Date: 12-15-2014

Case Style: Chuck O'Dell v. Murphy Resources, Inc., Larence Smith and Lori Smith

Case Number: CJ-2008-9028

Judge: Daman H. Cantrell

Court: District Court, Tulsa County, Oklahoma

Plaintiff's Attorney: Steve Mathis

Defendant's Attorney: Mike Masterson, John Desbarres, Dave Fleury, Amanda Mims, Rebecca Murphy, John O'Connor, Clint Patterson and Dave Francy for Murphy Resources, Inc.

Tony Miller, Mark Smilng and Kim Ritchie for Lawrence and Lori Smith

Description: Chuck O'Dell v. Murphy Resources, Inc., Larence Smith and Lori Smith

Issue # 1.
Issue: PROFESSIONAL NEGLIGENCE (PROFNEG)
Filed by: ODELL, CHUCK
Filed Date: 12/24/2008
Party Name: Disposition Information:

Defendant: MURPHY RESOURCES INC
Disposed: DISMISSED - WITH PREJUDICE, 09/30/2013. Dismissed- Settled.

Defendant: SMITH, LAWRENCE
Disposed: DISMISSED - WITH PREJUDICE, 09/30/2013. Dismissed- Settled.

Defendant: SMITH, LORI
Disposed: DISMISSED - WITH PREJUDICE, 09/30/2013. Dismissed- Settled.

Issue # 2.
Issue: PROFESSIONAL NEGLIGENCE (PROFNEG)
Filed by: ODELL, MARY
Filed Date: 12/24/2008
Party Name: Disposition Information:

Defendant: MURPHY RESOURCES INC
Disposed: DISMISSED - WITH PREJUDICE, 09/30/2013. Dismissed- Settled.

Original Defendant (Amended): SMITH, LAWRENCE
Disposed: DISMISSED - WITH PREJUDICE, 09/30/2013. Dismissed- Settled.

Original Defendant (Amended): SMITH, LORI
Disposed: DISMISSED - WITH PREJUDICE, 09/30/2013. Dismissed- Settled.

Issue # 3.
Issue: COUNTERCLAIM - TRESPASS / NUISANCE (OTHER)
Filed by: SMITH, LAWRENCE
Filed Date: 04/15/2010
Party Name: Disposition Information:

Original Plaintiff (Amended): ODELL, CHUCK
Disposed: DISMISSED - WITH PREJUDICE, 10/18/2013. Dismissed- Settled.

Original Plaintiff (Amended): ODELL, MARY
Disposed: DISMISSED - WITH PREJUDICE, 10/18/2013. Dismissed- Settled.

Issue # 4.
Issue: COUNTERCLAIM - RECOVERY OF REAL PROPERTY (OTHER)
Filed by: SMITH, LAWRENCE
Filed Date: 04/15/2011
Party Name: Disposition Information:

Plaintiff: ODELL, CHUCK
Disposed: DISMISSED - WITH PREJUDICE, 10/18/2013. Dismissed- Settled.

Plaintiff: ODELL, MARY
Disposed: DISMISSED - WITH PREJUDICE, 10/18/2013. Dismissed- Settled.

Issue # 5.
Issue: COUNTERCLAIM - NEGLIGENT OR WILLFUL INJURY TO PROPERTY (NEGL)
Filed by: SMITH, LAWRENCE
Filed Date: 04/15/2011
Party Name: Disposition Information:

Plaintiff: ODELL, CHUCK
Disposed: DISMISSED - WITH PREJUDICE, 10/18/2013. Dismissed- Settled.

Plaintiff: ODELL, MARY
Disposed: DISMISSED - WITH PREJUDICE, 10/18/2013. Dismissed- Settled.

Issue # 6.
Issue: CROSS CLAIM - INDEMNITY (OTHER)
Filed by: SMITH, LAWRENCE
Filed Date: 04/15/2011
Party Name: Disposition Information:

Defendant: MURPHY RESOURCES INC
Disposed: DISMISSED - SETTLED, 12/15/2014. Dismissed- Settled.

Defendant: MURPHY RESOURCES INC
Disposed: DISMISSED - WITH PREJUDICE, 10/18/2013. Dismissed- Settled.

Issue # 7.
Issue: CROSS CLAIM - BREACH OF EXPRESS WARRANTY / IMPLIED WARRANTY (OTHER)
Filed by: SMITH, LAWRENCE
Filed Date: 04/15/2011
Party Name: Disposition Information:

Defendant: MURPHY RESOURCES INC
Disposed: DISMISSED - SETTLED, 12/15/2014. Dismissed- Settled.

Defendant: MURPHY RESOURCES INC
Disposed: DISMISSED - WITH PREJUDICE, 10/18/2013. Dismissed- Settled.

Issue # 8.
Issue: CROSS CLAIM - NEGLIGENCE (NEGL)
Filed by: SMITH, LAWRENCE
Filed Date: 04/15/2011
Party Name: Disposition Information:

Defendant: MURPHY RESOURCES INC
Disposed: DISMISSED - SETTLED, 12/15/2014. Dismissed- Settled.

Defendant: MURPHY RESOURCES INC
Disposed: DISMISSED - WITH PREJUDICE, 10/18/2013. Dismissed- Settled.

Issue # 9.
Issue: CROSS CLAIM - BREACH OF DUTY ARISING UNDER INDEMNITY AGREEMENT (OTHER)
Filed by: SMITH, LAWRENCE
Filed Date: 04/15/2011
Party Name: Disposition Information:

Defendant: MURPHY RESOURCES INC
Disposed: DISMISSED - SETTLED, 12/15/2014. Dismissed- Settled.

Defendant: MURPHY RESOURCES INC
Disposed: DISMISSED - WITH PREJUDICE, 10/18/2013. Dismissed- Settled.

Issue # 10.
Issue: C/C & CROSS CLAIM - NEGLIGENCE (NEGL)
Filed by: SMITH, LAWRENCE
Filed Date: 04/15/2011
Party Name: Disposition Information:

Original Plaintiff (Amended): ODELL, CHUCK
Disposed: DISMISSED - WITH PREJUDICE, 10/18/2013. Dismissed- Settled.

Original Plaintiff (Amended): ODELL, MARY
Disposed: DISMISSED - WITH PREJUDICE, 10/18/2013. Dismissed- Settled.

Defendant: MURPHY RESOURCES INC
Disposed: DISMISSED - SETTLED, 12/15/2014. Dismissed- Settled.

Defendant: MURPHY RESOURCES INC
Disposed: DISMISSED - WITH PREJUDICE, 10/18/2013. Dismissed- Settled.

Outcome: Settled in mediation for an undisclosed sum and dismissed with prejudice.

Plaintiff's Experts:

Defendant's Experts:

Comments: