Date: 09-26-2017

Case Style:

Case Number: CJ-2013-3576

Judge: Aletia Haynes Timmons

Court: District Court, Oklahoma County, Oklahoma

Plaintiff's Attorney: Tom Cummings

Defendant's Attorney: Phillip S. Spatt

Description: Oklahoma City, OK - Harry O'Brien v. Robert Wayne McGaugh

Issue # 1. Issue: ASSAULT & BATTERY (A&B)
Filed By: O Brien, Harry
Filed Date: 06/24/2013
Party Name Disposition Information
Defendant: Mcgaugh, Robert Wayne Disposed: JUDGEMENT FOR PLAINTIFF, 09/26/2017. Jury Trial
Docket
Date Code Description Count Party Amount
06-24-2013 TEXT

CIVIL RELIEF MORE THAN $10,000 INITIAL FILING.
1
06-24-2013 A&B

ASSAULT & BATTERY

06-24-2013 DMFE

DISPUTE MEDIATION FEE
$ 2.00
06-24-2013 PFE1

PETITION
$ 163.00
06-24-2013 PFE7

LAW LIBRARY FEE
$ 6.00
06-24-2013 OCISR

OKLAHOMA COURT INFORMATION SYSTEM REVOLVING FUND
$ 25.00
06-24-2013 CCADMIN02

COURT CLERK ADMINISTRATIVE FEE ON $2 COLLECTIONS
$ 0.20
06-24-2013 OCJC

OKLAHOMA COUNCIL ON JUDICIAL COMPLAINTS REVOLVING FUND
$ 2.00
06-24-2013 OCASA

OKLAHOMA COURT APPOINTED SPECIAL ADVOCATES
$ 5.00
06-24-2013 CCADMIN04

COURT CLERK ADMINISTRATIVE FEE ON COLLECTIONS
$ 0.50
06-24-2013 LTF

LENGTHY TRIAL FUND
$ 10.00
06-24-2013 SMF

SUMMONS FEE (CLERKS FEE)
$ 5.00
06-24-2013 EAA

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY TOM CUMMINGS ATTORNEY FOR HARRY O'BRIEN

Document Available (#1021686842) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

06-24-2013 P

PETITION

Document Available (#1022140760) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

06-24-2013 TEXT

OCIS HAS AUTOMATICALLY ASSIGNED JUDGE DAVIS, LISA T TO THIS CASE.

06-24-2013 ADJUST

ADJUSTING ENTRY: MONIES DUE TO AC09-CARD ALLOCATION
$ 5.47
06-24-2013 ACCOUNT

ADJUSTING ENTRY: MONIES DUE TO THE FOLLOWING AGENCIES REDUCED BY THE FOLLOWING AMOUNTS:
CJ-2013-3576: AC81 LENGTHY TRIAL FUND -$0.25
CJ-2013-3576: AC79 OCIS REVOLVING FUND -$0.63
CJ-2013-3576: AC64 DISPUTE MEDIATION FEES -$0.05
CJ-2013-3576: AC59 OKLAHOMA COUNCIL ON JUDICIAL COMPLAINTS REVOLVING FUND -$0.05
CJ-2013-3576: AC58 OKLAHOMA COURT APPOINTED SPECIAL ADVOCATES -$0.13
CJ-2013-3576: AC31 COURT CLERK REVOLVING FUND -$0.02
CJ-2013-3576: AC23 LAW LIBRARY FEE -$0.15
CJ-2013-3576: AC01 CLERK FEES -$4.19

06-24-2013 ACCOUNT

RECEIPT # 2013-3152524 ON 06/24/2013.
PAYOR:TOM CUMMINGS TOTAL AMOUNT PAID: $218.70.
LINE ITEMS:
CJ-2013-3576: $163.81 ON AC01 CLERK FEES.
CJ-2013-3576: $5.47 ON AC09 CARD ALLOCATIONS.
CJ-2013-3576: $5.85 ON AC23 LAW LIBRARY FEE.
CJ-2013-3576: $0.68 ON AC31 COURT CLERK REVOLVING FUND.
CJ-2013-3576: $4.87 ON AC58 OKLAHOMA COURT APPOINTED SPECIAL ADVOCATES.
CJ-2013-3576: $1.95 ON AC59 OKLAHOMA COUNCIL ON JUDICIAL COMPLAINTS REVOLVING FUND.
CJ-2013-3576: $1.95 ON AC64 DISPUTE MEDIATION FEES.
CJ-2013-3576: $24.37 ON AC79 OCIS REVOLVING FUND.
CJ-2013-3576: $9.75 ON AC81 LENGTHY TRIAL FUND.

07-31-2013 SMS

SUMMONS RETURNED, SERVED: ROBERT MCGAUGH BY CERTIFIED MAIL ON 7-26-13

Document Available (#1022511645) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

08-16-2013 EAA

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE

Document Available (#1022474636) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
Mcgaugh, Robert Wayne
09-27-2013 A

ANSWER

Document Available (#1023040673) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

01-09-2014 MO

PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO ENTER ON NON-JURY TRIAL DOCKET

Document Available (#1023960324) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

02-13-2014 JIF

DEFENDANT'S MOTION TO ENTER ON THE JURY TRIAL DOCKET

Document Available (#1024219877) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
$ 349.00
02-13-2014 ACCOUNT

RECEIPT # 2014-3294815 ON 02/13/2014.
PAYOR:C MERLE GILE ATTORNEY AT LAW TOTAL AMOUNT PAID: $349.00.
LINE ITEMS:
CJ-2013-3576: $349.00 ON AC01 CLERK FEES.

02-14-2014 TEXT

ADMINISTRATIVELY REASSIGNED BY AOC MIS PER HELP DESK CONTACT HD27347

02-20-2014 CTFREE

JUDGE B. JONES; MOTION TO ENTER - GRANTED, PRETRIAL CONFERENCE SET 3/5/2014 @ 10:30AM

02-21-2014 SCHO

SCHEDULING ORDER / JUDGE B. JONES

Document Available (#1024340775) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

03-05-2014 CTFREE

JUDGE B. JONES; PRETRIAL CONFERENCE - HELD, STATUS CONFERENCE SET 5/2/2014 @ 2:30PM

03-12-2014 MO

MOTION TO WITHDRAWAL AS ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT

Document Available (#1024455076) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

03-12-2014 O

ORDER ALLOWING WITHDRAWAL/JUDGE B JONES

Document Available (#1024471126) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

04-03-2014 EAA

ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY AND THROUGH ATTORNEY, J. WESLEY CHSER FOR DEFENDANT, ROBERT WAYNE MCGAUGH

Document Available (#1024676359) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF
Mcgaugh, Robert Wayne
05-22-2015 NO

SUBSTITUTION OF COUNSEL

Document Available (#1029473580) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

07-08-2015 NO

NOTICE OF DISPOSITION DOCKET

Document Available (#1029961653) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

07-24-2015 APLI

APPLICATION FOR ALLOWING THE ACTION TO REMAIN UPON DOCKET

Document Available (#1029973312) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

07-27-2015 CTFREE

HEARING ON DISPOSITION SET 7/29/2015 IS STRICKEN, MOTION TO ENTER SET 8/20/2015 @ 9:30AM

07-27-2015 MO

PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO ENTER ON JURY TRIAL DOCKET

Document Available (#1029971424) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

08-05-2015 TEXT

ADMINISTRATIVELY REASSIGNED BY AOC MIS PER HELP DESK CONTACT HD44922

08-20-2015 CTFREE

JUDGE TIMMONS: MOTION TO ENTER - GRANTED, PRETRIAL SET 1/20/2016 @ 2:30PM

08-20-2015 SO

SCHEDULING ORDER / TIMMONS

Document Available (#1030353454) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

01-07-2016 MOCON

MOTION FOR CONTINUANCE OF PRETRIAL

Document Available (#1031927455) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

01-13-2016 O

ORDER ON MOTION FOR CONTINUANCE OF PRETRIAL

Document Available (#1031922721) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

01-20-2016 CTFREE

JUDGE TIMMONS: PRETRIAL CONFERENCE - CONTINUED TO 3/16/2016 @ 2 PM

02-17-2016 CTFREE

PRETRIAL CONFERENCE SET 2/16/2016 IS CONTINUED BY THE COURT TO 7/13/2016 @ 3:30 PM

07-13-2016 PTO

PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE ORDER

Document Available (#1033822477) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

07-13-2016 CTFREE

JUDGE TIMMONS: PRETRIAL CONFERENCE - HELD, JURY TRIAL SET 2/27/2016 @ 9 AM. HEARING ON MOTIONS IN LIMINE SET 2/10/2017 @ 1:30 PM

02-03-2017 MO

MOTION IN LIMINE EXCLUSION OF PREJUDICIAL EVIDENCE:

Document Available (#1036075360) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

02-10-2017 RESP

PLAINTIFF'S RESPONSE TO DEFENDANT'S MOTION IN LIMINE

Document Available (#1036081146) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

02-10-2017 CTFREE

MOTION IN LIMINE EXCLUSION OF PREJUDICIAL EVIDENCE SET 2/10/2017 IS CONTINUED TO 2/23/2017 @ 2:30 PM

02-21-2017 B

PLAINTIFF'S TRIAL BRIEF

Document Available (#1036072465) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

02-22-2017 REQ

PLAINTIFF'S REQUESTED JURY INSTRUCTIONS

Document Available (#1036073415) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

02-23-2017 O

COURT MINUTE \ TIMMONS

Document Available (#1035724162) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

03-31-2017 MO

PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO ENTER ON NON-JURY TRIAL DOCKET

Document Available (#1036576528) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

05-02-2017 CTFREE

JUDGE TIMMONS: MOTION TO ENTER - JURY TRIAL RESET ON 9/25/2017 @ 9 AM

09-20-2017 B

PLAINTIFF'S TRIAL BRIEF

Document Available (#1038250780) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

09-22-2017 MO

DEFENDANT'S MOTION TO EXCLUDE PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBITS AT TRIAL

Document Available (#1038253929) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

09-25-2017 MO

DEFENDANT'S MOTION TO EXCLUDE SHIPLEY DEPOSITION AT TRIAL

Document Available (#1038253933) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

09-25-2017 REQ

DEFENDANTS' REQUESTED JURY INSTRUCTION

Document Available (#1038253925) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

09-25-2017 CTFREE

JUDGE TIMMONS: CASE COMES ON FOR JURY TRIAL. PLAINTIFF APPEARS WITH ATTORNEY TOM CUMMINGS. ATTORNEY PHILLIP SPRATT APPEARS WITH DEFENDANT. BOTH SIDES ANNOUNCE READY. (25) JURORS SWORN TO ANSWER QUESTIONS. (19) JURORS CALLED TO THE BOX. COURT INQUIRES OF THE BOX. JURY EXAMINATION BY PLAINTIFF AND DEFENDANT, THEN PASSED FOR CAUSE. PEREMPTORY CHALLENGES. ALL CHALLENGES CALLED. (13) JURORS SWORN TO TRY CASE. COURT'S INSTRUCTION #1. OPENING STATEMENTS BY PLAINTIFF THEN DEFENDANT. PLAINTIFF CALLS WITNESSES, SWORN TESTIMONY IS HEARD, EXHIBITS OFFERED. COURT ADMONISHES JURY AND IS IN RECESS UNTIL 9/26/2017 @ 9 AM. COURT REPORTER T. NIXON

09-26-2017 VERD

VERDICT FORM, FOR PLAINTIFF, PUNITIVE DAMAGES(FIRST STAGE); SIGNED

Document Available (SEALED DOCUMENT)

09-26-2017 VERD

VERDICT FORM - SECOND STAGE; SIGNED

Document Available (SEALED DOCUMENT)

09-26-2017 JL

JURY LIST

Document Available (SEALED DOCUMENT)

09-26-2017 VERDU

VERDICT FORM; UNSIGNED

Document Available (#1035724281) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

09-26-2017 IJ

COURT'S INSTRUCTIONS TO THE JURY PANEL

Document Available at Court Clerk's Office

09-26-2017 IJ

COURT'S SECOND STAGE INSTRUCTIONS TO THE JURY PANEL

Document Available at Court Clerk's Office

09-26-2017 OAT

OATH OF BAILIFF

Document Available at Court Clerk's Office

09-26-2017 ADJUST

ADJUSTING ENTRY: MONIES DUE TO AC09-CARD ALLOCATION
$ 0.50
09-26-2017 ACCOUNT

ADJUSTING ENTRY: MONIES DUE TO THE FOLLOWING AGENCIES REDUCED BY THE FOLLOWING AMOUNTS:
CJ-2013-3576: AC01 CLERK FEES -$0.50

09-26-2017 ACCOUNT

RECEIPT # 2017-4213758 ON 09/26/2017.
PAYOR: PHILLIP SCOTT SPRATT TOTAL AMOUNT PAID: $ 20.00.
LINE ITEMS:
CJ-2013-3576: $19.50 ON AC01 CLERK FEES.
CJ-2013-3576: $0.50 ON AC09 CARD ALLOCATIONS.

09-28-2017 MO

PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO SETTLE JOURNAL ENTRY OF JUDGMENT

Document Available (#1038261153) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

09-28-2017 MO

PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO TAX COSTS

Document Available (#1038261149) Download document in TIFF format.TIFF Download document in PDF format.PDF

Outcome: 09-26-2017 DISPJP

JUDGE TIMMONS: JURY TRIAL RESUMES AFTER NIGHT'S RECESS, ALL PARTIES RETURN. WITNESSES SWORN, TESTIMONY HEARD, EXHIBITS OFFERED. PLAINTIFF RESTS. DEFENDANT RESTS. COURT'S INSTRUCTIONS TO THE JURY. CLOSING ARGUMENTS BY PLAINTIFF AND DEFENDANT. JURY RETIRES TO DELIBERATE, RESTURNS WITH VERDICT, AND FINDS IN FAVOR OF PLAINTIFF IN THE AMOUNT OF $2,400,000.00. SECOND STAGE INSTRUCTIONS ON PUNITIVE DAMAGES GIVEN TO THE JURY. ARGUMENT BY PLAINTIFF AND DEFENDANT. JURY RETIRES TO DELIBERATE, RETURNS WITH VERDICT, AND FINDS PUNITIVE DAMAGES IN THE AMOUNT OF $1,000,000.00. JURY DISCHARGED. CLERK DIRECTED TO FILE AND RECORD VERDICT ACCORDINGLY. COURT REPORTER T. NIXON.

Plaintiff's Experts:

Defendant's Experts:

Comments: