| New Jersey Jury Verdicts, Settlements and Court Decisions |
| |
|
Merck & Co., Inc. v. Apotex, Inc. and Apotex Corporation
|
|
Appellants Apotex, Inc. and Apotex Corporation appeal from the final judgment of dismissal of their counterclaims for declaratory judgment against appellee Merck & Co., Inc. Because we find that the current dispute does not ââadmi[t] of specific relief through a decree of a conclusive character, as distinguished from an opinion advising what the law would be upon a hypothetical state of facts,... More... $0 (08-21-2008 - NJ)
|
|
New Jersey Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, et al. v. New Jersey Department of Agriculture, et al.
|
|
In 1996, with little discernable fanfare, the Legislature enacted a new section of the existing statute regulating animal cruelty. Although that statute, since at least 1898, had essentially left animal welfare and the protection of animals to the New Jersey Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (âNJSPCAâ) and its related county organizations, the Legislature decreed that the Depart... More... $0 (07-30-2008 - NJ)
|
|
Jason Cutler v. Theodore Dorn, Robert Shreve and Borough of Haddonfield
|
|
This appeal involves a claim brought under the Law Against Discrimination (LAD), N.J.S.A. 10:5-1 to -49, by a Jewish police officer who alleged that he was subjected to a hostile work environment based on his religion and ancestry. The principle issue before us is whether the trial court erred in denying a motion for involuntary dismissal and allowing the claim to be decided by the jury. The jury ... More... $0 (08-05-2008 - NJ)
|
|
Beth Godfrey, et al. v. Princeton Theological Seminary
|
|
In Lehmann v. Toys âRâ Us, Inc., 132 N.J. 587 (1993), Justice Garibaldi, writing for this Court, delineated the standards of proof that are necessary in order to bring a discrimination claim premised on acts of sexual harassment. To demonstrate a discriminatory hostile environment caused by
sexual harassment, a plaintiff must show that âthe complained-of conduct (1) would not have occ... More... $0 (08-05-2008 - NJ)
|
|
Blase J. Toto, et al. v. Sheriff's Officer Rolando Ensuar, et al.
|
|
In this case we decide whether the verbal threshold, N.J.S.A. 59:9-2(d), of the New Jersey Tort Claims Act (Act), N.J.S.A. 59:1-1 to 12-3, which essentially requires an objective permanent injury to recover damages, applies to a willful misconduct claim against a public employee. Additionally, we decide whether the trial courtâs failure to charge the jury that the Actâs good faith defense, N.J... More... $0 (08-05-2008 - NJ)
|
|
Jill Golden and Sheldon Golden v. GMAC Insurance Company
|
|
Plaintiff, Jill Golden,1 was allegedly injured on April 9,
1999, when her vehicle was struck from behind by a vehicle
driven by Walter Koonce and owned by Koonce's employer, Access
Corporation. Plaintiff instituted a personal injury suit in the
Law Division on March 29, 2001, against Koonce and his employer.
At the time of the accident, Koonce and his employer were
covered by a liability ins... More... $0 (06-24-2008 - NJ)
|
|
Wartsila NDS North America v. Hill International v. John H. Clegg, et al.
|
|
Hill International, Inc. ("Hill") appeals from the denial of a
post-trial motion it called a "Motion to Mold the Verdict and Enter
Judgment Consistent with the Parties' Written Contract" ("the
Motion"). Hill was found liable for negligence and breach of its
contract with Wartsila NSD North America, Inc. ("Wartsila"). The
jury awarded Wartsila $2,047,952 in damages.
Hill filed its Moti... More... $1 (06-24-2008 - NJ)
|
|
Nicholas Saffos v. Avaya, Inc. and M. Foster Werner, Jr.
|
|
Nicholas Saffos sued Avaya, Inc. and M. Foster Warner, Jr. on an age discrimination theory claiming that he was fired as business relationship manager in Avaya's real estate department on September 23, 2003 as part of a purge of older workers. The average age of those fired was 49 and those who replaced them 35 according the Plaintiff. Saffos, then 49, was replaced by someone 14 years younger.
... More... $10743000 (06-20-2008 - NJ)
|
|
Family and Estate of Sohayla Massachi v. City of Newark
|
|
The Family and Estate of Sohayla Massachi sued the City of Newark on a governmental tort claim negligence theory claiming that as a direct result of the City's 911 operator's failure to use due care, Ms. Massachi was murdered by her ex-boyfriend in 2000. Plaintiffs claimed that Sohayla was killed by her ex-boyfriend because 911 personnel botched a call reporting the woman's abduction. They furthe... More... $5500000 (05-31-2008 - NJ)
|
|
Robert Still v. Orkin
|
|
Robert Still sued Orkin on whistleblower and retaliation theories claiming a violation of the New Jersey Conscientious Employee Protection Act for firing him after he complained of illegal activities on the part of Orkin where he worked. Robert Still, 50, told a regional manager in 2003 that his Pennsauken branch was illegally applying insecticides. Still was fired the next day. Still worked for O... More... $5112184 (05-10-2008 - NJ)
|
|
Nilda Gutierrez, et al. v. Johnson & Johnson
|
|
Petitioners are former employees of Johnson &
Johnson. They allege that Johnson & Johnson discriminated
against them on the basis of their race. Petitioners attempted
to certify a class of plaintiffs that encompassed any African-
American or Hispanic employee of Johnson & Johnson or any
of its United States subsidiaries who was employed at any
time during an approximately ten-year period. Th... More... $0 (04-22-2008 - NJ)
|
|
Family and Estate of Steven Motelson v. Ford Motor Company
|
|
The family and estates of Steven Motelson, age 60, his grandson and others sued Ford Motor Company on a products liability theory claiming that the roof support system on the 1998 Ford Explorer that Motelson was driving was defective and unreasonably dangerous and, as a direct result, the roof sheared away exposing Motelson to fatal head injuries. Motelson. 9-year-old grandson, who was a passenge... More... $6500000 (03-29-2008 - NJ)
|
|
Bonnie Kowalski v. Aravind Palav
|
|
Bonnie Kowalski, individually and on behalf of her son, Brandon Kowalski, sued Dr. Aravind Palav on a medical negligence (medical malpractice) theory claiming that Dr. Palav acted below the standard of care when he cared for Mrs. Kowalski during her pregnancy with Brando and, as a result result of Dr. Palav's failure to exercise due care, Brandon suffered brain damage that left him completely and ... More... $19000000 (03-19-2008 - NJ)
|
|
The Business Edge Group, Inc. v. Champion Mortgage Company, Inc.
|
|
This case involves a company, The Business Edge Group,
Inc. ("Business Edge"), which targeted and subscribed to a vanity
toll free telephone number in order to take advantage of the value
it presented to Champion Mortgage Company, Inc. ("Champion").1
The issue we address is whether Business Edge's actions violated
an FCC regulation which prohibits entities from acquiring toll free
telephone ... More... $0 (03-13-2008 - NJ)
|
|
Warner Lambert Company v. LIP Profit International, Inc., et al.
|
|
Warner-Lambert Company ("Warner-Lambert") appeals
from the District Court's entry of final judgment limiting the
liability of Federal Express Corporation ("FedEx"), LEP Profit
International Inc. ("LEP Profit"), and LEP International (Japan),
Ltd. ("LEP Japan") to $9.07 per pound, pursuant to Article 22(2)
of the Warsaw Convention, for pharmaceutical cargo destroyed
when a FedEx plane crashed... More... $0 (02-29-2008 - NJ)
|
|
Aaliyah N. Alvarado, etc. v. J & J Snack Corp.
|
|
Petitioner Aaliyah Nicole Alvarado appeals from that
portion of the Workers' Compensation order limiting the award of
fees to Alvarado's attorney on the ground that N.J.S.A. 34:15-
64(c) did not permit the Workers' Compensation judge to award
more than $50. The judge also found that, even if there was an
exception to that statute, respondent J & J Snack Foods Corp. (J
& J), the employer... More... $0 (01-08-2008 - NJ)
|
|
Rosemary Connell v. Edward Diehl
|
|
In this quintessential palimony action, defendant Edward
Diehl appeals from a December 6, 2005, judgment in favor of
plaintiff Rosemary Connell awarding $107,494.40 in palimony,
$70,000 as a return of an inheritance Connell received in 1997
and gave to Diehl and $15,000 in counsel fees, less a partial
payment of $36,000 from Diehl to Connell after they separated.
Connell cross-appeals f... More... $0 (01-14-2008 - NJ)
|
|
Erica D. Vitanza v. Sam H. James, Jr. a/k/a Samuel James
|
|
Defendant appeals from an order granting summary judgment
to plaintiff on liability and denying defendant's motion to
dismiss plaintiff's complaint which alleged libel and slander by
defendant. However, leave to appeal was neither sought nor
obtained.1 Accordingly, we dismiss the appeal.
We may grant leave to appeal from interlocutory orders,
including those granting partial summar... More... $0 (01-09-2008 - NJ)
|
|
People For Open Government, et al. v. David Roberts, in his capacity as Mayor of Hoboken, etc., et al.
|
|
In this appeal we must determine whether four individual
plaintiffs, Ann Graham, Robert T. DuVal, Alice Crozier and James
D. Vance, and People for Open Government (POG), an organization
of which they are members, have standing to challenge what they
claim to be a lack of enforcement of an ordinance adopted by the
City of Hoboken (the City) designed to curtail the nefarious
practice of "... More... $0 (01-09-2008 - NJ)
|
|
Noel Gowran v. Wawa, Inc. and Countryway Insurance Company
|
|
In this appeal, we hold that an intervenor was not required
to personally serve a third-party complaint that sought relief
from plaintiff, but was only required to serve the pleading on
plaintiff's attorney of record.
Plaintiff Noel Gowran filed a complaint against defendant
Wawa, Inc., in which he sought damages for personal injuries
allegedly sustained while a patron of defendant... More... $0 (01-13-2008 - NJ)
|
|
W.H. Industries, Inc. v. Fundicao Balancins, Ltda
|
|
In April 2005, plaintiff, W.H. Industries, Inc., a
corporation located in New Jersey, sued defendant, Fundicao
Balancins, Ltda, a company located in Brazil, in the Law
Division, Bergen County. The complaint alleged breach of
contract. In August 2005, defendant filed a motion to dismiss
the New Jersey complaint for lack of jurisdiction based on
improper service of process, lack of person... More... $0 (01-13-2008 - NJ)
|
|
Pond Run Watershed Association, etc. v. Township of Hamilton Zoning Board of Adjustment and Crestwood Construction, LLC
|
|
Plaintiffs, several residents of Hamilton Township ("the
Township") and a watershed preservation advocacy group, seek to
invalidate numerous use and bulk variances the Township's Zoning
Board of Adjustment ("the Board") granted to a developer,
Crestwood Construction, LLC ("Crestwood" or "the developer").
The variances authorized Crestwood to build on a 10.9-acre site
a mixed-use project... More... $0 (01-10-2008 - NJ)
|
|
James Sarnowski v. Air Brooke Limousine, Inc.
|
|
James Sarnowski was terminated by his employer, Air
Brook Limousine, Inc. Sarnowski claims that his termination
violated the Family Medical Leave Act of 1993 (FMLA), 29
U.S.C. § 2601, et seq.; the New Jersey Law Against
Discrimination (LAD), N.J.S.A. 10:5-1, et seq.; and the New
Jersey Conscientious Employee Protection Act (CEPA),
N.J.S.A. 34:19-1, et seq. The District Court granted sum... More... $0 (01-03-2008 - NJ)
|
|
Robert Baer v. David Chase and Chase Films, Inc.
|
|
Robert Baer sued David Chase on a quantum meruit theory claiming that he should be paid for helping David Chase develop ideas for the mob drama, Sopranos. Baer claimed he provided help by arranging meetings with police and prosecutors during a three-day tour of New Jersey mob sites in 1995 and in subsequent conversations that sparked ideas for what became the hit HBO series that ended in June. ... More... $0 (12-20-2007 - NJ)
|
|
The Lighthouse Institute for Envangelism, Inc., etc. v. City of Long Branch, etc.
|
|
This appeal requires us to clarify the nature of the
constitutional and statutory protections enjoyed by religious
assemblies against governmental interference in the form of
land-use regulations. The plaintiff/appellants are the Lighthouse
Institute for Evangelism, which describes itself as "a Christian
church that seeks to minister to the poor and disadvantaged in
downtown Long Branch, ... More... $0 (12-04-2007 - NJ)
|
|
United States of America for the Use and Benefit of E&H Steel Corporation v. C. Pyramid Enterprises, Inc., et al.
|
|
In this Miller Act case, we decide that a firm acted as a
subcontractor when it supplied fabricated steel to the prime
contractor that then used the material to construct the framework
for a large Air Force facility. The subcontractor defaulted in
payments due the company that it hired to fabricate the steel and
deliver it to the construction site. The District Court denied
recovery to th... More... $0 (12-04-2007 - NJ)
|
|
Directv, Inc. v. Nelson Seijas, et al.
|
|
Defendant Scott Williamson appeals the District Court's
grant of summary judgment in favor of DIRECTV, Inc., finding
that Williamson violated the Federal Communications Act, 47
U.S.C. § 605, and the Electronic Communications Privacy Act
of 1986, 18 U.S.C. § 2511. This appeal presents the question of
whether there is a private right of action for the unlawful
interception of encrypted sa... More... $0 (12-04-2007 - NJ)
|
|
Michael Koruba v. American Honda Motor Co., Inc.
|
|
This case arises out of an accident that occurred when
plaintiff Michael Koruba attempted an extreme jump on his sports
all-terrain vehicle (ATV), resulting in his sustaining serious
neurological and orthopedic injuries. Plaintiff sued both the
manufacturer of the ATV, defendant American Honda Motor Co.,
Inc. (Honda), asserting a product liability claim for failure to
adequately warn... More... $0 (11-23-2007 - NJ)
|
|
Janelle Frederico, etc. v. Home Depot
|
|
Plaintiff Janelle Frederico, for herself and on behalf of
a class of similarly situated persons, appeals a judgment of the United States District Court for the District of New Jersey that
dismissed her complaint against The Home Depot, Inc.
Alleging fraud and breach of contract, the complaint was
dismissed without prejudice pursuant to Rules 9(b) and
12(b)(6), Federal Rules of Civil Procedure... More... $0 (11-23-2007 - NJ)
|
|
E.I. DUPONT DE NEMOURS AND COMPANY;
CONOCO, INC.; SPORTING GOODS PROPERTIES, INC. v. UNITED STATES OF AMERICA; et al.
|
|
This matter is before us on the order of the Supreme
Court of the United States dated June 18, 2007, which granted
the petition for a writ of certiorari filed by DuPont, vacated the judgment of this court, and remanded for further consideration in
light of its opinion in United States v. Atlantic Research Corp.,
551 U.S. , 127 S. Ct. 2331 (2007). In our earlier opinion, a
majority of this ... More... $0 (11-23-2007 - NJ)
|
|
In re: Vioxx Litigation Settlement
|
|
Merck & Co., Inc. today announced that it has entered into an agreement with the law firms that comprise the executive committee of the Plaintiffs' Steering Committee of the federal multidistrict VIOXX litigation as well as representatives of plaintiffs' counsel in state coordinated proceedings to resolve state and federal myocardial infarction (MI) and ischemic stroke claims already filed ag... More... $4850000000 (11-09-2007 - NJ)
|
|
Jane Edgar v. Avaya, Inc., et al.
|
|
UnknownIn this lawsuit, Jane Edgar, a former employee of Avaya
Inc., alleges that Avaya and several of its officers ("defendants")
breached their fiduciary duties under § 404 of the Employee
Retirement Income Security Act ("ERISA"), 29 U.S.C. § 1104, by
offering participants in three employee pension benefit plans the
option of investing in Avaya common stock. Edgar commenced
the lawsuit aft... More... $0 (10-03-2007 - NJ)
|
|
Sarah Jones v. Allstate Insurance Co.
|
|
Sarah Jones sued Allstate Insurance Co. on a breach of contract theory for failing and refusing to enter into settlement negotiations on her claims for injuries suffered in the accident asserting that Ms. Jones' claims were all pre-existing conditions. Jones claimed that she was disabled as a result of a low back herniation that caused numbness in her leg and carpal tunnel injuries. Jones was ... More... $50000 (09-29-2007 - NJ)
|
|
Long Branch, New Jersey v. Bruce MacCloud
|
|
The Long Branch, New Jersey sued Bruce MacCloud on an eminent domain theory seeking to acquire by condemnation a Victorian style house owned by MacCloud to make way for a massive redevelopment project. The City paid MacCloud $140,000 for the property but he demanded $630,000. MacCloud objected to the taking claiming that it was an abuse of the power of eminent domain. ... More... $220000 (09-27-2007 - NJ)
|
|
IN RE GABAPENTIN PATENT LITIGATION
|
|
Warner Lambert Co., Pfizer Inc., and Gödecke Aktiengesellschaft (collectively "Warner Lambert") appeal from the judgment of the United States District Court for the District of New Jersey granting summary judgment of noninfringement of claims 7-11 of U.S. Patent 6,054,482 ("the '482 patent") in favor of appellees Purepac Pharmaceutical Co., Faulding Inc., Teva Pharmaceutical Industries, Inc.,... More... $0 (09-21-2007 - NJ)
|
|
NEW YORK SUSQUEHANNA AND WESTERN RAILWAY CORPORATION v. LISA P. JACKSON, in her official capacity as Commissioner of the New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection; et al.
|
|
Shipping solid waste to Midwestern landfills has become
big business - particularly in places like New Jersey where
capacity at in-state landfills is scarce. Railroads are prime
beneficiaries of the increased demand for the means of shipping
waste across the country. Many railroads accommodate this
demand by building facilities within their rights-of-way for the
storage and loading of was... More... $0 (09-12-2007 - NJ)
|
|
International Union of Operating Engineers Local No. 68 Welfare Fund v. Merck & Co., Inc.
|
|
In July 2005, a Law Division judge granted the motion of
plaintiff International Union of Operating Engineers Local #68 Welfare Fund "to certify a nationwide class of third-party[,]
non-government payors who . . . paid any person or entity for
the purchase of a prescription anti-inflammatory arthritis and
acute pain medication marketed by defendant Merck & Company,
Inc. . . . under the bra... More... $0 (09-07-2007 - NJ)
|
|
BASF Corporation v. Lyondell Chemical Co.
|
|
BASF Corporation sued Lyondell Chemical Co. on a breach of contact theory claiming that defendant sell propylene oxide, a compound that BASF uses to make polyols, used in making all sorts of goods, from gym floors to adhesives at the lowest price paid by any customer.
Defendant admitted that it overcharged BASF but contested the amount of damages.... More... $169932670 (08-15-2007 - NJ)
|
|
New Jersey Transit Corporation v. Harsco Corporation, et al.
|
|
This appeal requires us to decide if, in a contract
governed by Article 2 of New Jersey's Uniform Commercial
Code ("U.C.C."), see N.J. Stat. Ann. § 12A:2-101 et seq.,
appellant New Jersey Transit Corporation ("Transit") can rely
on the implied warranties of merchantability and fitness for a
particular purpose to recover damages, where the contract's one year express warranty had expired ... More... $0 (08-14-2007 - NJ)
|
|
Cosmetic Gallery, Inc. d/b/a The Salon At Image Beauty v. Schoeneman Corporation d/b/a Schoeneman Beauty Supply and F. Dale Schoeneman
|
|
At issue in this civil antitrust suit alleging a group boycott
is whether plaintiff offered sufficient evidence to survive defendants' motion for summary judgment. We will affirm the
grant of summary judgment.
I
Plaintiff Cosmetic Gallery, Inc. is a New Jersey
corporation that owns and operates a hair salon and retails hair
care products and professional beauty supplies. Defendant... More... $0 (08-02-2007 - NJ)
|