M ORE L AW
LEXAPEDIA
Salus Populi Suprema Lex Esto

Information
About MoreLaw
Contact MoreLaw

Please E-mail suggested additions, comments and/or corrections to Kent@MoreLaw.Com.

Help support the publication of case reports on MoreLaw

Date: 03-03-2018

Case Style:

Family and Estate of Garolyn S. Langell v. Dr. Micahael Paul, Timothy Horrigan and Physicians Healthcare Network, P.C. and McLaren Port Huron

Morelaw Internet Marketing for Legal Professionals
MoreLaw Can Make Your Phone Ring
888-354-4529

Case Number: 15-002567-NH

Judge: Daniel Kelly

Court: Circuit Court, St. Clair County, Michigan

Plaintiff's Attorney: Brian McKeen

Defendant's Attorney: Keith P. Felty for Michael Paul


Stephen D. McGraw for Horrrigan and Partridge Family Physicians, P.c.


Donald K. Warwick for McLaren Port Huron

Description: Port Huron, MI - Jury Awards Family $3.99 Million In Wrongful Death Case

The family and estate of Garylyn Langell sued Dr. Michael Paul, Physicians Healthcare Network, P.C., McLaren Port huron, Partraidge Family Physicians, P.C. on medical negligence (medical malpractice) and respondeat superior theories claiming that Garylyn Langell, age 47, received substandard care when she presented with with symptoms of a dissecting aorta in 2011.


Plaintiffs alleged that Ms. Langell demonstrated life threatening symptoms when she was examined but was misdiagnoses with "musculoskeletal chest pain."

Docket Entries:

10/23/15 SUMMONS AND COMPLAINT $235.00 nik
nik
10/23/15
10/23/15
PTF 1
DEF 1
10/23/15 JURY DEMAND nik 10/23/15
RECEIVABLES/PAYMENTS
PTF 1 GARYLYN S ESTATE OF LANGELL
Assessed Paid/Adjusted Balance
$275.00 $275.00 $0.00
DEF 1 MCLAREN PORT HURON
Assessed Paid/Adjusted Balance
$60.00 $60.00 $0.00
DEF 2 PHYSICIAN HEALTHCARE NETWORK PC
Assessed Paid/Adjusted Balance
$20.00 $20.00 $0.00
DEF 3 PARTRIDGE FAMILY PHYSICIANS PC
Assessed Paid/Adjusted Balance
$60.00 $60.00 $0.00
DEF 4 MICHAEL PAUL
Assessed Paid/Adjusted Balance
$20.00 $20.00 $0.00
DEF 5 TIMOTHY HORRIGAN
Assessed Paid/Adjusted Balance
$40.00 $40.00 $0.00
STATE OF MICHIGAN
31ST CIRCUIT COURT
ST CLAIR COUNTY
REGISTER
OF
ACTIONS
CASE ID
15-002567-NH
C/C31/S
Public
3/3/2018
9:44:58 AM
Page: 1 of 12
Activity Date Activity User Entry Date
PTF 1
10/23/15 JUDICIAL OFFICER ASSIGNED TO KELLY, DANIEL 24338 nik 10/23/15
10/23/15 RECEIVABLE JURY DEMAND FEE $85.00 nik 10/23/15
10/23/15 RECEIVABLE CIVIL FILING FEE $150.00 nik 10/23/15
10/23/15 PAYMENT $235.00 nik 10/23/15
RECEIPT NUMBER: C31.0006844
METHOD: CHECK $235.00
12/11/15 RETURN OF SERVICE - PERSONAL nik 12/14/15
DEF 1
12/11/15 RETURN OF SERVICE - PERSONAL nik 12/14/15
DEF 2
DEF 4
12/11/15 RETURN OF SERVICE - PERSONAL nik 12/14/15
DEF 3
DEF 5
12/16/15 ANSWER, CIVIL nik 12/17/15
DEF 2
DEF 4
12/16/15 AFFIDAVIT nik 12/17/15
12/16/15 PROOF OF SERVICE nik 12/17/15
12/17/15 APPEARANCE nik 12/18/15
DEF 1
12/17/15 ANSWER, CIVIL nik 12/18/15
DEF 1
12/21/15 PAYMENT $20.00 mlp 12/21/15
RECEIPT NUMBER: C31.0009826
METHOD: CHECK $20.00
12/21/15 RECEIVABLE MOTION FEE $20.00 mlp 12/21/15
12/21/15 PROOF OF SERVICE nik 12/21/15
12/21/15 NOTICE OF DEPOSITION FOR S DOUGLAS TOUMA nik 12/21/15
12/21/15 MOTION PROTECTIVE ORDER nik 12/21/15
DEF 1
12/21/15 MOTION ESTABLISH DEADLINE TO FILE-SERVE AFFIDAVITS OF
MERITOUS DEFENSE
nik 12/21/15
DEF 1
12/22/15 MOTION ESTABLISH DEADLINES/PROTECTIVE ORDER CANCELLED 1/11/16 10:00 A mlk 12/22/15
LOC: 3500
12/22/15 PRAECIPE nik 12/23/15
12/28/15 PROOF OF SERVICE nik 12/28/15
12/28/15 APPEARANCE nik 12/28/15
DEF 5
12/30/15 STIPULATION AND ORDER TO ESTABLISH DEADLINE TOFILE/SERVE
AFFIDAVITS
nik 12/30/15
12/30/15 STIPULATION AND ORDER GRANTING EXTENSION OF TIME TO FILE
MERITORIOUS DEFENSE
nik 12/30/15
STATE OF MICHIGAN
31ST CIRCUIT COURT
ST CLAIR COUNTY
REGISTER
OF
ACTIONS
CASE ID
15-002567-NH
C/C31/S
Public
3/3/2018
9:44:58 AM
Page: 2 of 12
Activity Date Activity User Entry Date
1/6/16 MOTION 1/11/16 10:00 AM mlk 1/6/16
CANCELLED
OTHER
PER KATHY AT DON WARWICK'S OFFICE MOTION TO ESTABLISH DEADLINES IS DISMISSED
AND MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER IS TO BE SET BACK ON FOR 1/19/16
1/6/16 PROOF OF SERVICE nik 1/6/16
1/8/16 MOTION PROTECTIVE ORDER CANCELLED 1/19/16 10:00 A mlk 1/8/16
LOC: 3500
1/8/16 ANSWER, CIVIL nik 1/11/16
DEF 3
DEF 5
1/8/16 FURTHER ANSWER TO COMPLAINT nik 1/11/16
1/8/16 AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE nik 1/11/16
DEF 3
DEF 5
1/8/16 RELIANCE ON JURY DEMAND nik 1/11/16
DEF 3
DEF 5
1/8/16 PROOF OF SERVICE nik 1/11/16
1/8/16 RE-NOTICE OF HEARING nik 1/11/16
1/11/16 RE-PRAECIPE nik 1/11/16
1/13/16 PROOF OF SERVICE nik 1/14/16
1/19/16 MOTION 1/19/16 10:00 AM mlk 1/19/16
CANCELLED
OTHER
KATHY FROM ATTYS OFFICE CALLED WILL RESCHEDULE FOR 2 WEEKS OUT
1/19/16 ANSWER TO MOTION RE PROTECTIVE ORDER nik 1/20/16
PTF 1
1/19/16 BRIEF FILED RE PROTECTIVE ORDER nik 1/20/16
PTF 1
1/21/16 ENTRY OF PRETRIAL SCHEDULING ORDER NO
APPEARANCE NECESSARY
SET 2/5/16 3:00 P ljn 1/21/16
LOC: 3500
1/21/16 MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER SET 2/1/16 10:00 A ljn 1/21/16
LOC: 3500
1/21/16 NOTICE TO APPEAR nik 1/21/16
1/21/16 PRE-TRIAL SCHEDULING ORDER nik 1/21/16
1/21/16 RE-NOTICE OF HEARING nik 1/21/16
1/21/16 RELIANCE UPON AFFIDAVIT OF MERITOROUS DEFENSE nik 1/21/16
DEF 1
1/22/16 RE-PRAECIPE nik 1/25/16
2/1/16 MOTION 2/1/16 10:00 AM ljn 2/1/16
COURT REPORTER: K TORRES, #4247 CSR
MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER GRANTED; ORDER TO BE SUBMITTED.
HELD
STATE OF MICHIGAN
31ST CIRCUIT COURT
ST CLAIR COUNTY
REGISTER
OF
ACTIONS
CASE ID
15-002567-NH
C/C31/S
Public
3/3/2018
9:44:58 AM
Page: 3 of 12
Activity Date Activity User Entry Date
2/4/16 NOTICE OF PRESENTMENT - 7 DAY PROTECTIVE ORDER RE:EXPARTE
MEETINGS
nik 2/4/16
DEF 1
2/4/16 STIPULATION AND ORDER TO AMEND PT STATEMENT & CASE
SCHEDULING ORDER/STIPULATION & ORDER TO AMEND CASE
SCHEDULING ORDER
nik 2/4/16
2/10/16 AFFIDAVIT OF MERITOREOUS DEFENSE MARK J THOMSON MD nik 2/11/16
2/10/16 PROOF OF SERVICE nik 2/11/16
2/11/16 PROOF OF SERVICE nik 2/11/16
2/17/16 SEVEN DAY ORDER **SIGNED** RE: PROTECTIVE ORDER nik 2/18/16
2/18/16 RELIANCE ON AFFIDAVIT OF MERITORIOUS DEFENSE FILED ON
BEHALF
nik 2/19/16
DEF 2
DEF 4
2/24/16 PROOF OF SERVICE nik 2/26/16
3/4/16 AFFIDAVIT MERITORIOUS DEFENSE OF MARC WEISMANDO nik 3/4/16
3/4/16 PROOF OF SERVICE nik 3/4/16
4/18/16 MOTION MT TO COMPEL DISOCERY $20.00 mlp
mlp
4/18/16
4/18/16
PTF 1
DEF 5
4/18/16 RECEIVABLE MOTION FEE $20.00 mlp 4/18/16
4/18/16 PAYMENT $20.00 mlp 4/18/16
RECEIPT NUMBER: C31.0016175
METHOD: CHECK $20.00
4/18/16 NOTICE OF HEARING nik 4/18/16
4/18/16 PROOF OF SERVICE nik 4/18/16
4/18/16 MOTION TO COMPEL CANCELLED 5/2/16 10:00 A mlk 4/18/16
LOC: 3500
4/19/16 PRAECIPE nik 4/20/16
4/26/16 MOTION 5/2/16 10:00 AM mlk 4/26/16
CANCELLED
OTHER
KAREN FROM ATTYS OFFICE CALLED AND REMOVED - WILL SET BACK ON FOR 5/9
4/28/16 MOTION TO COMPEL CANCELLED 5/9/16 10:00 A ljn 4/28/16
LOC: 3500
4/28/16 RE-NOTICE OF HEARING nik 4/29/16
4/28/16 PROOF OF SERVICE nik 4/29/16
4/29/16 PRAECIPE kab 5/2/16
5/2/16 RESPONSE CONCURRENCE IN MOT TO COMPEL DISCOVERY kab 5/2/16
5/4/16 JOINDER IN MOTION TO COMPEL nik 5/4/16
DEF 1
5/5/16 MOTION TO COMPEL CANCELLED 5/16/16 10:00 A ljn 5/5/16
LOC: 3500
5/5/16 RE-NOTICE OF HEARING nik 5/5/16
5/5/16 PROOF OF SERVICE nik 5/5/16
STATE OF MICHIGAN
31ST CIRCUIT COURT
ST CLAIR COUNTY
REGISTER
OF
ACTIONS
CASE ID
15-002567-NH
C/C31/S
Public
3/3/2018
9:44:58 AM
Page: 4 of 12
Activity Date Activity User Entry Date
5/6/16 RE-PRAECIPE nik 5/6/16
5/9/16 MOTION 5/9/16 10:00 AM ljn 5/9/16
CANCELLED
ADJOURNED WITHOUT A DATE
RE-PRAECIPED FOR 5/16.
5/12/16 MOTION 5/16/16 10:00 AM ljn 5/12/16
CANCELLED
ISSUE SETTLED
5/13/16 STIPULATION AND ORDER COMPELLING PLTFS ANSWERS TO DEF nik 5/16/16
5/17/16 STIPULATION AND ORDER COMPELLING DISCOVERY nik 5/18/16
5/23/16 PROOF OF SERVICE nik 5/23/16
5/23/16 STIPULATION AND ORDER TO PROVIDE DEF'S W/ ANSWERS TO
INTERROGATORIES & REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION
nik 5/24/16
6/16/16 NOTICE OF DEPOSITION SCOTT LANGELL nik 6/17/16
6/17/16 PROOF OF SERVICE nik 6/17/16
7/1/16 MOTION ADJOURN SCHEDULING ORD 90 DAYS $20.00 mlp
mlp
7/1/16
7/1/16
PTF 1
7/1/16 RECEIVABLE MOTION FEE $20.00 mlp 7/1/16
7/1/16 PAYMENT $20.00 mlp 7/1/16
RECEIPT NUMBER: C31.0020159
METHOD: CHECK $20.00
7/1/16 MOTION TO ADJOURN SCHEDULING ORDER 90 DAYS SET 7/11/16 10:00 A ljn 7/1/16
LOC: 3500
7/1/16 BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF MOTION ADJOURN SCHEDULING ORDER W/
NOTICE OF HEARING
nik 7/1/16
PTF 1
7/1/16 WITNESS LIST nik 7/1/16
PTF 1
7/5/16 PRAECIPE nik 7/5/16
7/7/16 CONCURRENCE TO ADJOURN SCHEDULING ORDER nik 7/7/16
DEF 2
DEF 4
7/7/16 CONCURRENCE TO ADJOURN SCHEDULING ORDER nik 7/7/16
DEF 1
7/11/16 MOTION 7/11/16 10:00 AM mlk 7/11/16
COURT REPORTER: K TORRES, #4247 CSR
MOTION TO ADJOURN SCHEDULING ORDER 90 DAYS - GRANTED. ORDER TO BE SUBMITTED.
HELD
7/19/16 STIPULATION AND ORDER ADJOURNMENT nik 7/19/16
10/24/16 PROOF OF SERVICE nik 10/24/16
11/1/16 EXHIBIT LIST nik 11/2/16
DEF 1
11/1/16 WITNESS LIST nik 11/2/16
DEF 1
STATE OF MICHIGAN
31ST CIRCUIT COURT
ST CLAIR COUNTY
REGISTER
OF
ACTIONS
CASE ID
15-002567-NH
C/C31/S
Public
3/3/2018
9:44:58 AM
Page: 5 of 12
Activity Date Activity User Entry Date
11/4/16 WITNESS LIST nik 11/4/16
DEF 3
DEF 5
11/4/16 EXHIBIT LIST AND WITNESS nik 11/4/16
DEF 2
DEF 4
11/4/16 WITNESS LIST nik 11/4/16
11/4/16 NOTICE OF DEPOSITION nik 11/4/16
11/8/16 PROOF OF SERVICE nik 11/8/16
12/15/16 EXHIBIT LIST nik 12/16/16
DEF 1
12/15/16 WITNESS LIST nik 12/16/16
DEF 1
1/4/17 ADR NOTICE TO APPEAR nik 1/4/17
1/9/17 MOTION TO COMPEL/ADJOURN SCHEDULING ORDER 90
DAYS
SET 1/23/17 10:00 A mlk 1/9/17
LOC: 3500
1/9/17 MOTION SECOND MT TO ADJOURN SCHEDULING ORDER $20.00 mlp
mlp
1/9/17
1/9/17
PTF 1
1/9/17 RECEIVABLE MOTION FEE $20.00 mlp 1/9/17
1/9/17 PAYMENT $20.00 mlp 1/9/17
RECEIPT NUMBER: C31.0030424
METHOD: CHECK $20.00
1/9/17 MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY $20.00 mlp
mlp
1/9/17
1/9/17
DEF 3
1/9/17 RECEIVABLE MOTION FEE $20.00 mlp 1/9/17
1/9/17 PAYMENT $20.00 mlp 1/9/17
RECEIPT NUMBER: C31.0030426
METHOD: CHECK $20.00
1/10/17 PRAECIPE nik 1/10/17
1/10/17 PRAECIPE nik 1/10/17
1/11/17 CONCURRENCE TO ADJOURN SCHEDULING ORDER nik 1/11/17
DEF 2
DEF 4
1/12/17 RE-NOTICE OF HEARING nik 1/12/17
1/12/17 PROOF OF SERVICE nik 1/12/17
1/13/17 PROOF OF SERVICE nik 1/13/17
1/13/17 CONCURRENCE W/ PLTD MOTION TO ADJOURN ORDER DATES nik 1/13/17
DEF 3
DEF 5
1/13/17 RE-PRAECIPE nik 1/13/17
1/20/17 CONCURRENCE IN PLTFS MOTION TO ADJOURN ORDER 90 DAYS nik 1/20/17
DEF 1
STATE OF MICHIGAN
31ST CIRCUIT COURT
ST CLAIR COUNTY
REGISTER
OF
ACTIONS
CASE ID
15-002567-NH
C/C31/S
Public
3/3/2018
9:44:58 AM
Page: 6 of 12
Activity Date Activity User Entry Date
1/23/17 MOTION 1/23/17 10:00 AM mlk
mlk
1/23/17
1/23/17
MOTION TO ADJOURN SCHEDULING ORDER DATES 90 DAYS - GRANTED. ORDER TO BE
SUBMITTED WITH TRIAL DATE AND FACILITATION DATE. MOTION TO COMPEL HAS BEEN
AGREED UPON, WILL SUBMIT ORDER.
HELD
1/31/17 JURY TRIAL RESCHEDULED 10/17/17 9:00 A mlk 1/31/17
LOC: 3500
2/1/17 STIPULATION AND ORDER COMPELLING ANS TO INTERROGATORIES kab 2/1/17
2/1/17 ORDER ADJ SCHEDULING DATES kab 2/1/17
2/1/17 NOTICE TO APPEAR kab 2/1/17
2/13/17 NOTICE OF DEPOSITION nik 2/13/17
3/6/17 NOTICE OF DEPOSITION nik 3/7/17
3/16/17 NOTICE OF DEPOSITION nik 3/16/17
3/17/17 NOTICE OF DEPOSITION nik 3/17/17
3/20/17 MOTION DETERMANATION OF WITNESS FEE $20.00 nik
nik
3/20/17
3/20/17
DEF 3
DEF 5
3/20/17 RECEIVABLE MOTION FEE $20.00 nik 3/20/17
3/20/17 PAYMENT $20.00 nik 3/20/17
RECEIPT NUMBER: C31.0034510
METHOD: ELECTRONIC FUND TRANSFER $20.00
3/21/17 MOTION MORE REASONABLE EXPERT WITNESS FEE SET 3/27/17 10:00 A mlk 3/21/17
LOC: 3500
3/21/17 PRAECIPE nik 3/22/17
3/23/17 ANSWER TO MOTION RE MOTION DETERMINATION nik 3/23/17
PTF 1
3/27/17 MOTION 3/27/17 10:00 AM ljn 3/27/17
COURT REPORTER: K TORRES, #4247 CSR
MOTION FOR MORE REASONABLE EXPERT WITNESS FEE DENIED; ORDER TO BE
SUBMITTED.
HELD
3/30/17 PROOF OF SERVICE nik 3/30/17
3/30/17 NOTICE OF DEPOSITION FINLEY BROWN nik 3/30/17
3/31/17 NOTICE OF PRESENTMENT - 7 DAY kab 3/31/17
3/31/17 PROOF OF SERVICE kab 3/31/17
4/3/17 NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITIONS DE BENE ESSE kab 4/4/17
4/3/17 PROOF OF SERVICE kab 4/4/17
4/6/17 NOTICE OF DEPOSITION PETER FARIES MD kab 4/7/17
4/11/17 SEVEN DAY ORDER ***SIGNED***DENYING DEF MOTION nik
nik
4/11/17
4/11/17
5/12/17 NOTICE OF DEPOSITION nik 5/12/17
5/16/17 PROOF OF SERVICE nik 5/16/17
6/6/17 STIPULATION AND ORDER RE CASE EVAL nik 6/6/17
6/12/17 PROOF OF SERVICE nik 6/12/17
9/12/17 NOTICE OF CONFLICT FOR TRIAL nik 9/12/17
STATE OF MICHIGAN
31ST CIRCUIT COURT
ST CLAIR COUNTY
REGISTER
OF
ACTIONS
CASE ID
15-002567-NH
C/C31/S
Public
3/3/2018
9:44:58 AM
Page: 7 of 12
Activity Date Activity User Entry Date
DEF 1
9/18/17 MOTION DEF MCLAREN PH FOR SUMMARY DISPOSITION $20.00 dkf
dkf
9/18/17
9/18/17
DEF 1
9/18/17 RECEIVABLE MOTION FEE $20.00 dkf 9/18/17
9/18/17 PAYMENT $20.00 dkf 9/18/17
RECEIPT NUMBER: C31.0044737
METHOD: CHECK $20.00
9/19/17 MOTION SUMMARY DISPOSITON (PORT HURON
HOPSITAL)
CANCELLED 10/9/17 10:00 A mlk 9/19/17
LOC: 3500
9/20/17 MOTION TO RESCHEDULE TRIAL $20.00 pm
pm
9/20/17
9/20/17
DEF 1
9/20/17 RECEIVABLE MOTION FEE $20.00 pm 9/20/17
9/20/17 PAYMENT $20.00 pm 9/20/17
RECEIPT NUMBER: C31.0044885
METHOD: CHECK $20.00
9/20/17 PRAECIPE nik 9/20/17
9/21/17 CONCURRENCE SUMMARY DISPO nik 9/21/17
DEF 1
9/21/17 MOTION TO RESCHEDULE TRIAL/TO STRIKE SUMMARY
DISPOSITION MOTION
SET 10/2/17 10:00 A ljn 9/21/17
LOC: 3500
9/22/17 PRAECIPE nik 9/22/17
9/22/17 BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF MOTION nik 9/25/17
PTF 1
9/22/17 NOTICE OF HEARING nik 9/25/17
9/25/17 CONCURRENCE SUMMARY DISPO nik 9/25/17
DEF 5
9/25/17 MOTION ADJOURNMENT $20.00 nik
nik
9/25/17
9/25/17
DEF 2
9/25/17 RECEIVABLE MOTION FEE $20.00 nik 9/25/17
9/25/17 PAYMENT $20.00 nik 9/25/17
RECEIPT NUMBER: C31.0045128
METHOD: CHECK $20.00
9/26/17 PRAECIPE nik 9/26/17
9/27/17 PRAECIPE nik 9/27/17
9/27/17 ANSWER TO MOTION SUMMARY DISPO nik 9/27/17
DEF 1
9/28/17 RE-NOTICE OF HEARING nik 9/28/17
9/28/17 ANSWER TO MOTION RESCHEDULE TRIAL nik 9/29/17
PTF 1
9/28/17 ANSWER TO MOTION ADJOURNMENT OF TRIAL nik 9/29/17
PTF 1
STATE OF MICHIGAN
31ST CIRCUIT COURT
ST CLAIR COUNTY
REGISTER
OF
ACTIONS
CASE ID
15-002567-NH
C/C31/S
Public
3/3/2018
9:44:58 AM
Page: 8 of 12
Activity Date Activity User Entry Date
9/29/17 ANSWER TO MOTION RESCHEDULE TRIAL nik 9/29/17
DEF 5
10/2/17 MOTION 10/2/17 10:00 AM mlk 10/2/17
COURT REPORTER: K TORRES, #4247 CSR
MOTION TO RESCHEDULE TRIAL - ASK ATTYS TO TALK; MOTION TO STRIKE SUMMARY
DISPOSITION - DENIED.
HELD
10/2/17 JURY TRIAL 10/17/17 9:00 AM mlk 10/2/17
RESCHEDULED TO: 2/21/18 9:00 AM
REQUESTED BY DEFENDANT/ATTORNEY
10/2/17 JURY TRIAL SET 2/21/18 9:00 A mlk 10/2/17
LOC: 3500
10/2/17 NOTICE TO APPEAR nik 10/2/17
10/3/17 MOTION 10/9/17 10:00 AM mlk 10/3/17
CANCELLED
OTHER
KATHY FROM ATTYS OFFICE CALLED TO REMOVE FROOM DOCKET WILL SET BACK ON FOR
10/23
10/5/17 ORDER DENYING PLTFS MOTION TO STRIKE nik 10/5/17
10/5/17 RE-NOTICE OF HEARING nik 10/5/17
10/5/17 MOTION SUMMARY DISPOSITION CANCELLED 10/23/17 10:00 A ljn 10/5/17
LOC: 3500
10/6/17 RE-PRAECIPE nik 10/9/17
10/9/17 ORDER ADJOURN TRIAL nik 10/9/17
10/16/17 PROOF OF SERVICE nik 10/16/17
10/16/17 ANSWER TO MOTION SUMMARY DISPO nik 10/17/17
PTF 1
10/17/17 MOTION 10/23/17 10:00 AM mlk 10/17/17
CANCELLED
OTHER
KATHY FROM ATTYS OFFICE CALLED AND REMOVED FROM DOCKET WILL SET BACK ON FOR
10/30
10/18/17 RE-NOTICE OF HEARING nik 10/18/17
10/18/17 MOTION FOR SUMMARY DISPOSITION CANCELLED 10/30/17 10:00 A mlk 10/18/17
LOC: 3500
10/18/17 RE-PRAECIPE nik 10/19/17
10/24/17 MOTION FOR SUMMARY DISPOSITION 10/30/17 10:00 AM mlk 10/24/17
CANCELLED
OTHER
KATHY FROM ATTYS OFFICE CALLED AND TOOK OFF DOCKET WILL SET BACK ON FOR 11/6
10/26/17 RE-NOTICE OF HEARING nik 10/26/17
10/27/17 MOTION FOR SUMMARY DISPOSITION SET 11/6/17 10:00 A mlk 10/27/17
LOC: 3500
10/27/17 RE-PRAECIPE nik 10/27/17
11/6/17 MOTION FOR SUMMARY DISPOSITION 11/6/17 10:00 AM mlk 11/6/17
STATE OF MICHIGAN
31ST CIRCUIT COURT
ST CLAIR COUNTY
REGISTER
OF
ACTIONS
CASE ID
15-002567-NH
C/C31/S
Public
3/3/2018
9:44:58 AM
Page: 9 of 12
Activity Date Activity User Entry Date
COURT REPORTER: K TORRES, #4247 CSR
MOTION FOR SUMMARY DISPOSITION - TAKEN UNDER ADVISEMENT. OPINION TO BE ISSUED.
HELD
11/15/17 ADR ENVELOPE nik 11/15/17
11/30/17 PROOF OF SERVICE nik 11/30/17
11/30/17 OPINION AND ORDER SUMMARY DISPO DENIED nik 11/30/17
DEF 1
12/6/17 ADR ENVELOPE nik 12/7/17
1/22/18 NOTICE OF DEPOSITION nik 1/22/18
1/22/18 PROOF OF SERVICE nik 1/22/18
1/29/18 MOTION IN LIMINE RE SPECULATIVE ECONOCMIC DAMAGES $20.00 mlp
mlp
1/29/18
1/29/18
DEF 4
1/29/18 RECEIVABLE MOTION FEE $20.00 mlp 1/29/18
1/29/18 PAYMENT $20.00 mlp 1/29/18
RECEIPT NUMBER: C31.0051565
METHOD: CHECK $20.00
1/29/18 NOTICE OF PRESENTMENT - 7 DAY SUMMARY DISPO nik 1/29/18
1/29/18 PROOF OF SERVICE nik 1/29/18
1/29/18 NOTICE OF DEPOSITION nik 1/29/18
1/29/18 NOTICE OF HEARING nik 1/29/18
1/29/18 BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF MOTION nik 1/29/18
DEF 4
1/30/18 MOTION IN LIMINE CANCELLED 2/5/18 10:00 A mlk 1/30/18
LOC: 3500
1/30/18 MOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE REFERENCE TO LIABILITY
INSURANCE COMPANY
$20.00 pm
pm
1/30/18
1/30/18
DEF 5
1/30/18 RECEIVABLE MOTION FEE $20.00 pm 1/30/18
1/30/18 PAYMENT $20.00 pm 1/30/18
RECEIPT NUMBER: C31.0051607
METHOD: CHECK $20.00
1/30/18 MOTION IN LIMINE(6) DEFENDANTS (TIMOTHY
HORRIGAN, M.D.)/ IN LIMINE (DR. PAUL AND PHYSICIAN
HEALTHCARE)
SET 2/12/18 10:00 A mlk 1/30/18
LOC: 3500
1/30/18 PRAECIPE nik 1/30/18
1/31/18 PRAECIPE MULTIPLES nik 1/31/18
2/1/18 MOTION 2/5/18 10:00 AM mlk 2/1/18
CANCELLED
OTHER
VIVIAN CALLED FROM ATTYS OFFICE TO REMOVE WILL SET ON FOR 2/12
2/1/18 CONCURRENCE RE:SPECULATIVE ECONOMIC DAMAGES nik 2/2/18
DEF 1
2/2/18 CONCURRENCE SPECULATIVE ECONOMIC DAMAGES nik 2/2/18
DEF 3
STATE OF MICHIGAN
31ST CIRCUIT COURT
ST CLAIR COUNTY
REGISTER
OF
ACTIONS
CASE ID
15-002567-NH
C/C31/S
Public
3/3/2018
9:44:58 AM
Page: 10 of 12
Activity Date Activity User Entry Date
DEF 5
2/2/18 PROOF OF SERVICE nik 2/2/18
2/2/18 PROOF OF SERVICE nik 2/2/18
2/2/18 MOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE PLTF FROM INTRODUCING AUTOPSY
PHOTO INTO EVIDENCE AT TRIAL
$20.00 mlp
mlp
2/2/18
2/2/18
DEF 3
2/2/18 RECEIVABLE MOTION FEE $20.00 mlp 2/2/18
2/2/18 PAYMENT $20.00 mlp 2/2/18
RECEIPT NUMBER: C31.0051822
METHOD: CHECK $20.00
2/2/18 BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF MOTION nik 2/2/18
DEF 3
2/5/18 CONCURRENCE MOTION IN LIMINE /PROOF kab 2/6/18
2/6/18 PRAECIPE kab 2/6/18
2/6/18 COMMENT kab 2/6/18
SENT 7 DAY TO JUDGE FOR SIGNATURE
2/7/18 RE-PRAECIPE kab 2/8/18
2/8/18 RESPONSE TO MOT IN LIMINE kab 2/8/18
2/8/18 RESPONSE TO MOT IN LIMINE kab 2/8/18
2/8/18 RESPONSE TO MOT IN LIMINE kab 2/8/18
2/8/18 RESPONSE TO MOT IN LIMINE kab 2/8/18
2/12/18 MOTION 2/12/18 10:00 AM mlk 2/12/18
COURT REPORTER: K TORRES, #4247 CSR
MOTION IN LIMINE (6) DEFENDANT TIMOTHY HORRIGAN, M.D. - TAKEN UNDER ADVISEMENT
AND OPINION TO BE ISSUED. MOTION IN LIMINE DR. PAUL/PHYSICIAN HEALTHCARE - TAKEN
UNDER ADVISEMENT AND OPINION TO BE ISSUED.
HELD
2/13/18 SEVEN DAY ORDER ***SIGNED*** DENYING SUMMARY DISPO nik 2/13/18
2/13/18 PROOF OF SERVICE nik 2/14/18
2/13/18 OPINION AND ORDER MOTION RE DAMAGES DENIED- ORDER TO BE
SUBMITTED
nik 2/14/18
DEF 1
2/20/18 PROOF OF SERVICE nik 2/20/18
2/20/18 ORDER PRECLUDE PLTF FROM QUESTIONING DEF'S WITNESS ABOUT
MALPRACTICE SUITS
nik 2/21/18
2/20/18 ORDER PRECLUDE REFERENCE TO LIABILITY INSURANCE nik 2/21/18
2/20/18 ORDER PRECLUDE USE OF AUTOPSY PHOTOS nik 2/21/18
2/21/18 JURY TRIAL 2/21/18 9:00 AM mlk 2/22/18
COURT REPORTER: K TORRES, #4247 CSR
JURY SELECTION - OPENING STATEMENTS - TESTIMONY BEGINS
HELD
2/21/18 JURY TRIAL SET 2/22/18 9:30 A mlk 2/22/18
LOC: 3500
2/22/18 JURY TRIAL 2/22/18 9:30 AM mlk 2/22/18
TESTIMONY CONTINUED
HELD
STATE OF MICHIGAN
31ST CIRCUIT COURT
ST CLAIR COUNTY
REGISTER
OF
ACTIONS
CASE ID
15-002567-NH
C/C31/S
Public
3/3/2018
9:44:58 AM
Page: 11 of 12
Activity Date Activity User Entry Date
2/22/18 JURY TRIAL SET 2/23/18 9:30 A mlk 2/22/18
LOC: 3500
2/23/18 JURY TRIAL 2/23/18 9:30 AM mlk 2/23/18
TESTIMONY CONTINUED
HELD
2/23/18 JURY TRIAL SET 2/27/18 9:00 A mlk 2/23/18
LOC: 3500
2/27/18 TRANSCRIPT ****EXCERPT OF JURY TRIAL TESTIMONY OF FINLEY
BROWN-2-23-18***
nik 2/27/18
2/27/18 TRANSCRIPT ****EXCERPT OF JURY TRIAL TESTIMONY OF ROBERT
MULLIKEN 2-22-18***
nik 2/27/18
2/27/18 JURY TRIAL 2/27/18 9:00 AM mlk
mlk
2/27/18
2/28/18
COURT REPORTER: K TORRES, #4247 CSR
MOTION TO DISMISS MADE BY MR. WARWICK (ATTY FOR MCLAREN) - GRANTED; ORDER TO
BE SUBMITTED; TESTIMONY CONTINUES
HELD
2/27/18 JURY TRIAL SET 2/28/18 9:00 A mlk 2/27/18
LOC: 3500
2/28/18 JURY TRIAL HALF DAY mlk 2/28/18
COURT REPORTER: K TORRES, #4247 CSR
TESTIMONY COMPLETED
HELD
2/28/18 JURY TRIAL SET 3/1/18 9:00 A mlk 2/28/18
LOC: 3500
3/1/18 NOTICE OF PRESENTMENT - 7 DAY GRANTING MOTION FOR DIRECTED
VERDICT
nik 3/1/18
3/1/18 JURY TRIAL 3/1/18 9:00 AM mlk 3/1/18
COURT REPORTER: K TORRES, #4247 CSR
CLOSING ARGUMENTS - JURY INSTRUCTIONS - VERDICT
DEF 4 MICHAEL PAUL
HELD
DISPOSITION: JUDGMENT FOR PLAINTIFF - JURY VERDICT
3/1/18 JURY TRIAL mlk 3/1/18
COURT REPORTER: K TORRES, #4247 CSR
DEF 3 PARTRIDGE FAMILY PHYSICIANS PC
DEF 5 TIMOTHY HORRIGAN

Outcome: Plaintiff's verdict for $3.5 million in past non-economic damages and $490,000 in past economic damages against Dr. Micahel Pauland Physicians Healthcare Network. The jury returned a defendant's verdict in favor of Dr. Horrigan.

Plaintiff's Experts:

Defendant's Experts:

Comments:



 
 
Home | Add Attorney | Add Expert | Add Court Reporter | Sign In
Find-A-Lawyer By City | Find-A-Lawyer By State and City | Articles | Recent Lawyer Listings
Verdict Corrections | Link Errors | Advertising | Editor | Privacy Statement
© 1996-2018 MoreLaw, Inc. - All rights reserved.