2014-1: $0.70 ON AC31 COURT CLERK REVOLVING FUND.
CJ-2014-1: $5.00 ON AC58 OKLAHOMA COURT APPOINTED SPECIAL ADVOCATES.
CJ-2014-1: $2.00 ON AC59 OKLAHOMA COUNCIL ON JUDICIAL COMPLAINTS REVOLVING FUND.
CJ-2014-1: $2.00 ON AC64 DISPUTE MEDIATION FEES.
CJ-2014-1: $25.00 ON AC79 OCIS REVOLVING FUND.
CJ-2014-1: $10.00 ON AC81 LENGTHY TRIAL FUND.

01-14-2014 EAA

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE (JASON E MARSHALL ENTERS AS COUNSEL)

Document Available (#1023930799) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
ZAYAT, LARRY
01-31-2014 A

ANSWER (C. MICHAEL COPELAND ENTERS AS COUNSEL - COVERSHEET ATTACHED) / CERTIFICATE OF MAILING

Document Available (#1024171752) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
NIBCO INC
01-31-2014 MOD

MOTION TO DISMISS & BRIEF IN SUPPORT / CERTIFICATE OF MAILING

Document Available (#1024171756) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
NIBCO INC
02-18-2014 S

PARTY HAS BEEN SUCCESSFULLY SERVED. NIBCO INC SERVED / CERT MAIL / SIGNED BY MIKE MEREDITH / DEL ON 1-18-14

Document Available (#1024322006) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

02-20-2014 OBJ

PLAINTIFF'S OBJECTION AND RESPONSE TO DEFENDANT NIBCO, INC'S MOTION TO DISMISS

Document Available (#1024322523) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
ZAYAT, LARRY
02-28-2014 APLI

DEFT'S OPPOSED APPLICATION FOR LEAVE TO FIE REPLY BRIEF IN SUPPORT MOTION TO DISMISS / CERTIFICATE OF MAILING

Document Available (#1024422769) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
NIBCO INC
03-05-2014 S

PARTY HAS BEEN SUCCESSFULLY SERVED. SUMMONS SERVED ON PREFERRED TOTAL MECHANICAL & PLUMBING INC, CORPORATION SERVICE BY SERIVNG TRENTON EARP ON 3-04-14 BY PROCESS SERVER

Document Available (#1024420753) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
PREFERRED TOTAL MECHANICAL AND PLUMBING
03-06-2014 CTFREE

KUEHN, DANA: MINUTE ORDER ENTERED.

NOW, ON THIS 6TH DAY OF MARCH, 2014, THE COURT HAS FOR CONSIDERATION THE DEFENDANT'S MOTION TO DISMISS, FILED JANUARY 31, 2014.

IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED BY THE COURT THAT THE MOTION IS DENIED.

NOTICE MAILED BY CLERK TO PARTIES.

03-06-2014 O

C

Document Available (#1024419485) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

03-24-2014 A

DEFENDANT PREFERRED TOTAL MECHANICAL & PLUMBING'S ANSWER TO PLAINTIFF'S PETITION

Document Available (#1024733076) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
PREFERRED TOTAL MECHANICAL AND PLUMBING
06-25-2014 MO

DEFENDANT PREFERRED TOTAL MECHANICAL & PLUMBING INC'S MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY FROM PLAINTIFF / A2J

Document Available (#1026059962) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
PREFERRED TOTAL MECHANICAL AND PLUMBING
08-06-2014 CTFREE

KUEHN, DANA: MINUTE ORDER ENTERED.

NOW, ON THIS 5TH DAY OF AUGUST, 2014, THE COURT HAS FOR CONSIDERATION THE DEFENDANT'S MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY, FILED JUNE 25, 2014.


IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED BY THE COURT THAT THE MOTION IS GRANTED. DEEMED CONFESSED. PLAINTIFF TO RESPOND TO DISCOVERY BY 8-15-14.

NOTICE MAILED BY CLERK TO PARTIES.

08-06-2014 O

MINUTE ORDER / SEE MINUTE ENTRY

Document Available (#1026818869) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

08-13-2014 TEXT

DEFENDANT PREFERRED TOTAL MECHANICAL & PLUMBING INC'S CROSSCLAIM AGAINST NIBCO INC / A TO J

Document Available (#1026816471) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

09-12-2014 A

DEFENDANT NIBCO INC'S ANSWER TO CROSS-CLAIM OF DEFENDANT PREFERRED TOTAL MECHANICAL & PLUMBING INC / CERTIFICATE OF MAILING

Document Available (#1027192609) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
NIBCO INC
01-22-2015 CTFREE

KUEHN, DANA: NOTICE ENTERED OF SCHEDULING CONFERENCE SET ON 2-19-15 AT 1:30 PM, COURTROOM 701.

NOTICE MAILED BY CLERK TO PARTIES.

01-22-2015 NO

NOTICE/ SCHEDULING CONFERENCE SET ON 2-19-15 @ 1:30 PM / CERTIFICATE OF MAILING / TO: C MICHAEL COPELAND

Document Available (#1028390157) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

01-22-2015 NO

NOTICE/ SCHEDULING CONFERENCE SET ON 2-19-15 @ 1:30 PM / CERTIFICATE OF MAILING / TO: DOUGLAS M BOROCHOFF

Document Available (#1028390161) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

01-22-2015 NO

NOTICE/ SCHEDULING CONFERENCE SET ON 2-19-15 @ 1:30 PM / CERTIFICATE OF MAILING / TO: JARRETT A WILSON

Document Available (#1028390165) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

01-22-2015 NO

NOTICE/ SCHEDULING CONFERENCE SET ON 2-19-15 @ 1:30 PM / CERTIFICATE OF MAILING / TO: JASON E MARSHALL

Document Available (#1028390169) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

02-17-2015 CTFREE

KUEHN, DANA: AGREED SCHEDULING ORDER ENTERED. SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE TO BE COMPLETED PRIOR TO PRETRIAL CONFERENCE. SCHEDULING CONFERENCE ON 2-19-15 IS STRICKEN.

PRETRIAL CONFERENCE IS SET ON 10-26-15 AT 9:30 AM, COURTROOM 701.

02-18-2015 SO

AGREED SCHEDULING ORDER

Document Available (#1028668800) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

03-09-2015 MO

PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE AN AMENDED PETITION IN ORDER TO ADD PARTIES / A2J

Document Available (#1028985957) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
ZAYAT, LARRY
03-19-2015 CTFREE

KUEHN, DANA: AGREED ORDER ENTERED GRANTING PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE AN AMENDED PETITION IN ORDER TO ADD PARTIES.

04-02-2015 SMF

SUMMONS FEE (CLERKS FEE)-2
$ 10.00
04-02-2015 SMIMA

SUMMONS ISSUED - MAILED BY ATTORNEY-2

04-02-2015 AMP

AMENDED PETITION

Document Available (#1029179240) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
ZAYAT, LARRY
04-02-2015 ACCOUNT

RECEIPT # 2015-3062449 ON 04/02/2015.
PAYOR:CATHCART & DOOLEY TOTAL AMOUNT PAID: $10.00.
LINE ITEMS:
CJ-2014-1: $10.00 ON AC01 CLERK FEES.

07-01-2015 EAA

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE AS COUNSEL FOR NIBCO INC / CERT OF MAILING / COVER SHEET

Document Available (#1030127048) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
NIBCO INC
07-01-2015 EAA

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE AS COUNSEL FOR NIBCO INC / CERT OF MAILING / COVER SHEET

Document Available (#1030127044) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
NIBCO INC
07-09-2015 MO

MOTION TO WITHDRAW AS ATTORNEY OF RECORD / A TO J / CERTIFICATE OF MAILING

Document Available (#1030265839) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
NIBCO INC
07-10-2015 CTFREE

KUEHN, DANA: ORDER ENTERED ALLOWING WITHDRAWAL OF COUNSEL, MICHAEL COPELAND AND TADD BOGAN FOR DEFENDANT NIBCO.

07-13-2015 MO

MOTION FOR ADMISSION OF COUNSEL PRO HAC VICE / A TO J / CERTIFICATE OF MAILING

Document Available (#1030266343) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
NIBCO INC
07-13-2015 O

ORDER ALLOWING WITHDRAWAL OF COUNSEL / C MICHAEL COPELAND AND TADD J P BOGAN /

Document Available (#1030266357) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

07-20-2015 CTFREE

KUEHN, DANA: ORDER ENTERED FOR ADMISSION OF COUNSEL PRO HAC VICE.

07-22-2015 O

ORDER FOR ADMISSION OF COUNSEL PRO HAC VICE

Document Available (#1030260253) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
NIBCO INC
09-22-2015 MO

MOTION TO WITHDRAW AS COUNSEL OF RECORD / DAN S FOLLUO AND TROY J MCPHERSON / CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

Document Available (#1030905666) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
NIBCO INC
09-22-2015 EAA

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE/ JARED R BOYER ENTERING AS COUNSEL / CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

Document Available (#1030905622) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
NIBCO INC
09-23-2015 CTFREE

KUEHN, DANA: ORDER ENTERED GRANTING DEFEDNTANT'S MOTION TO WITHDRAW.

09-23-2015 O

ORDER GRANTING MOTION TO WITHDRAW / DAN S FOLLUO AND TROY J MCPHERSON

Document Available (#1030901653) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

10-14-2015 S

PARTY HAS BEEN SUCCESSFULLY SERVED. / FOR SUTTON CONCRETE INC / CORP SRV / SRVD VERONICA OSBORN / ON 10-10-15 / BY PS

Document Available (#1031275842) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
Sutton Construction Inc
10-21-2015 CTFREE

KUEHN, DANA: PRE TRIAL CONFERENCE STRICKEN FOR 10-28-15.

AMENDED SCHEDULING ORDER TO BE SUBMITTED.

10-22-2015 S

PARTY HAS BEEN SUCCESSFULLY SERVED. RUHL CONSTRUCTION LLC SERVED / CORP SERV TO DANA HUDSON / ON 10-21-15 BY PS

Document Available (#1031271089) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
Ruhl Construction Llc
11-30-2015 EAA

DEFENDANT SUTTON CONCRETE INC'S SPECIAL ENTRY OF APPEARANCE AND MOTION TO DISMISS / A TO J / CERTIFICATE OF MAILING

Document Available (#1031729828) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
Sutton Construction Inc
12-22-2015 DISPCVDMWP

AGREED MOTION TO DISMISS WITH PREJUDICE

Document Available (#1031726527) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
1 Sutton Construction Inc
02-01-2016 MO

MOTION TO WITHDRAW AS COUNSEL OF RECORD / REBECCA J MCMAHON / A TO J / CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

Document Available (#1032175606) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
NIBCO INC
02-01-2016 EAA

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE/ RODNEY HUNSINGER AND JARED R BOYER ENTERING AS COUNSEL / W-CS / CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

Document Available (#1032268850) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
NIBCO INC
02-03-2016 CTFREE

KUEHN, DANA: ORDER ENTERED ALLOWING REBECCA J. MCMAHON TO WITHDRAWAL AS COUNSEL OF RECORD FOR DEFENDANT NIBCO, INC.

02-04-2016 O

ORDER GRANTING MOTION TO WITHDRAW

Document Available (#1031972739) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

02-10-2016 MOC

DEFENDANT PREFERRED TOTAL MECHANICAL & PLUMBING INC'S MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY FROM DEFENDANT NIBCO INC / A TO J/ CERTIFICATE OF DELIVERY

Document Available (#1032262348) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
PREFERRED TOTAL MECHANICAL AND PLUMBING
02-29-2016 B

NIBCO INC'S BRIEF IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT PREFERRED TOTAL MECHANICAL & PLUMBING INC'S MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY / CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

Document Available (#1032596711) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
NIBCO INC
03-29-2016 CTFREE

KUEHN, DANA: MINUTE ORDER ENTERED.

NOW, ON THIS 28TH DAY OF MARCH, 2016, THE COURT HAS FOR CONSIDERATION THE DEFENDANT PREFERRED TOTAL MECHANICAL & PLUMBING, INC.'S MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY FROM DEFENDANT NIBCO, INC., FILED FEBRUARY 10, 2016.

THE MOTION IS OVERRULED. DEFENDANT PREFERRED'S REQUESTS ARE OVERLY BROAD IN REGARDS TO THE WORD “PRODUCTS.” ONCE THE REQUESTS ARE MORE NARROWLY TAILORED TO THE SPECIFIC PRODUCTION IN THIS CASE, DEFENDANT NIBCO SHALL RESPOND FULLY TO THE REQUESTS. THE OBJECTION TO REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION NO. 24 IS SUSTAINED AS IRRELEVANT.

DONE THIS 28TH DAY OF MARCH, 2016.

ORDER MAILED BY CLERK TO PARTIES.

03-29-2016 O

MINUTE ORDER / SEE ABOVE ENTRY / AFFIDAVIT OF MAILING

Document Available (#1032809583) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

04-21-2016 MO

MOTION TO WITHDRAW AS COUNSEL OF RECORD FOR DEFENDANT

Document Available (#1032978212) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
NIBCO INC
04-25-2016 CTFREE

KUEHN, DANA: ORDER ENTERED ALLOWING RACHAEL F. HUGHES WITHDRAWAL AS ATTORNEY OF RECORD FOR NIBCO, INC.

04-29-2016 O

ORDER ALLOWING WITHDRAWAL / RACHAEL F HUGHES TO WITHDRAW FOR NIBCO INC

Document Available (#1033111920) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

12-06-2016 CTFREE

KUEHN, DANA: AMENDED AGREED SCHEDULING ORDER ENTERED.
PRETRIAL CONFERENCE IS SET ON 10-24-17 AT 9:45 AM IN COURTROOM 701.

12-29-2016 AM

AMENDED AGREED SCHEDULING ORDER / 12-6-16

Document Available (#1035218138) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

02-07-2017 NO

NOTICE OF CHANGE OF ADDRESS / C TO CV

Document Available (#1036085513) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

Outcome: 10-24-2017 DISPCVDM

KUEHN, DANA: PER JASON MARSHALL PRETRIAL CONFERENCE STRICKEN AS SETTLED.
1 NIBCO INC
10-24-2017 DISPCVDM

KUEHN, DANA: PER JASON MARSHALL PRETRIAL CONFERENCE STRICKEN AS SETTLED.
1 PREFERRED TOTAL MECHANICAL AND PLUMBING
10-24-2017 DISPCVDM

KUEHN, DANA: PER JASON MARSHALL PRETRIAL CONFERENCE STRICKEN AS SETTLED.
1 Ruhl Construction Llc
10-24-2017 DISPCVDM

KUEHN, DANA: PER JASON MARSHALL PRETRIAL CONFERENCE STRICKEN AS SETTLED.
2 NIBCO INC
10-24-2017 DISPCVDM

KUEHN, DANA: PER JASON MARSHALL PRETRIAL CONFERENCE STRICKEN AS SETTLED.
2 PREFERRED TOTAL MECHANICAL AND PLUMBING
10-24-2017 DISPCVDM

KUEHN, DANA: PER JASON MARSHALL PRETRIAL CONFERENCE STRICKEN AS SETTLED.
3 NIBCO INC
10-24-2017 DISPCVDM

KUEHN, DANA: PER JASON MARSHALL PRETRIAL CONFERENCE STRICKEN AS SETTLED.
3 PREFERRED TOTAL MECHANICAL AND PLUMBING
10-24-2017 DISPCVDM

KUEHN, DANA: PER JASON MARSHALL PRETRIAL CONFERENCE STRICKEN AS SETTLED.
4 NIBCO INC

Plaintiff's Experts:

Defendant's Experts:

Comments: